Francesca R
Girl
The idea of gold creating wealth sounds like some kind of alchemy to me . . . .
yes, it was pointless, for 2 reasons. First, the timeframe you quote is very short, and nonspecific. I, with every effort to be fair, calculated a total return for you of 5%. You cite 229%. This merely by picking a slightly different ending point for the Dow value. In other words, your 1400% obsfucated your returns, and your point. It's ridiculous to gloat over overperforming an index by changing the start or end date by a month or so. If you have multi-decade record of beating the Dow, that's a different story. Saying somebody beat the dow by 5% over 4 decades is impressive and noteworthy.The 14x figure was from a while ago, it's even more now as the Dow has since retreated.
My annualized rate of return on spot gold is 15%, for a cumulative return of 229% over about 8.7 years.
Meanwhile the Dow over roughly the same period of time (week ending Feb 14, 2000 to date) has returned a whopping .7% annualized - it's moved up about 600 points in nearly nine years.
My annualized return in spot gold has beaten the annualized Dow return by 20.43 times, or 2043%.
See above. Also note that this is simply the spot price of gold I'm talking about. My total return is higher because I have a diversified portfolio including ETFs, mining shares, and other metals. For example, my average cost basis in KGC is only $2.67 a share, a 550% gain. That's destroyed the Dow too.
In fact, it's not pointless. Why not compare it to the Dow, when the idea is to beat the market with less risk? You can pick a broader based index if you want, the difference is going to be similar. The point is, investing in an inert metal over the past 8.7 years has smoked an index of 30 industrial stocks.
Sorry, I don't believe in that silly theory. It's trivial to find counterexamples. But, that does not bear (too much) in this. The EMH certainly does not say that everything will acquire value at the same rate. My Honda is depreciating, my gold (if I had any) more or less follows inflation, my stocks appreciate satisfactory (in the sense that Ben Graham uses the term).
The argument against using gold as an investment (as opposed to preservation of capital), is that when you buy stocks, you are buying a part of a business that is out there producing things. They are creating wealth (I think a lot of gold bugs might disagree with the concept of creating wealth, but I digress - that is econ 101). Hence, it makes sense to invest in them, in exactly the same way it makes sense to start your own business - you do work to create value for your customers, some of which they then share with you. If you feel the market is efficient, buying an index fund in a broad index will still give you wealth creation, and is a sound investment.
Gold, on the other hand, just sits there. It's price will rise and fall, certainly, but there is no wealth creation. In the long term, it just floats along with inflation, tipppit's short term performance non-withstanding. There's no reason for it to acquire value above and beyond that, and it doesn't. If you believe you can predict macro economic events, then it may make sense to buy gold, but I've never seen evidence, or a theoretical framework, for doing so. There is no reason for it to match or exceed the Dow.
As with any argument, this one comes with premises. The premises here are: efficient market theory is nonsense (some stocks are efficiently priced, I grant, but some are not), value can be identified in stocks (in some cases, not any stock at any time), companies create wealth, gold does not. I'd be happy to discuss (not debate - too tedious, I'm here for fun) the first 2 in a different thread. The latter 2 are covered in any econ 101 text, and in this thread.
yes, it was pointless, for 2 reasons. First, the timeframe you quote is very short, and nonspecific. I, with every effort to be fair, calculated a total return for you of 5%. You cite 229%. This merely by picking a slightly different ending point for the Dow value. In other words, your 1400% obsfucated your returns, and your point. It's ridiculous to gloat over overperforming an index by changing the start or end date by a month or so. If you have multi-decade record of beating the Dow, that's a different story. Saying somebody beat the dow by 5% over 4 decades is impressive and noteworthy.
FWIW, my returns are better than yours, and I didn't invest in gold, but so what? Neither proves or disproves the value of investing in gold. Neither proves we are intelligent investors, or that I'm better at it than you.
"I made 15% investing in gold" would have been a noncontraversial statement. I'm happy to believe that statement. Throwing around things like 1400% annualized honestly painted you as either a liar, completely incompetent in finance, or purposefully trying to make things sound more impressive than they are. I made 14x nearly 0. Gee whiz. I'm making 80x* nearly 0. Big freaking deal![]()
I suppose that all sounds like an attack, but it was my honest reaction to seeing your post (and to my knowledge we have never communicated before - I'm not out to 'get you'). It doesn't paint a good picture when somebody tries to argue about how the US economy and markets should be structured, and they don't understand interest. It's up to you, but I suggest trying to get these very simple points right.
Gold, on the other hand, just sits there. It's price will rise and fall, certainly, but there is no wealth creation. In the long term, it just floats along with inflation, tipppit's short term performance non-withstanding. There's no reason for it to acquire value above and beyond that, and it doesn't. If you believe you can predict macro economic events, then it may make sense to buy gold, but I've never seen evidence, or a theoretical framework, for doing so. There is no reason for it to match or exceed the Dow.
A.
I couldn't agree with you more, which is why I also own non-mining stocks. I made a ton in ORCL, CSCO, et al based on discounted cash flow analysis before the dot.com crash. I'm not a big fan of index funds, because I know I can beat the market.
Broad diversification is a hedge against ignorance.
That's a prediction about price-supply-demand. It may be right or it may be wrong (there are plenty of reasons why it might be wrong). But is is not about gold "creating wealth". Gold doesn't do that and neither does any commodity.The supply is limited. There is a certain demand for gold (Jewels for culture (India) Industry, etc) It is a fact that the world population is increasing exponential. I think the demand for gold will increase faster than the supply of new found gold. Considering this I can see reasons (aside from temporary economic shifts in gold price) for the gold price to increase in the future.
Growing need plus limited source should equal higher prices. But there are ways to take advantage of that in the equity market, which, once again, should provide superior returns. And what would the effect on wildly increasing gold prices be on inflation itself? This is getting way to crystal ball to suit my investing needs, at least. In the end, I think it is pretty sound advice to put money into endevours which do work and add to the world - those seem most like to lead to increases in capital. So, I don't invest in oil or NG, but I do invest in oil&gas E&P companies. I think that's a pretty sound strategy for somebody who doesn't think they can predict macro events, but can identify undervalued companies (many would quibble with both points).I can think of arguments to counter this. Gold is physical stuff. We have to dig it out of the earth. This means we can't go on and create unlimited more. The supply is limited. There is a certain demand for gold (Jewels for culture (India) Industry, etc) It is a fact that the world population is increasing exponential. I think the demand for gold will increase faster than the supply of new found gold. Considering this I can see reasons (aside from temporary economic shifts in gold price) for the gold price to increase in the future.
If our economy was moving in the right direction, gold and silver would be a terrible investment. But our economy is moving towards hyperinflation, which will happen in the next 5 years IMO, so gold and silver are a terrific buy right now. They are there more as a safety net than an investment, but you would of made a huge profit if you bought gold or silver in 2002, so I guess it has money making potential.
Had you bought gold in 1980 at an inflation adjusted $2200, your "investment" would now be worth $875.
So, I guess the "safety net" is that you would still have 39% of your money, as opposed to zero? Thanks, but no thanks.
That is completely irrelevant. I was talking about in 2002 if you invested you would of tripled your orinigal investment, and I expect that to continue due to our massive debt. I am not talking about 1980 or 1990, just 2002 until now.
The only advice from Cramer I ever liked was that in "Iron Man".Yes, Jim Cramer is crazy. I would not listen to any investment advice from him.
That's a prediction about price-supply-demand. It may be right or it may be wrong (there are plenty of reasons why it might be wrong). But is is not about gold "creating wealth". Gold doesn't do that and neither does any commodity.
And the world population is not increasing exponentially. I remember you thinking incorrectly that India's fertility rate was 6% a while back
A. I didn't say gold is creating wealth. I just gave a reason why you could think gold is a good investment now, or in the future.
I think the EMT is garbage. If that were true then good stock pickers couldn't differentiate themselves from the market.
It is a fact that the world population is increasing exponential.
Except world population growth is not "proportional to its current level".(Exponential growth (including exponential decay) occurs when the growth rate of a mathematical function is proportional to the function's current value)