Gold will go $1,500/oz

Oh no no no no. You can't try the same thing Tippit always does and tell us what happened because everyone is an idiot except him

Can't speak for Tippit, but I never said nor meant to imply that. Unless you can show me where I called someone and idiot in which case I'll stand corrected.

What you need to explain is how much gold you're planning to buy right now and how much cleverer you're going to be than the rest of us when you sell it at a substantial profit...

I don't really need to explain anything, but to move the conversation along, I'm not in a position to buy anything right now, for reasons that can be implied from some of my earlier posts. Plus, I've said repeatedly that I don't know where gold (or anything) is going. And that selling any of my metal holdings will not be based on price nor profit, but on necessity. And I've never said I'm cleverer than anyone else. Either you're mistaking me for someone else or this is a collossal straw man.
So don't tell us what happened. Tell us what you plan on doing. That's what interests everyone.

Thanks for speaking for everyone. I believe Santayana had a nice quote about those not willing to learn about the past being condemned to repeat it.
 
Last edited:
I respect the fact that there are many different investment strategies, and that our opinions are based on past experiences. No need to call any one strategy "foolish".

I don't think your overall strategy is foolish, just the specific remark about price being irrelevant. I agree that technical analysis is likely useless. Price should never be ignored when buying groceries, or stocks. Even wild optimism can and should be quantified.

I see two general types of investors. Lets take Ford Motor as an example.

One type of investor will look at today's closing price of $10.56 and attempt to glean from charts and multiples and whatever whether its overpriced, underpriced or fairly priced at that price. That investor can then attempt to profit from this information by buying the stock or selling it short, and capitalizing on its predicted "move".

Another type of investor will look at the big picture, and using intuition and specific knowledge may determine that the long term prospects for Ford are rosy. This knowledge is knowledge available to anyone, and is already in the price of the stock (Efficient Market Hypothesis), so he or she will decide to buy they stock without even necessarily considering the price.

Much like TA, I think EMT is bunk. Neither is knowledge about Ford fully transparent, nor are methods used to forecast its future cash flows and discount them back to the present equally sound or reliable.

I would add that auto makers are fairly bad invesments, generally speaking, as they have high capital expenditures. You can verify this by comparing their P/Es to say, a software company with the same earnings. Ford would have to be remarkably cheap, some small multiple of book for me to be interested.

If GM and Chrysler fade and imports lose their luster and Ford prospers the stock price, long term, should reflect its increased value. Five years from now if the price is $100, it will matter very little exactly where that second investor type bought in.

If Ford is efficiently priced today, then in five years the stock price will not appreciate any more than its weighted average cost of capital would indicate, by definition.

Again, we're all products of past experiences. Once I was using a company's products and finding them fairly well designed. I heard the company was going public, and I thought I'd throw some money (maybe a few thousand dollars) at the IPO. I called my broker, and he told me why he thought the IPO was overhyped and overpriced and told me it was an unwise investment. I listened to him and didn't buy any.

Oh, the company was Microsoft.

From this I learned to trust my own instincts, and that alleged "experts" often don't have a clue what's really going on.

I'm not sure that anything other than perhaps keyboards and mice by Microsft are "well designed", but I'm sorry your broker talked you out of buying it. That would have been a life changing event, certainly. You may have a keen insight into companies poised for explosive growth, but these are fairly rare. By completely ignoring price, you're setting yourself up for staggering losses when you're wrong, or stagnant performance and dead money when you're right - when the rest of the market was right along with you.

The companies I have my biggest profits in (Apple and Netflix) I bought with no regard to the price - each for different reasons. My basis in each is less than $10. At their current levels whether I paid a little more or less ($5 or $15, let's say) would make a miniscule difference in my total return, even though those are large percentage differences in purchase price.

Congratulations, those were great picks, at great prices. I would love to get in Apple, it seems fairly cheap at first glance, but I think it is more expensive than it looks because of the Fed's artificially low rates, time will tell, I might regret not buying it now but I have a feeling it will get it cheaper, later. Netflix on the other hand, is probably a good short. They dont own any content, there is nothing special about their business model, and they failed to ink a new deal with Starz. Oh, and it's very expensive. A 50 multiple for a company that is going to lose share to content providers who stream directly to customers, and facing a customer backlash in light of recent price increases? No thanks. I am personally cancelling my Netflix sub.

I also had a friend in the 80's who paid a lot of money to have currency prices sent to his Mac, and showed me his scheme for profiting from trading currency futures. He told me it was foolproof. You can guess how that turned out.

"Foolproof" is always a red flag.

In any case, I have surmised that "value investors" do far, far better in the long run than traders attempting to use any sort of technical analysis for gains, either short- or long-term.

But it's a big world and there's plenty of room for all types of investors.

Traders lose a lot of their gains to short term capital gains taxes and commissions, unless they're using retirement accounts. Seems silly to me, let alone much time wasted that could otherwise be spent playing Starcraft 2!
 
Last edited:
....I think EMT is bunk. Neither is knowledge about Ford fully transparent,.....
Neither is knowledge about the government's future manipulative strategies and intents for the economy itself fully transparent, rather the complete reverse.

A general idea can be gleaned as to what and why they are doing what they are doing, though, and then you have the question.

How to invest, in a partially rigged market. I'm using the phrase broadly, to include the stock market, bonds, real estate, and commodities. I'm also using the phrase "invest" broadly, to include placing funds at risk as well as taking actions to preserve capital, both in electronic transactions and in the conversion of electronic assets to physical.
 
Maybe EMT is not 100% valid, but bunk?

I guess if one holds that the market is NOT efficient, the next question is how can the alleged inefficiencies be used to make investment decisions.

IOW, are the inefficiencies themselves efficient and clear enough to make reliable predictions of future price moves? I think we get into an infinite regression again - people try to use inefficiencies to profit, and those behaviors themselves pull the market back towards efficiency, until new inefficiencies arise, and so on ad infinitum.

I'm not sure that anything other than perhaps keyboards and mice by Microsft are "well designed"

I was referring mainly to the Mac versions of "Multiplan" and "Chart", both of which seemed elegant and intuitive to me at the time (1986). Multiplan grew into Excel, which I still use as part of a rather old vers.on of "Office" on my Mac

But, Tippit, I appreciate the time and effort it took to compose your post and thoughts, and I really did mean to thank you. I remain open to being educated on this stuff - I have my opinions, and perusing articles on technical analysis and efficient market theory and random walk theory, opinions abound but settled science seems hard to come by.
 
Last edited:
I guess if one holds that the market is NOT efficient, the next question is how can the alleged inefficiencies be used to make investment decisions.

You would need an objective method of valuation that would enable you to capture alpha, that portion of your return in financial assets that come from other investors mispricing the asset.

IOW, are the inefficiencies themselves efficient and clear enough to make reliable predictions of future price moves? I think we get into an infinite regression again - people try to use inefficiencies to profit, and those behaviors themselves pull the market back towards efficiency, until new inefficiencies arise, and so on ad infinitum.

I think so. There are so many forces acting on markets as a whole, and so many decisions made by investors that have little to nothing to do with business fundamentals, that there are opportunities everywhere.

I was referring mainly to the Mac versions of "Multiplan" and "Chart", both of which seemed elegant and intuitive to me at the time (1986). Multiplan grew into Excel, which I still use as part of a rather old vers.on of "Office" on my Mac

I was a teenager then, playing with a Commodore AMIGA which was technically superior both to PCs and Macs, but Commodore's marketing was inept. If only I cared about investing then (and had some money), I might have invested in MSFT.

But, Tippit, I appreciate the time and effort it took to compose your post and thoughts, and I really did mean to thank you. I remain open to being educated on this stuff - I have my opinions, and perusing articles on technical analysis and efficient market theory and random walk theory, opinions abound but settled science seems hard to come by.

Yep, different strokes for different folks. I guess that is what makes a market. I wish I had only put my money where my mouth was and bought Apple after Jobs left, and shorted Netflix. Apple is significantly up, and Netflix significantly down. I still have pretty much the same opinion of both companies. Apple is now trading at roughly 16x ttm earnings, which is far as I'm concerned is pricing in Armageddon, given their explosive growth and bright prospects. The world could enter a global depression and I think Apples top line would be flat, at worst. I still think Netflix is terrible, and Hastings seems to be making enemies of customers and shareholders alike.
 
I was a teenager then, playing with a Commodore AMIGA which was technically superior both to PCs and Macs, but Commodore's marketing was inept. If only I cared about investing then (and had some money), I might have invested in MSFT.

Thanks for making me feel old.

Amiga 500 was awesome.
 
I don't think your overall strategy is foolish, just the specific remark about price being irrelevant. I agree that technical analysis is likely useless. Price should never be ignored when buying groceries, or stocks. Even wild optimism can and should be quantified.

Much like TA, I think EMT is bunk. .....
But careful examination of t he fundamentals will on occasion signal EITHER the buying or selling of a stock based on either short, medium or long term factors.

I can think of 3 stocks in two decades where I made out on that. On was selling for about $1, but had cash in their bank equal to $ 0.50 per share.

But decisions based on examining the fundamentals remains.....investing based on the fundamentals.
 
See, what gold bugs haven't figured out is that the natural market for gold is very small, and when the gold bugs push the price up, that market all but disappears. And that has happened. And we see gold falling in spite of the world being on the edge of financial collapse. Silver too.

Gold and silver, while valuable metals, are not money and are not a magic talisman against economic chaos.
 
See, what gold bugs haven't figured out is that the natural market for gold is very small, and when the gold bugs push the price up, that market all but disappears. And that has happened. And we see gold falling in spite of the world being on the edge of financial collapse. Silver too.

Either that, or CME hiked margin requirements again (which they did), and the central banks dumped the only asset that measures the extent of their fraud, to help conceal their fraud.

Gold and silver, while valuable metals, are not money and are not a magic talisman against economic chaos.

And, the USD and Treasuries are! Or, wait awhile and see what happens.
 
See, what gold bugs haven't figured out is that the natural market for gold is very small, and when the gold bugs push the price up, that market all but disappears. And that has happened. And we see gold falling in spite of the world being on the edge of financial collapse. Silver too.

Gold and silver, while valuable metals, are not money and are not a magic talisman against economic chaos.

Consider this is fact-based forum, let's lay down a few facts on gold/silver.

- CME announced margin hikes after the markets are closed on gold, silver, and copper. With the mass sell off in the past two days, it would suggest inside trading.

- Gold and Silver, especially some of the mining stock, have given insane returns in the past decade

- The recent wikileaks show China very interested in becoming the world reserve currency using gold as their back up.

- The biggest buyers of gold right now are China and India, due to economic and cultural reasons

- Most of the "gold" trades in the West are mainly leveraged paper-trading based on gold that these organizations (such as Comex) don't have. Just look at the charts during our hours and compare it to the Asian markets.
 
Given all those facts about gold, can we answer either of the following two questions:

1) What is a proper price for it right now?

2) What is the price going to do going forward?

I can easily answer the first...$1,656.85/oz if my "metalquotes" app is correct.

The second? Well, by now you should know my answer, but for newbies I can state with some certainty that the price of gold will either go up, or down, or will stay the same. And I can predict this with the same certainty over any time horizon you choose.
 
2) What is the price going to do going forward?

At this point no one can tell and it's a gamble. If you think the price reduction was strictly the margin calls, it would go up on Monday because the sell off is already completed. If you think it was more than the margin calls, it hasn't even started to go down then.

I'm sitting on the sidelines for now.
 
Last edited:
See, what gold bugs haven't figured out is that the natural market for gold is very small, and when the gold bugs push the price up, that market all but disappears. And that has happened. And we see gold falling in spite of the world being on the edge of financial collapse. Silver too.

Gold and silver, while valuable metals, are not money and are not a magic talisman against economic chaos.

Gold is quasi money. Otherwise central banks wouldn't hold it. In the recent decline gold has dropped less than platinum which now is priced lower than gold. Gold is largely a fear trade and partially a commodity trade. When the ratio of gold/platinum prices exceed one you have a very high level of fear. As it is gold is grossly overpriced and reflects the fear of monetary collapse and the increased possibility of debt restructuring. Arguably, Brown's Bottom, the sale of substantial amounts of the UK's gold at $200/oz was a good sale based on gold as a commodity when the fear factor was relatively low.
 
As it is gold is grossly overpriced...

A) What does that even mean?

B) Does that statement inform us as to the future price of gold, and,

C) Can one use that "observation" to profit from either the purchase or sale of either physical gold or selling gold short or other strategies?
 
Arguably, Brown's Bottom, the sale of substantial amounts of the UK's gold at $200/oz was a good sale based on gold as a commodity when the fear factor was relatively low.

I had never heard of Brown's Bottom and had to go to Wikipedia*.

I suppose one could argue that that was a "good" sale, but one must consider...

The decision to sell gold at the low point in the price cycle has been likened to the mistakes in 1992 that led to Black Wednesday, when the UK was forced to withdraw from the European Exchange Rate Mechanism, which HM Treasury has estimated cost the UK taxpayer around £3.3 billion.

As at the 10th August 2011 the price of gold was $1749 per ounce, the difference in price making the loss in value $18 billion or £13 billion.


To be fair, it appears that the sales price was between $250 and $280/oz, not $200 - if I read the article right.

Anyway, if that's a good sale, I'd hate to see a bad one!


*one reason I engage in debates like this is to learn...and I learned something today. Thanks!
 
Last edited:
At any point no one can tell and it's a gamble.

Fixed it for you!

Disagree. The retail investor like you and I won't probably know, but the central banks or big financial institutions like JP Morgan? You need to remember the Market isn't very efficient, and not all the information is priced into a piece of stock or commodity.

Going back to Gold, the idea gold going down to over a 100 bucks at one point (don't forget the mass decline the day before) and suddenly a margin hike is announced on the same day in the after market hours? Someone knew something. Besides the other PMs like Silver and Copper, no other commodity went through such a price beat down.
 
Last edited:
Golds ONLY value is as a commodity. The rest is psychology. When the price gets this high, commodity use goes away, but production goes up. Even dentists and jewelers find alternatives. Thus the inventory expands much faster than it is depleted. This is not a recipe for any sort of price stability or security from disaster. Literally the only reason for gold to be this high is a shared delusion, and that can evaporate rather suddenly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom