I respect the fact that there are many different investment strategies, and that our opinions are based on past experiences. No need to call any one strategy "foolish".
I don't think your overall strategy is foolish, just the specific remark about price being irrelevant. I agree that technical analysis is likely useless. Price should never be ignored when buying groceries, or stocks. Even wild optimism can and should be quantified.
I see two general types of investors. Lets take Ford Motor as an example.
One type of investor will look at today's closing price of $10.56 and attempt to glean from charts and multiples and whatever whether its overpriced, underpriced or fairly priced at that price. That investor can then attempt to profit from this information by buying the stock or selling it short, and capitalizing on its predicted "move".
Another type of investor will look at the big picture, and using intuition and specific knowledge may determine that the long term prospects for Ford are rosy. This knowledge is knowledge available to anyone, and is already in the price of the stock (Efficient Market Hypothesis), so he or she will decide to buy they stock without even necessarily considering the price.
Much like TA, I think EMT is bunk. Neither is knowledge about Ford fully transparent, nor are methods used to forecast its future cash flows and discount them back to the present equally sound or reliable.
I would add that auto makers are fairly bad invesments, generally speaking, as they have high capital expenditures. You can verify this by comparing their P/Es to say, a software company with the same earnings. Ford would have to be remarkably cheap, some small multiple of book for me to be interested.
If GM and Chrysler fade and imports lose their luster and Ford prospers the stock price, long term, should reflect its increased value. Five years from now if the price is $100, it will matter very little exactly where that second investor type bought in.
If Ford is efficiently priced today, then in five years the stock price will not appreciate any more than its weighted average cost of capital would indicate, by definition.
Again, we're all products of past experiences. Once I was using a company's products and finding them fairly well designed. I heard the company was going public, and I thought I'd throw some money (maybe a few thousand dollars) at the IPO. I called my broker, and he told me why he thought the IPO was overhyped and overpriced and told me it was an unwise investment. I listened to him and didn't buy any.
Oh, the company was Microsoft.
From this I learned to trust my own instincts, and that alleged "experts" often don't have a clue what's really going on.
I'm not sure that anything other than perhaps keyboards and mice by Microsft are "well designed", but I'm sorry your broker talked you out of buying it. That would have been a life changing event, certainly. You may have a keen insight into companies poised for explosive growth, but these are fairly rare. By completely ignoring price, you're setting yourself up for staggering losses when you're wrong, or stagnant performance and dead money when you're right - when the rest of the market was right along with you.
The companies I have my biggest profits in (Apple and Netflix) I bought with no regard to the price - each for different reasons. My basis in each is less than $10. At their current levels whether I paid a little more or less ($5 or $15, let's say) would make a miniscule difference in my total return, even though those are large percentage differences in purchase price.
Congratulations, those were great picks, at great prices. I would love to get in Apple, it seems fairly cheap at first glance, but I think it is more expensive than it looks because of the Fed's artificially low rates, time will tell, I might regret not buying it now but I have a feeling it will get it cheaper, later. Netflix on the other hand, is probably a good short. They dont own any content, there is nothing special about their business model, and they failed to ink a new deal with Starz. Oh, and it's very expensive. A 50 multiple for a company that is going to lose share to content providers who stream directly to customers, and facing a customer backlash in light of recent price increases? No thanks. I am personally cancelling my Netflix sub.
I also had a friend in the 80's who paid a lot of money to have currency prices sent to his Mac, and showed me his scheme for profiting from trading currency futures. He told me it was foolproof. You can guess how that turned out.
"Foolproof" is always a red flag.
In any case, I have surmised that "value investors" do far, far better in the long run than traders attempting to use any sort of technical analysis for gains, either short- or long-term.
But it's a big world and there's plenty of room for all types of investors.
Traders lose a lot of their gains to short term capital gains taxes and commissions, unless they're using retirement accounts. Seems silly to me, let alone much time wasted that could otherwise be spent playing Starcraft 2!