Gold will go $1,500/oz

gold_5_year_o_b_usd.png
 
Interesting chart.

A couple points...

1) The time frame chosen is important. The chart can look very different with different date ranges, and "gold bugs" (I can't believe I'm using that term) are good at truncating the chart to make the best possible case for appreciation arguments.

2) I believe "technical analysis" is hogwash. Charts show past performance, which does not predict future performance - if it did, we could all get very rich, very fast.

3) "Making predictions is tough...especially about the future!" or words to that effect, commonly attributed to Yogi Berra. Whether the price shoots above $2,000/oz or pulls back to $200/oz, some wag will pull up this or another chart and show how it portended that. Post-dictions are always easier!
 
Last edited:
Sounds like gold is coming right down in price. Margin requirements are being hiked and this seems to have forced a great deal of traders to cash out. Gold will probably rebound but I really thought it was going to hit 200$ by the end of August
 
Sounds like gold is coming right down in price.

I hope so, but I think Mark is right about the Jackson Hole speech. Depending on what Bernanke says, gold could either drop further or shoot back up again.

Margin requirements are being hiked and this seems to have forced a great deal of traders to cash out.

Yes. But I think this will only end up delaying the inevitable.

Gold will probably rebound but I really thought it was going to hit 200$ by the end of August

There was always a very real possibility that the powers that be would take action to stop what was looking like a parabolic rise.

What I am willing to bet is this: private individuals who have been buying gold, both in the western world and elsewhere, are not going to sell into this pullback. They are going to hold on to their gold. And as soon as it turns around and looks like it is going to go back up again, more of these "longs" will enter the market or buy more. There is a flow of physical gold into the hands of these "longs", and this will eventually ratchet up the price whatever anybody does to the margins (which do not affect private buyers of gold bullion).

There are a lot of people out there for whom this uncontrollable rise in the price of gold is very bad news. They will not give up easily. If there's anything at all they can do to get the price down, then they will do it.

My question is this: Is it possible that the US goes back into recession and Bernanke does NOT do QE3? And if so, what would happen next?
 
Last edited:
1) The time frame chosen is important. The chart can look very different with different date ranges, and "gold bugs" (I can't believe I'm using that term) are good at truncating the chart to make the best possible case for appreciation arguments.

This is true, but also on the other side. There was an article by someone trying to attack Ron Paul, suggesting he wanted the US to crash because he held gold stocks. He assumed RP wanted his portfolio to rise because they weren't doing so well. His argument? Using three-year charts.

Of course, any critical thinker like myself decided to investigate and RP held these stocks for over a decade, one of them being Silver Wheaton. Just look at their stocks in the past decade, and tell me RP hasn't done well for himself. In fact, he has done much better than most hedge fund managers out there. I'm envious of him.

2) I believe "technical analysis" is hogwash. Charts show past performance, which does not predict future performance - if it did, we could all get very rich, very fast.

I disagree on two points:

- You are trading with computers, not human beings. They are the real market makers, and these computers use these charts. If a computer looks at the charts and says "time to sell", you are in for the ride as a retail investor. Understanding technical analysis in this level of technology is important, even if you don't agree with it.

- I have used technical analysis and they are very good at telling you of an upcoming trend or how risky a stock is, depending on the different types of tools you use and what your objectives are. Considering I tend to buy and hold (although sometimes holding is no more than a month), I find technical analysis with such tools like B. Bands and MACD to be extremely helpful when you look at long-term charts.

3) "Making predictions is tough...especially about the future!" or words to that effect, commonly attributed to Yogi Berra. Whether the price shoots above $2,000/oz or pulls back to $200/oz, some wag will pull up this or another chart and show how it portended that. Post-dictions are always easier!

This I completely agree with. You can't make accurate predictions, only predictions that are likely to happen. It is essential a gamble, especially with this level of volatility we have been witnessing for the past decade. I would highly suggest to read up on the volatility index...we have been above the historical average for quite some time now.
 
Last edited:
I hope so, but I think Mark is right about the Jackson Hole speech. Depending on what Bernanke says, gold could either drop further or shoot back up again.



Yes. But I think this will only end up delaying the inevitable.



There was always a very real possibility that the powers that be would take action to stop what was looking like a parabolic rise.

What I am willing to bet is this: private individuals who have been buying gold, both in the western world and elsewhere, are not going to sell into this pullback. They are going to hold on to their gold. And as soon as it turns around and looks like it is going to go back up again, more of these "longs" will enter the market or buy more. There is a flow of physical gold into the hands of these "longs", and this will eventually ratchet up the price whatever anybody does to the margins (which do not affect private buyers of gold bullion).

There are a lot of people out there for whom this uncontrollable rise in the price of gold is very bad news. They will not give up easily. If there's anything at all they can do to get the price down, then they will do it.

My question is this: Is it possible that the US goes back into recession and Bernanke does NOT do QE3? And if so, what would happen next?

Well Gold is due for another bounce back up, this drop is rather contrived. Definitely next week's trend will be set when Ben opens his mouth, QE3 means the price goes up as inflationary expectations set in. In any case I have no doubt that eventually QE3 will happen even if it is pushing on a string, the US government has nothing else left to use. The teabaggers and other deficit hawks have effectively barred any more fiscal stimulus and every other country is going into austerity mode. If there is no QE3 I think there will be a recession, if there is QE3 I think there will be a recession anyway.
 
- You are trading with computers, not human beings. They are the real market makers, and these computers use these charts. If a computer looks at the charts and says "time to sell", you are in for the ride as a retail investor. Understanding technical analysis in this level of technology is important, even if you don't agree with it.

Interesting point, and maybe so.

But imagine a computer program that can spot a "head and shoulders" (for instance) pattern and can tell you the exact perfect time to sell gold short. That could work to make a lot of money, but only until someone fine tunes the program to predict an impending top just a tiny bit earlier, so those using that program sell a tiny bit earlier, until a new program comes along, and so on in what appears to be an infinite regression.

And, as a final "argument from final consequences", if someone DID have a program that could consistently, over time, eke out profits, they could eventually have all the money in the world - and that hasn't happened. One could make the case the the Warren Buffets of the world who got really rich trading on fundamentals far outnumber those who tried to get rich trading on "technical analysis".

Whenever I see someone point to a chart and say something like, "Gold has met some real resistance at the $1,500 level. If it can break through, the upside is xxx - otherwise I see a likely retreat to the xxx level, unless resistance continues to hold at this level."

Translated: Gold may go up, it may go down, or it may stay the same. Convenient in that whatever happens, the "prediction" is vindicated!
 
I am. I don't consider myself a gold bug, but rather an opportunist. To say the least, this price hike has made me some nice profits that I wasn't getting from other investments. I don't buy into "gold backed currencies" nor do I see any value in Gold...but I know that someone out there believes so, and if I can sell them at a higher price then I paid for, I will do it.

So you're the one. The greater fool. Good to know! Thanks for the bid.
 
So you're the one. The greater fool.

I know the "greater fool" theory, but still uncalled for on a personal level.

In any case, people who have bought gold all the way up from $35 have all been called foolish at some point.

Goes with the territory. I guess nothing could ever happen to the value of gold that would make these people "un-foolish" in the eyes of some.

So it goes.
 
Last edited:
I know the "greater fool" theory, but still uncalled for on a personal level.

In any case, people who have bought gold all the way up from $35 have been called foolish at some point.

Goes with the territory. I guess nothing could ever happen to the value of gold that would make these people "un-foolish" in the eyes of some.

So it goes.

I'm not insulted. In fact, I'm glad that there is such a theory because now I know that my type of investment method is recognized instead of lunacy.

Besides, I don't like holding commodities that get a margin hike on a daily basis.
 
I do live in the US, and I'm pretty sure you're wrong here.

I should have specified long term capital gains tax - short term is at your regular tax rate. Gambling winnings are, I think, always considered short term and taxed at your regular rate.

And the long term rate (assets held for a year or more) is, in fact, currently 15%, unless its been raised very recently. From Wikipedia:

[qimg]http://farm7.static.flickr.com/6076/6076799838_3e0b3fe2d2_z.jpg[/qimg]

Interesting...

There is no capital gains tax on gold sovereigns in the UK, because they are legal tender. No VAT and no CGT makes them the only sensible way to hold gold in the UK. All you lose (apart from losses/gains in the value of the metal) is the dealer's difference between buy price and sell price. Is there no equivalent of this in the US?
 
Interesting point, and maybe so.

But imagine a computer program that can spot a "head and shoulders" (for instance) pattern and can tell you the exact perfect time to sell gold short. That could work to make a lot of money, but only until someone fine tunes the program to predict an impending top just a tiny bit earlier, so those using that program sell a tiny bit earlier, until a new program comes along, and so on in what appears to be an infinite regression.

And, as a final "argument from final consequences", if someone DID have a program that could consistently, over time, eke out profits, they could eventually have all the money in the world - and that hasn't happened.

That's not true. It assumes that one person has the program and everybody else has nothing. In reality there are just lots of progams, some of which are better than others in certain circumstances...

No computer program could ever predict whether or not Henry Paulson was going to decide to let Lehman's fail or decide to bail them out. I can say no more without this becoming a debate about free will, but I maintain no computer could ever make that call and have any more hope of doing it accurately than choosing lottery numbers.
 
In reality there are just lots of progams, some of which are better than others in certain circumstances...

I suppose...

...but wouldn't they still have the effect of cancelling each other out?

I guess I still take the position that there's no computer program that can look at this...

caps_advanced.chart


...and tell me what Apple stock is going to do tomorrow. Or next week. Or next year. And isn't that what technical analysis pretends to do?
 
I suppose...

...but wouldn't they still have the effect of cancelling each other out?

I guess I still take the position that there's no computer program that can look at this...

[qimg]http://www.motleyfool.idmanagedsolutions.com/charts/advanced/caps_advanced.chart?TIME_SPAN=1Y&RESOLUTION=D&SYMBOL_US=AAPL&ID_NOTATION=&IND_4=CAPS[/qimg]

...and tell me what Apple stock is going to do tomorrow. Or next week. Or next year. And isn't that what technical analysis pretends to do?

Wait...you think a technical analysis only look at that? Where are the B. Bands? The MACD? The moving averages? Volumes? Relative Price Index?

Technical analysis is far more than just looking at support and resistance.
 
Wait...you think a technical analysis only look at that? Where are the B. Bands? The MACD? The moving averages? Volumes? Relative Price Index?

I've never delved too deeply into technical analysis, because I think the premise is flawed. So I don't know what a couple of those things are.

But they all deal with the past, right?. Which does not necessarily inform or predict the future.

Even with all of the things you listed, can you (or anyone) tell me where Apple is headed?

You can find a lot of technical details in astrological charts and tea leaves and iridology as well. Mumbo-Jumbo does not always a science make.

Then again, maybe there's something to technical analysis - but I'm not convinced. Maybe I'll do some Wikipedia reading on it to start.

Can you point me to some controlled studies that show its effectiveness?
 
Last edited:
Interesting...

There is no capital gains tax on gold sovereigns in the UK, because they are legal tender. No VAT and no CGT makes them the only sensible way to hold gold in the UK. All you lose (apart from losses/gains in the value of the metal) is the dealer's difference between buy price and sell price. Is there no equivalent of this in the US?

Does this apply to other bullion in the UK, such as Krugs, Philarmonicas, Maples, Eagles, and Britannias?

Reason being I have a decent stash of such coins, including some Sov's, I paid around £5000 for all in, but now worth about £15000 at the gold dealers scrap prices.

I'm not going to cash them in, but certainly don't want to pay CGT on them when I do!

Vast majority of my holding is in Bullionvault in Switzerland. There seems to be some nasty new legislation on taxing UK deposits in Swiss banks at extortionate rates. I have no idea if this also applies to vaulted bullion?
 
I've never delved too deeply into technical analysis, because I think the premise is flawed. So I don't know what a couple of those things are.

But they all deal with the past, right?. Which does not necessarily inform or predict the future.

Even with all of the things you listed, can you (or anyone) tell me where Apple is headed?

You can find a lot of technical details in astrological charts and tea leaves and iridology as well. Mumbo-Jumbo does not always a science make.

Then again, maybe there's something to technical analysis - but I'm not convinced. Maybe I'll do some Wikipedia reading on it to start.

Can you point me to some controlled studies that show its effectiveness?

They are lagging indicators, so yes they do rely on past information. The purpose of technical analysis is to tell you what trend the stock price is going. Is there any controlled studies? Sadly, I don't know. I just use it because after examining long-term charts using these tools and investing my own money (with adequate success), I find these tools useful. If you want to try it yourself, nab yourself a stock chart program and have a virtual portfolio and try to use these tools yourself. Investopedia is actually a great place to start understanding the technical tools.

As for Apple...sure, I'll give it a shot. I'm a complete amateur at this though, and by no means a professional. To say that every trade I've made is a success story is simply false. I also use a mixture of fundamental and technical. I picture the fundamentalist as the engine of the price, while the charts as the performance of the price.

Anyways...my opinion on Apple is pretty much this: The price will continue downwards for tomorrow. If it continues to down for the next couple of periods, there might be a point where it will be oversold, which would be a good time to buy. Right now, it isn't oversold nor overbought. If you want to know when it will hit that Oversold mark, Relative Strength Index.

Basically Apple will be a buying opportunity in the very near future, but it will bounce back up because long term indicators suggest Apple will still grow despite this minor set back.
 
Last edited:
I've never delved too deeply into technical analysis, because I think the premise is flawed. So I don't know what a couple of those things are.

But they all deal with the past, right?. Which does not necessarily inform or predict the future.

Even with all of the things you listed, can you (or anyone) tell me where Apple is headed?

You can find a lot of technical details in astrological charts and tea leaves and iridology as well. Mumbo-Jumbo does not always a science make.

Then again, maybe there's something to technical analysis - but I'm not convinced. Maybe I'll do some Wikipedia reading on it to start.

Can you point me to some controlled studies that show its effectiveness?

i am a qualifed to speak on this subject based on numerous certification and designations.

"technical analysis" is a very broad term but the general conclusion is that it works, until it doesnt. another poster defined it perfectly by describing technical analysis as a tool. if your investing or trading based on fundamental anlysis, the same critiques you make of TA applies to using a firms past operating performance to estimate future growth or profit potential.

many people agree AAPL is a good company and it doesnt take a CFA, MBA, financial anlyst to tell you its very profitable and has been growing for the past 2 decades. does that mean buying stock today will be a profitable investment in 6 months, 2 years, 5? 10? will it be outperform the index? will it beat inflation? is it the best alternative?

investing based on multiples or ratios, free cash flow, dividends, or any other fundamental informtation is as good as any mean reversion technique, elliot wave count, or trend line. you need to find statistical patterns in something. you wont find any professional money management firm not looking at charts, implied volatility, beta, upside potential, and moving averages. the reason support and resistence levels work, is because someone bought/sold there before, made money.. so they will do it agian.
 
Last edited:
I know the "greater fool" theory, but still uncalled for on a personal level.

In any case, people who have bought gold all the way up from $35 have all been called foolish at some point.

Goes with the territory. I guess nothing could ever happen to the value of gold that would make these people "un-foolish" in the eyes of some.

So it goes.

It's merely commentary on those who would trade in something for which they "see no value in". Blind men with weak hands.
 
Does this apply to other bullion in the UK, such as Krugs, Philarmonicas, Maples, Eagles, and Britannias?

It certainly doesn't apply to gold bars, for example. There is no VAT on those, but there is CGT. I believe the same applies to everything which isn't legal tender in the UK.

Reason being I have a decent stash of such coins, including some Sov's, I paid around £5000 for all in, but now worth about £15000 at the gold dealers scrap prices.

I'm not going to cash them in, but certainly don't want to pay CGT on them when I do!

Vast majority of my holding is in Bullionvault in Switzerland. There seems to be some nasty new legislation on taxing UK deposits in Swiss banks at extortionate rates. I have no idea if this also applies to vaulted bullion?

Sorry...I'm not an expert. I don't know how any of this applies to allocated accounts like Bullionvault.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom