gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
No. But if Scrut didn't sell anything today, he didn't "lose" any money.

Everyone at work today was moaning about "the hit" that their 401(k)'s took. I finally asked one of them, "Did you cash out of your plan today?" They said no. "So," I asked them, "What exactly did you lose?"

They couldn't answer. They didn't seem to understand that while their 401(k) might not be worth what it was yesterday, they haven't "lost" any money unless they cash it in when it is worth less than they put into it. And only a pea-brain would do that. If you have $1000 worth of stock and the price drops to where it's only worth $500 you don't sell it then, you hang onto it until the price is somewhere above $1000. If you aren't ready to roll with the changes (and possibly get shafted in the deal, it happens), bury your money in a mason jar in the backyard.

Wow, let me get this straight. Are you saying unrealized losses aren't the same as realized losses? If true this would be revelatory news. Did they all perk up when you told them they could just hold their positions for as long as it takes until the market recovers? You might have the makings of a top notch FA! The mason jar advice is epic, I'm sure all the fiat money fanboys appriciate that.
 
Gold is always a lousy investment in the long run, because it doesn't produce anything.

Yes, of course. Gold is a safe haven, not an investment. It's a place where you can store your wealth, and be sure it's still worth something later.

If you want to grow your wealth, you need to invest in businesses. Of course, for that you need businesses that are growing.
 
Wow, let me get this straight. Are you saying unrealized losses aren't the same as realized losses? If true this would be revelatory news. Did they all perk up when you told them they could just hold their positions for as long as it takes until the market recovers? You might have the makings of a top notch FA! The mason jar advice is epic, I'm sure all the fiat money fanboys appriciate that.

No, but it isn't a reason to panic right now.

Buy low, sell high. I thought that was fairly well known. ;)
 
Last edited:
If you have $1000 worth of stock and the price drops to where it's only worth $500 you don't sell it then, you hang onto it until the price is somewhere above $1000. If you aren't ready to roll with the changes (and possibly get shafted in the deal, it happens), bury your money in a mason jar in the backyard.

Depends on the fundamentals. If the $1000 was overpriced, and the $500 was still overpriced, you'd be better off selling it at $500 instead of waiting for the price to settle on the correct value.
 
In order for that to work, you need somebody else who will sell it low, and buy it high. ;)


Right. And if you're in the stock market trying to make a living, that's the rub.

But the people I'm talking about are not serious players, they're just people invested in a 401(k) through their jobs. They're carrying on like they have to sell this investment tomorrow and live the rest of their lives on the proceeds. One bump in the road right now doesn't mean they're going to spend the future eating dog food, if you get my drift. It's not a good sign, to be sure, but if you're holding this investment for thirty more years, it isn't a reason to jump out of a high rise or get yourself fitted for a barrel just yet.
 
But the people I'm talking about are not serious players, they're just people invested in a 401(k) through their jobs. They're carrying on like they have to sell this investment tomorrow and live the rest of their lives on the proceeds. One bump in the road right now doesn't mean they're going to spend the future eating dog food, if you get my drift.

Correct. As long as you also don't cheer about your profits on a good day, a bad day (or even a bad couple of years) shouldn't matter.

I'd still worry about 401(k) plans in general, but for another reason. When the baby-boomers retire, how many "greater fools" will buy their stocks ? At some point in time, stocks will have to be sold to buy groceries every day, no matter what the price is.
 
I'm pleasantly surprised by the poll, if this many intelligent people don't yet get it, it's hardly a bubble yet, it will be one day though.

but there's a full on mania to come first with the dumb money all finally piling in near the top, as the early birds are all cashing out into real estate and stocks once the ratios get back to somewhere near the lows of the cycle.
 
I'm pleasantly surprised by the poll, if this many intelligent people don't yet get it, it's hardly a bubble yet, it will be one day though.

but there's a full on mania to come first with the dumb money all finally piling in near the top, as the early birds are all cashing out into real estate and stocks once the ratios get back to somewhere near the lows of the cycle.

Exactly what I was thinking. When the same bears come back in a few years to tell me that gold is going up, they can have some of mine.
 
Well, in some circles, it's just "buy gold, it's cheap as long as you can buy it with money." In a few years, we'll be getting wonderful conspiracy theories on how Goldman Sachs or some other Jews cheated all goldbugs out of their well-deserved fortune.

Maybe. ;)
 
Well, in some circles, it's just "buy gold, it's cheap as long as you can buy it with money." In a few years, we'll be getting wonderful conspiracy theories on how Goldman Sachs or some other Jews cheated all goldbugs out of their well-deserved fortune.

So I take it you're short gold then. No? So it's just more ignorant, racist blather out of your mouth, as per usual. STFU and short gold, put your money where your mouth is. That way you will actually lose money for being wrong, like you've been wrong on this forum for years now.
 
So I take it you're short gold then. No? So it's just more ignorant, racist blather out of your mouth, as per usual. STFU and short gold, put your money where your mouth is. That way you will actually lose money for being wrong, like you've been wrong on this forum for years now.

Oh, did you think I was talking about you? Why?
 
So I take it you're short gold then.

If somebody is negative on gold, it doesn't mean they should logically be shorting it. A simple reason could be that they lack the funds to do so. Or maybe they don't like the risk of being wrong, or maybe they can't predict the timing, or maybe there are other financial opportunities with an even higher yield.
 
So I take it you're short gold then. No? So it's just more ignorant, racist blather out of your mouth, as per usual. STFU and short gold, put your money where your mouth is. That way you will actually lose money for being wrong, like you've been wrong on this forum for years now.

Gold is buoyed by the greater fool theory as it has been since the time of the pharaohs. There are still piles of idiots out there willing to pay 2K, 4K--hell, $100,000--an ounce if they thought someone else would eventually pay them more for it.

Anyone gambling on price stability or ROI or any other metric regarding gold or any other metal (either way) is overdue for a psychiatric examination at the very least.
 
Anyone gambling on price stability or ROI or any other metric regarding gold or any other metal (either way) is overdue for a psychiatric examination at the very least.

Suppose you had some money to save for later. What is a better place than gold regarding the criteria you mentioned ?

I don't know many investments that you could have bought in the time of the pharaohs, and still sell for a decent return today.
 
Suppose you had some money to save for later. What is a better place than gold regarding the criteria you mentioned ?

I don't know many investments that you could have bought in the time of the pharaohs, and still sell for a decent return today.

It depends on when later is and naturally any transaction fees. If I had gold right now then I'd sell it.
 
If somebody is negative on gold, it doesn't mean they should logically be shorting it. A simple reason could be that they lack the funds to do so. Or maybe they don't like the risk of being wrong, or maybe they can't predict the timing, or maybe there are other financial opportunities with an even higher yield.

Why do you feel the need to enumerate every possible reason for why someone logically shouldn't necessarily be doing this or that? Do you think these possibilities aren't obvious, or are only visible to you, and that you need to reveal them as nuggets of imparted wisdom on a forum? Here's my logic. I'm tired of dumb trolls who have not only been wrong, but spectacularly wrong in the past, making useless predictions in the form of useless posts, filled with race baiting garbage. Put up, or shut up. Here's betting he won't do either, and just continue to look stupid. I was just entertained reading some of his past posts on the subject. I will just post some links to old threads if he persists, though with his shamelessness it will probably not make much difference, except to other readers.

I must confess, I'm not all that annoyed. I'm up over 500% on gold alone. He's been, well, wrong as usual.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom