Gold Bugs must feel pretty stupid today.

But for hundreds of years the "lead role" was assigned exclusively to Jews, until that became frowned upon due to events in the 1940s.

Now code words are used instead.

The problem here, of course, is that if the "code-words" are actually the only ways to describe various institutions or political movements, and people like you get to choose the code-words, then you can effectively (at least in small-minded people) associate any legitimate criticism of the institutions or politics in question with bigotry and racism.

I'll give an example. The state of Israel is considered a "jewish state". But it is also a sovereign nation, with it's own politics, and political agendas. Whether you agree or disagree with, like or dislike its policies or actions, it is a sovereign nation with a political agenda that, like any other sovereign nation, must be held accountable and subject to legitimate criticism, where deserved. But if people like you can claim that any criticism of Israel is by definition racist, then this gives a free pass to Israel to enact whatever policies it wants, with no repercussions.

The same thing with banking. If "bankers" is really code for "jews", which is ridiculous, then clearly the entire banking industry is beyond criticism, as only a vicious anti-semite would dare criticize it. Just because some bigots have, in your mind, co-opted criticism of banking, doesn't mean that their specific non-bigoted conclusions aren't valid, or that the related criticism of others isn't valid. You and people like you (no, not jews) are ultimately just trying to employ a version of the ad hominem fallacy, because you have repeatedly failed to provide substantial counter-arguments. What makes it even more transparent, is that the only evidence you have that anyone who disagrees with you is a racist, are the code-words which you yourself have designated as racist.
 
well if anyone's interested in discussing the OP at all, apparently "we" aren't, apparently lots of us, unprecedented amounts almost, are feeling quite pleased with themselves currently, at our new bargain buys. :D

Chinese Gold & Silver Exchange Society Runs Out of Gold... Importing from Switzerland and London

Chinese Gold & Silver exchange http://www.cgse.com.hk/en/about_01.php

The Chinese Gold and Silver Exchange Society operates in Hong Kong as a registered society. At present, we have 171 member firms which are sole proprietorships, partnerships or limited companies. Among these 171 firms, 30 are bullion group members. Bullion group members who want to manufacture good delivery bars may apply for the qualification of accredited refineries. Upon accreditation, these member firms may produce 99% fineness 5-tael gold bullions and 999.9% 1-kg gold bullions for delivery on the Exchange. The bullions they produce also circulate widely in the open market. To encourage more industry players to participate in spot gold market, we accept settlement accreditation applications from non members.

watch the Bloomberg interview with the head of the exchange if you can.

Hong Kong’s Chinese Gold & Silver Exchange Society has been in operations for over a century, and it’s President Haywood Cheung was interviewed by Bloomberg news earlier today. Whoever orchestrated the attack on gold and silver in the last week or so has gravely miscalculated, since the response to the drop has been surging demand for physical gold and silver.

While I tend to be skeptical when I hear about silver shortages since these reports have been so exaggerated in the past, the lack of silver coin availability and premiums are the most extreme I have seen since the financial and economic meltdown of 2008. Now we discover that the Chinese Gold & Silver Exchange Society has essentially sold out of gold bullion, and must wait until Wednesday for shipments to arrive from Switzerland and London.

hahaha had to add this, message from Chinese Gold exchange to Paul Krugman

http://www.flickr.com/photos/expd/8661920104/
 
Last edited:
very interesting article with an angle even I have never heard of / seen before and a compelling argument.

http://www.alhambrapartners.com/2013/04/15/we-have-seen-gold-prices-act-like-this-before/

gold holds a property in banking that makes it especially valuable (pun intended) – it is universal. It crosses national boundaries easily. In the modern financial world of short-term liabilities and wholesale money, this universality can come in handy. A US$ mortgage bond can obtain a bank wholesale repo funding only in US$’s, but gold can obtain “repo” funding in any currency trading.

That means in times of extreme stress, gold acts like a universal liquidity stopgap – when all else fails, repo gold. The operational reality of a gold repo is a gold lease, charged at the forward rate (GOFO). In terms of market mechanics, a dramatic increase in gold leasing is seen as a massive increase in supply on the paper markets.

For various reasons in the past five years, collateral chains and the available collateral pool has dwindled dramatically. That has left banks to scramble for operational bypasses, but it also has led to periods of very acute stress.

When we match the price of gold against these stressed periods, they coincide perfectly. In other words, whenever collateralized lending has become problematic banks appeal to the universal collateral. Unfortunately, that looks like gold selling to the uninitiated.
 
So Scrut has nearly completely derailed this thread with this:



It's so obvious. So trite. So concise. So efficient.

Man, I need to take some lessons. He truly is a god among posers.
Why does Scrut get all the credit when others (in all seriousness) made the comment before him?
 
CBC had a very interesting documentary on gold last night. Unfortunately it says the video is only available within Canada: The Secret World of Gold.

Maybe people can find other ways to access it.

It was a fascinating account of countries' relationship to their economies and the gold in their nations' vaults. Also some banks "leased" gold, which is ludicrous on its face, and the organizations that took out the leases then sold the gold. The lending banks then continue to use the ghost gold as assets.

The whole affair is quite specious.
 
If gold is high...Yay! our investment is awesome!. If gold is low...Yay! we can buy it up!



No downside.


:cool:
 
CBC had a very interesting documentary on gold last night. Unfortunately it says the video is only available within Canada: The Secret World of Gold.

Maybe people can find other ways to access it.

It was a fascinating account of countries' relationship to their economies and the gold in their nations' vaults. Also some banks "leased" gold, which is ludicrous on its face, and the organizations that took out the leases then sold the gold. The lending banks then continue to use the ghost gold as assets.

The whole affair is quite specious.

its on Youtube, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4wgbpGF9kT0

didn't watch yet, but they edited out all the whistleblower testimony the CTFC have been sitting on for years.
 
Velocity: The X Factor for Hard Asset Investors

MoneyMorning.com.au puts forward a theory for the decline in hard asset prices.

It centres on this chart:
mmw20130420a.jpg


It says that despite the money printing by the Fed, the velocity of money (how much people spend relative to the money supply) is decreasing. If Ben Bernanke continues with his attempts to stimulate inflation, he might not be able to control the end result and that is when precious metals will be worth having.
 
MoneyMorning.com.au puts forward a theory for the decline in hard asset prices.

It centres on this chart:
[qimg]http://www.moneymorning.com.au/images/mmw20130420a.jpg[/qimg]

It says that despite the money printing by the Fed, the velocity of money (how much people spend relative to the money supply) is decreasing. If Ben Bernanke continues with his attempts to stimulate inflation, he might not be able to control the end result and that is when precious metals will be worth having.

it could be a slow moving macro factor or reason for a trend change perhaps, but it doesn't explain once in 4500 year moves very readily, nor the 174% rise from the 2008 low to the 2011 highs does it?

it would lend further credence to the theory (and my longheld opinion) that QE is all about trying to prop up the shadow banking system anyway, and that it wont ever stop until it's too late though.

Scrut appears to think that 5 perfect correlations with previous hard price falls and rapidly escalating banking problems under the hood in the last 5 years dont mean anything. It almost seems to me he is perennially trying to argue that this time is different, well from what one can perceive from "Da Jooz" and laughing dogs anyway. maybe I give him too much credit.

Lets look at the facts as we know them.

1. On Thursday Obama has meeting with CEOs of the biggest US banks

2. Friday am Comex (US trading hours) gold (and silver) stumble into a once in our galactic lifetime down move

3. A Bullion bank (supposedly Merril) short sold 0.15% of global production in what can only be realistically described as highly suspect, or absolutely desperate trading activity. A large forced liquidation on margin calls could in theory produce similar moves, although as this has happened many thousands of times in the market and not produced anything like this kind of response, there is definitely something unusual about this one as noted in virtually all media, whichever slant they put on it.

4. That there is significant correlation between major gold declines and periods of deteriorating deflationary banking stress under the hood, for *unknown* (or apparently just funny if you are Scrut :boggled: ) reasons.

5. Mining is a rapidly increasingly expensive business, that can produce nasty financial surprises, legal, geopolitical and natural, the average estimated cash cost of both metals is about where the futures price is now, and that approximately 14% of US silver production just went offline for a year or two ie 5 million Oz from 36 million annually

6. There has already been record demand all year at street level at the US mint. For silver Jan was an all time record, followed by another in Feb, and would have been followed by another again in March too, were it not for dubious accounting adding the last week of March, onto April's figures (on Easter Monday while closed)

7. That the US mint sell approximately the same $ for $ value of gold, to silver, so with a GSR at 50-60:1 that's 50x as much silver as gold, and the ratio that it comes out of the ground at is more like 17:1

8. That the futures prices decline has seemingly spurred what could fairly be described as a run on physical metals at street level at multiple locations all around the world this last week, and many dealers have sold out of Silver products en masse at considerably higher street prices than futures suggest, and are now dealing with supply chain delays, and premiums diverging significantly from futures price in places.

9. That the gold price has considerably more room for elasticity than silver, as it is primarily investment demand, and not also essential to many major industries. As silver is generally used in small quantities per unit produced, much higher prices could be absorbed easily into their business models. this would appear to be corroborated by gold margins not rising comparatively (unless you believe some of the more outlandish stories of $2000 per Oz if you want tons of it right now)

10. That (for almost the first time in documented history) 95% of the speculative market (trading herd) were right in shorting the metals and are now in decent profit on those trades.

..once they close them out with a buy order, anyway.

interesting times approaching I think, one way or another.
 
Last edited:
I also received this last week by email. BV are a global company so I would contend that their stats are a reasonable representation of "world view" by physical owners

A gold bull’s broken confidence? Not just yet.

BullionVault’s CEO, Paul Tustain, reflects on the week.


Dear BullionVault user,

My personal gold valuation has lost about 14% since 2nd April. Gold is by far my largest investment holding, so I am taking a hit.

Markets overshoot, and they correct … both ways. I don’t forget that the dizzy top of 6th September 2011 was followed by a $400 per ounce reverse in 3 weeks.

Neither do I forget that currencies with large debt overhangs, run by governments which have extreme fiscal problems, will tumble into unpredictable and spectacular failure sooner or later.

That’s neither a unique nor brilliant insight and very large numbers of people agree with me. We shouldn’t be too surprised when a few of them sell during counter-trend phases of a complicated journey.

Here’s a thought which reminds me to keep my cool:- The significant majority of the tiny number who eventually succeed in holding onto their wealth through a failure of their currency will be those who acted as the storm gathered and bought gold. By the end they will have been through the mill, having endured countless hours of anguished doubt.

But when the market tests them, with temporary movements against them, they will be resolute, provided of course
they have the fundamental confidence in their own judgement of the process of their national economic unravelling. This is what it takes to be a successful investor through the failure of a money system.

I believe I am still on the right side of the long term decline of Sterling, even if I also believe that market commentators will, for a while, be right as gold bears. In time I expect the upturn to be as sharp as this setback. Were I to sell before that upturn I don’t trust myself to switch fast depreciating Sterling back into gold at suddenly much higher prices. It would be just too painful.

Markets don’t offer smooth passage. They pitch up after each trough and slump over every crest. It gets rough from time to time, so you batten down the hatches, point her steadfastly to the wind, and trust she’ll take the beating. She will, if you hold your course.

In the meantime here are some BullionVault statistics from the last few days, which I think offer a useful reminder about how markets work. Remember, first of all, that for all those people who sold in a bit of a panic, someone bought...

* Monday and Tuesday were our strongest 48 hour period for new customers this year.

* Since Friday the gross value of customer bullion sales increased markedly. About 1% of gold we look after was sold back to the main market. That was characterised by a few large sellers. Holders of 99% of BullionVault inventory were not panicked.

* Those who did sell have mostly not withdrawn their cash from the BullionVault system. To me that suggests they may be intending to buy back into gold sooner rather than later.

* We normally have about 230 deposits a day (300 on a Monday) and about 100 withdrawals a day (120 on a Monday). Mondays are usually higher because they include weekend activity.

* On Monday we had 723 deposits versus 284 withdrawals. On Tuesday we had 732 deposits versus 150 withdrawals.

* Monday was a record day for business transacted, beating the previous peak of September 2011.
Regards,

Paul Tustain, Director

seems like the physical metals buying public at large have worked out what BTFD means and are taking a punt.
 
Last edited:
I also received this last week by email. BV are a global company so I would contend that their stats are a reasonable representation of "world view" by physical owners



seems like the physical metals buying public at large have worked out what BTFD means and are taking a punt.

A standard letter they send to all the rubes...err...I mean "customers".
 
it could be a slow moving macro factor or reason for a trend change perhaps, but it doesn't explain once in 4500 year moves very readily, nor the 174% rise from the 2008 low to the 2011 highs does it?
Money Morning has been spruiking gold all year so I guess they have to come up with some face saving explanation. Clearly, picking how the paper gold traders will affect the price of gold is something where a detailed analysis is not much different to the dart board approach.

However, the main message seems to be that what ever the short term gold price variations might be, precious metals are still a good hedge against the currency wars. Bullion sales (especially in small amounts) are up so a lot of people must be thinking the same way.
 
A standard letter they send to all the rubes...err...I mean "customers".

are you saying you disbelieve their figures? :rolleyes:

BV are externally audited every single day they have definitely got the gold they say they have.

http://www.bullionvault.com/audit.do

What is the Daily Audit?
BullionVault is the only bullion business that publishes a Daily Audit online. It proves that your gold, silver and currency are where they should be in full every day.

How? The audit shows you the full list of BullionVault's user records. You will see that these public records contain your correct balances. That is true for all other BullionVault users too.

The audit also shows you the vault bar lists from our independent secure storage specialists holding your bullion in the vaults.

The sum total of bullion belonging to BullionVault users matches exactly to the quantity being cared for by our storage specialists. This reconciliation is open to public scrutiny. No double counting is possible. You can make the same check for client money, using the bank account statements from Lloyds TSB. The documents are further verified by independent financial auditors, Albert Goodman, who publish a report on BullionVault's Daily Audit process on their website.
To check your holdings in the Daily Audit, please look for your "nickname" in the alphabetical list. For your security, this is not the same as your username. To confirm your public nickname, log in and go to Account > Settings.

The Daily Audit relies on delivery of documents both from our banks and our vault operators. There may be days when we cannot publish a full audit because we cannot guarantee their submission of documents in good time.

so BV don't have the luxury of hiding secrecy behind "National Security" laws nor the "freedom of accounting" enjoyed by the TBTF (but already did once in 2009) bullion banks in their dealings.

this is why (most) people believe it's there in this instance.
 
I would rather go to the Perth Mint myself. The numbers on their bars of gold look pretty accurate.

you might have to queue..

Gold sales from Australia’s Perth Mint, which refines nearly all of the nation’s bullion, surged after prices plunged, adding to signs that the metal’s slump to a two-year low is spurring increased demand.

“The volume of business that we’re putting through is way in excess of double what we did last week,” Treasurer Nigel Moffatt said by phone, without giving precise figures. “There’s been people running through the gate.”

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...ng-of-business-at-australia-s-perth-mint.html

and margins, where you going to store it, selling it again.. BV's the way forwards for me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom