Gold Bugs must feel pretty stupid today.

If gold is such a great investment, why would you ever sell? Just wait and it will go up. Sell when you retire.
Even if currencies don't collapse or gold doesn't see a spectacular rise, that might still be the best advice on this thread.
 
Even if currencies don't collapse or gold doesn't see a spectacular rise, that might still be the best advice on this thread.

Oh yeah. Tie up all your money in an investment that gives you nothing for decades, and then sell for the approx value of what you paid for it originally + inflation. Well done, you've successfully trod water.
 
Oh yeah. Tie up all your money in an investment that gives you nothing for decades, and then sell for the approx value of what you paid for it originally + inflation. Well done, you've successfully trod water.
I meant that it is better than trying to chase the highs and lows.

OTOH there might be more profitable ways to invest your money - if you get lucky - but treading water isn't a bad way to be nowadays.
 
Oh yeah. Tie up all your money in an investment that gives you nothing for decades, and then sell for the approx value of what you paid for it originally + inflation. Well done, you've successfully trod water.

lots of decades where this is entirely incorrect. although like inflation adjusted home ownership (below) at times it has been a fairly static proposition.


Inflation-Adjusted+U.S.+Home+Prices+Since+1900.jpg
 
If you are trying to suppress debate by playing the race card then the only reasonable inference I can make is that there really is a gold cartel and you are trying to protect it.

And if he isn´t trying to suppress the debate, but instead to point out that gold bug nutters would rather blame the Jews for anything bad happening rather than admit that gold isn´t everything they´re cracking it up to be? What "reasonable inference" can you make then?
 
And if he isn´t trying to suppress the debate, but instead to point out that gold bug nutters would rather blame the Jews for anything bad happening rather than admit that gold isn´t everything they´re cracking it up to be? What "reasonable inference" can you make then?

if you knew the poster's history with always dragging this up everywhere, in every financial thread, you would understand what inferences to make more clearly.
 
There's still that persistent rumor about Cyprus planning to dump a bunch of gold. That has to factor into the current situation somewhere. We're seeing a confluence of down pressures on gold that broke the support. Let's see where it goes from here before we declare "gold is dead".
 
There's still that persistent rumor about Cyprus planning to dump a bunch of gold. That has to factor into the current situation somewhere. We're seeing a confluence of down pressures on gold that broke the support. Let's see where it goes from here before we declare "gold is dead".

Cyprus has such a tiny amount of gold this is utterly meaningless. 13.9 tonnes, compared to the 500+ that got this rolling all in one trading session.

what some traders were inferring from the Cyprus announcement was the *template* possibility of all Euro disintegrating countries being forced to sell their gold to cover gaps between bailouts and deficits, along with the coming bail - ins.

Portugal for example have lots of gold and are (very shortly) back up at the bailout trough after (before?) Ireland's upcoming second one..
 
Last edited:
lots of decades where this is entirely incorrect.

Wrong. If you hold gold for decades, it gives you exactly a 0% return on your investment during the period between buying and selling. That's a whole lot of return you could be getting elsewhere to re-invest.

although like inflation adjusted home ownership (below) at times it has been a fairly static proposition.


[qimg]http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-kjOHoEKbH7A/ULQgiAZ45RI/AAAAAAAABh4/8U-RJx1-pGg/s1600/Inflation-Adjusted+U.S.+Home+Prices+Since+1900.jpg[/qimg]

Except of course that you can rent out a home during those decades. Nobody wants to borrow your gold.
 
So.. gold is a fantastic inflation hedge and a terrific store of wealth -- until someone starts a rumor?

I've never been an advocate of gold as a routine investment. Buying and holding some physical gold if you can makes sense from an emergency standpoint (hedging against a hyperinflation, for example), but I would never recommend it as an "earning" investment unless you are going to be doing it as a buy-sell-buy-sell speculative investment.

That I think is what happened to the gold price. The rumors about Cyprus/Portugal/et al combined with other economic data to trigger a minor "run for the exit" on the part of the speculative portion of the gold market. I expect the "insurance" investors to either hold pat or attempt to increase their holdings on the downsell.

That's why I said that we should wait and see what happens next before making any declaratives to the effect of "it's over for gold".
 
And if he isn´t trying to suppress the debate, but instead to point out that gold bug nutters would rather blame the Jews for anything bad happening rather than admit that gold isn´t everything they´re cracking it up to be? What "reasonable inference" can you make then?
That he is a racist.
 
Even if currencies don't collapse or gold doesn't see a spectacular rise, that might still be the best advice on this thread.

Oh yeah. Tie up all your money in an investment that gives you nothing for decades, and then sell for the approx value of what you paid for it originally + inflation. Well done, you've successfully trod water.

I meant that it is better than trying to chase the highs and lows.

OTOH there might be more profitable ways to invest your money - if you get lucky - but treading water isn't a bad way to be nowadays.

Successfully not losing your ass is a heck of a lot better than many people manage to do. Making money? Yeah, no, it's no good way to make money, but "buy, hold, and make one or two percent at best" is... well, it's better than a savings account :)
 
That he is a racist.

And that you are the useful idiot defending him against the correction interpretation of his racist attacks by making false accusations against those who see him for what he is.
 
I've never been an advocate of gold as a routine investment. Buying and holding some physical gold if you can makes sense from an emergency standpoint (hedging against a hyperinflation, for example), but I would never recommend it as an "earning" investment unless you are going to be doing it as a buy-sell-buy-sell speculative investment.

That I think is what happened to the gold price. The rumors about Cyprus/Portugal/et al combined with other economic data to trigger a minor "run for the exit" on the part of the speculative portion of the gold market. I expect the "insurance" investors to either hold pat or attempt to increase their holdings on the downsell.

That's why I said that we should wait and see what happens next before making any declaratives to the effect of "it's over for gold".

I voted "don't know" on the prediction thread before all this happened and I agree that we really don't know. The problem with gold-bugs is that they never identify an appropriate level at which they will turn in their gold for something useful--like cash. They also rarely confront the evidence supplied--usually by TCS as KO or some other dividend investment with a capital gains upside to it. My own preferences are Intel and Qualcomm.

Many gold-bugs won't sell at 1,700 an oz or even 2,500 an oz. So how exactly does gold qualify as an investment?

Some people also seem to overlook the fact that gold is not a hedge against anything at all and that the US government once simply confiscated all of it. In fact, it's really easy to confiscate and has none of the downside of confiscating equities or even cash hidden under your mattress.

My judgement of all of this is that gold-bugs get exactly what they deserve for this myopic and irrational attachment to a commodity. They wouldn't do it with orange juice or pork bellies. Their luck finally ran out after a pretty decent decade but, of course, none of them sold so they didn't even realise any of their gains.
 
That, and have other folks pay for your house, which you can then sell.

Friends of mine did that. They would buy distressed apartment buildings, move in, renovate, and then rent them out, finally getting another and moving and renting their space in the original place.

I'm not much of a carpenter, or I would have emulated that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom