God's existence, and man-made concepts and words

Who's into evasion? Well you are Gerry...Post #414

Everyone has seen your act; Will you continue evading Post #414?


I'm going to take a nap now, so when I come back perhaps you will have addressed Post # 414 by that time.
X's note: removed large-size text to simplify quote; replaced with bolded text.


I appreciate the attention my posts is receiving, it's nice to know I contributed something of value. But it is, I think, unfair to lump all the credit on me. I will grant that my post is the broadest in scope, but others have made valuable contributions as well (some of which I used as inspiration for post #414).

To that end, let me once again pimp the posts I think are deserving of yrreg's attention. I will not give myself airs by prioritizing them in any manner other than order of creation.

We are not going to play your game until you honestly and sincerely address Bruto's post (link), my post (link), Kid Eager's post (link), Sun Countess' post (link), Slingblade's post (link), Dancing David's post (link), and Loss Leader's post (link).
 
We seem to have skipped stage 4.

If this follows the typical yrreG pattern:

1. yrreG has it handed to him
2. yrreG realizes it long after everyone else does
3. yrreG turns tail and flees the thread
4. yrreG licks his wounds and goes into hibernation mode
5. yrreG starts a new thread and never mentions this one again
6. yrreG eventually convinces himself that he won against the evil atheists
 
When are you going to start using logical arguments in this thread as I told you to do?

As you could see in the other thread, according to Yrreg logic is something dumb atheists use to 'trick' smart theists into stop believing in God.
 
As you could see in the other thread, according to Yrreg logic is something dumb atheists use to 'trick' smart theists into stop believing in God.
And he decided to cross the road and reduce to shards the core of that pert belief call science by asking the mathematical formulation of the lack of deities prior to the Big Bang (what is comfortably expressed by a single blank space -or many ones, if one is a polytheist-).
 
For those who are always repeatedly abusing me that I have not presented my argument for the thesis that the universe is the evidence for God's existence, here it is:

1. First we agree on the concepts of God and the universe as:

God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
​

2. Then we present
the fact of the nose existing in the universe so it is a part and parcel of the universe.​

3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.​

4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.​

5. Wherefore
everything in the universe has need of an agent to bring them to the beginning of their existence.​

6. And this fact that everything in the universe has a need of an agent to bring them to existence and the fact that they do exist,
that double fact is the evidence that:​

7. There is an agent which I call
God, who is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​

Thus, from the realm of concepts we arrive at the realm of real actualities in
the existence of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.​
​

That is what I call proof from evidence by way of ratiocination i.e. reasoning on facts which facts make up evidence.

Yrreg

Here are concerns I have with your proof.

1. In points 5 and 6 you conclude that an agent is necessary for everything in the universe. However, you present no analysis that the same agent applies to every thing.

2. In point 7, where you call an agent "God", that definition does not further the analysis of the evidence to establish a proof because definitions do not constitute evidence or proof.

3. You have provided no analysis that the agents in points 5 and 6 are the same as the agent in point 7.

Until these issues are resolved the conclusion of your proof is invalid.
 
4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.​

You really don't see the problem with this statement? Seriously? Because one thing in the universe possesses an attribute, EVERY thing in the universe must possess that attribute?
 
Dear X, let us go back to your step by step reply to my argument.

highlighting mine


"Part and partial"? That makes even less sense than "parcel".


And no, yrreg. We are not going to follow your breadcrumbs.



Dear X, let us go back to your step by step reply to my argument.



Yrreg
 
Here is the reply I gave to you on your reaction to my argument.

Here is the reply I gave to you on your reaction to my argument.

Please read my text in the bolded enlarged font.


Okay, let us deal with your first comment.
Originally Posted by X

Originally Posted by yrreg
For those who are always repeatedly abusing me that I have not presented my argument for the thesis that the universe is the evidence for God's existence, here it is:
Thank you.



Originally Posted by yrreg
1. First we agree on the concepts of God and the universe as:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.

I have mentioned before that your definition of god is so vague as to be useless, but for the sake of argument I agreed to let it stand. This was before your inserted the added detail of it being the Christian god. I will still honour my agreement and accept your definitions for the purpose of looking at your proof of god. But I reject the a-priori Christian assumption as unnecessary. Your argument will work for any god equally well. Once you've proven the existence of a god, you may freely argue that Christianity, specifically, is true. But that's best saved for another thread.

Thus,
Definition 1: God is the pre-existing maker of the universe.
Definition 2: The Universe is everything that exists, be the things known or unknown to us.



Originally Posted by yrreg
2. Then we present
the fact of the nose existing in the universe so it is a part and parcel of the universe.

I see no reason to quibble over this; the statement is fundamentally correct based on your definition of the Universe, which I have accepted for the sake of argument.

Thus,
Premise 1: The nose exists and thus is part of the universe.



Originally Posted by yrreg
3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.

I will state that I had some reservations about this one. "Beginning" and "ending", in reference to the nose, is vague. Are we counting left-to-right, top-to-bottom, bottom-to-top? Or are you referring to a start of formation (fetal development) and end of formation (death and decay)? The wording here is vague enough to allow equivocation. This is why I specified, in my post accepting the point for argument purposes, the bridge of the nose as the beginning and the tip of the nose as the end. If you wish to argue on a time-base definition o beginning and end, I suggest changeing your object of reference from the nose (a physical, geometric object) to a temporal one like life.

Thus,
Premise 2: The nose has a physical, geometric beginning and an end point (the bridge and tip, respectfully).



Originally Posted by yrreg
4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.

Stop. This is a non-sequiturWP. The non-sequitur fallacy ("non sequitur" means "does not follow") is an argument in which the premise does not support the conclusion. Here, your premise, which I have accepted with noted reservations, is that the nose has a beginning and end (see Premise 2. Your conclusion, that everything in the universe has a beginning and ending, is not in any way supported by the premise. I suggest you find a way to prove that everything in the universe has a beginning and end, and not try to broadcast the features on one object onto the whole universe.
Further, you are still playing fast and lose with the definition of "beginning" and "ending". You never clarified if you we speak on a time-basis or shape-basis. This is equivocation, another fallacy, but I have a feeling we'll get to that later. It's unimportant right now, as this is a non-sequitur using either basis. But I suggest you clarify what you mean, be defining beginning and end clearly (make them Definition 3 and Definition 4).

Thus,
Conclusion 1 (NS & UT): From Premise 2, everything in the universe has a beginning and ending.
INVALID: NON-SEQUITUR.
INVALID: UNDEFINED TERMS.



Originally Posted by yrreg
5. Wherefore
everything in the universe has need of an agent to bring them to the beginning of their existence.

Stop. This is an equivocationWP. The equivocation fallacy (in this case arising from your ambiguous use of the terms "beginning" and "end") is an argument in which a term having more than one meaning is used misleadingly. It can be both formal and informal. In this case, it is a formal fallacy. I suggest, as before, that you clarify your terms (in this case, clarifying whether you are referring to "beginning" and "end" as shape-based properties or time-based properties.

Stop. This is a non-sequiturWP. Here, your premise, Conclusion 1, which is in turn flawed, is that everything in the universe has a beginning and end. Your conclusion, that everything in the universe requires an agent to make them begin, is not in any way supported by the premise. I suggest you find a way to prove that everything that "begins" requires an agent to begin it.

Stop. This is an argument implicitly based on a premise (Conclusion 1) shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a second time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Conclusion 1.

Stop. This is an argument implicitly based on a premise (Premise 3) shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a third time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Premise 3.

Thus,
Premise 3 (implied) (NS & UD): Everything that begins has a cause
INVALID: NON-SEQUITUR.
INVALID: UNDEFINED TERMS.

Conclusion 2 (EQUIV & FP): From Conclusion 1 (NS & UT) and Premise 3 (NS & UT), the universe has need of an agent to cause it to begin.
INVALID: EQUIVOCATION.
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (CONCLUSION 1: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (PREMISE 3: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).



Originally Posted by yrreg
6. And this fact that everything in the universe has a need of an agent to bring them to existence and the fact that they do exist,
that double fact is the evidence that:
7. There is an agent which I call
God, who is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Stop. This is a non-sequiturWP. Your conclusion that there exists a god who created the universe (based on Definition 1) is based on a flawed premise (Conclusion 2)


Stop. This is an argument based on a premise (Conclusion 2) shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a second time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Conclusion 2.

Stop. This is an argument based on a premise (Conclusion 2) whose premise (Conclusion 1) is shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise, which in turn uses another fallacious argument as its premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a third time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Conclusion 1.

Stop. This is an argument based on a premise (Conclusion 2) whose premise (Premise 3) is shown to be flawed. So you are making a fallacious argument using fallacious argument as your premise, which in turn uses another fallacious argument as its premise. This means that this part of your argument is invalid a fourth time. I suggest you correct the flaws to Premise 3.

Thus,
Conclusion 3 (NS & FP & FP): From Conclusion 2 (EQUIV & FP), there is an agent called "god" who caused the universe to exist.
INVALID: NON-SEQUITUR
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (CONCLUSION 2: EQUIVOCATION & FALLACIOUS PREMISE & FALLACIOUS PREMISE).
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (CONCLUSION 1: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).
INVALID: FALLACIOUS PREMISE (PREMISE 3: NON-SEQUITUR & UNDEFINED TERMS).


Originally Posted by yrreg
Thus, from the realm of concepts we arrive at the realm of real actualities in
the existence of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Your argument fails, yrreg. Even accepting your uselessly vague definition of god for the sake of argument, it fails. It has logical fallacies piled on top of logical fallacies, undefined terms and misleading examples of those terms. Above, I have shown where it fails, and provided you with suggestions on where to fix it. In addition to the noted suggestions, I also suggest you improve your definition of god so that it is not as amorphously worded. I have spent well over an hour writing this post, and I think it stands as evidence that I have given your proof of god due consideration, and avoided mockery, evasion, blind-thinking, and whatever other buzzwords you've latched onto.

Ball's in your court.


ETA: This argument is nothing new, yrreg. It's called the "Cosmological Argument"WP, or "First Cause Argument". It dates back to Plato and Aristotle, and has always been flawed.




Okay, let us deal with your first comment:

Originally Posted by X
Originally Posted by yrreg
3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.


I will state that I had some reservations about this one. "Beginning" and "ending", in reference to the nose, is vague. Are we counting left-to-right, top-to-bottom, bottom-to-top? Or are you referring to a start of formation (fetal development) and end of formation (death and decay)? The wording here is vague enough to allow equivocation. This is why I specified, in my post accepting the point for argument purposes, the bridge of the nose as the beginning and the tip of the nose as the end. If you wish to argue on a time-base definition o beginning and end, I suggest changeing your object of reference from the nose (a physical, geometric object) to a temporal one like life.

Thus,
Premise 2: The nose has a physical, geometric beginning and an end point (the bridge and tip, respectfully).




It is obvious I submit: to anyone reading this thread that beginning and ending of the nose in the universe means beginning to exist and ending to exist.


I cannot imagine but pardon my limited imagination in this particular regard, that you go into geometry of the nose and its surrounding environment.

So, ask anyone with ordinary reading comprehension to go through this thread carefully taking into account the whole context of the thread, and tell you what they understand of the nose having a beginning and an ending in the universe.


Anyway, so as not to waste time, please understand beginning as beginning to exist, and ending as ending to exist, so that antecedent to beginning of the nose there was no nose existing, and posterior to its ending there is no longer any nose existing.



Here, I will reproduce my whole argument step by step, and you see why I can't imagine if you read in context you could come to the nose's geometry in the face.


Originally Posted by Yrreg

For those who are always repeatedly abusing me that I have not presented my argument for the thesis that the universe is the evidence for God's existence, here it is:

1. First we agree on the concepts of God and the universe as:
God = in the Christian faith in His fundamental relation to the universe, maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Universe = the totality of existence where man lives in and is part and parcel of, as also everything else that exists or at least can be the subject of man's imagination and discourse.
2. Then we present
the fact of the nose existing in the universe so it is a part and parcel of the universe.

3. Next we inform readers of
the fact that the nose has a beginning and an ending.

4. Further we bring to the attention of readers that
the fact of the nose having a beginning and an ending is a one for all fact that everything in the universe has a beginning and an ending.

5. Wherefore
everything in the universe has need of an agent to bring them to the beginning of their existence.

6. And this fact that everything in the universe has a need of an agent to bring them to existence and the fact that they do exist,
that double fact is the evidence that:

7. There is an agent which I call
God, who is the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.

Thus, from the realm of concepts we arrive at the realm of real actualities in

the existence of God as the maker of everything in the universe that is not Himself.


That is what I call proof from evidence by way of ratiocination i.e.

reasoning on facts which facts make up evidence.




Let us take up one item at a time of your comments.

When we are through with your present concern which is misplaced in the geometry of the nose, we will go to your next comment.





Yrreg



Dear X, are you now properly informed that the nose I am talking about in regard to its having a beginning and an ending has to do with the nose in our face the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that beginning and ending has to do with time, meaning before the beginning time point of the nose the nose had no existence, and after the ending time point of the nose the nose has no more existence.


On your now properly correct understanding of the nose having a beginning and an ending we can proceed to your next point.




Yrreg
 
Dear X, are you now properly informed that the nose I am talking about in regard to its having a beginning and an ending has to do with the nose in our face the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that beginning and ending has to do with time, meaning before the beginning time point of the nose the nose had no existence, and after the ending time point of the nose the nose has no more existence.

When chronologically does a nose begin to exist? Please support with references to embryology.

At what stage in decomposition does a nose cease to exist? Did Michael Jackson's nose still exist after his many plastic surgeries?
 
Yrreg, even if you successfully quantify the beginning-point and end-point of the existence of any particular nose, this has nothing to do with whether the universe had (or has) a beginning-point or an end-point.

Further, you are still using the idiomatic phrase "part and parcel" incorrectly.
 
Here is the reply I gave to you on your reaction to my argument.

Please read my text in the bolded enlarged font.


<snip quoted text>


Dear X, are you now properly informed that the nose I am talking about in regard to its having a beginning and an ending has to do with the nose in our face the external organ between the eyes and the mouth, and that beginning and ending has to do with time, meaning before the beginning time point of the nose the nose had no existence, and after the ending time point of the nose the nose has no more existence.


On your now properly correct understanding of the nose having a beginning and an ending we can proceed to your next point.



I have already responded to that, yrreg. My reasoning for choosing a geometric as opposed to a temporal beginning and end was explained in the post you quote. It has to do with your misleading example. Ultimately, quibbling about this is meaningless. Your argument still fails, for the same reasons. Instead of zeroing in on one definition, caused by your bad choice of example, you should concentrate on the non-sequiturs, fallacious premises and unsupported assertions which run rampant throughout your argument.



It is obvious I submit: to anyone reading this thread that beginning and ending of the nose in the universe means beginning to exist and ending to exist.
<snip>


Yes, that's all nice and patronizing.

Read my post. I covered my decision to take your meaning geometrically; it has to do with your choice of example. The nose is a feature of animal faces. It is a physical feature. I did suggest you use a temporal example instead. Life would be one. Or a train ride. Your misleading choice of example is a problem you need to deal with, not me.



Let us take up one item at a time of your comments.

When we are through with your present concern which is misplaced in the geometry of the nose, we will go to your next comment.


All this does is remove the equivocation fallacy from Conclusion 2. Conclusion 2 still has 2 fallacious premises (Conclusion 1 & Premise 3) that are unaffected by the definition of "beginning" and "end".

Your argument is still fatally flawed in many many ways.

<snip unrelated end>



Edit: Also, please consider this an example of how to nest multiple levels of quotes. Your method of just copying and pasting the text makes it very hard to decipher who is saying what, where.
 
Last edited:
This is clear from you, nose is organic nose and beginning and ending means time.

I have already responded to that, yrreg. My reasoning for choosing a geometric as opposed to a temporal beginning and end was explained in the post you quote. It has to do with your misleading example. Ultimately, quibbling about this is meaningless. Your argument still fails, for the same reasons. Instead of zeroing in on one definition, caused by your bad choice of example, you should concentrate on the non-sequiturs, fallacious premises and unsupported assertions which run rampant throughout your argument.







Edit: Also, please consider this an example of how to nest multiple levels of quotes. Your method of just copying and pasting the text makes it very hard to decipher who is saying what, where.



This is clear from you, nose is organic nose and beginning and ending means time duration of nose's existence, so that between beginning and ending of nose, nose does not exist.


Okay?


If okay, I will take up your next immediately next comment to my argument on the universe as the evidence of God's existence.





Yrreg
 
This is clear from you, nose is organic nose and beginning and ending means time duration of nose's existence, so that between beginning and ending of nose, nose does not exist.

One issue with this that is nagging me is that a nose is a short-term reconfiguration of pre-existing material. After the nose ceases to exist, the material does not disappear - it is reconfigured into other forms (eg, you rot under the ground, sooner or later some of you will end up in a tree).

The stuff you're made of has been around a long time, and was made inside stars. Before that, it was probably hydrogen.

I dont see how you're getting a "beginning" or "end" from this, as nothing is created or destroyed.
 
One issue with this that is nagging me is that a nose is a short-term reconfiguration of pre-existing material. After the nose ceases to exist, the material does not disappear - it is reconfigured into other forms (eg, you rot under the ground, sooner or later some of you will end up in a tree).

The stuff you're made of has been around a long time, and was made inside stars. Before that, it was probably hydrogen.

I dont see how you're getting a "beginning" or "end" from this, as nothing is created or destroyed.
I don't understand the argument for a creator even being relevant. At most, it is the idea that a creator existed in the past, not the present. So the hell what if it *was* turtles all the way down in the beginning ? They're not around any longer holding anything up.
 
I should also add, that based on the logic of your argument Gerry, the knowledge that matter is neither created nor destroyed in our universe should cause you to change your position from:

* Things have beginnings and ends, therefore so does the universe, therefore god

to

* Things dont have beginnings or ends, therefore neither does the universe, therefore no god.

You have an opportunity here to be honest with yourself and admit that you have a predefined conclusion and are trying to cherrypick evidence to suit. Will you now change your position, or will you go off looking for other evidence to cherrypick?
 
Correction please, between should be changed to outside of.

This is clear from you, nose is organic nose and beginning and ending means time.


Originally Posted by X
I have already responded to that, yrreg. My reasoning for choosing a geometric as opposed to a temporal beginning and end was explained in the post you quote. It has to do with your misleading example. Ultimately, quibbling about this is meaningless. Your argument still fails, for the same reasons. Instead of zeroing in on one definition, caused by your bad choice of example, you should concentrate on the non-sequiturs, fallacious premises and unsupported assertions which run rampant throughout your argument.


Edit: Also, please consider this an example of how to nest multiple levels of quotes. Your method of just copying and pasting the text makes it very hard to decipher who is saying what, where.

​


This is clear from you, nose is organic nose and beginning and ending means time duration of nose's existence, so that between beginning and ending of nose, nose does not exist.


Okay?


If okay, I will take up your next immediately next comment to my argument on the universe as the evidence of God's existence.




Correction please, between should be changed to outside of, so that the line concerned should now read:
This is clear from you, nose is organic nose and beginning and ending means time duration of nose's existence, so that outside of [ not: between ] beginning and ending of nose, nose does not exist.​



Sorry for the mistake, please be guided accordingly.



Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom