Geoff Boltwood / "Tareth" - Psyhic Healer

Hello Particleman..

I lived a mile from Glastonbury town centre for about 17 years, and I know Geoff Boltwood very well. He is definitely a great bloke, and I HAVE seen the oil from the palms of his hands thing.....we had gone to one of his meetings in the Assembly rooms there, for the sake of my wife, who had a TERRIBLE "woman's " problem, and I MEAN terrible ! Months of a terrible abdominal pain, doctors were constantly unable to help her in any way whatsoever....I am at least as skeptical as anyone in here, I assure you.....but all I can say is that Geoff called my wife up, he sat there in a very sleeveless shirt, meditated for a a few minutes, then slowly held his hands near her, and some very pleasant smelling oil substance suddenly very much appeared to gush from his hands, which he gently applied to my wife.....and this next bit is true, I promise...within almost no time at all, she got better, and stayed better.....I have PLENTY of other things I can tell you about of him, let's see how this goes first.....

There's enough contradiction in the surrounding text to convince me that you're not quite as sceptical as you think you are.

I know....I have simply stated what happened...it's the same with a medium I know.....absolutely stunning, next best thing to "proof"....but actual life after death ?

And bingo, my initial scepticism was spot on. You might be interested in a lovely bridge that I've got for sale.
 
There's enough contradiction in the surrounding text to convince me that you're not quite as sceptical as you think you are.



And bingo, my initial scepticism was spot on. You might be interested in a lovely bridge that I've got for sale.

I think you missed his next contribution.....
 
I think you missed his next contribution.....

No, unfortunately I didn't, I post in hope of him lurking or to let other lurkers/newbies understand that scepticism does not mean what some think it means.
 
You people aren't skeptics at all....I won't bother explaining this....good riddance morons.....

How unfortunate. I wish he would bother explaining it. This seemed like it could have been a very informative exercise on both sides. I think we could have learned something from billbryant. I'd never heard of Tareth before, so I've already learned something.

Ward
 
How unfortunate. I wish he would bother explaining it.

Indeed, what I've always enjoyed about skepticism is that it's not so much what exactly you hold, but why you hold it. I enjoyed a brief personal friendship with one of the men who walked on the Moon. He also happened to believe in UFOs, aliens (and government coverup of same), and various aspects of telepathy. But, he was always willing to talk about it in cordial and rational terms. And he freely conceded that his beliefs were rationally predicated on knowledge he believed he had but could not share, and that people bereft of that knowledge were quite likely to -- just as rationally -- conclude quite differently. In no way did he consider me closed-minded or overly skeptical for not believing as he did on those points. Our differences in belief were not an impediment to having mutual respect for each other because each of us could dispassionately elucidate why we held certain beliefs.

In contrast, "You're all morons and I'm not going to bother explaining myself" is in my estimation the least skeptical approach a person could follow.
 
Indeed, what I've always enjoyed about skepticism is that it's not so much what exactly you hold, but why you hold it. I enjoyed a brief personal friendship with one of the men who walked on the Moon. He also happened to believe in UFOs, aliens (and government coverup of same), and various aspects of telepathy. But, he was always willing to talk about it in cordial and rational terms. And he freely conceded that his beliefs were rationally predicated on knowledge he believed he had but could not share, and that people bereft of that knowledge were quite likely to -- just as rationally -- conclude quite differently. In no way did he consider me closed-minded or overly skeptical for not believing as he did on those points. Our differences in belief were not an impediment to having mutual respect for each other because each of us could dispassionately elucidate why we held certain beliefs.

In contrast, "You're all morons and I'm not going to bother explaining myself" is in my estimation the least skeptical approach a person could follow.

Really!
My scepti-radar is going nuts.
:)
 
Really!
My scepti-radar is going nuts.
:)

Yes, Edgar Mitchell held some rather unconventional personal beliefs. Yet he remained an inquisitive explorer, a fine scientist and engineer, and an expert pilot. (Although I've known a few pilots who briefly swore off their atheism in particular circumstances.)

To fill in the details: Mitchell believed that the U.S. government was not being fully honest about its knowledge of extraterrestrial visitation. He asked a personal acquaintance in the military to make inquiries for him, including among those who had classified knowledge. Mitchell did not reveal the name of his source as a courtesy to protect its anonymity. But right around the time of Mitchell's death, the source came forward on his own and clarified that he had given the response Mitchell attributed to him, but that Mitchell had misunderstood it. I don't know the exact nature of the materials alluded to, nor do I remember the name of the source. (Notes are somewhere in a box in the attic, etc.) But the gist of the misunderstanding, as I recall it, was that Mitchell had asked about certain UFO-related documents. The source said he hadn't obtained them, which Mitchell interpreted as their having been suppressed or withheld. In fact what the source had intended to convey was that he had not actually looked for them.

Sure, you might say poor Ed just heard what he wanted to hear. But if the ambiguity never occurs to him, it's not necessarily anti-skeptical. Even skeptics need others to help them skirt perceptual filters. But more to the point, even in the middle of all that he was gracious enough to say, in effect, "I accept that I can't share the information I have, so I accept also that it's rational for you to conclude differently than I have on this point." Conversely I had to accept that if I were privy to Mitchell's information, it might necessitate changing my belief. That's the sort of give-and-take I wish had been presented in this thread.
 
Of course a lot of magical thinking dresses itself up in scientific language. That's an old tactic.

Very old. A good example is the Malleus Malificarum, the volume justifying witch hunts. Parts of it are very well reasoned, and the whole thing comes across as a learned treatise. But of course it's all reasoned from religious dicta, from scripture, and from the speculation of church fathers. If you take it as an incontrovertible truth, for example, that supernatural healing occurs, then you can reason all manner of correct consequents from it -- correct in the sense that the reasoning stands up to scrutiny. Then it has the appearance of skepticism. As with any such intellectual construct, sooner or later you need to look at its axioms.

So you hear a lot of rhetoric on both sides of some question accusing each other of "pseudo-skepticism" -- the appearance of rational analysis without sufficient evidence or employing unsound reasoning. In general you can say that people are trying to make the expression of their beliefs sound like science or reason. But not everyone who tries (even honestly) succeeds.
 
.....I have PLENTY of other things I can tell you about of him, let's see how this goes first.....


You people aren't skeptics at all....I won't bother explaining this....good riddance morons.....

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means. But now I doubt that you had plenty of other things you could tell us, which is rather disappointing, as I was prepared to read them with great interest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom