Geoff Boltwood / "Tareth" - Psyhic Healer

Whenever I see a guy in a very sleeveless shirt with greasy hands, my first thought is "let's have him touch my wife!"
 
I did a quick google search and added the word 'fraud' to his name. It looks as if no serious debunking has been done. I only saw sites singing his praises. I am surprised. He just reeks sweaty, greasy fraud.

It makes me miss RSLancaster even more. He would have ripped the fraud with facts.
 
I am at least as skeptical as anyone in here, I assure you...

I am not assured. If what you say is true, then you would know how unconvincing an anonynous unverifiable anecdote is when trying to prove a paranormal claim. If you know Mr Boltwood "very well," as you claim, then perhaps you could help arrange for a scientifically controlled demonstration of his purported gifts.
 
Whenever I see a guy in a very sleeveless shirt with greasy hands, my first thought is "let's have him touch my wife!"

I assume he omitted the sleeves so that no one could accuse him of having something up them. No matter; I know at least two ways to palm a capsule so as to hide it from even relatively close inspection. Having a liquid suddenly appear on your hands is not really a hard problem in stage magic.
 
I assume he omitted the sleeves so that no one could accuse him of having something up them. No matter; I know at least two ways to palm a capsule so as to hide it from even relatively close inspection. Having a liquid suddenly appear on your hands is not really a hard problem in stage magic.

I would guess that it would be a bigger problem to repeat the act with already greasy hands ...
 
As far as I'm concerned, props, gimmicks, fancy names, and exotic clothing are immediate red flags for any claim of healing efficacy.

Oil from hands and sprouting seeds are easy slight of hand for an amateur magician.

Greasy!
We saw this one in Vegas from the front row.
Still no idea how it was done (and don’t care)


ETA: also rather pleased that mine was the last 2009 post in the thread before being zombied.
 
Last edited:
Still no idea how it was done (and don’t care).

Okay, I won't tell you how it's done. I had my suspicions watching it happen in real time, but I have to confess it took a frame-by-frame to collect the data needed to test my hypothesis. And to be further honest, I'm still not sure I caught all the technique. Often it is not the sophistication of the trick or apparatus that casts the convincing vote, but simply the deftness and skill of the magician in executing it. What you see in this trick is something that works only if you practice it a lot. Teller practices a lot.
 
The beauty of their act is that they often explain the trick and then perform it without the “shielding”, e.g., clear pedestals, containers, etc.

And still manage to amaze (that sai, I did manage to catch one palming)
 
I know....I have simply stated what happened...it's the same with a medium I know.....absolutely stunning, next best thing to "proof"....but actual life after death ?
 
Hello billbryant,

Welcome to the forum. Allow me to echo Pixel42's sentiment that we are glad that your wife's situation improved and that she's stayed well. I cannot access the first chapter of Tareth's book that pakeha linked to over a decade ago. But if we believe Moochie's interpretation, Tareth says it's impossible to test healing powers, which means that even he admits that there's no proof that he was responsible for your wife's recovery.

I don't know if you and your wife paid him for his services, but it does appear that he makes money doing this. If that is the case, it seems odd that he would agree to appear to be tested with Uri Gellar and then back out. While I doubt the sincerity of Geller's intentions (I think he was just trying to eliminate competition), it sounds like the test should have been fair, with Tareth's "second" from the university there to watch out for his interests. It should have been an easy 10,000 pounds. And again, this was not a test of his healing ability (which he says can't be tested), but his bean sprout ability, which seems easy to test.

If you do know him well, you should do your best to convince him to accept one of the many challenges that offer cash prizes for proof of abilities like his. Some of these prizes also offer a finder's fee. So if you are instrumental in convincing him to take the challenge, not only would he take home a large amount of cash, but you would, as well (if he wins the challenge).

This is something Geller has never done, nor does it seem like he ever will. I wonder why.

Again, welcome to the forum,

Ward
 
I know....I have simply stated what happened

Agreed. And having proclaimed yourself to be a skeptic, you should have expected that such anecdotes can't be considered evidence, much less a body of evidence large and rigorous enough to meet even a cursory standard of proof.

...absolutely stunning, next best thing to "proof"

No. Since the feats described are well within ordinary stage magic, all that I would consider your anecdote to prove is that the practitioner probably had some training in stage magic.

And I too am glad your wife recovered. Were this a less personal anecdote I would point out that most people do recover on their own eventually, and that much stage healing is based on a preconception to the contrary. But since you obviously are happy that your wife recovered, I'll just be happy with you.
 
I assume he omitted the sleeves so that no one could accuse him of having something up them. No matter; I know at least two ways to palm a capsule so as to hide it from even relatively close inspection. Having a liquid suddenly appear on your hands is not really a hard problem in stage magic.


When I was a kid, I had a magic kit that included two flesh-colored molded plastic caps made to look like thumbs, intended to fit over your actual thumb to conceal things inside them.
That's not breaking the rules, is it? :)
 
I think we are able to reveal how trick are done now we've split from JREF, so if anybody knows..............
 
It's been a couple of weeks since billbryant posted here. He said, "let's see how this goes, first." Apparently, he did not like how this was going. I don't know how how he was expecting it to go. I, personally, welcome him to return. He can tell us how he wants this to go and there are members here who will probably try to make it go that way. Others might not, but they can be ignored.

Ward
 
It's been a couple of weeks since billbryant posted here. He said, "let's see how this goes, first." Apparently, he did not like how this was going. I don't know how how he was expecting it to go. I, personally, welcome him to return. He can tell us how he wants this to go and there are members here who will probably try to make it go that way. Others might not, but they can be ignored.

Ward

Yes. Not even a good intuition. Coming here, spewing this fairytale, was not a well thought decision.
 
You people aren't skeptics at all....I won't bother explaining this....good riddance morons.....
 
We can only hope billbryant's extreme gullibility does not negatively impact his, or his family's, welfare.
 
I don't know how how he was expecting it to go.

I don't see how it could reasonably have gone any differently. He was met by people who listened to him carefully, offered an expected amount of sympathy for the personal aspects of his story, and then patiently pointed out how it couldn't be considered evidence of genuine healing. That gentle rebuttal took two predictable forms: reminding what evidence consists of, and pointing out reasonable alternative hypotheses to the observations, most of which were considerably more parsimonious than the proffered one. That's the bread-and-butter of skepticism as I understand it.

He can tell us how he wants this to go...

Apparently he prefers to tell us where to go. Not the most eloquent flounce, to be sure. His rejoinder went no farther than ipse dixit. Yes, he assured us he was just "telling us what happened," but that's not where we stop. Apparently he had a firm belief in what made it happen and is not in a mood to entertain alternatives. And it may indeed have stunned him, but that reaction is no more proof that our relative indifference is proof in the other direction. It was he who put "proof" in cautionary quotes, so perhaps he came here with a preconception of where the burden of proof should lie and how high the standard of proof should have been.

But the bottom line is that if he's going to simply repeat his anecdotes and demand they be given a certain weight, then insult people when they rightly decline, he's probably not going to get much further patience from any faction of regulars here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom