A dreadful book, deconstructed many times, fairly recently as Rodoh's first book club selection. The material on the ghettos, for example, is not just wrong: it is risible. Butz confuses the course of the liquidation of Warsaw ghetto in order to tout Treblinka as a way station, as well as scoring a big fail in trying to prettify the ghettos as salutary for their inmates, whose ill discipline undermined Nazi attempts to keep things healthy and decent. The confused author confuses the nature of institutions like the Jewish Councils and order police, in order to confuse readers about how ghettos were established, managed, and run. Maybe we should do a reprise of the Rodoh idea here and discuss this thing?
That said, I didn't ask for a link to a book that does not construct an alternative history. I asked for Saggy to summarize how the hoax was constructed--naming names, dates, etc.--and supporting the narrative with evidence. According to Saggy. In his own words. He has flopped as badly as Clayton. I cannot even tell if Saggy understands what is meant by writing a proper history.
