Gaydar

I saw a description of a study that was posted within the last two months that monitored people's eyes while they looked at photographs of other people.

Women tended to look primarily at the faces of men.

Men, straight or gay, looked at the faces and crotches of men fairly equally. Guys check out other guys.


And I can probably guess which portion of the woman's anatomy the men were looking at (straight and gay from what my gay relatives/friends tell me). ;)
 
I saw a description of a study that was posted within the last two months that monitored people's eyes while they looked at photographs of other people.

http://www.kottke.org/07/03/men-look-at-crotches

Women tended to look primarily at the faces of men.

Men, straight or gay, looked at the faces and crotches of men fairly equally. Guys check out other guys.
Yeah but I wasn't talking about photographs, C. I meant real life, out and about.

One of the funniest commercials was one of the beer ones, bud or miller. Anyway it was the one with Randy Cross, former center for an NFL team (I'm thinking Oakland). I don't remember exactly how it went, but a woman comes up to the bar, he's there, she sees his face, no recognition, nothing. Randy drops something and bends over to pick it up, butt sticking out prominently. And she says: Hey, are you Randy Cross?

In real life when I'm dealing with men? Let's say at the office, work environment? I can't recall looking at a guy's crotch. And I've never detected a guy looking at mine - unless he's "interested".

It's one of the great things about men wearing suits to the office, and typically dark suits. As far as most men are concerned - who cares? Who the hell cares what the guy is dressed like?
 
Last edited:
Interesting thread. Think I'll chime in with a few comments on the subject.

I used to have no sense for gay vs. hetero, however, after 15 years in LA, my "gaydar" as one might call it has become much more evolved. In simple and very general terms, some gay men have body language that tends to lean towards effeminate, such as the way they hold their hands or the way they might wiggle their backside when they walk. Sometimes it's their evolved sense of style that gives it away, such as wearing a bold color or style that no heterosexual man would be caught dead in. Sometimes, it's a verbal clue, sort of a gay dialect, similar in a way to valley girl speak from the 80s. With that said, however, I have also known gay men who exhibit none of those mannerisms, verbal, or style clues, and are as "macho" as any heterosexual man. If they didn't tell you they were gay, you'd never know it.

I had a co-worker several years ago who I thought was simply a shy man. I had no idea he was gay until he showed up at the company holiday party with his partner. On the other hand, I had a roommate for a while who claims to be hetero, however, nearly everyone who meets him, men and women alike, all come away believing he's gay. I've always sort of felt bad for him with that. ((-:

Anyway, I'm a huge reality tv watcher, and was amused a few months ago when I came across a show on the Fox Reality Channel called "Playing It Straight." The idea was that there was one girl, and 14 men. Not all of the men were hetero -- many were gay. Each episode, the girl had to eliminate two men from the group, until there was only one man left, presumably the man who captured her heart. If the girl fell for a straight man, the couple would get $200K to split between them. But if she fell for a gay man, the gay man would take the entire $200K and the girl would walk away empty handed and presumably broken hearted. From an audience perspective, the gay men were instructed to speak to the cameras in their personal diaryroom entries as though they were all hetero, so the audience was playing the same guessing game as the girl was. I didn't completely keep track of my guesses, but I can say this. There were many gay men who I thought for sure were straight, and there were several straight men who I thought for sure were gay. I'd probably say in the end, I only guessed correctly about 20% of the time, which as we all know here on the JREF forum, is what one could expect by chance. I think in this case though, the gay men were actually trying to pass themselves as being straight, several of them going to far as to makeout with the girl so that they would be the one she would choose and they would get to keep the $200K. So in the end, I don't know that it was really a great situation for testing gaydar abilities.
 
Last edited:
Yes, the phrase is from The Empire Strikes Back. Good catch!

Totally off topic, but... Vampire, are you a Star Wars fan?

I went to the Celebration IV convention last weekend at the LA Convention Center. It was seriously the most fun I've had in years!!!
 
ConspiRaider - I'd be surprised if most people are aware of where their eyes spend time.

If a straight guy approaches a woman and it turns out she's not interested, he'll probably take a hit in the self-esteem and, maybe, a slap, but that's probably all.

If a gay guy approaches a guy and it turns out he's straight, a lot more is at risk - the straight guy might take offense at the thought that he could be mistaken for gay, or simply upset that gays exist, and the gay guy could end up hit, beat up, or killed.

I think that gaydar is simply a heightened awareness that is of particular value for gay males. Many people have it with varying degrees of accuracy, while others are oblivious to the whole thing.

Several people have made reference to gaydar keying in on effeminate behaviors, physicality, speech, etc. You'd be surprised how many men who have some effeminate aspects are straight, though that is often an indicator.

The tough part is recognizing that a guy who slips easily into one of the all-American stereotypes (e.g. jock, soldier, blue-collar worker, fireman, cowboy) or simply the guy next door is gay, bi, gay-for-trade, or some other variety of non-straight. You'd probably be amazed how many guys fall into this category.

I'm glad to say that I hear more straight guys that get approached by another guy are taking it as a compliment rather than a threat to their manhood, but there are still a lot of guys that will take offense.
 
Anyway it was the one with Randy Cross, former center for an NFL team (I'm thinking Oakland).


Psst, ConspiRaider, don't let any SF fans hear you say this (he was with the 'Niners).

It was tested by Penn and Teller: looking at women that is...



I guess it states the obvious. Not like we didn't know already...

SYL :)


Linky no worky.
 
Edit: Always look for visual cues. Notice what people are wearing. Nine times out of ten, if a woman is wearing Brikenstocks, and certain clothing, it gives them away. I knew Ellen DeGeneres was gay the first time I saw her on Johnny Carson. Dockers, Hushpuppies or sneakers? Sistahhhhh!

You know I have a problem with this. I am a firmly hetero woman and yet I like to wear comfortable casual clothes (jeans or chinos, sweaters, polo shirts, etc). I always wear sneakers. I've even worn Birkenstocks (hey they're comfortable sandals and I have messed up feet!) I'm not a girly, girl. I don't usually wear makeup. I don't fuss over my clothes or my hair. I don't wear much jewelry. I don't act feminine (I like to put my feet up on my desk, etc).

I'd probably throw off anyone's gaydar. ...

I agree with you Supercorgi! My footwear of choice is a pair of sneakers, I prefer jeans, my skin destroys makeup and I don't always have time to constantly reapply it.

I'd hate to think people would think that I"m gay just because of that. I'd at least want a nice juicy rumour floating around to back that hunch up! :D

Seriously, I think most people realize/assume that I'm straight, but I know that at least a few people have assumed that I'm not. {shrug}
 
Last edited:
I'm interested in how signals change, or are perceived to change, in different countries. I'm not aware of ever having been approached by another man in most of the countries I've lived in (France, UK, Ireland), but when I was a postgrad in Germany it was a regular occurrence. I wasn't doing anything different to what I usually did, but something about me was setting off their gaydar.

(It might also be worthy of mention that my success rate with German ladies was markedly lower than with other nationalities, so clearly I was completely in the wrong place there :( .)
 
Psst, ConspiRaider, don't let any SF fans hear you say this (he was with the 'Niners).
Thanks for straightening me out on that, H, holy friggin' Toledo I hope no San Franciscans noticed :boxedin:

Come to think of it, even though I primarily focus on a guy's eyes in this case I'll make an exception and confess. Randy DID have a nice caboose, yes?
 
Come to think of it, even though I primarily focus on a guy's eyes in this case I'll make an exception and confess.


That might be your problem. If you are the nose tackle in a 3-4 defense, you really should be watching the center's chest or hips. However, if you are a defensive end, watch the QB's eyes.

Randy DID have a nice caboose, yes?


Yes!
 
That might be your problem. If you are the nose tackle in a 3-4 defense, you really should be watching the center's chest or hips. However, if you are a defensive end, watch the QB's eyes.
I think my problem during my Cleveland Browns tryout (cough) is that as a defensive end I was trying to eyeball the defensive "end" of the defensive end clear across the field. How could I not? Thing was at least as juicy as Randy Cross's. As a result the tight end would roll over me every time. Not that I minded so much. But, the coaching staff did and they sent me packing...
 
I think my problem during my Cleveland Browns tryout (cough) is that as a defensive end I was trying to eyeball the defensive "end" of the defensive end clear across the field. How could I not? Thing was at least as juicy as Randy Cross's. As a result the tight end would roll over me every time. Not that I minded so much. But, the coaching staff did and they sent me packing...


I suppose you could then have tried out for the cheerleading squad. You would have had a legitimate reason to follow the action . . .


ETA: Hey, did I just manage to completely derail a thread that was created as a result of a major derail? Cool.
 
All my friends from school were shocked and confused when I came out - took them completely by surprise. But all my friends whom I had met in just the past year already knew I was gay - which took me by surprise.

It took me four years and a disastrously failed relationship to come to terms with being gay, and maybe the fact that I had decided to come out made it more obvious to those who I met during that time. I don't do anything overtly 'gay' - indeed, I'm quite the antithesis of a 'flamer' - but there must be a lot of subtle things to pick up on, and it seems to me that the more you're exposed to gay men and women, the more attuned your gaydar becomes.
 
As a gay guy myself, I believe in "gaydar." What it is, I couldn't tell you. It's not 100% accurate -- maybe 50 to 75 percent.

It's a combination of the way people move, the way the voice sounds, the way they dress, and this indefinable "something," like the indefinable something that makes someone a star. For example, I remember reading an interview with Barbra Streisand, where she related how she and her manager took Madonna out for lunch before she was famous, and she said you could just TELL even then that Madonna was going to be a huge star. But not every gay guy gives off these "signals."

I find many gay men seem to sort of carry themselves differently -- not just the way they move, but this sort of... prissy demeanor that you can see even when they're just sitting still. Many gay men seem to be sort of overly-groomed -- a little too perfect perfect hair, a little more attention to their appearance than even the vainest straight guy would pay.

And there's something else. A few years ago, a female friend I worked with asked me, "What is it about gay guys? So many of them actually LOOK different. Don't take this the wrong way, but they actually look physically different in the face... like Down Syndrome kids."

I laughed, but I got to thinking about it, and she's right. A fair number of gay guys really do have a different look about their face. It's like... a higher forehead, high cheekbones, and this sort of... slightly "pinched" look to their face. I don't know how to explain it. But I've bounced this off other gay friends (none of whom do have this appearance) and they agreed with me.

All I know is I've had many people, mostly women, tell me they knew immediately, the second I walked in the room, that I was gay. I ask how they know. Some responses:

"I don't know, gay guys just seem to put out this different energy."

"Oh... just mannerisms."

"You can just tell."

And as carefully closeted as I once was, I was always surprised to find out from coworkers that, "Everyone at work knows you're gay. They all talk about it. Everyone knows."

Which is part of what led me to stop being so closeted -- everyone always seemed to know anyway. :)
 
I have to see a person for a bit, preferably interacting with other people, before sense of what his or her interests are. Some are easy, some I flipflop on, and I love the ones that keep me guessing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom