As a gay guy myself, I believe in "gaydar." What it is, I couldn't tell you. It's not 100% accurate -- maybe 50 to 75 percent.
It's a combination of the way people move, the way the voice sounds, the way they dress, and this indefinable "something," like the indefinable something that makes someone a star. For example, I remember reading an interview with Barbra Streisand, where she related how she and her manager took Madonna out for lunch before she was famous, and she said you could just TELL even then that Madonna was going to be a huge star. But not every gay guy gives off these "signals."
I find many gay men seem to sort of carry themselves differently -- not just the way they move, but this sort of... prissy demeanor that you can see even when they're just sitting still. Many gay men seem to be sort of overly-groomed -- a little too perfect perfect hair, a little more attention to their appearance than even the vainest straight guy would pay.
And there's something else. A few years ago, a female friend I worked with asked me, "What is it about gay guys? So many of them actually LOOK different. Don't take this the wrong way, but they actually look physically different in the face... like Down Syndrome kids."
I laughed, but I got to thinking about it, and she's right. A fair number of gay guys really do have a different look about their face. It's like... a higher forehead, high cheekbones, and this sort of... slightly "pinched" look to their face. I don't know how to explain it. But I've bounced this off other gay friends (none of whom do have this appearance) and they agreed with me.
All I know is I've had many people, mostly women, tell me they knew immediately, the second I walked in the room, that I was gay. I ask how they know. Some responses:
"I don't know, gay guys just seem to put out this different energy."
"Oh... just mannerisms."
"You can just tell."
And as carefully closeted as I once was, I was always surprised to find out from coworkers that, "Everyone at work knows you're gay. They all talk about it. Everyone knows."
Which is part of what led me to stop being so closeted -- everyone always seemed to know anyway.
