Can I start the competition for the world's worst gaydar? I submit myself as a prime candidate. I actually went out on four dates (at least I thought they were dates) with a girl before she finally had to take me aside and say, "Stop trying to kiss me, dammit. I like girls."
I'm no better with guys either. Paul was just a really good friend, I thought, until he suddenly kissed me on the lips at a New Year's Eve party. I'd like to think I didn't freak out, but he immediately apologized. For the record, we're still friends, but not "that kind" of friends. I'm happily married to a woman who has even worse gaydar than me. She tells me of the time when she "really thought it was just a pajama party for twenty-five-year-old women."
Let's hear it for the blissfully naive.
I'm going to go out a limb and say I have to you beat. My uncle is gay, and despite blatantly obvious mannerisms, I really didn't connect any dots; a) never had or talked a girlfriend in the many years I've known him well b) used to be in charge of
floral arrangements at weddings and other services c) continually (read: carefully and neutrally) told stories about male friends and roommates.
But the real kicker is his website, which I had known about and seen many times before realizing. It is one of the most blatantly gay things (and I, of course, mean that stereotypically, not insultingly, if that's possible) I have ever seen. Unfortunately, I can't link it, as the cartoons contained therein may or may not break rules.... Said cartoons are also a dead giveaway, as well. Perhaps a moderator could approve it. Anyways, it is perhaps not as... active a story as the above, but it had me slapping my forehead afterward.
I'd like to think I'm not naive, so I'm either gaydar-jammed or stupid.
On the other hand, my uncle seems to have a very finely tuned gaydar (or bidar, in this case). He picked up (so he says) me some time ago, and I'm one of the most unassuming persons one can meet, or so everyone tells me, even him.
And for the "gay is genetic" crowd, I'm afraid my uncle is adopted, sorry

. No proof here.