Gahhh! Hillary's trippin'!

I admit that it's conceivable that he had some information from a reliable source, but it is unlikely, since the comments[1] came so soon after the blast and since he has not claimed that he spoke to any authorities. He's not shy when it comes to describing his contacts and influence.

So, I find it improbable that Trump had any inside knowledge, but I'll admit that it is not impossible.
In fact, he said as much. From NBC:
"Just before I got off the plane, a bomb went off in New York, and nobody knows exactly what's going on, but boy, we are living in a time," Trump said. Exactly how Trump learned of the incident is yet to be determined.
In the highlighted part he contradicts the claim about the bomb.
 
Ok, so if you want to be skeptical, what is the evidence that Trump had insufficient information? The argument seems to be that Trump can't known if the press wasn't saying, but that's not a skeptical position either. There are other avenues of information.

Yeah, I suppose we should consider the possibility he was in on it. :rolleyes:
 
What a silly bit of sophistry.

Not at all. The odds of an event after it's happened are 100% (or close enough to 100% as to make no difference). It's not like there's any uncertainty now about what caused the explosion. If you want, we can make a forum bet. You can bet the explosion wasn't due to a bomb and I'll give you a billion-to-1 odds, and you still won't bet me on it.
 
Putting aside the fact that all of the investigations into Hillary's shenanigans were absolutely justified, and, in fact, she almost certainly has committed many crimes (including obstruction of justice multiple times, lying under oath, and political corruption),...
You acknowledge decades of investigations into HRC's activities yet there has not been even one indictment of her. Yet you feel confident to assert that she has committed numerous, major crimes. You are simultaneously asserting near omniscience on your own part and total and complete incompetence on the part of hundreds of conservative lawyers and prosecuters. A trifecta of brilliance, sunmaster. Well done.

It doesn't matter how she became paranoid and dishonest. Whether it was a predisposition at birth (as I believe)

That is truly astonishing. You believe that dishonesty is an inheritable trait? Really? I never took you for a Lamarkian tool but one never ceases to learn new insights.
 
Technically, Fudbucker is right: the post-hoc odds are 100%.

You just lost a great chance of keeping your ignorance to yourself (unless you were joking, and Fudbucker obviously doesn't think you were).

There is no such thing as post-hoc odds. The probability of an event happening don't change because you hapoen to observe it.

It reminds of the old "simplification of statistics": every event as a 50% probability... either it happens or it doesn't.
 
Which is based on a fallacy that we've all abused arguing with CTers. The odds of it being correct at the time Trump spoke were not 100%. You know it. I know it. DDT knows it.

That wasn't what was asked.

But, the odds of the explosion being a bomb before we knew it was a bomb after the New Jersey bombing had just taken place were through the roof. I said at the time I would have given 50-1 odds of a natural cause for the explosion, and that's pretty conservative. Both Clinton and Trump used "bomb" before any officials did: a harmless speculation based on what was known at the time.
 
You just lost a great chance of keeping your ignorance to yourself (unless you were joking, and Fudbucker obviously doesn't think you were).

There is no such thing as post-hoc odds. The probability of an event happening don't change because you hapoen to observe it.

It reminds of the old "simplification of statistics": every event as a 50% probability... either it happens or it doesn't.

You should probably delete this and think it through some more.

ETA: In fact, post-hoc probabilities cause all sorts of grief with Bayesian analyses: the problem of old evidence. But this is a digression, merely meant to illustrate the foolishness of some "statisticians" here.
 
Last edited:
That wasn't what was asked.

But, the odds of the explosion being a bomb before we knew it was a bomb after the New Jersey bombing had just taken place were through the roof. I said at the time I would have given 50-1 odds of a natural cause for the explosion, and that's pretty conservative. Both Clinton and Trump used "bomb" before any officials did: a harmless speculation based on what was known at the time.

I think you mis-spelled, "Yeah, I was just goofing around with the 100% thing but in my amateur opinion it sure seemed to me like there was a pretty good chance that they were related."
 
You should probably delete this and think it through some more.
Why, are you afraid you might learn something?

: In fact, post-hoc probabilities cause all sorts of grief with Bayesian analyses: the problem of old evidence. But this is a digression, merely meant to illustrate the foolishness of some "statisticians" here.

Wow, someone went to google. Hope you realized how stupid it is to say that the probability of an observed event is 100%.

Post-hoc statistics exist, evidently. Post-hoc odds as 100% if you happen to observe the event don't.
 
I think you mis-spelled, "Yeah, I was just goofing around with the 100% thing but in my amateur opinion it sure seemed to me like there was a pretty good chance that they were related."

The "100% thing" is the more fascinating part of this whole topic. There are actual people ignorant here of the most basic concepts of probability theory.

Yes, in my amateur opinion, the attacks were obviously related, and in fact the same guy was behind both attacks. What a shock.
 
Why, are you afraid you might learn something?



Wow, someone went to google. Hope you realized how stupid it is to say that the probability of an observed event is 100%.

Post-hoc statistics exist, evidently. Post-hoc odds as 100% if you happen to observe the event don't.

OK, here's what you do: Go to the racetrack. Try and bet on a race that's already been run. Let us know how it goes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom