Gahhh! Hillary's trippin'!

That anyone would consider "the media" as biased towards Mr. Trump and against Ms. Clinton is laughable and pretty much disqualifies the person from being taken seriously in other matters of discussion. The very idea is beyond Pluto measures of "out there."
Matt Lauer? Is that you?
 
We need to get really tough? No specifics?

Nonsense

You are confused. The issue being discussed in this exchange is specifically about using the word "bombing" to describe a bombing. And Trump was right to call it a bombing, because it was.
 
You are confused. The issue being discussed in this exchange is specifically about using the word "bombing" to describe a bombing. And Trump was right to call it a bombing, because it was.

And when he's not? Are you really defending the inflammation of spirits by a populist when no real information is available? The same cretin that swears he saw hundreds of muslims celebrate the 9/11 events?

Seems to me like a good way to get someone lynched, eventually.
 
You are confused. The issue being discussed in this exchange is specifically about using the word "bombing" to describe a bombing. And Trump was right to call it a bombing, because it was.

That's hardly a given. If he called it a bombing before there was really adequate information to know it was a bombing, it's really not "right to call it bombing" even you accidentally turn out to be right later.
 
That's hardly a given. If he called it a bombing before there was really adequate information to know it was a bombing, it's really not "right to call it bombing" even you accidentally turn out to be right later.

There was enough information. The odds of a pipe bomb going off in New Jersey and then an explosion happening in New York hours later that wasn't a bomb were too ridiculous to be believable.
 
Given that the term was invented by some subset of the counterculture generally and militant feminism in particular, yes, they are the authority on how they intended the word to be used.
You're mistaken in this. According to the wiki article:
"Ms." began to be used as early as the 17th century, along with "Miss" and "Mrs.", as a title derived from the then formal "Mistress", which, like Mister, did not originally indicate marital status.[5][6] "Ms.", however, fell into disuse in favor of the other two titles and was not revived until the 20th century.[7][8]

The earliest known proposal for the modern revival of "Ms." as a title appeared in The Republican of Springfield, Massachusetts on November 10, 1901:
[...]
The term was again suggested as a convenience to writers of business letters by such publications as the Bulletin of the American Business Writing Association (1951) and The Simplified Letter, issued by the National Office Management Association (1952).[9]
That all predates the counterculture of the 1960s. It was indeed popularized by a feminist magazine with that name.

As to the choice of surname, that seems obvious to me: Hillary herself goes by the name Clinton and doesn't use her maiden name. So why would you?
 
The amount of crap statistics in this forum is too damn high!

You're right. Explosions happen all the time in New York, especially after pipe bombs go off in a neighboring state. It was obviously a gas main. That was the first thing you thought, right? Everyone was floored when it turned out an actual bomb caused the explosion. Who saw that coming?
 
You're right. Explosions happen all the time in New York, especially after pipe bombs go off in a neighboring state. It was obviously a gas main. That was the first thing you thought, right? Everyone was floored when it turned out an actual bomb caused the explosion. Who saw that coming?

If you don't want people to tell you that you post crap statistics, then stop posting crap statistics. I have no obligation to patch your inadequacies.
 
100%, since the explosion turned out to be a bomb.

The amount of crap statistics in this forum is too damn high!
Technically, Fudbucker is right: the post-hoc odds are 100%.

Concerning bombs, I once got sage advice from a statistics professor. He said he always brings a bomb with him on a plane. The probability there are two bombs on the plane is infinitesimally small, so it lowers his chances there's actually a terrorist with a bomb on the plane.

OK, back to our regularly scheduled program, viz. the health of Ms. Clinton.
 
If it doesn't matter that Trump was right, then the obvious corollary is that it doesn't matter when he's wrong.

What matters is whether he had sufficient evidence to warrant the claim at the time he made it. If not, then he is behaving irresponsibly. If so, then he is not.

This is a skeptics' board, yes? Whether one happens to guess right is not a feather in his cap, not even if his claim was somewhat probable. Rather, we prefer that claims are well justified at the time they are made.

At least that's how I understand skepticism.
 
What matters is whether he had sufficient evidence to warrant the claim at the time he made it. If not, then he is behaving irresponsibly. If so, then he is not.

This is a skeptics' board, yes? Whether one happens to guess right is not a feather in his cap, not even if his claim was somewhat probable. Rather, we prefer that claims are well justified at the time they are made.

At least that's how I understand skepticism.

Ok, so if you want to be skeptical, what is the evidence that Trump had insufficient information? The argument seems to be that Trump can't known if the press wasn't saying, but that's not a skeptical position either. There are other avenues of information.
 
Ok, so if you want to be skeptical, what is the evidence that Trump had insufficient information? The argument seems to be that Trump can't known if the press wasn't saying, but that's not a skeptical position either. There are other avenues of information.

I admit that it's conceivable that he had some information from a reliable source, but it is unlikely, since the comments[1] came so soon after the blast and since he has not claimed that he spoke to any authorities. He's not shy when it comes to describing his contacts and influence.

So, I find it improbable that Trump had any inside knowledge, but I'll admit that it is not impossible.

[1] The above CNN article says Trump's speech began half an hour after the explosion. The probability that he spoke to someone who had good evidence it was a bomb seems very, very slim.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom