From Cracked: 5 ridiculous things you probably believe about Islam

Turkey was why I said "one". Their economy isn't all that great and they have some human rights issues, but they're doing OK.



Ummm

Citizens did not have the right to change the constitutional provisions establishing their monarchical form of government or the establishment of the practice of Islam. Reports of torture and other abuses by various branches of the security forces persisted, and prison conditions remained below international standards. Reports of arbitrary arrests, incommunicado detentions, and police and security force impunity continued. Politics, as well as corruption and inefficiency, influenced the judiciary, which was not fully independent. The government restricted freedoms of speech, religion, and the press. Corruption was a serious problem in all branches of government. Trafficking in persons continued, and child labor, particularly in the unregulated informal sector, remained a problem.
http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/nea/119122.htm




Ummm

There were significant limitations on citizens' right to change their government. Local and international nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) reported that security forces tortured and physically abused prisoners and detainees and arbitrarily arrested and detained individuals. Security forces acted with impunity sanctioned by high-ranking officials. There were also reports of lengthy pretrial and incommunicado detention. The government infringed on citizens' privacy rights and continued to impose severe restrictions on freedoms of speech, press, assembly, and association. The government remained intolerant of public criticism, and there were widespread reports that it used intimidation, criminal investigations, the judicial system, arbitrary arrests, residential restrictions, and travel controls to discourage criticism by human rights and opposition activists. Media freedom was severely restricted during the year and corruption was a problem.
http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/nea/119128.htm

Other than torture, rampant corruption, and restriction of personal freedoms, they're great places to live, if you like making $4,000 a year.*

*Belgium has approx. the same population as Tunisia. So by way of comparison:

The government generally respected the human rights of its citizens, and the law and the judiciary provided effective means of addressing individual instances of abuse. The following human rights problems were reported: overcrowded prisons, lengthy pretrial detention, poor detention conditions prior to expulsion of adults and children whose asylum applications were refused, violence against women, child abuse, trafficking in persons, and racial and ethnic discrimination in the job market.
http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/eur/119070.htm

Per capita income is $38,600.

So your two shining examples (other than Turkey) were upstaged by Belgium (75% Catholic).

which were Tunesias colonies?
 
Ah, thanks for the info, learned something today.

But i guess that such occurrences are a rare thing, compared to the total number of christian sects?

Greetings,

Chris

I think I overstated this. The first female preacher in a Dutch protestant church was in 1968. Orthodox protestant churches still resist the idea, and I also found a recent newspaper article that locally, the orthodox wing in the mainstream PKN protestant church had resisted appointing a female preacher.

Gay marriage is wholesale accepted and performed in the Remonstrant church. the Mennonite church and the Old Catholic church - yes, those are all fringe churches in numbers. The mainstream PKN church leaves it to the individual parishes.

Now factor in that Dutch churches tend to be more liberal than elsewhere. :)
 
I think I overstated this. The first female preacher in a Dutch protestant church was in 1968 (*). Orthodox protestant churches still resist the idea, and I also found a recent newspaper article that locally, the orthodox wing in the mainstream PKN protestant church had resisted appointing a female preacher.

Gay marriage is wholesale accepted and performed in the Remonstrant church. the Mennonite church and the Old Catholic church - yes, those are all fringe churches in numbers. The mainstream PKN church leaves it to the individual parishes.

Now factor in that Dutch churches tend to be more liberal than elsewhere. :)

(*) ETA: in the Reformed Church, a fairly orthodox church which merged into the PKN in 2004. The first overall female preacher was a Mennonite (1911), the Lutherans opened up female preachership in 1922, and the moderate calvinist Dutch Reformed Church in 1966.
 
So the point stands; there are many non-muslim majority nations one might want to live in, that respect personal and economic freedoms. There are few majority Muslim nations that respect personal and economic freedoms.

Everyone agrees, right? The two counterexamples given (Morocco and Tunisia) failed miserably.

So the question is, why are so many Muslism countries failures?
 
So the point stands; there are many non-muslim majority nations one might want to live in, that respect personal and economic freedoms. There are few majority Muslim nations that respect personal and economic freedoms.

Everyone agrees, right? The two counterexamples given (Morocco and Tunisia) failed miserably.

So the question is, why are so many Muslism countries failures?

Not enough separation of religion and state i would guess. a lack of secularization.
 
and btw, the most secular countries are the most successful. Scandinavia
 
I think one reason Christian nations managed to get a "leg up" (for lack of a better term) in development compared to Muslim nations is that Christianity had a Reformation. It became acceptable to dissent from Rome's line after Martin Luther aired the Church's dirty laundry, which in turn allowed for an already stagnant culture to thrive once more once a shackle to innovation ahd been somewhat loosened, which helped pave way for the Enlightenment.
 
Last edited:
There's a glaring problem with your analysis: countries that had no church influence "happily" murdered the most people, and were some of the most restrictive countries on Earth. China and Russia being the two worst offenders.
How do you know they would have killed fewer people had they been theocracies? Only possible answer: you don't.
 
Really liked the Founding Fathers bit:

...
Thomas Jefferson, for example, taught himself Arabic using his own copy of the Quran and hosted the first White House Iftar during Ramadan.


John Adams hailed the Islamic prophet Muhammad as one of the great "inquirers after truth." Benjamin Rush, who was so Christian he wanted a Bible in every school, also said he would rather see the opinions of Confucius or Mohammad "inculcated upon our youth" than see them grow deprived "of a system of religious principles." Benjamin Franklin once declared: "Even if the Mufti of Constantinople were to send a missionary to preach Mohammedanism to us, he would find a pulpit at his service." Even George f****** Washington personally welcomed Muslims to come work for him at Mount Vernon.

Read more: http://www.cracked.com/article_1891...obably-believe-about-islam.html#ixzz18y4AFEZa
 
It depends on one's definition of success.

If you pick quality of life, low crime rates, stable economies, most of the top highest scores on those metrics are among the most secular countries in the world. The only countries among the most secular that don't also have great success in those metrics are those burdened with totalitarian governments.
 
I think that it is also important to point out that Islam is about 600 years younger than Christianity. Given that, one has to take a look and see where Christianity was, or what it did, around 1400 AD.

About 200 years before that date, there was the Medieval Inquisition. About 80 years after that date there was the Spanish Inquisition. And of course there were two more Inquisitions after that. Just take a look here.

Next, we have the crusades, which started long before that date, and continued through the 16th century. Take a look here.

It must be noted that the history of Christianity is not really a peaceful one, especially at, and after, the high and late middle ages. Then there was the period of the European wars of religion.

It was only from the post-enlightenment era onwards that Christianity lost its power, and secularization finally began.

So, to claim that Islam is oh-so-bad when compared to Christianity is absolutely dishonest if not done in the proper timeframe. In fact, Christianity was no better, if not even worse. Just give it another 600 years and let's see how it develops. Until then, comparisons between Christianity nowdays and Islam nowdays are simply not valid.

But of course that would not work so well for the islamophobes and their stupid propaganda.

And i'm pretty sure that it will become much better before 600 years have elapsed. Just look at the trends for example in Turkey.

Greetings,

Chris
 
Judaism is about 4,000 years old, Christianity about 2,000, Islam about 1,300.

It takes centuries for a religion to grow up from its roots, to evolve, and to mature.

Divide by 100.

Jews acts like they are 40 years old, Christians like 20, and Muslims like 13 year old teenagers.

That is my perspective.

Jews used to, Christians used to, but Muslims still do.
 
I don't think there's much of a comparison. If you go to someone's blog, you're going to read their thoughts. If those thoughts don't happen to be funny... well, who is funny all the time? Cracked, on the other hand, explicitly sells itself as a humor site. If an article isn't funny, I'm left thinking "why did I just read that?" and "whatever it would cost them to get Jay Pinkerton to do some articles for them would be totally worth it."

Where is Jay writing now? I haven't seen anything of his in a very long time.
 
I hate to revive this thread, but this question will bug me all night if I don't answer it.

Where is Jay writing now? I haven't seen anything of his in a very long time.

Jay is writing for Valve now. Last I checked he was one of the writers for Portal 2, and I'm pretty sure he had a hand with the original and one of the L4D games.

He has been known to drop by the Cracked forums and make a post or two, but those are super rare.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom