From Cracked: 5 ridiculous things you probably believe about Islam

In fact, let me give you a few other countries which different sources have deemed among the worst in the world for women:

Papua New Guinea: violence (an astounding 58% of women have been victims of violence), a HIV rate 4 times higher than for men, lots of rape. 96% of the population is Christian, and not only there is buggerall Islam influence in that, they actually had a few proposals to basically forbid or limit the freedom of religion when it comes to Islam.

Haiti: rape was criminalized only 3 years ago. No, seriously. An estimated whole 50% of women have been raped. A third of those were raped under the age of 13. Again 96% of the country is Christian (80% Catholic, 16% Protestant.)
 
So, since Guatemala is on that list, can we also conclude that Christianity as a whole is bad?

Only if you ignore the seven Muslim countries that were also on the list. Also you have to ignore countries where women have equal rights. None of them have a Muslim majority. Hmmm, wonder why that is? :rolleyes:

Also, non-sequitur duly noted. How do you jump from that to "religion of peace" is beyond me, but I guess that's the kind of mental gymnastics needed to support bigotry.

Nearly all Muslim-majority countries are ********* you would never want to live in. This is universally known, hence my "religion of peace" quip. But you're right, it had nothing specifically to do with women's rights. We can talk about general human rights abuses in countries like Iran, Nigeria, Yemen, etc.

Also, I note the fine art of dishonest quoting out of context. Because the reasons it gives there for being worst for women typically have nothing to do with Islam.

Of course not. Sharia Law has absolutely nothing to do with how women are treated. :rolleyes:

Sharia Law in Britain: A Threat to One Law for All and Equal Rights, reveals the adverse effect of sharia courts on family law. Under sharia's civil code, a woman's testimony is worth half of a man's. A man can divorce his wife by repudiation, whereas a woman must give justifications, some of which are difficult to prove. Child custody reverts to the father at a preset age; women who remarry lose custody of their children even before then; and sons inherit twice the share of daughters
http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2010/jul/05/sharia-law-religious-courts

The root causes in half the cases: war. E.g., the women's problem in Iraq isn't anywhere near religious in the original article you plucked that from, it's being impoverished and displaced by the war.

So when women are stoned to death in Iran it's because of war?

They say chutzpah is that quality which allows someone on trial for murdering his parents to ask for clemency because he's an orphan. And it takes a shameless lot of chutzpah for the country that invaded Iraq and caused the problems described in the article, to then blame them via an association fallacy on the Islam. No, really, it's so bullcrap, it's insulting.

Americans caused women to be mistreated in Iraq? ********. Our stupid invasion created a lawless environment where Iraqis reverted to treating women like ****. Just like every other Muslim country surrounding Iraq. But blame lies with those who are doing the mistreatment. Did we also cause women to be mistreated in Egypt? Saudia Arabia? Iran?

Edit: I also note that you manage not to notice other countries noted there as being crap -- if indeed you actually read the article that list is from, and not just the list as a canned propaganda talking point -- such as Zambia, an officially Christian nation. What did _Christianity_ do for women there? Or, yeah, in Guatemala?

I have no love for Christianity. But it's followers have a much more mature belief system compared to Muslims. Majority Christian countries that actually respect freedom and are decent places to live:
America
Canada
UK
Greece
Spain
Sweden
(Basically all of Western Europe)

I'm sorry if it makes Muslims feel bad, that nearly all the countries where they're a majority suck, but recognizing there's a problem is the first step towards recovery.
 
Last edited:
In fact, let me give you a few other countries which different sources have deemed among the worst in the world for women:

Papua New Guinea: violence (an astounding 58% of women have been victims of violence), a HIV rate 4 times higher than for men, lots of rape. 96% of the population is Christian, and not only there is buggerall Islam influence in that, they actually had a few proposals to basically forbid or limit the freedom of religion when it comes to Islam.

Haiti: rape was criminalized only 3 years ago. No, seriously. An estimated whole 50% of women have been raped. A third of those were raped under the age of 13. Again 96% of the country is Christian (80% Catholic, 16% Protestant.)

I don't dispute there are non-muslim nations that are complete failures. But there are also plenty of non-Muslim successful nations that repect personal and economic freedom. How many Muslim nations fit that bill? One? None? THAT'S the problem.
 
I don't dispute there are non-muslim nations that are complete failures. But there are also plenty of non-Muslim successful nations that repect personal and economic freedom. How many Muslim nations fit that bill? One? None? THAT'S the problem.

The message I am getting from you is this: Islam is inherently more evil than Christianity.

If that is true, then how do you explain all of the evil things Christianity did in Europe over hundreds of years? If Christianity was truly the "religion of peace" then European slavery and witch burnings never would have existed.
 
The message I am getting from you is this: Islam is inherently more evil than Christianity.

If that is true, then how do you explain all of the evil things Christianity did in Europe over hundreds of years? If Christianity was truly the "religion of peace" then European slavery and witch burnings never would have existed.

I don't think they're more evil. For whatever reason they have a very rigid belief system that is rarely questioned or open to interpretation. When it is interpretated, it often becomes even more restrictive and regimented (e.g., Taliban). Christians were like this for a long time. Russian communists for much of the 20th century were also like this. It isn't endemic to Islam.

Personally, I think it has to do with soul age, but that's a whole nother thread. I just don't like people whitewashing the glaring problems that exist in nearly all of the Muslim world.
 
I don't think they're more evil. For whatever reason they have a very rigid belief system that is rarely questioned or open to interpretation. When it is interpretated, it often becomes even more restrictive and regimented (e.g., Taliban). Christians were like this for a long time. Russian communists for much of the 20th century were also like this. It isn't endemic to Islam.

Personally, I think it has to do with soul age, but that's a whole nother thread. I just don't like people whitewashing the glaring problems that exist in nearly all of the Muslim world.

No. It has to do with the fact that most, if not all, of the "christian nations" were secularized. That means, the power was taken away from the church, and rightfully so. The church simply had no influence on state matters anymore. While they had, they happily murdered people, using their silly holy books as justification.

Many of the muslim nations are governed by religious "laws", respectively religious leaders. That's why they impose it on the people. If they would be as secular as we are, it would certainly stop.

Greetings,

Chris

ETA: And about the "equal rights for women" comment you made in another post. You are aware that these rights came because (and only after) the churches had no say anymore, are you? Do you seriously believe that would have happened if the churches still had their power in governments? When was the last time you have seen a female priest, for example? Ask the catholic church what they think about womans rights.
 
Last edited:
No. It has to do with the fact that most, if not all, of the "christian nations" were secularized. That means, the power was taken away from the church, and rightfully so. The church simply had no influence on state matters anymore. While they had, they happily murdered people, using their silly holy books as justification.

There's a glaring problem with your analysis: countries that had no church influence "happily" murdered the most people, and were some of the most restrictive countries on Earth. China and Russia being the two worst offenders.

Many of the muslim nations are governed by religious "laws", respectively religious leaders. That's why they impose it on the people. If they would be as secular as we are, it would certainly stop.

Greetings,

Chris

ETA: And about the "equal rights for women" comment you made in another post. You are aware that these rights came because (and only after) the churches had no say anymore, are you? Do you seriously believe that would have happened if the churches still had their power in governments? When was the last time you have seen a female priest, for example? Ask the catholic church what they think about womans rights.

All that just raises a similar question: what is it about Muslism nations that doesn't allow them to become secular? (Or conversely, what is it about Christian nations that allowed them to become secularized?) Again, it goes back to rigidity of belief systems.
 
There's a glaring problem with your analysis: countries that had no church influence "happily" murdered the most people, and were some of the most restrictive countries on Earth. China and Russia being the two worst offenders.

That's a non sequitur if I ever saw one. Who said the church was the only institution to murder people?
 
I don't dispute there are non-muslim nations that are complete failures. But there are also plenty of non-Muslim successful nations that repect personal and economic freedom. How many Muslim nations fit that bill? One? None? THAT'S the problem.

Oh, gee, if it's not the "they never did anything right" piece of bigoted propaganda. And you actually believe it, don't you?

You want one example? Turkey. The women have jobs, drive cars, and aren't in burqas either. And rape incidence is at 0.0180876 per 1,000 people, a good two orders of magnitude less than the world leader South Africa (79.7% of the population of South Africa is Christian, btw) and actually quite a bit better than the USA or most of Europe.

Lemme guess, now one example isn't enough? Ok. Morocco. (Predominantly Sunni Islam. You know, same as Saudi Arabia.) Sure, it used to be crap, but they starting reforming the heck out of it in the 21'st century, and it's generally going for the better.

Lemme guess, two still aren't enough? Tunisia. They legalized abortions without needing any permission from the father, removed the legal allowances for "honor killings" (now you face a life sentence if you kill your wife even if you find her in bed with another guy), launched several campaigns against domestic violence, etc. They actually managed to use the Quran in that too, by getting a bunch of muftis to rule that actually it condemns all violence against women, and a bunch of them actually preach against such violence in the mosques.
 
All that just raises a similar question: what is it about Muslism nations that doesn't allow them to become secular? (Or conversely, what is it about Christian nations that allowed them to become secularized?) Again, it goes back to rigidity of belief systems.

You can start with Guns, Germs and Steel for an insight into the whole complex phenomenon. Reducing it all to purely religious systems is so oversimplified, it's stupid.
 
There's a glaring problem with your analysis: countries that had no church influence "happily" murdered the most people, and were some of the most restrictive countries on Earth. China and Russia being the two worst offenders.

Which simply says that people are bastards and power corrupts, regardless of the belief system (religious, political, or otherwise) that the corrupt use to justify their excesses.

All that just raises a similar question: what is it about Muslism nations that doesn't allow them to become secular? (Or conversely, what is it about Christian nations that allowed them to become secularized?)

Nothing. Or, rather, nothing that's different between Islam and Christianity. For a variety of complicated reasons that are mostly unrelated to the religious belief systems themselves, Christianity and the Christian World as a whole has become more moderate, tolerant, and (dare I say it) secular, while Islam and the Muslim World has gone in the other direction. But it hasn't always been this way - there was a time when the Muslim World was more moderate and tolerant than the Christian World was, albeit by the standards of the day, not today's standards.

It's long been understood and accepted by Islamic Modernists (like, 150 years long) that the Muslim World needs an equivalent of the Enlightenment to happen. There's a quote from one of them that I've posted in other threads before, since it basically sums up the dissatisfaction of these Muslims with the state of Islam as compared to the state of Christianity and the desire to reform the Muslim World:

"If it is true that the Muslim religion is an obstacle to the development of sciences, can one affirm that this obstacle will not disappear someday? How does the Muslim religion differ on this point from other religions? All religions are intolerant, each one in its way. The Christian religion, I mean the society that follows its inspirations and its teachings and is formed in its image, has emerged from the first period to which I have just alluded; thenceforth free and independent, it seems to advance rapidly on the road of progress and science, whereas Muslim society has not yet freed itself from the tutelage of religion. Realizing, however, that the Christian religion preceded the Muslim religion in the world by many centuries, I cannot keep from hoping that Muhammadan society will succeed someday in breaking its bonds and marching resolutely in the path of civilization after the manner of Western society…No I cannot admit that this hope be denied to Islam.” Jamal-al-Din Afghani, 1838-1897.
 
Oh, gee, if it's not the "they never did anything right" piece of bigoted propaganda. And you actually believe it, don't you?

You want one example? Turkey. The women have jobs, drive cars, and aren't in burqas either. And rape incidence is at 0.0180876 per 1,000 people, a good two orders of magnitude less than the world leader South Africa (79.7% of the population of South Africa is Christian, btw) and actually quite a bit better than the USA or most of Europe.

Lemme guess, now one example isn't enough? Ok. Morocco. (Predominantly Sunni Islam. You know, same as Saudi Arabia.) Sure, it used to be crap, but they starting reforming the heck out of it in the 21'st century, and it's generally going for the better.

Lemme guess, two still aren't enough? Tunisia. They legalized abortions without needing any permission from the father, removed the legal allowances for "honor killings" (now you face a life sentence if you kill your wife even if you find her in bed with another guy), launched several campaigns against domestic violence, etc. They actually managed to use the Quran in that too, by getting a bunch of muftis to rule that actually it condemns all violence against women, and a bunch of them actually preach against such violence in the mosques.

Indonesia's mostly pretty good too, though not without problems. Also you're more likely to run into an Indonesian Muslim than an Arab Muslim, statistically.
 
Oh, gee, if it's not the "they never did anything right" piece of bigoted propaganda. And you actually believe it, don't you?

You want one example? Turkey. The women have jobs, drive cars, and aren't in burqas either. And rape incidence is at 0.0180876 per 1,000 people, a good two orders of magnitude less than the world leader South Africa (79.7% of the population of South Africa is Christian, btw) and actually quite a bit better than the USA or most of Europe.

Turkey was why I said "one". Their economy isn't all that great and they have some human rights issues, but they're doing OK.

Lemme guess, now one example isn't enough? Ok. Morocco. (Predominantly Sunni Islam. You know, same as Saudi Arabia.) Sure, it used to be crap, but they starting reforming the heck out of it in the 21'st century, and it's generally going for the better.

Ummm

Citizens did not have the right to change the constitutional provisions establishing their monarchical form of government or the establishment of the practice of Islam. Reports of torture and other abuses by various branches of the security forces persisted, and prison conditions remained below international standards. Reports of arbitrary arrests, incommunicado detentions, and police and security force impunity continued. Politics, as well as corruption and inefficiency, influenced the judiciary, which was not fully independent. The government restricted freedoms of speech, religion, and the press. Corruption was a serious problem in all branches of government. Trafficking in persons continued, and child labor, particularly in the unregulated informal sector, remained a problem.
http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/nea/119122.htm


Lemme guess, two still aren't enough? Tunisia. They legalized abortions without needing any permission from the father, removed the legal allowances for "honor killings" (now you face a life sentence if you kill your wife even if you find her in bed with another guy), launched several campaigns against domestic violence, etc. They actually managed to use the Quran in that too, by getting a bunch of muftis to rule that actually it condemns all violence against women, and a bunch of them actually preach against such violence in the mosques.

Ummm

There were significant limitations on citizens' right to change their government. Local and international nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) reported that security forces tortured and physically abused prisoners and detainees and arbitrarily arrested and detained individuals. Security forces acted with impunity sanctioned by high-ranking officials. There were also reports of lengthy pretrial and incommunicado detention. The government infringed on citizens' privacy rights and continued to impose severe restrictions on freedoms of speech, press, assembly, and association. The government remained intolerant of public criticism, and there were widespread reports that it used intimidation, criminal investigations, the judicial system, arbitrary arrests, residential restrictions, and travel controls to discourage criticism by human rights and opposition activists. Media freedom was severely restricted during the year and corruption was a problem.
http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/nea/119128.htm

Other than torture, rampant corruption, and restriction of personal freedoms, they're great places to live, if you like making $4,000 a year.*

*Belgium has approx. the same population as Tunisia. So by way of comparison:

The government generally respected the human rights of its citizens, and the law and the judiciary provided effective means of addressing individual instances of abuse. The following human rights problems were reported: overcrowded prisons, lengthy pretrial detention, poor detention conditions prior to expulsion of adults and children whose asylum applications were refused, violence against women, child abuse, trafficking in persons, and racial and ethnic discrimination in the job market.
http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2008/eur/119070.htm

Per capita income is $38,600.

So your two shining examples (other than Turkey) were upstaged by Belgium (75% Catholic).
 
That's a non sequitur if I ever saw one. Who said the church was the only institution to murder people?

Here:

Originally Posted by Christian Klippel
No. It has to do with the fact that most, if not all, of the "christian nations" were secularized. That means, the power was taken away from the church, and rightfully so. The church simply had no influence on state matters anymore. While they had, they happily murdered people, using their silly holy books as justification.

This implies that when the power of the church waned, people stopped being "happily murdered". In fact, the opposite happened. As religious influence waned in countries like China and Russia, and they adopted atheistic regimes, more people were "happily murdered".
 
I don't think they're more evil. For whatever reason they have a very rigid belief system that is rarely questioned or open to interpretation. When it is interpretated, it often becomes even more restrictive and regimented (e.g., Taliban). Christians were like this for a long time. Russian communists for much of the 20th century were also like this. It isn't endemic to Islam.

So why focus on Islam? Yes, Islamic terrorism is the authoritarianism du jure but that doesn't Islam special. It just happens to be the era you live in.

Personally, I think it has to do with soul age, but that's a whole nother thread.

Dude! I friggin' loved that game!

Oh...what the hell is "soul age"?
 
This implies that when the power of the church waned, people stopped being "happily murdered". In fact, the opposite happened. As religious influence waned in countries like China and Russia, and they adopted atheistic regimes, more people were "happily murdered".

What about western Europe? The Holy Roman Empire collapsed and it was eventually replaced by democracy.
 
This implies that when the power of the church waned, people stopped being "happily murdered".

No.

In fact, the opposite happened. As religious influence waned in countries like China and Russia, and they adopted atheistic regimes, more people were "happily murdered".

And, just to make a point: Atheist regimes who religiously followed political dogma.
 
No. It has to do with the fact that most, if not all, of the "christian nations" were secularized. That means, the power was taken away from the church, and rightfully so. The church simply had no influence on state matters anymore. While they had, they happily murdered people, using their silly holy books as justification.
(bolding Malerin's, highlighting mine)
This implies that when the power of the church waned, people stopped being "happily murdered". In fact, the opposite happened. As religious influence waned in countries like China and Russia, and they adopted atheistic regimes, more people were "happily murdered".
You might want to do something about your reading comprehension. The "they"s and "their" refer back to "the church". I'm not aware that it was the church in the Soviet Union (not Russia) and in China that murdered people. :rolleyes:

ETA: And about the "equal rights for women" comment you made in another post. You are aware that these rights came because (and only after) the churches had no say anymore, are you? Do you seriously believe that would have happened if the churches still had their power in governments? When was the last time you have seen a female priest, for example? Ask the catholic church what they think about womans rights.
Nitpick: many protestant variants of Christianity have women priests. Some (at least in my neck of the woods) even have instituted religious gay marriage. But then, the Dutch calvinist church never controlled the state, more the other way round.
 
Nitpick: many protestant variants of Christianity have women priests. Some (at least in my neck of the woods) even have instituted religious gay marriage. But then, the Dutch calvinist church never controlled the state, more the other way round.

Ah, thanks for the info, learned something today.

But i guess that such occurrences are a rare thing, compared to the total number of christian sects?

Greetings,

Chris
 
Here:



This implies that when the power of the church waned, people stopped being "happily murdered". In fact, the opposite happened. As religious influence waned in countries like China and Russia, and they adopted atheistic regimes, more people were "happily murdered".

Try reading it again. You reading comprehension seems to be sub-par.

Greetings,

Chris
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom