Fort Worth bus ads make fundies crazy

I noticed something: the majority of people in this thread who have a problem with Texas live in the Dallas area. Every other supporter of Texas lives elsewhere in the state.

Maybe we're all blind people trying to describe the elephant.

For the record, I live in the Dallas area, and I can agree unequivocally that my portion of Texas is comprised of a lot of very vocal Christians. I actually work with several who are rabidly Christian, to the extent of "if ya'll ain't Christian, then GTFO". Two of them think nothing of having Bibles on their desks at work, and often pray out loud during work hours (these are men, btw).

The wealthy and policy-making people in this area (very often the same people) are all unabashedly Christian, in a GW Bush sort of way. It's a peculiar culture to live in, having transplanted myself from New York/ New England a decade ago. There is a veneer of civility and yet, I know I might lose my job if it were discovered I'm an atheist (hell, they barely tolerate the fact that I'm a Democrat!).

My only salvation is that I moved closer to Denton, which is a tiny mecca of indy music and independent thinking.
 
The wealthy and policy-making people in this area (very often the same people) are all unabashedly Christian, in a GW Bush sort of way.

I've previously mentioned Prestonwood Baptist Church. They are huge and less of a church than a country club. If you want to do business or get elected in the area in and around Plano you will grease many wheels by joining the afore-mentioned megachurch.
 
I noticed something: the majority of people in this thread who have a problem with Texas live in the Dallas area. Every other supporter of Texas lives elsewhere in the state.

I'm not seeing the part in bold at all. A better way to have put it is those of us in D-FW are more cognizant of influence of Conservative Christians than those in other metropolitan areas of the state.

Channel 4 offered another example tonight.
http://www.myfoxdfw.com/dpp/news/120710-site-lists-‘naughty’-and-‘nice’-businesses
 
I was a bit surprised when I picked up the church bulletin* this week and the letter from the priest was on this topic. He is a Bishop, so I was hoping to see a pretty well reasoned bit of writing. I was actually shocked at how bad the response was.

What really got me was that he missed the entire point of the ad, and then attacked what he assumed the ad was about.

My comments here are in regard to
the slogan itself. What I would like
to say to those who paid all the
money and fought so hard for this
ad is simply, “Is this your best
shot?” “Is this the best you can do
to undermine our Faith?” This
statement reveals an ignorance of
Christian teaching and of the harsh
reality of people’s lives when they
try to live without Christian hope.
I guess he can't wrap his head around the fact that the ads were an outreach program meant to let those without faith know that they are not alone while also assuring those with faith that the faithless aren't bad people.

That would have required going to the COR site and reading their press release:

"The point of our national campaign is to reach out to the millions of humanists, atheists and agnostics living in the United States," explained Fred Edwords, national director of the United Coalition of Reason. "Nontheists like these sometimes don't realize there's a community out there for them because they're inundated with religious messages at every turn. So we hope this will serve as a beacon and let them know they aren't alone."

Reaching out to a secular audience isn't the only goal of the campaign, however. "We want religious people to understand that non-believers are basically the same as everyone else," added Terry McDonald. "We are as 'good', as moral as any other group. If you look you'll find us among your friends, neighbors, coworkers and family members."
He then goes on to beat that strawman with straw sticks of bad logic. To summarize:

1. We can't know what is good without God.

2. People without faith lead empty lives. Just ask our converts about their prior lives . .

3. Being good without God is akin to trying to be God. See serpent in tale of Adam and Eve.

4. Being good for God brings us closer to God because he will pay us off in Heaven.

He even ends it with this little jewel:
What a shame it would be for a
person just to be good—for nothing!
I guess it has to do with my experience with Jesuits, but I expect better reasoning and better writing from a bishop. This was just awful.

I really don't want to discuss all the flaws in his reasoning, it is so bad that it doesn't merit the criticism. I just wanted to point out how such shoddy writing is acceptable if the picture next to the by-line is a guy with a stiff collar.

*It is not available in a public link yet, but I can send a pdf on request, or actually give a link to the pdf that is on their servers, via PM.
 
On the other side of the coin, what would be a good pithy saying to let non-believers know that they aren't alone out there?
 
I was a bit surprised when I picked up the church bulletin* this week and the letter from the priest was on this topic. He is a Bishop, so I was hoping to see a pretty well reasoned bit of writing. I was actually shocked at how bad the response was...

Unfortunately, within church heirarchy, neither debating skills, nor theological brilliance are as important as politics in moving up the chain of church authority and status.
 
This part:
What I would like to say to those who paid all the money and fought so hard for this ad is simply, “Is this your best shot?” “Is this the best you can do to undermine our Faith?”
is reminiscent of a lot of the comments I saw on local media websites and last Sundays DMN letters to the editor.

Talk about not getting it. DK has already pointed out the awful hermoneutics, but there was not fight, hard or otherwise, to get the signs on Fort Worth buses. They paid

- Wait minute.. as I'm typing this Channel 11 is reairing the 10pm news and they just reported that the T has changed it's policy to not allow any religious related advertising.
http://dfw.cbslocal.com/2010/12/15/the-t-bans-religious-ads-from-buses/

Good job Christian zealots and your dupes at Fox 4, etc. Not only did you prevent those militant atheists from putting advertising on buses, now you can't either. Dummies.

Oh, and look that this quote from the story:
The morning team at Christian radio station 90.9 KCBI took a different approach.

“We at KCBI made the conscious decision to be on the offensive this year, and to keep Christ in Christmas,” said morning show host Jim Wilson. “We thought this would be the best and most positive way to do that, by singing Christmas carols on the buses.”
and this CT post in the comments section:
Congrats. You just took the bait. This was exactly what was wanted. I didn’t want the prevalence of these ads to continue anymore than the next guy, but I am smart enough to see a baited hook. Religion in the eyes of the law isn’t divided even by atheism/believer. You just opened the door to challenge what made Ft. Worth’s rebuild after the tornado such a shining example of how to make a miracle out of disaster. There was a reason these ads were taken out in Ft. Worth instead of Deep Ellum. Now any religious presence on city/public property that can be manipulated into being classified as advertising will be challenged under this president. Don’t be so quick in your religious zeal as to not see when you are being tested. That being said ….. it was pure in reaction so it will all work out.

I'm sorry "Publius", but you fantasies about Machiavellian machinations on the part of COR are misplaced. I don't think they wanted a ban on all religious advertising on T buses. I think they just wanted an equal seat at the table.
 
Well, clearly it's better that no one have a seat at the table than that they might have to sit with us.
 
Great town, but the traffic sux, and cannot bear much more influx to the population. Yankee go home! ;)

The yankees are the only thing that make Texas livable.

If you think Texas isn't over the top lunatic fundy try living in Houston.
 
On the other side of the coin, what would be a good pithy saying to let non-believers know that they aren't alone out there?

But...I LIKE being alone.

It's when all my great thoughts come to me (and even when I'm plaigerizing them off the net I'm alone).
 
The yankees are the only thing that make Texas livable.

If you think Texas isn't over the top lunatic fundy try living in Houston.

I grew up in Houston, still visit there from time to time, and we've obviously had completely different experiences with it.

Most of my friends and relatives, in Houston, Austin and elsewhere, are and have been native Texans, atheist or agnostic, liberal, artists, filmmakers, teachers, poets, intellectuals, and not at all the "over the top lunatic fundy" types you appear to believe inhabit the state.

(My wife is from Michigan originally but has been in Texas over 20 years.)

The assertion "The yankees are the only thing that make Texas livable." is either a snarky anti-Texas joke or a bigoted untruth.
 
I grew up in Houston, still visit there from time to time, and we've obviously had completely different experiences with it.

Most of my friends and relatives, in Houston, Austin and elsewhere, are and have been native Texans, atheist or agnostic, liberal, artists, filmmakers, teachers, poets, intellectuals, and not at all the "over the top lunatic fundy" types you appear to believe inhabit the state.

(My wife is from Michigan originally but has been in Texas over 20 years.)

The assertion "The yankees are the only thing that make Texas livable." is either a snarky anti-Texas joke or a bigoted untruth.
They're just jealous...
 
I grew up in Houston, still visit there from time to time, and we've obviously had completely different experiences with it.

Most of my friends and relatives, in Houston, Austin and elsewhere, are and have been native Texans, atheist or agnostic, liberal, artists, filmmakers, teachers, poets, intellectuals, and not at all the "over the top lunatic fundy" types you appear to believe inhabit the state.

(My wife is from Michigan originally but has been in Texas over 20 years.)

The assertion "The yankees are the only thing that make Texas livable." is either a snarky anti-Texas joke or a bigoted untruth.

We've certainly had different experiences with Houston. I can't even begin to imagine where in Houston you worked or lived to have hung out with so many normal people.

BTW, you're the one who made what could be considered a snarky and bigoted yankee-go-home comment so you shouldn't be surprised, or offended, when someone replies in kind.
 
Last edited:
We've certainly had different experiences with Houston. I can't even begin to imagine where in Houston you worked or lived to have hung out with so many normal people.

Are you unaware that Houston is the home of at least three universities? There have to be faculty members living there. In fact, I know someone who is the daughter, stepdaughter and daughter-in-law of three different Rice professors.

Are you unfamiliar with the museum district and Montrose?

I have found that people generally see what they look for, and not much else.
 
Are you unaware that Houston is the home of at least three universities? There have to be faculty members living there. In fact, I know someone who is the daughter, stepdaughter and daughter-in-law of three different Rice professors.

Are you unfamiliar with the museum district and Montrose?

I have found that people generally see what they look for, and not much else.

Your right. What was I thinking?!!!
I forgot to consider how those 2000 faculty members and their relatives affect the balance of power in the 4th largest city in the nation.

Here's a Houston museum you may not know of. If you have some time to kill it's very interesting.
 
I have found that people generally see what they look for, and not much else.

Your right. What was I thinking?!!!
I forgot to consider how those 2000 faculty members and their relatives affect the balance of power in the 4th largest city in the nation.

Here's a Houston museum you may not know of. If you have some time to kill it's very interesting.

Thanks for proving my point for me.
 
We've certainly had different experiences with Houston. I can't even begin to imagine where in Houston you worked or lived to have hung out with so many normal people.

Galleria area, 1972 - 1988. I still visit my friend who is a civil rights lawyer and lives in the University district. Growing up, I was surrounded by my mother's Houstonian friends, many of whom lived in Montrose or the Heights and are/were photographers, artists and musicians. Perhaps such people are a minority, but I just don't mingle or run into or associate with the "fundy"-type person you seem so certain dominates the landscape there.

BTW, you're the one who made what could be considered a snarky and bigoted yankee-go-home comment so you shouldn't be surprised, or offended, when someone replies in kind.

Did I? Can you quote me or provide a link?
 
Are you unaware that Houston is the home of at least three universities? There have to be faculty members living there. In fact, I know someone who is the daughter, stepdaughter and daughter-in-law of three different Rice professors.

In addition there are consulate offices for any country that produces or uses oil, or so it seems. Not to mention all of the energy company employees from the best universities around the world. Do you really think XOM and Haliburton hire based on religious affiliation?

I think Houston is a far more diverse city than you are giving it credit for. I wouldn't live there again, but that has more to do with the weather than anything else.

Finally, everyone knows that it is the influx of Kalifornians that keeps Texas sane. Yankees have never brought as much to the table.
 
Here's a Houston museum you may not know of. If you have some time to kill it's very interesting.

My kids loved the exhibit of Terra Cotta Warriors last time they were in Houston. Was that at this funeral museum?

Also, is the beer can house still up near memorial park? That was culture, baby.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom