Fort Worth bus ads make fundies crazy

...OP, you appear to be cherry-picking information in order to paint Texas and its citizens as apoplectic religious zealots. This is incorrect.

Agreed, cherry-picking is completely unnecessary to confirm what the overwhelming majority (but not all) Texans themselves loudly proclaim and embrace.
 
The OP does not prove their premise. If it is these ads that have made Fundamentalists crazy, then how exactly have Fundamentalists been around for thousands of years?
 
Texas is not a "fundy state". We have a population of about 25 million; of those, a little over 5 million are Baptists, aka "evangelical Protestants", aka "religious fundamentalists". That's about 21% of the population -- hardly a majority. 11% profess "no religion". Source.
...

Baptists are not the only fundies, especially in Texas. Liberal varieties of christianity are extremely rare in that environment. Looking at your link, I would suggest that the "fundie" rate in Texas probably varies somewhere between 60-80%

Historically fundementalist christian belief and culture run deep in the lone star state.
http://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/online/articles/itf01
 
The OP does not prove their premise. If it is these ads that have made Fundamentalists crazy, then how exactly have Fundamentalists been around for thousands of years?

I read this and I'm completely unable to determine what the second sentence means when.

How does fundamentalism being around for thousands of years disallow the ads from making the fundies crazy?
 
...As an aside; sadly, it seems like many atheists have no better grasp of the logic behind their position than Christians do. I get the feeling they chose Atheism because it makes sense to them on a gut level, but they lack the knowledge to articulate why it makes sense to them. They are Atheism hooligans, ready to call names and shout down people that disagree with them, all in the name of rationality. Ironic.

Regards, Canis

Unfortunately, that is the impression most people have of Atheism, because that is the only brand they have ever been exposed to. Not that this represents most atheists, but the loudest voices tend to become the public face.
 
Agreed, cherry-picking is completely unnecessary to confirm what the overwhelming majority (but not all) Texans themselves loudly proclaim and embrace.

No.

If you want to speculate, as you do in your post further down, I speculate that, regardless of what denomination they belong to, the vast majority of church members in Texas are pretty much like church members anywhere else - they go because it's the socially acceptable thing to do, because their mamas and daddies went, for the community interaction, and because bidness is often much better if you're known as a church-goer.
 
Well, let's see:

FBI Report - Crime in the United States 2009 - murder and non-negligent manslaughter

Texas - 1,328
California - 1,972

So I guess you'll be staying away from California even harder than you stay away from Texas? And I believe certain other regions have higher murder rates, based on population.
...

from your source:
California - 1,972 out of 36,961,664 for a ratio of 5.3 per 100,000
Texas - 1,328 out of 24,782,302 for a ratio of 5.4 per 100,000

your point seems to be refuted by your "support"
 
from your source:
California - 1,972 out of 36,961,664 for a ratio of 5.3 per 100,000
Texas - 1,328 out of 24,782,302 for a ratio of 5.4 per 100,000

your point seems to be refuted by your "support"

Gosh, if you would take the time to read the whole thread, you would see that this has been addressed.
 
Baptists are not the only fundies, especially in Texas. Liberal varieties of christianity are extremely rare in that environment. Looking at your link, I would suggest that the "fundie" rate in Texas probably varies somewhere between 60-80%

I would disagree. "Cultural Catholics" make up a fairly large portion of the Catholic numbers as do non-practicing members of the other listed faiths. Up until recently I would have answered Episcopalian, even though I haven't been a regular for more than 20 years.

If 60-80% of Texans were fundies you'd expect a bit more traffic on Sunday morning. Instead I'm waiting in line at the donut shop. That's where the action seems to be. I've always noted that Sunday is when my neighbors pull out their Harleys or golf clubs, not their church suits.

What I found most startling from those numbers was the low percentage of Jews. My kids have lots of friends who are Jewish, at least 10% of their friends. Maybe it is a function of where I live. I also live near a lot of Mormons, but I know that's an anomaly.
 
I read this and I'm completely unable to determine what the second sentence means when.

How does fundamentalism being around for thousands of years disallow the ads from making the fundies crazy?

Not much of a sense of humor, eh?
 
No.

If you want to speculate, as you do in your post further down, I speculate that, regardless of what denomination they belong to, the vast majority of church members in Texas are pretty much like church members anywhere else - they go because it's the socially acceptable thing to do, because their mamas and daddies went, for the community interaction, and because bidness is often much better if you're known as a church-goer.

Having been to many Catholic churches in Texas, I can state unequivocally that they teach and preach a much more fundementalist varient than what is heard and learned in areas of the country where there are more liberal theological influences among the local culture. Though this is anecdotal, it is in accordance with your "socially acceptable," what their "mamas and daddies" believe and community interaction, hypothesis. Texas has a long and broad history of christian fundementalism ground into its cultural and political background, you may not like it, you may be an exception to it, but you are definitely a minority and vastly outnumbered in your perspective.
 
I read this and I'm completely unable to determine what the second sentence means when.

How does fundamentalism being around for thousands of years disallow the ads from making the fundies crazy?
Simple- they were crazy to begin with- the ads didn't make them this way.

As I believe I said on the first page of the thread....
 
Gosh, if you would take the time to read the whole thread, you would see that this has been addressed.

Backtracking quibbles are a fairly poor addressment, got any spelling errors you'd care to point out?
 
Simple- they were crazy to begin with- the ads didn't make them this way.

As I believe I said on the first page of the thread....

Ahh, I did skim looking for similar posts, but I guess the tiny writing or my own incompetence made me miss that post of yours.
 
Agreed, cherry-picking is completely unnecessary to confirm what the overwhelming majority (but not all) Texans themselves loudly proclaim and embrace.

Oh, they do not. I've lived here all my life (and QV my earlier post about my range of experiences in rural areas, small towns, and cities) and I do not hear, see or encounter an "overwhelming majority [of] Texans" who "loudly proclaim and embrace" religious zealotry.

You're exaggerating the claim of a conservative Christian majority to absurd, unsupportable proportions.
 
Ahh, I did skim looking for similar posts, but I guess the tiny writing or my own incompetence made me miss that post of yours.
Think nothing of it- posts that deal with the actual bus ads are easily lost amid the roar of the Texans.
 
I would disagree. "Cultural Catholics" make up a fairly large portion of the Catholic numbers as do non-practicing members of the other listed faiths. Up until recently I would have answered Episcopalian, even though I haven't been a regular for more than 20 years.

If 60-80% of Texans were fundies you'd expect a bit more traffic on Sunday morning. Instead I'm waiting in line at the donut shop. That's where the action seems to be. I've always noted that Sunday is when my neighbors pull out their Harleys or golf clubs, not their church suits.

What I found most startling from those numbers was the low percentage of Jews. My kids have lots of friends who are Jewish, at least 10% of their friends. Maybe it is a function of where I live. I also live near a lot of Mormons, but I know that's an anomaly.

This presumes that fundementalist beliefs actually correspond to devout religious practices, something that is little evidenced or supported in many surveys and polls.

Take a look at any of the polls asking about beliefs in evolution or abortion and weekly church attendance. Weekly church attendance tends to lag the beliefs by nearly half.
 
Last edited:
Oh, they do not. I've lived here all my life (and QV my earlier post about my range of experiences in rural areas, small towns, and cities) and I do not hear, see or encounter an "overwhelming majority [of] Texans" who "loudly proclaim and embrace" religious zealotry.

You're exaggerating the claim of a conservative Christian majority to absurd, unsupportable proportions.

your conflation of zealotry and fundementalist beliefs is the absurdity most clearly presented. Proclaiming and embracing fundementalist beliefs does not necessarily mean fanaticism, in most cases, these are just the sociocultural family values they were brought up with regardless of whether or not they are even particularly religious.
 
Backtracking quibbles are a fairly poor addressment, got any spelling errors you'd care to point out?
Well, since you asked:
This presumes that fundementalist beliefs actually correspond to devout religious practices, something that is little evidenced or supported in many surveys and polls.
Should be "fundamentalist".
 
Baptists are not the only fundies, especially in Texas. Liberal varieties of christianity are extremely rare in that environment. Looking at your link, I would suggest that the "fundie" rate in Texas probably varies somewhere between 60-80%

You can "suggest" whatever you like, your numbers are still invented and unsupportable. Broadly labeling all professed Christians in the state, including Catholics, as "fundamentalists" strips the word of its meaning. Not all who profess a religion are pious adherents, and not all pious adherents are "fundamentalist".

Your lumping together of Mexican-Americans, who comprise a significant portion of Texas Roman Catholics, with fundamentalist "religious zealots" who persecute atheists and religious minorities, is ridiculous and wholly unsupportable.

Historically fundementalist christian belief and culture run deep in the lone star state.
http://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/online/articles/itf01

That's a helpful article, thank you for posting it. I'm getting from it that fundamentalists began to come to power in the 1930s, and gained prominence in the 70s and 80s. This is hardly the "deep" entrenchment of such beliefs in the underpinning culture or history of the state you would have us believe exists. Nor am I seeing that it in any way supports your bare assertions about "60-80%" of the population being "fundies". You're appear to be inventing numbers, exaggerating claims and posting articles that do not support either.

Having been to many Catholic churches in Texas, I can state unequivocally that they teach and preach a much more fundementalist varient than what is heard and learned in areas of the country where there are more liberal theological influences among the local culture. Though this is anecdotal, it is in accordance with your "socially acceptable," what their "mamas and daddies" believe and community interaction, hypothesis. Texas has a long and broad history of christian fundementalism ground into its cultural and political background, you may not like it, you may be an exception to it, but you are definitely a minority and vastly outnumbered in your perspective.

Here's a shocker: My anecdotes are different from your anecdotes! In my anecdotes, Mexican Catholicism is akin to pagan folk tradition mingled with the best of the New Testament, and could not be more liberal in character.

In my anecdotes, sermons of many denominations are becoming less "fire-and-brimstone" and more about compassion and getting along with each other.

In my anecdotes, three or five "fundamentalists" and "religious zealots" stand on the corners of 6th street shouting religious slogans and pronouncements of doom, while thousands of night-clubbing party people and college students pass by without a second glance.

In my anecdotes, New Age shops, witchcraft emporiums, Buddhist and Hindu temples have existed for decades and decades, serving happy clientele, practitioners and/or worshippers who -- and this is key -- do not live in fear of Christian fundamentalists or zealots.

Have you got anything besides anecdotes, or articles that do not bear out your opinions? Because you're batting 0 for 3 here.

Backtracking quibbles are a fairly poor addressment, got any spelling errors you'd care to point out?

Numerous. Also, when you're met with the response that your point has been previously addressed, it behooves you to go and read the rebuttal. Otherwise you come across as a troll with no interest in a fair and equitable exchange of ideas and information.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom