FDNY conducts a week long high rise fire study

NYCEMT86: I'm a bit ignorant on the topic of fire fighting. Take that back: I'm a lot ignorant. Besides the obvious physical issues i.e. bigger distances, more floors to climb, what are some unique characteristics of high-rise fires that would lead to greater understanding of the WTC events? For example: I see someone mention the "chimney" effect, and there have been times I wondered if this was an issue with the Twin Towers, or with any tall buildings having elevator shafts or other potential sources to "draw" air in through. Conspiracy addicts tend to subscribe to this notion that the fires in the towers weren't that substantial or widespread. Ignoring the fuel - not the jet fuel, but the furniture and other office contents - I'd think that the forced airflow through the towers due to a sort of "chimney" effect would have an impact. Am I right about that?
.

I know this isn't addressed to me. I am a paramedic student. Firefighting is not my area of expertise. That being said:

Fire is fueled by oxygen. The elevator shafts have shafts running down most or the entire length of the building. In 1993, this allowed smoke to travel from the basement levels where a bomb had gone off up to the top of the building injuring some 4000 people. Most people on 9/11 above the crash probably suffocated to death due to heavy smoke rising if they didn't burn, jump or fall.

Firefighters wear heavy bunker gear, carry tools, hoses and other equipment. Each firefighter was carrying 100 plus lbs of equipment up 75 to 80 flights only to then fight a massive fire fueled by holes in the building caused by a crash and the resulting winds. I don't know if anyone has worn bunker gear, itgs heavy and hot. It was summer weather on 9/11.

Mo
 
I know this isn't addressed to me. I am a paramedic student. Firefighting is not my area of expertise. That being said:

<snip>

Mo

[/derail]
Hey medic student, I am going out drinking tonight, wanna hook me up with a line and a bag of B12? ^.^
[/end derail]
 
Last edited:
Today the FDNY sets fire to an abandoned high rise building (project building) outfitted with cameras and temperture sensors on govenors island ...


... in a weeklong study as to whether it is scientifically possible to make Governors Island any worse.
 
NYCEMT86 and firecoins have already hit this, but... the chimney effect simply means that fire gases and smoke will travel up vertical penetrations in a building - like stairwells, elevator shafts, and even cable and pipe chases - and make things very hot when they reach the top of their travel and "mushroom" across the top floor(s). That's why vertical ventilation is so important in high-rise fires; it lets the nasty hot stuff out skylights or other holes and buys time for the occupants up top.

What happened with WTC 1 and 2, and to an extent WTC 7 (and other buildings struck by debris) was massive and uncontrolled horizontal ventilation on many floors, together with an ignition source spread over many floors (flaming debris and of course in 1 and 2, jet fuel). Premature ventilation - i.e, before the guys with hoses are ready - on an "ordinary" fireground is generally a bad thing. On that day, it was disastrous; fire had a ready supply of fresh air and could be pushed by the wind down corridors and across open floor plans.
 
I know this isn't addressed to me. I am a paramedic student. Firefighting is not my area of expertise. That being said:

Fire is fueled by oxygen. The elevator shafts have shafts running down most or the entire length of the building. In 1993, this allowed smoke to travel from the basement levels where a bomb had gone off up to the top of the building injuring some 4000 people. Most people on 9/11 above the crash probably suffocated to death due to heavy smoke rising if they didn't burn, jump or fall.

Firefighters wear heavy bunker gear, carry tools, hoses and other equipment. Each firefighter was carrying 100 plus lbs of equipment up 75 to 80 flights only to then fight a massive fire fueled by holes in the building caused by a crash and the resulting winds. I don't know if anyone has worn bunker gear, itgs heavy and hot. It was summer weather on 9/11.

Mo

Please, feel free to chime in. Like I said, I'm very much ignorant of what's involved in fighting high-rise blazes, and every little bit of info helps.

Like I've said previously: I can't imagine running up 7 or 8 floors with just a 10 pound bag of potatoes, let alone 70+ flights with 75+ pounds of firefighting gear. Hell, I can't imagine running up 5 floors with just a bag of potato chips! The effort needed in order to just get to a fire is amazing, let alone what has to happen once you're there. I'm interested in reading it.
 
NYCEMT86 and firecoins have already hit this, but... the chimney effect simply means that fire gases and smoke will travel up vertical penetrations in a building - like stairwells, elevator shafts, and even cable and pipe chases - and make things very hot when they reach the top of their travel and "mushroom" across the top floor(s). That's why vertical ventilation is so important in high-rise fires; it lets the nasty hot stuff out skylights or other holes and buys time for the occupants up top.

What happened with WTC 1 and 2, and to an extent WTC 7 (and other buildings struck by debris) was massive and uncontrolled horizontal ventilation on many floors, together with an ignition source spread over many floors (flaming debris and of course in 1 and 2, jet fuel). Premature ventilation - i.e, before the guys with hoses are ready - on an "ordinary" fireground is generally a bad thing. On that day, it was disastrous; fire had a ready supply of fresh air and could be pushed by the wind down corridors and across open floor plans.

Ok--what do you fire experts call the natural draft that results when all those heated gasses leave by the roof, drawing fresh, clean air in at the base of the fire.
In my experience as a Boy Scout, Mountain Man, blacksmith, and from my HVAC larnin' as an ME, the bigger the fire gets, the bigger the draft gets, caausing a more intense burn, which draws in more air, etc, up to a limit based on fuel type, surface area, and quantity, among others. I have been around (Large!) grass fires, and the force of the inflow to the fire can be very intense--and those are in open country, so you get 360 degree inflow...
That's what I call the 'Chimney Effect", so maybe we are discussing different things...
 
Indirectly, flight 11 did.
No, it didn't. Why must you consistently lie?

Once again, JHarrow, you are the one who is caught lying.

Care to explain what is happening in this picture (I've included a couple of subtle clues to help you out)?

WTC7gothit.jpg


Lapman's state was completely accurate.
 
Flight 11 hit WTC 1. Pieces of WTC 1 hit WTC 7. Hence the indirect hit. Why must you make unsubstantiated accusations and claims?

No plane hit building 7. You cannot make it so with whining so just accept it.
 
Last edited:
Ok--what do you fire experts call the natural draft that results when all those heated gasses leave by the roof, drawing fresh, clean air in at the base of the fire.
In my experience as a Boy Scout, Mountain Man, blacksmith, and from my HVAC larnin' as an ME, the bigger the fire gets, the bigger the draft gets, caausing a more intense burn, which draws in more air, etc, up to a limit based on fuel type, surface area, and quantity, among others. I have been around (Large!) grass fires, and the force of the inflow to the fire can be very intense--and those are in open country, so you get 360 degree inflow...
That's what I call the 'Chimney Effect", so maybe we are discussing different things...

That is the natural process of the fire, I dont have a better word for it at the moment, the "Chimney Effect" is probably a better term.

A brush fire can burn for weeks or even months at a time due to the fact that there is almost an unlimited amount of fuel and oxygen.


Now if you placed a fire in an enclosed area and pump o2 into the area, when the super heated gasses are released they settle to the floor where it is cooler and consumed again by the fire. You can cut the o2 and the fire will become a self contained fire. However, after awhile of this cycle the air temp becomes uniformed from floor to ceiling and the fire dies out or becomes a potential backdraft.


I hope that helps
 
Great thread subject, NYCEMT86, thanks!

(And one of my FDNY contacts is quoted in the NY Times article linked above, too. Very cool.)
 
Last edited:
Great thread subject, NYCEMT86, thanks!

(And one of my FDNY contacts is quoted in the NY Times article linked above, too. Very cool.)

Not a problem, I figure this is going to be a great educational tool for all of us. While we watch the troof movement's attempt to recreate a "scale" model of the wtc out of chicken wire and legos, NIST and other federal/city agencies get involved to actually learn more about fires in a real world situation.


Though this study is not focused on 9/11 specifically, I wouldn't be surprised if NIST finds something to add or change on their report. No that doesn't mean the report is wrong, it just means the scientific method is an important tool for learning how things work in this world.

[/Steps off soap box]
 
Though this study is not focused on 9/11 specifically, I wouldn't be surprised if NIST finds something to add or change on their report. No that doesn't mean the report is wrong, it just means the scientific method is an important tool for learning how things work in this world.

[/Steps off soap box]

Yes, true. Modeling only gets you so far; at some point, you need empirical evidence. I can't imagine the difficulties involved in, say, computer modeling a structure fire; the event is so inherently complex and chaotic that you probably can only model broad characteristic, then observe live fires for info that lets you refine the model.

Then again, the Purdue team did a bang up job on their modeling, from what I understand. So it's possible, just a complex pain in the :rule10.

Going back to the original question I asked about high-rise fires, and air draw from the "chimney" effect: In a tall building, just how strong is that air draw effect? Ignoring what it does to the fires, I'm wondering exactly what it does to the fire fighters. I can't imagine that a virtual wind tunnel makes manuvering easy, let alone what it does to screw up your aim with the hoses.

And going back to the fires: So much of the conspiracy fantasy is invested in claiming that temperatures were relatively low (Mackey in the other thread talks about the folks saying NIST can't prove anything more than 250 degrees C. (482 degrees F), which is ridiculously low). Your Basic Principles thread discusses how even mundane fires can reach 1000 degrees F. My question arising from all of that is this: If you consider the convection airflow through either of the main towers - an airflow I would guess was considerable - how likely is it that the temperatures at the fires exceeded the 1000 degree fahrenheit mark? It seems to me, a total layman, that you'd have a considerable amount of convection airflow feeding those fires. It wouldn't quite be a blast furnace, or even a bellows effect because both of those scenarios involve more pressure than is naturally present, but you'd still have one hell of a stoked fire.

And thanks again for the thread.
 
The chimney effect can very efficient at transporting heat and nasty stuff up, but as to the "wind" being a physical problem, I dunno. I've never been in a high-rise fire - we only have one high-rise in our first due area - but I've never heard anyone talk about the force of moving air, only about heat and smoke. That is just my limited secondhand view.

As far as temperatures go, check out the scary dry-Christmas-tree fire video. When you start to see flashes in the smoke beginning around the 0:35 mark, that's gases in the air starting to ignite. The room is flashed over by the end of the video; at that point, pretty much everything in the room is burning, with a heat release rate of (IIRC) upwards of 20 kW/m2. (By comparison, full sun in the Arizona desert is around 1 kw/m2.) The CO in the air, for example, ignites around 1100 deg. F. That's just a mocked-up living room.

ETA: I looked at the PDF report associated with that test. They measured a peak heat release rate of just over five megawatts.
 
Last edited:
The chimney effect can very efficient at transporting heat and nasty stuff up, but as to the "wind" being a physical problem, I dunno. I've never been in a high-rise fire - we only have one high-rise in our first due area - but I've never heard anyone talk about the force of moving air, only about heat and smoke. That is just my limited secondhand view.

As far as temperatures go, check out the scary dry-Christmas-tree fire video. When you start to see flashes in the smoke beginning around the 0:35 mark, that's gases in the air starting to ignite. The room is flashed over by the end of the video; at that point, pretty much everything in the room is burning, with a heat release rate of (IIRC) upwards of 20 kW/m2. (By comparison, full sun in the Arizona desert is around 1 kw/m2.) The CO in the air, for example, ignites around 1100 deg. F. That's just a mocked-up living room.

ETA: I looked at the PDF report associated with that test. They measured a peak heat release rate of just over five megawatts.


You know, that brings up a musing I never remembered to ask until now: Does anyone have a rough idea of how much "fuel" energy was available in the fire-affected floors in either of the Twin Towers, or in WTC 7? I'm sure it's possible to come up with a general idea by just making assumptions of how many joules/kcals/whatever-unit-you-wanted-to-use are in the average office desk, the average chair, the average cubicle partition, ceiling tile, etc., but I've been waaaaaay too lazy to try and come up with any such calculation myself.

I'm musing over this again because of the continued fantasy claims that the fires were not large. Granted, you're never going to convince a truther, but having even a rough figure ("If you assume x-many furniture contents, you get x-many joules") helps in understanding the magnitude of the fires in the WTC buildings. And your figures involving the number of watts expended brought that musing back to mind.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom