FDNY conducts a week long high rise fire study

NYCEMT86

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jul 14, 2007
Messages
1,091
FDNY conducts high-rise fire in the name of that pesky thing called science.

Today the FDNY sets fire to an abandoned high rise building (project building) outfitted with cameras and temperture sensors on govenors island in a week long study to better understand high rise fires and impliment better firefighting techniques. Firefighters, fire officials, and engineers where on hand to witness this study.

The building did not collapse for all you troofers who are sitting on the edge of your seats, but that is obvious because this high rise wasn't hit by a commerical airliner.


So, What did the fire dept. learn?


Well from what I caught from the ABC 7 eyewitness news coverage was that the fires quickly spread and temps climbed to 1700*F due to higher wind speeds that fueled the fire in the building.


I am still waiting for more information to be released tonight, so everyone keep their eyes open this week as more studies are conducted and more knowledge about these fires is finally revealed.
 
Did they rig thermocouples to the beams and trusses, by any chance?
(guess why I ask...)
 
Did they rig thermocouples to the beams and trusses, by any chance?
(guess why I ask...)

I am not sure if they did, we will have to wait for the final report to see if they recorded more than just air temp. I don't know the exact construction of the projects, but I believe there is more brick and mortar than beams and trusses.
 
Which airliner hit building 7?

Yeah yeah and the NWO provides me with an additional salary.


Maybe if you read the non quote mined statements of eyewitnesses who talked about the damage to wtc7 from the collapse of tower 1, you would know that, but since that is an entirely different thread I ask that you don't derail this thread.
 




“We are turning this building into a very large laboratory instrument,” said Daniel Madrzykowski, a fire protection engineer with the National Institute of Standards and Technology, a division of the federal Department of Commerce, moments before the first of the intentionally set blazes roared through a seventh-floor apartment on Saturday.



Man, the NWO isn't even trying to hide it anymore!
 
FDNY conducts high-rise fire in the name of that pesky thing called science.

Today the FDNY sets fire to an abandoned high rise building (project building) outfitted with cameras and temperture sensors on govenors island in a week long study to better understand high rise fires and impliment better firefighting techniques. Firefighters, fire officials, and engineers where on hand to witness this study.

The building did not collapse for all you troofers who are sitting on the edge of your seats, but that is obvious because this high rise wasn't hit by a commerical airliner.

So, What did the fire dept. learn?

Well from what I caught from the ABC 7 eyewitness news coverage was that the fires quickly spread and temps climbed to 1700*F due to higher wind speeds that fueled the fire in the building.

I am still waiting for more information to be released tonight, so everyone keep their eyes open this week as more studies are conducted and more knowledge about these fires is finally revealed.
Looks from the article like this was an old brick building, I assume with wood framing. Interesting. Of course PPV is used to defend evacuation stairwells, and to clear smoke and heat after, or in conjunction with, an active fire attack, but the notion of using it to counter the wind effects is new to me. Seems to me in a typical high-rise scenario, you'd have a rough time getting the fans situated effectively to help you push down the corridor... but I'd certainly like to see more about it.
 
Terral, a material's ability to support load in fire is determined by heat, mechanical & thermal properties of the material and the effect of load upon the material.

You could have a fire at 300 degrees C cause a collapse if the effect of load is great enough, and on the other hand you could have a structure survive temperatures of 1100 degrees C if the load is light enough.
 
Looks from the article like this was an old brick building, I assume with wood framing. Interesting. Of course PPV is used to defend evacuation stairwells, and to clear smoke and heat after, or in conjunction with, an active fire attack, but the notion of using it to counter the wind effects is new to me. Seems to me in a typical high-rise scenario, you'd have a rough time getting the fans situated effectively to help you push down the corridor... but I'd certainly like to see more about it.

It is going to be interesting to see. In my old dept we had an SOP for a 14 story retirement home that called for dual ppvs at the fire exit doors to help with both evacuations and knock down. We never brought ppvs inside, but if I remember correctly its against nfpa standard to bring a gas operated fan into a building.

It might be possible to use ppv as a counter to the winds if they used 2 or more fans to increase the air flow, however as you said placement is going to be everything especially to create the cone effectively.
 
Hey, guys, take it easy. Let's just ignore JHarrow's derail. It's off topic, not to mention already covered in dozens of previous threads and external sites too.

NYCEMT86: I'm a bit ignorant on the topic of fire fighting. Take that back: I'm a lot ignorant. Besides the obvious physical issues i.e. bigger distances, more floors to climb, what are some unique characteristics of high-rise fires that would lead to greater understanding of the WTC events? For example: I see someone mention the "chimney" effect, and there have been times I wondered if this was an issue with the Twin Towers, or with any tall buildings having elevator shafts or other potential sources to "draw" air in through. Conspiracy addicts tend to subscribe to this notion that the fires in the towers weren't that substantial or widespread. Ignoring the fuel - not the jet fuel, but the furniture and other office contents - I'd think that the forced airflow through the towers due to a sort of "chimney" effect would have an impact. Am I right about that?

Also, if you have anything to add that doesn't have to do with that chimney example, go right ahead.
 
Hey, guys, take it easy. Let's just ignore JHarrow's derail. It's off topic, not to mention already covered in dozens of previous threads and external sites too.

NYCEMT86: I'm a bit ignorant on the topic of fire fighting. Take that back: I'm a lot ignorant. Besides the obvious physical issues i.e. bigger distances, more floors to climb, what are some unique characteristics of high-rise fires that would lead to greater understanding of the WTC events? For example: I see someone mention the "chimney" effect, and there have been times I wondered if this was an issue with the Twin Towers, or with any tall buildings having elevator shafts or other potential sources to "draw" air in through. Conspiracy addicts tend to subscribe to this notion that the fires in the towers weren't that substantial or widespread. Ignoring the fuel - not the jet fuel, but the furniture and other office contents - I'd think that the forced airflow through the towers due to a sort of "chimney" effect would have an impact. Am I right about that?

Also, if you have anything to add that doesn't have to do with that chimney example, go right ahead.

If I miss something, someone please add it, I am doing this from my sidekick because my computer is a pos.


With the damage to the stairwells, which were IIFC pressured since the bombing of 93. Since those walls where taken out by the aircraft, you are going to have air escaping from the stairwells which will in turn fuel the fire. Not only that, but the high winds that enter the building via the impact holes will additionally fuel this fire. Since they weren't equal size holes on both side, there is no way for the building to properly cross ventilate itself. The other issue is going to be the design of the building, the fireproofing specifically. The areas that are undamaged by the impact will trap in heat and gases, which will continue to spread out on that floor until its like an oven (no I don't mean the temps will be like an oven, just the idea). Usually when this happens, a flash over will occure which than ignites all combustibles in the room/area/floor.

IIRC, the study they conducted yesterday had one window open in the fire room, which eventually forced the fire to the other side of the room and blew out the window. After this week, there is going to be so much more information out there on these fires, plus once fdny completes their high rise simulator on the rock it, the easier it will be to understand the behavior of these types of fires.

All of this goes back to the basic principle of fighting any fire. Every fire needs fuel, o2, and heat. Remove any one of those things and the fire dies.


So to answer your question Elmondo, it is more than a possibility that the air being consumed by the fire helped a great deal in bringing the temps up and spreading it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom