Examples of Freeman success stories

Let me restate some of the salient points from my wall o' text:

There are none so self-righteous as those who use the undeniable fact that facts are on their side to provide justification for rudeness.

Just because one's opponents are obviously delusional idiots doesn't mean that behaving in a trollish manner isn't about stroking one's own ego more than it is about being a brave crusader for the truth. And then there's the three options for the potential outcomes of going thermonuclear at the slightest hint of blood in the water. To mix my metaphors horribly oh god I hope Gillianren from BAUT doesn't come here.

My oeuvre is usually Apollo hoax theories. I've seen more than one person come charging in to the ApolloHoax forum with all guns blazing calling everyone there complete idiots for believing in something so stoopid, and even refusing to listen when it's pointed out that the overwhelming majority of the members are firm opponents of such silliness. It's blatantly obvious in most cases that they are just there to act out. They have enough nous to know that they can prove beyond any shadow of a doubt that the conspiracist claims are vacuous nonsense, but rather than dealing with it calmly and politely they have gleefully jumped on the (perceived) opportunity for using this as an excuse to pump their own ego by venting at any of the "idiots" who dare to think otherwise.

This is not, in the long run, a helpful attitude.

If you unload a handgun into a barrelful of credulous minnows, like on the Icke site, all you will do is annoy the minnows oh god the metaphor police would kill me nobody tell them I'm here. You're not fighting a meaningful crusade if you only pick your fights with the sanity-challenged. It's more about your ego.

Again, whatever your experiences on other sites, that's no reason to bring that baggage here. Classiness and restraint are always a far, far more mature response than co-dependent flaming.

You might try classiness and restraint next time rather than behaving in a trollish manner.
 
or a typo
lego-clock.jpg
 
Of course, it might yet turn out that therival58 is actually Menard himself thinking he's being clever.

I'm actually not trying to prove or sway any members' views with the links I post. This is a forum, its for discussion, and by posting about the Joe Edwards guy, I was wondering if other members heard of his case.

As it so happens, I have not been able to find his case in any official source on google.

If I honestly believed the freeman's POV I wouldnt be hiding my views. maybe other members would do that but I don't
 
I'm actually not trying to prove or sway any members' views with the links I post. This is a forum, its for discussion, and by posting about the Joe Edwards guy, I was wondering if other members heard of his case.

As it so happens, I have not been able to find his case in any official source on google.

If I honestly believed the freeman's POV I wouldnt be hiding my views. maybe other members would do that but I don't

I don't get too excited about "the mark of woo" any more. Amused, in the sense that each of them thinks they've come up with a clever idea, but not excited.


As this is a forum for discussion, why do you feel a need to hide your views?
 
I don't get too excited about "the mark of woo" any more. Amused, in the sense that each of them thinks they've come up with a clever idea, but not excited.


As this is a forum for discussion, why do you feel a need to hide your views?

But I'm not, I already stated I dont see sufficient evidence to support the FOTL legal claims. With that being said, when I read claims of FOTL actually "winning", I want to post them here to brew further discussion - maybe another member has heard of 'so-and-so's' case and they find a different source to challenge that freeman's claims, etc.

I was just saying that by the way I post some suspect I may be hiding my true views.
 
therival58 you wrote
This could be considered a success stoy.

what could?
You cant find any info on it as you admit here
As it so happens, I have not been able to find his case in any official source on google.

Care to explain why you thought it may be a success story?
 
therival58 you wrote


what could?
You cant find any info on it as you admit here


Care to explain why you thought it may be a success story?

Well, the post I quoted attached mp3 files which contained full shows of judicial reform activist Randy Kelton, and Joe Edwards comes in occasionally to talk about his cases. But the poster said Edwards doesn't come in right away, and I doubt anyone would want to spend all that time listening in.

Here's the continuation of what I posted:


"Snippet" mp3s with Joe Edwards would have been better instead of the whole show.

He also posted an article by Howard Freeman who explains his success stories.
 
Last edited:
Your concern is noted. Post as you want and don't try to censor others.
What "censorship"? Puh-leeze. I don't believe I've tried to stop anyone from posting anything. Are you censoring me by telling me not to censor etc?

This sort of behaviour is one of the reasons I find myself posting on this sort of forum less and less - it's proof that it's possible to be right while still acting in a less that ideal manner, and I strongly get the feeling that for some people it's all just a bit too much about using the fact that they are right in justification of that behaviour. I'm going to use that word "codependency" again.
 
I "lumped" you with therival58 because you seem to suggest that I had to find evidence for him rather than me telling him to find it himself, which was the post which triggered your OP in this thread.

In which case you've missed my point entirely. I even gave you an example of the fact that there's more than one way to tell them that you've not going to do their legwork for them without going straight to being rude.

I noticed you also wrote

You then wrote


I don't remember calling you names.
I suggest you practice what you preach in future.
If you want to continue this without the ego stroking do it by PM which is frankly what you should have done in the first place.
This thread is about FMOTL success stories not about analysing my mindset for posting on a forum.

I think it's something that bears a public airing, as it's something I'm finding endemic to debunker boards and I think it's ugly. "I know you are, but what am I" is hardly justification for bad behaviour.
 
In which case you've missed my point entirely. I even gave you an example of the fact that there's more than one way to tell them that you've not going to do their legwork for them without going straight to being rude.



I think it's something that bears a public airing, as it's something I'm finding endemic to debunker boards and I think it's ugly. "I know you are, but what am I" is hardly justification for bad behaviour.

Then make a thread to discuss it in. This thread does not have that as a topic.
 
I've had vague plans to do so for some time now, and had drafted a first post for one just before bed last night, it'll go up soon. But I thought it was worth referencing what I thought was a particularly egregious example of it in the thread in which it occurred, because it was where I hoped it had the best chance of being seen by those who IMHO could do best with a little self-reflection.

Will you read and participate in the new thread, or was your request just code for "go away"? I have strong doubts that those who it is mostly aimed at will have anything to contribute there.
 
I even gave you an example of the fact that there's more than one way to tell them that you've not going to do their legwork for them without going straight to being rude.
Good for you
But I thought it was worth referencing what I thought was a particularly egregious example of it in the thread in which it occurred, because it was where I hoped it had the best chance of being seen by those who IMHO could do best with a little self-reflection.
Opinions are like butt holes, everyones got one, thanks for sharing yours
 
Y'know, JB...

I've haunted various skepticism-themed boards for a fair number of years, and the ones I tend to stay with are the ones where there is a basic level of respect and courtesy, even in the face of obvious or not-so-immediately-obvious provocation. We've all seen the various rhetorical tricks and ruses used - JAQing, "Conspiracies are rubbish, let's make fun of them, but THIS is the real deal", "This conspiracy is nonsense, isn't it, but hey! Look at this, I'm starting to change my mind", and so on. The thing is, the princes amongst debunkers are the ones who remain courteous and rational even when doubts start to arise about the intentions of new arrivals. I tend to find that the ones who go straight for the jugular are the ones who are, in their own way, also acting out to some extent. There are none so self-righteous as those who use the undeniable fact that facts are on their side to provide justification for rudeness.

Read that last sentence again. Just because one's opponents are obviously delusional idiots doesn't mean that behaving in a trollish manner isn't about stroking one's own ego more than it is about being a brave crusader for the truth.

Give people the benefit of the doubt. Even when there are reasonable grounds for suspicion (and I'm not necessarily saying there are in the present circumstances) that someone isn't playing straight, the classy way to proceed is to simply and calmly deal with the issues raised, rather than use any perceived opening as justification for sneers and other discourteousness, because either 1) you've misinterpreted the motives of someone who is firmly on your side and you've just made an ass of yourself; or 2) your hair trigger has just needlessly antagonised someone who really was just asking questions and needed reassurance from calm, rational, fully informed people who can demonstrate that they are not as agenda-driven as the other side; or 3) congratulations, you've unmasked a troll early and you can both get down to the flame war you both seem to co-dependently desire so much.

At present, I see no reason to treat therival58 in the way you seem determined to. I think your desire to bait FoTLers into coming to a place you can let rip on them without being banned means that you are opening up on full auto way, way too early. Be courteous. Be mature. Be restrained. It would reflect well on you, and presents a much more reasonable face to that slim minority who truly are uncertain but are yet reachable by moderately presented logic.

Of course, it might yet turn out that therival58 is actually Menard himself thinking he's being clever. But perhaps I am, too. Play the ball, not the man*, as bogus, delusional arguments are easily refuted no matter how much camouflaging preamble is engaged in, and friendly fire incidents are always an embarrassment.

*I know this sporting metaphor from cricket, does it translate to the odd activities that pass for ball sports in North America?

Edit: Um, whut? If I use the word banned, does it always insert a hyperlink to the definition like that? Odd.

Edit2: and now the hyperlink is gone. Is this standard, or is it just my low post history that causes it?

What "censorship"? Puh-leeze. I don't believe I've tried to stop anyone from posting anything. Are you censoring me by telling me not to censor etc?

This sort of behaviour is one of the reasons I find myself posting on this sort of forum less and less - it's proof that it's possible to be right while still acting in a less that ideal manner, and I strongly get the feeling that for some people it's all just a bit too much about using the fact that they are right in justification of that behaviour. I'm going to use that word "codependency" again.

If you're right you never have to make excuses.
 
This sort of behaviour is one of the reasons I find myself posting on this sort of forum less and less - it's proof that it's possible to be right while still acting in a less that ideal manner, and I strongly get the feeling that for some people it's all just a bit too much about using the fact that they are right in justification of that behaviour. I'm going to use that word "codependency" again.
Look mate, "this sort of forum" is what it is, its where people bring ideas and people look at them using reason and logic and try to establish the truth.
Its not about being all honourable and noble and trying to make out you are on a crusade of enlightenment, its mostly banter and a bit of fun.
If people keep posting daft things and don't listen to reason after its been made quite clear it is daft, what do you expect people to do?
now either fit in or ...well you know the rest.
 
Being rude off the batto a new poster who has questions or doubts will drive them right into the other camp. It costs nothing to give a new poster the benefit until they establish their position.
 
It costs nothing to give a new poster the benefit until they establish their position.
It doesn't cost anything regardless.
Go and read his posts and make up your own mind as to his intentions, he's asking for explanations to things he could find himself in ten seconds.
 
Maybe he wants an experienced opinion.

This whole diversion into Meta Discussion shows the lack of Freeman Success Stories to report in the thread I suppose.
 
Please get back to the subject matter of the thread, folks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Please get back to the subject matter of the thread, folks.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL

Erm, but the subject of the thread appears to be a non-existant entity. Doesn't that make the whole thread a tad pointless?

No disrespect intended, your moderaterness, ma'am.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom