Sledge
Grammaton Cleric
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2009
- Messages
- 7,114
... for some definitions of 'win'.
As defined by Charlie Sheen.
... for some definitions of 'win'.
This is a really good observation. I'm a relatively recent law grad, and there was a tremendously concerted effort to train us using plain English. We were even discouraged from saying actus reus/mens rea. The FOTLers actively seek out outdated and confusing terms which they then misapply to construct their bizarre narratives.
Many people in the "law profession" who have major problems with UCC and STRAWMAN issues (such as Larry Becraft, L.B. Bork) are steeped in statutory law and therefor have problems unwinding their minds from what they thought they've known all these years. The Randy Kelton interviews I posted below are a perfect example of this. Randy is one of the country's acknowledged legal reform experts in the statutory realm and a true American hero, and he was blown away when he heard how Joe Edwards used some very simple issues of citizenship and jurisdiction to literally tie a court in knots over the driver license issue.
Be courteous. Be mature. Be restrained
i for one am not up for playing games and spoon-feeding numpties, why don't you go and research...
Thats exactly why I told therival58 to get the information and as such cavort.Ironically, this is one of the standard manoeuvres used by people who want to avoid presenting evidence to support their position.
and its your ego which prompted your post, if there were no egos there would be no forums.It's more about your ego.
As defined by Charlie Sheen.
It's "Cavorite", btw. If you'd prefer me to call you "Jargon Buster" rather than the commonly used "JB", just let me know.Thats exactly why I told therival58 to get the information and as such cavort.
I don't know if you've ever hung out at ApolloHoax or BAUT and thus encountered JayUtah, but there's a whole swagload of reasons why for many of those of us of this kind of inclination that he is considered the paragon of debunkers. Impeccably logical, witty yet restrained, erudite and informative, and always, always polite and solicitous when treated likewise.
the classy way to proceed is to simply and calmly deal with the issues raised, rather than use any perceived opening as justification for sneers and other discourteousness, because either 1) you've misinterpreted the motives of someone who is firmly on your side and you've just made an ass of yourself; or 2) your hair trigger has just needlessly antagonised someone who really was just asking questions and needed reassurance from calm, rational, fully informed people who can demonstrate that they are not as agenda-driven as the other side; or 3) congratulations, you've unmasked a troll early and you can both get down to the flame war you both seem to co-dependently desire so much.
You then wroteClassiness and restraint are always a far, far more mature response than co-dependent flaming.
my point was that you were frankly being a jerk in the manner of doing so, when you were quite free to do so with more class and politeness.
Y'know, JB...
I've haunted various skepticism-themed boards for a fair number of years, and the ones I tend to stay with are the ones where there is a basic level of respect and courtesy, even in the face of obvious or not-so-immediately-obvious provocation. We've all seen the various rhetorical tricks and ruses used - JAQing, "Conspiracies are rubbish, let's make fun of them, but THIS is the real deal", "This conspiracy is nonsense, isn't it, but hey! Look at this, I'm starting to change my mind", and so on. The thing is, the princes amongst debunkers are the ones who remain courteous and rational even when doubts start to arise about the intentions of new arrivals. I tend to find that the ones who go straight for the jugular are the ones who are, in their own way, also acting out to some extent. There are none so self-righteous as those who use the undeniable fact that facts are on their side to provide justification for rudeness.
Read that last sentence again. Just because one's opponents are obviously delusional idiots doesn't mean that behaving in a trollish manner isn't about stroking one's own ego more than it is about being a brave crusader for the truth.
Give people the benefit of the doubt. Even when there are reasonable grounds for suspicion (and I'm not necessarily saying there are in the present circumstances) that someone isn't playing straight, the classy way to proceed is to simply and calmly deal with the issues raised, rather than use any perceived opening as justification for sneers and other discourteousness, because either 1) you've misinterpreted the motives of someone who is firmly on your side and you've just made an ass of yourself; or 2) your hair trigger has just needlessly antagonised someone who really was just asking questions and needed reassurance from calm, rational, fully informed people who can demonstrate that they are not as agenda-driven as the other side; or 3) congratulations, you've unmasked a troll early and you can both get down to the flame war you both seem to co-dependently desire so much.
At present, I see no reason to treat therival58 in the way you seem determined to. I think your desire to bait FoTLers into coming to a place you can let rip on them without being banned means that you are opening up on full auto way, way too early. Be courteous. Be mature. Be restrained. It would reflect well on you, and presents a much more reasonable face to that slim minority who truly are uncertain but are yet reachable by moderately presented logic.
Of course, it might yet turn out that therival58 is actually Menard himself thinking he's being clever. But perhaps I am, too. Play the ball, not the man*, as bogus, delusional arguments are easily refuted no matter how much camouflaging preamble is engaged in, and friendly fire incidents are always an embarrassment.
*I know this sporting metaphor from cricket, does it translate to the odd activities that pass for ball sports in North America?
Edit: Um, whut? If I use the word banned, does it always insert a hyperlink to the definition like that? Odd.
Edit2: and now the hyperlink is gone. Is this standard, or is it just my low post history that causes it?