I'm shocked that he was convicted. Shocked, I tell you.
I'm shocked that he was convicted. Shocked, I tell you.
The judge claimed the court to be a De Jure court, and claimed it to be a court of law, she said she never heard of De Facto before, and when I asked her what law I was accused of breaking, she said the highway traffic act, to which I replied are you saying the highway traffic act is the law of this land? She said "Yes, it is". I asked all the rite questions and she lied on 99 percent of the questions, the 1 percent she answered correct was that a "Summons IS an invitation to court".
So now these nutters are telling idiots to not pull over when a police officer catches them? The next time one of them tries that they'll find themselves likely in jail with far higher offenses than not having ID.
I know where he went wrong.
The officer asked him to turn off the "VEHICLE" and he did.
He therefore admitted that the car was a "vehicle" as stated in the act
These cops are good.![]()
It even has a victim surcharge on it.(see attached)
Who was the victim?
I like how the cop just went thru his ritual and it worked.
He gives it away here:Of course, he was convicted because he didn't do the legal ritual right, not because the Freeman on the Land stuff has no relationship to reality. Clearly, if he did the legal ritual right the police officer would have fled in terror.
...
Freeman guy said:I asked all the rite questions
I like how the cop just went thru his ritual and it worked.
and these guys claim to read the law![]()
Bey brought the case and the judge dismissed it. Many of Bey's arguments were ********** up, which led the judge to make his decision. He obviously understood Bey's promissory note argument - but even that was slightly off. However, the judge said Bey can file an amended complaint, giving merit to some of his arguments. The most important is the promissory note being an equal trade for the house.
The Court will consider each of Mr. Ade Bey's specific claims in this next section, but it is important to note that if, as the Court strongly suspects, the allegations contained in the Amended Complaint are premised on one or more of the above-described theories, that fact alone would be sufficient to grant CitiMortgage's Motion to Dismiss, as all three of these theories have been universally and emphatically rejected by numerous federal courts for at least the last 25 years. See, e.g., Torne, 2010 WL 1904507 (dismissing, in some instances sua sponte, claims alleging fraud, conversion, conspiracy, extortion, securities fraud, and violations of the Truth in Lending Act (TILA), the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), the Fair Debt Collection
Practices Act (FDCPA), and GAAP, all based on theories advanced here); Barber v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc., No. 2:09CV40, 2010 WL 398915, at *4 (W.D.N.C. Oct. 7, 2009) (dismissing "utterly frivolous" and "patently ludicrous" claims of fraud, racketeering, and conspiracy, and advising plaintiffs that their "tactics are a waste of their time as well as the court's time, which is paid for by hard-earned tax dollars"); Marrakush Soc. v. New Jersey State Police, No. 09CV2518 et al., 2009 WL 2366132 (D.N.J. July 30, 2009) (considering 19 consolidated cases raising arguments virtually identical to those here, all filed in the District Court for the District of New Jersey within approximately one year, and discussing similar
influxes of cases in the Federal District Courts in Delaware and Florida); Richardson, 2008 WL 5225824, at *7 (dismissing claims as "patently frivolous and a waste of judicial resources"); Demmler, 2006 WL 640499, at *3 (characterizing such claims as "patently ludicrous" and noting
that "these arguments have been repeatedly rejected by every court to consider the issue"); Carrington v. Federal Nat'l Mortg. Assoc., No. 05CV73429, 2005 WL 3216226, at *2-3 (E.D. Mich. Nov. 29, 2005) (recognizing that these theories have been "universally rejected by
numerous federal courts"); Thiel v. First Fed. Savings & Loan Ass'n of Marion, 646 F. Supp. 592 (N.D. Ind. 1986) (rejecting claims that lender had violated RICO and National Bank Act by issuing loan check in exchange for promissory note, and dismissing the claims as frivolous);
Nixon v. Individual Head of St. Joseph Mortg. Co., 615 F. Supp. 898, 900 (D.C. Ind. 1985) (finding the plaintiff's arguments and claims "absurd"). Lest there be any confusion, the Court notes that every other case cited in this decision that has considered similar claims also rejected them.
Before discussing whether Mr. Ade Bey will be permitted one last opportunity to amend his complaint, the Court wishes to make one thing clear: Mr. Ade Bey is undoubtedly entitled to the free exercise of his religion, and nothing the Court has stated herein is meant to cast doubt on that fact, or to diminish or demean Mr. Ade Bey or his chosen religion in any way. The Court is ignorant as to whether this lawsuit is a product of Mr. Ade Bey's religious beliefs or not, but that issue is simply not relevant to the merits of his claims, for not even the constitutionally-protected right to free exercise entitles one to impose his views on others, such as the Defendant, when they conflict so fundamentally with the laws of this country. As Chief Judge Frank Easterbrook of the Seventh Circuit put it in a related context, "Some people believe with great fervor preposterous things that just happen to coincide with their self-interest. . . . The government may not prohibit the holding of these beliefs, but it may penalize people who act on them." Coleman v. C.I.R., 791 F.2d 68, 69 (7th Cir. 1986); see also Thiel, 646 F. Supp. at 597 ("[Plaintiffs,] along with all other Americans[,] are free to hold whatever economic or political views they so choose. With this freedom, however, comes the responsibility to express these views appropriately. It is difficult to imagine a more irresponsible forum for the plaintiffs to express their particular economic views than this court.").
The Court has carefully considered imposing sanctions on Mr. Ade Bey, and it is with considerable reluctance that it chooses not to do so at this time. Additionally, while the Court is extremely skeptical that Mr. Ade Bey could ever state a plausible claim for relief under the facts already pleaded in this case, the Court will, out of due regard for his pro se status, grant him one final opportunity to attempt to do so.
...
However, this opportunity to amend, should Mr. Ade Bey choose to take advantage of it, comes with several conditions. First, any proposed amended complaint must be filed no later than July 2, 2010, and it must be accompanied by a Motion to Amend with the proposed second amended complaint attached. If Mr. Ade Bey has not filed a second amended complaint by this date, his claims will be dismissed with prejudice, and the Court will decline supplemental jurisdiction over CitiMortgage's counterclaims, which it would then be free to file in Connecticut state court. Second, if he chooses to amend his complaint, Mr. Ade Bey may not rely on the "Redemptionist," "vapor money," or the "unlawful money" theories, as described above, in any way, and regardless of whether he actually uses those terms.
^ Agreed. A very good decision. The judge strikes a delicate balance to completely reject the plaintiff's absurd arguments while still showing the patience and respect to fully consider them. That patience and respect is very important I think, no matter how absurd the arguments might be.
However, the judge said Bey can file an amended complaint, giving merit to some of his arguments.
I disagree. Well-written, well-reasoned decisions have as much effect on FOTLers as Obama's birth certificate does on birthers and NIST's comprehensive investigations do on truthers. These are not people that can distinguish between good and poor reasoning, nor are they capable of competently reading and interpreting case law.^ Agreed. A very good decision. The judge strikes a delicate balance to completely reject the plaintiff's absurd arguments while still showing the patience and respect to fully consider them. That patience and respect is very important I think, no matter how absurd the arguments might be. The absurdity/waste of judicial resources can be and should be dealt with through the award of costs. However, the only way to discourage people from self-destructing with freeman/sovereign snake oil is to have these well-written, well-reasoned decisions to show them.
You are wasting your time. They only deserve your derision, not your careful and respectful dialogue.EDIT: I know that many freeman adherents (especially those "at the top") won't change their mind no matter how many decisions you show them, but I think (hope) that some will. Otherwise I've really been wasting my time lately.
Exactly.This guy just does not see the absolute smack-down that this decision embodies, all he sees is the Judge saying, "Oh, nice try, why don't you come in and give it another shot? You almost got us that time!"