Evil / hypothetical

Well, if God created man, and God is Good, but man is not God, how could man not be construed as nothing but Evil?

Ah, but is God good? After all, if God created everything then he created Evil as well. And where did Evil come from if God is totally good to begin with?
 
Surely only the murder of the damned would be wrong, since you are condemning them to hellfire? Otherwise you're sending them off to heaven and eternal bliss...

Oh, hang on a minute, this is all based on total insanity, isn't it...

My bad...
 
Funny how so much of this dilema disolves with the idea of there not being a God -- that Good and Evil (not suffering and prosperity) are human constructs not found elsewhere in nature -- and that "free will" (in the purely physical sense) may not exist.
 
We all suffer as little children. This is how we become adults.
Did you read the OP? In that example, as in too many real examples, this is not how we become adults; it is how we become dead little children.
 
Mysterious is fine, but he can't work in contradictions. Seems impossible even for baby jesus.
There's always the sociopath option.

God creates a little bubble universe for each of us, and populates them with actors and controlled interactions with people in other bubbles. He doesn't allow real people in their little bubbles to have their free will taken from them by illness, kidnapping or death, it's only his actors that this appears to happen too.

He makes us live out this charade, so our souls will grow up big and strong.






........because they taste better that way. :D
 
Mysterious is fine, but he can't work in contradictions. Seems impossible even for baby jesus.
I have this idea that it is possible for something to be so complex that I can not even fathom it. Do you think there is nothing beyond your ability to understand? This is the reason I say I am an agnostic.
 
dogdoctor said:
I have this idea that it is possible for something to be so complex that I can not even fathom it. Do you think there is nothing beyond your ability to understand? This is the reason I say I am an agnostic.

I’ve had versions of this thrown at me during discussions when theists tell me that I am agnostic and not atheist after all.

But, nope, I’m atheist.

I find this argument specious simply because it plays both sides of the fence:


1. There may be something I can’t comprehend. {Okay; I have no problem with this; in fact, I’m certain there are many things I can’t comprehend.}

2. I’ll only consider one something: God. And it is cast in a form I can comprehend.


If you’re going to play the “Works in Mysterious Ways” game, which is what this is, then stop putting human constructs on it and then asserting Incomprehensible Properties for the constructs themselves when inconsistencies are pointed out within them.

When you do that, you’ll find yourself remarkably close to a scientific viewpoint which readily acknowledges, in fact requires an admission of incomprehension.
 
That was not exactly a God works in mysterious ways argument but a there could be something beyond my ability to comprehend argument. I don't have any belief in the bible or any other religious scriptures so I don't claim to understand that God (with a big G) works in mysterious ways. Rather that there may be something beyond my ability to comprehend which could include some type of godlike entity. The God works in mysterious ways argument is a common argument used by believers which I am not.
 
You're right, dogdoctor, and my apologies for mislabeling.

However, my argument still holds.

I, too, admit there may be something beyond my ability to comprehend.

This admission, though, is not in any sense supportive of a god, big G or little g.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom