Evil / hypothetical

bpesta22

Cereal Killer
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
4,942
I've never found a good answer to this one re: free will:

Suppose an adult male rapes and kills a 5 year old kid.

We can ask, why did god permit this evil?

This christian answer:

Free will-- the man chose to do the evil / rejected god / he will suffer in the end. If God had intervened, we wouldn't have free will!

Ok, but what about the kid?

If god is all knowing, then he knew before the murder that this kid he created would be brutally killed. God also knew the kid would be killed at a young age-- too young for him/her to even develop free will; too young to decide whether to love god, or reject god; too young to do anything worthy of god's praise, or his scorn.

But, god created this kid anyway. Why? What was god's purpose in creating this kid?

An all loving/knowing/powerful god cannot let someone trully innocent suffer evil. It's a contradiction.

It seems to me that god created the kid-- a human soul-- to be cannon fodder for the murderer, so that the murderer could exercise his free will (though god knew he would do that anyway; making this whole thing cruelly ironic and unnecessary).

So, does god value the murderer (by letting him grow to be an adult and kill) over the kid (by creating the kid beforehand, doomed to never develop a morality or make choices regarding his/her salvation)?

Also, what happens to the kid's soul? Does it go to heaven? If so, does it go there as a 5 year old kid? Will it ever develop into a thinking / reasoning adult? Or, will it be eternally happy in heaven as a 5 year old kid, lacking the capacity for rational thought. Is that even possible?

What if the murderer repents and accepts jesus before he dies? If he was sincerely sorry, wouldn't he want to apologize to his victim. Would god let the murder's soul meet the kid's soul in heaven so that they could get past the thing?

Can anyone reconcile this dilemma in a way that both saves the idea of freewill (for the kid) and the idea that god is all knowing / loving / powerful?
 
Run that one by your mental health provider during the next session. :D

Doc, you're the one who keeps showing me all those dirty pictures.
 
I've never found a good answer to this one re: free will:

Suppose an adult male rapes and kills a 5 year old kid.

We can ask, why did god permit this evil?
It seems we all have to "suffer" at the hands of each other. In which case we can learn how to be bitter, and pass the suffering along (which, is where it originates) or, we can learn how to forgive, and stop the suffering dead in its tracks.

In the case of a little child, however, that child is returned to God, and is purged of any unpleasantries it may have experienced while in this world. In which case it would seem, justice has been served.
 
It seems we all have to "suffer" at the hands of each other. In which case we can learn how to be bitter, and pass the suffering along (which, is where it originates) or, we can learn how to forgive, and stop the suffering dead in its tracks.
You don't have to "forgive" in order to prevent the cycle of suffering. You can still be outraged by brutality and still not commit it yourself. It's called "empathy". Most of us have it to some degree.

In the case of a little child, however, that child is returned to God, and is purged of any unpleasantries it may have experienced while in this world. In which case it would seem, justice has been served.
Gosh! That sounds wonderful. So we should go out and kill as many children as we can, so they too might have this wonderful experience of justice? Now you're sounding like Kurious Kathy, Iacchus.
 
Can anyone reconcile this dilemma in a way that both saves the idea of freewill (for the kid) and the idea that god is all knowing / loving / powerful?

No.

Omniscient, omnipotent, omnicompassionate. Pick two.
 
You don't have to "forgive" in order to prevent the cycle of suffering. You can still be outraged by brutality and still not commit it yourself. It's called "empathy". Most of us have it to some degree.
If you can't forgive someone for their crime you can only help to perpetuate it.


Gosh! That sounds wonderful. So we should go out and kill as many children as we can, so they too might have this wonderful experience of justice? Now you're sounding like Kurious Kathy, Iacchus.
We all suffer as little children. This is how we become adults.
 
If you think there is a trivial answer to that question, forget it. Go here if you really want to learn more: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/evil/

This is one of those questions which seems to have a simple answer (like the one UrsulaV gave) but gets complicated really fast.
 
Omniscient, omnipotent, omnicompassionate. Pick two.
When people talk about God's plan, and how everything will work out all right in the end, they seem to be implicitly claiming that God is omniscient (and supersapient) and omnicompassionate, but has limited power, and must therefore accept compromises in the process of perfecting the universe.
 
We all suffer as little children. This is how we become adults.

Speak for yourself. I had a happy childhood that I feel greatly influenced -- in a positive way -- the person I ended up becoming today.

So, should I ask...bah, why not. Iacchus, on what possible grounds do you claim that everyone suffers as a child?
 
No.

Omniscient, omnipotent, omnicompassionate. Pick two.

I've read more than one thread in this very forum that argued God's omniscience to be wholly incompatible with his omnipotence. I tried to distill it down to a sentence or two for this post, but that's a job for someone more qualified than I. :)
 
Speak for yourself. I had a happy childhood that I feel greatly influenced -- in a positive way -- the person I ended up becoming today.

So, should I ask...bah, why not. Iacchus, on what possible grounds do you claim that everyone suffers as a child?
You never had grounds for being angry at someone? Or being resentful? I saw this more often than not when I was growing up.
 
I've read more than one thread in this very forum that argued God's omniscience to be wholly incompatible with his omnipotence. I tried to distill it down to a sentence or two for this post, but that's a job for someone more qualified than I. :)

*grin* Oh, well, I always figured if you were omnipotent, you could make yourself omniscient, and if you were omniscient, you'd know how to make yourself omnipotent!

I admit, my philosophy is more akin to the sledgehammer than the surgical blade...
 
Basically if you are determined to accept God no matter what, you can find a lot of "good" explanations. Christians here often say that it is these very kids who die too young the ones that God loves the most. They are considered to be lucky, exactly because God didn't give them the chance to develop free will and granted them a free visa for Paradise.

The thing is, if they really believed all this crap, they should be pretty happy at the funeral.
 
The thing is, if they really believed all this crap, they should be pretty happy at the funeral.
There is no real justification in committing a heinous act against someone else. This is why we call it evil, remember? However, the fact is, we all die. And people are going to cry at the funeral, regardless.
 
There is no real justification in committing a heinous act against someone else. This is why we call it evil, remember?

Some people would call it evil, others may not. Morality is very, very subjective.
 
I knew some Satanists a while ago and they said they were counting on Jesus to save them at some point before they die. So they could do whatever they want without worry as long as sometime before they die they repent their sins and ask for forgiveness. Their major worry was sudden death so they did not get a chance to repent. No one has said it so the most common excuse I hear for such things is "God works in mysterious ways."
 
I knew some Satanists a while ago and they said they were counting on Jesus to save them at some point before they die. So they could do whatever they want without worry as long as sometime before they die they repent their sins and ask for forgiveness. Their major worry was sudden death so they did not get a chance to repent. No one has said it so the most common excuse I hear for such things is "God works in mysterious ways."


Mysterious is fine, but he can't work in contradictions. Seems impossible even for baby jesus.
 
Mysterious is fine, but he can't work in contradictions.

This is actually what makes the Problem of Evil more subtle than it first appears. If not even God can do the logically contradictory, then it becomes a possibility that even he may be forced to make tradeoffs in order to maximize the good, and the problems we see are the downside of those tradeoffs. Now this possibility may be unlikely because we can think of alternative scenarios that would seem to produce less suffering than we see. The catch, however, is that we don't necessarily have the capability to fully trace out the results of the scenarios to see if they have hidden problems that would actually make them worse than our current one. This means that it is difficult and perhaps impossible to establish that the presence of evil really does contradict the idea of an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God.
 
Dogdoctor said:
I knew some Satanists a while ago and they said they were counting on Jesus to save them at some point before they die. So they could do whatever they want without worry as long as sometime before they die they repent their sins and ask for forgiveness. Their major worry was sudden death so they did not get a chance to repent. No one has said it so the most common excuse I hear for such things is "God works in mysterious ways."
Does it have to be an honest repentance, or will some sort of phony surface repentance do the trick?

~~ Paul
 
Man is Nothing but Evil?

Well, if God created man, and God is Good, but man is not God, how could man not be construed as nothing but Evil?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom