Evidence of Buddhism

And how would this be demonstrated? Couldn't this apply to just about anything? What "questions" would you suggest?

1. It wouldn't be demonstrated. It would be understood.

2. Yes. (at least if someone were saying more and less about something else)

3. The same ones that have been asked, but actually paying attention to the replies.

yrreg seems to consistently misunderstand Buddhism, and especially Buddhism as applied by skeptics. When I saw him compare meditation to memorizing a multiplication table, it was obvious that he just didn't get it, despite the efforts. In his first attempts at "skeptical criticism of Buddhism", there was a lengthy discussion of the meaning of anatta (no-self or no-soul) in which he consistently twisted words to mean anything other than what the poster was saying.

He likes to say he is doing skeptical criticism of Buddhism, but the first step in skeptical criticism of anything is to try and understand it. It doesn't seem to me that he is doing much of that.
 
Now, we would like to request the Buddhists here, in particular Ryokan, to inform us what are the concrete effects in a person Buddhist meditation is supposed to produce?

For me, it makes me calmer. If I don't seem very calm, perhaps it is because I don't meditate enough.

I really don't know what laboratory certifiable effects and evidence are entertained in the minds of Buddhists here, who maintain the scientific validity of meditation, Buddhist style.

"Scientific validity of meditation". What does that mean? I am scientifically able to say that when I meditate, I sit in a dim room not moving much, unless I am doing walking meditation. As for its effects, this thread started with pretty good evidence of brain changes among people who do it a lot.

I don't know if it makes you smarter, happier, or a better person, because I don't know how to measure any of those things. The first one I might be able to measure a little bit, but even that one is problematic. Who is smarter, the person who memorizes 100 digits of pi, or the person who didn't bother to memorize 100 digits of pi?

Tell us, Buddhists here, please.


Yrreg[/QUOTE]
 
This is perhaps a silly question, but if one part of the Eightfold Path is "right meditation," but meditation is harmful for a particular person, would the right meditation for such a one be no meditation?

I really don't know. I have found meditation to release profound revelations, and some have been almost catastrophic in terms of my ability to deal with them. Others meditate and wish they had such experiences. Others meditate and are nearly destroyed by them. I would guess the percentage of people who fall into the latter category is quite small and predisposed to mental illness.

There actually are mental illnesses categorized that are related to meditation. I don't think they are common, but it just underscores the reality that meditation does seem to unlock things that normally would never see the light of day. Nothing supernatural or even metaphysical about it, just the way it is.
 
If we could improve the lives of 99 people with meditation and only harm one person, that seems like an acceptable sacrifice.

Or religious faith, being so helpful to so many people. It is good to promote even if false because only a few people suffer because of it.

If your product is potentially toxic and yet marketed as being safe, what does that say about you?
 
A certain amount and type of irrationality is natural, and has the potential to be a healthy part of being human.

Maybe we call it 'mental illness' when it starts wrecking our lives. Like many things it is a spectrum of characteristics that have a range of possible outcomes. People often get better and go on with their lives.

I find that examining how various religions view 'mental illness' is sort of like 'the canary in the mine'. If the canary is dead but nobody cares, there is a problem with the miners or the management (not to mention the mine itself). If the canary is set high on a pedestal and called a great prophet of doom, well that's a problem too...

And if the canary is staggering around gasping for breath, surrounded by miners trying to exercise its demons - there's a kind of dark humor no?

Here's my problem with religions claiming to be 'scientific'.

A common misconception of "anti skeptics" is that evil materialist skeptics think things should always be done like this:

"To get to 10 we must show steps 1 through 9":

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

*yawn* boring. if it were really like this I would hate skeptics too.

The mistake, is that to get to "10" we should proceed logically through the all steps. 10 is caused by 9 is caused by 8...

The outstanding thing about science and people like Sagan and Popper and Gardner and countless others is that they teach science really goes more like:
10?
And then we go on to show why it is 10, or why it could not be anything else but 10. Always with a litte doubt left over. Falsification is not a linear process, it is much more creative.

So if Buddhism is "scientific" in some sense, what? Is is a very good philosophy that might indeed help scientific thinking, but not something we can apply scientific method to itself.
 
And believe me I do question the value of talk therapy that is not behavioral and goal directed.
Freudian therapy as practised by Freud is in adifferent category that the Alderian and postmodern schools. Freud was able to admit his failings.

Well, I think that I am not getting my point across. There were some things that you said that I let slide, even though they weren't to the point.

Frued is dead, just like Gautama Buddha. They are truly history. I've read a lot of Freud, and it seems to me that he presented a lot of hypotheses, but partially due to his cult of personality, they got turned into pseudofacts. I don't have any problem with Freud the person, because I think he did about the best that could have reasonably been expected.

And it was meant as a general response, in general when people object to buddhism, it is grounds that are mistaken beliefs of what buddhism is. Such as 'Buddha is god, idol worship and world rejecting'.

Fine, but we don't have a general audience here. At least, I hope we don't have a general audience. If I wanted a general audience, I'd go to the bus stop. I hope that we have an audience that is more perspicatious with respect to skepticism than the average bear.

Hmm I said that the practices of buddhism are similar to CBT, but I made no claims that they were counseling.

Well, let's dont get too hung-up on the difference between counseling and self-help, because there are enough red herrings in the water already.

snif , CBT is research based, as least in theory.

Psychological theory and $2 will get you a cup of black water at Starbucks.
 
Meditation and memorization

Yrreg said:
Meditation is an operational process of the human entity.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Meditation is no different as an operation from memorization, like memorizing the multiplication table.

Now, we would like to request the Buddhists here, in particular Ryokan, to inform us what are the concrete effects in a person Buddhist meditation is supposed to produce?

If it is going to make a person attain enlightenment, or experience Nirvana, or become convinced of karma and rebirth, then I can't imagine how evidence can be obtained that is useful in the laboratory.

I really don't know what laboratory certifiable effects and evidence are entertained in the minds of Buddhists here, who maintain the scientific validity of meditation, Buddhist style.

Tell us, Buddhists here, please.


Yrreg

Meditation is an operation of the mind/brain just like memorizing the multiplication table is an operation of the mind/brain. So it can be studied in the laboratory, like how people memorize data, how fast people can memorize, and how they can improve their memorizing capacity.

If we look at meditation in this manner, then it is very possible to study it as it is very possible to bite a donut.

What we should do is to organize a panel of impartial scientists who are experts in studying mind/brain operations correlative to emotional and physical conduct.

For example, I am sure there are scientists who study ways and means to memorize data faster and retain the memorized data longer; so we can get them to study meditation correlative to emotional and physical conduct, its acquisition or habituation and its actual implementation in daily life in every day circumstances.

Now, these scientists will have to map out exact effects in emotional and physical conduct that meditation is supposed to produce or improve or instill for longer duration in the human subject.

Since the Buddhists here are not scientists and I am not a scientist -- Buddhists so far have not come up with concrete effects Buddhist meditation is supposed to produce -- and certainly both they and I are not impartial, we have to look for impartial expert scientists to design such a study.

Then we will have the answer from impartial experts, instead of arguing with words forever.


Yrreg
 
There's no such thing as an impartial expert, that's why we design blinded studies.
 
Single-blind and double-blind studies

There's no such thing as an impartial expert, that's why we design blinded studies.

What I know is that a single-blind study is one where the subject being studied does not know he is being studied.

A double-blind study is one where both the subject being studied does not know and the personnel doing the material study do not know about the study; for example, drinking ginseng tea is being studied in a subject, but he and the people dispensing the ginseng tea do not know that a study is going on.

Please correct me if I am wrong or imprecise.



Impartial experts are those publicly known and have an established reputation, and admitted by both sides in a study of the pro and con of an issue, to not harbor any sympathy for one or the other side of the issue; but they know what the study is all about as they conduct the study.

I can't imagine experts conducting a study to be blind to what they are conducting the study about; how then are they going to design the study?


Yrreg
 
Gotcha!

Originally Posted by yrreg :
Meditation is no different as an operation from memorization, like memorizing the multiplication table.​

----------------------

What is the sound of one mouth yapping?



ETA: Ok. That sounds worse than I meant. I'm being bad.

yrreg, I'm sure you mean well, but you really don't get it, and you never will until you stop making statements, and start asking questions. But, about those questions, I'm reminded of a story my father used to tell. He said he had a professor who, on the first day of class, told the class to ask questions, but he added. "There are three kinds of questions. One kind is meant to show how smart the person asking the question is. Another kind is the kind meant to show how stupid somone else is. Then, once in a while, someone actually wants some information."

Buddhism is much more, and much less, than you give it credit for.

See?

So, when Buddhists complain here that I don't attend to their answers, maybe what they mean is that I don't accept their answers but prefer to keep a polite silence.

And when Buddhists complain that I don't answer their questions, you have to ask them what those questions are; besides, I have written enough messages for them to have read the answers to their questions.

Yrreg
 
I can't imagine experts conducting a study to be blind to what they are conducting the study about; how then are they going to design the study?

Eliminating bias is one of the hardest things to do. There may be some kinds of topics where I'm not sure it can be done.

Let me try and give an example in a nutshell of how hard the testing would be and things we would need to watch for.

First, we must expect subject/observer bias and somehow account for it or eliminate it. In the US alone, well over 50% believe in the possibility of supernatural effects on a study. Additionally, there is a population who feel that such belief is a fundamental good. Even if they did not experience any effect they might well choose to pursue that 'good' despite the evidence. So, we should expect measurement bias from testers and participants.

We might think that the best way to test meditation is with some really experienced Buddhists, but that is probably not the case. Things like diet, culture, and social standing need to be eliminated, and a good Buddhist is not going to just meditate, they are going to eat well. (or we would study diet). They may live in a less industrialized society with different stresses etc.

That might be very interesting to study but let's say we want to only study the benefit of meditation.

A team of experts who knew what the study wanted to show would need to design some test questions that measure expected results - "enlightenment". this group cannot know anything about how the study will actually be done. These experts will not do any interviewing.

For the test group itself, what we'd really want is a large group who have little or no experience with meditation. They would need to be from similar socio economic background, and similar diets.

We then need a group of interviewers. These interviewers know nothing about anything but the questions before them. Each test group member is interviewed and scored by the 'blind' interviewers.

The test group would then be split into three or more subgroups:
1: One group does meditation (how do we verify that happens?)
2: One group does nothing (no sneaking in any side meditation)

3: But there needs to be a third group. What would they do? It would need to be something like a placebo that was like meditation but not meditation. Give them something like a pill and tell them it produces the effects of meditation like calmness and serenity.

The test subjects don't know what the study is really about. The interviewers don't know either.

It would be best if the experts knew nothing about the test protocols until the testing was over and everyone was scored. The people who handle managing the actual groups cannot be involved in the testing.

At the end of six months, the entire group is reinterviewed with the same questions. The testers know nothing about the methodology, and simply reinterview.

These interview questions would then be turned back over to the experts and evaluated. The experts should be able to identify which subjects meditated to more than chance. (To be determined).

Whew. ok, I think that is a triple blind study.

Even with all that, I can see places where bias might enter. Remember that both the test subjects and testers might want to believe or not. The experts could design poor questions, or include subtle clues about who was tested for meditation. The questions might not measure what I mentioned before - potential for harm.

There's a lot that can go wrong. A big question would be - could the study be duplicated with similar results just by following the protocols?
 
Last edited:
Suggestions for some concrete benefits from meditation

Thanks, Kopji, for your reply.

I am certain that we are all here after anything that is good for attaining a healthy lifestyle, one that enables us to do the things we like to do, like strolling in the park with ease and comfort, or sleeping soundly longer hours at night.

That might be very interesting to study but let's say we want to only study the benefit of meditation.

A team of experts who knew what the study wanted to show would need to design some test questions that measure expected results - "enlightenment". this group cannot know anything about how the study will actually be done. These experts will not do any interviewing.

Can you know of or imagine benefits from Buddhist meditation, for which we might agree on a panel of impartial scientists to study? like relief from:

insomnia,

constipation,

allergy to milk products,

stuttering or stammering,

tics (local and habitual twitching especially in the face),

erectile dysfunction,

frigidity,

and similar anatomical and physiological symptoms.


Would you not agree with me that the Buddhist concept of enlightenment, or non-self, karma, rebirth, nirvana are not subjects for scientific studies? maybe philosophical if at all?


I work in an environment where there are employees who habitually report late for work, use office stationery excessively, go to the bathrooms too often, I believe a scientific study on the efficacy of Buddhist meditation can be designed, to find out whether it might modify such behaviors as to gladden the heart of the employer.


Yrreg
 
Thanks, Kopji, for your reply.
y'welcome
Can you know of or imagine benefits from Buddhist meditation, for which we might agree on a panel of impartial scientists to study?...
There's a scene in the movie "O God" (the good one, with John Denver and George Burns). They ask God if Jesus is his son. He says yeah. And so was Buddha, Mohammed...
All hell breaks loose.

The 'experts' meeting would go something like that.
Would you not agree with me that the Buddhist concept of enlightenment, or non-self, karma, rebirth, nirvana are not subjects for scientific studies? maybe philosophical if at all?
Be sort of like doing a study on a large poem wouldn't it?
I work in an environment where there are employees who habitually report late for work, use office stationery excessively, go to the bathrooms too often, I believe a scientific study on the efficacy of Buddhist meditation can be designed, to find out whether it might modify such behaviors as to gladden the heart of the employer.
Oh that would be much less rigorous. Those are all measurable workplace things where a baseline could be created, initiate a change, and then measure again after. You don't need to prove Buddhism works other than produces some results for a limited population. A placebo might have the same effect. The trick of course with a placebo, it that you have to believe it will work. And do not underrate placebos, a good placebo effect is sometimes worth 25-30%. A lot of meds aren't that high.

Businesses are decidedly non scientific sometimes.
Business loves woo, remember that.
There are already businesses who hire clergy to do counseling at the workplace. Happy workers are productive workers... It does not matter if it works more than a placebo, a placebo that improves productivity 25-30% is called a "business solution".
 
Do you know some Buddhists well?

Dear Kopji:

Tell me, are you a Buddhist who do meditation the Buddhist way with guidance from a Buddhist master?

Maybe you can tell me also whether you believe in non-self (however which way it is explained to you), karma, rebirth, Nirvana, ultimate Nirvana for all sentient beings, or you are just into Buddhist meditation for attaining all the right behavioral traits of Buddhist Eightfold path.

Next, do you know at least ten Buddhists who do practice meditation as you do?

Do you know them well: how they are doing in work, in social life, in their home and family, as regards their physical health and their emotional life?

You see, I observe that where I am trying to interest Buddhists here doing meditation to pick up some very concrete good effects that are supposed to be attainable with meditation, like for example, to remedy constipation, insomnia, lack of punctuality reporting to work, erectile dysfunction, stammering and stuttering, tics, etc., they seem to be skirting this issue. And you keep harping about the parameters of a laboratory study.

Perhaps, then -- if you are a Buddhist in any sense and to any degree, at least you call yourself one and feel that you should explain and defend Buddhism -- without telling any of your fellow Buddhists about this idea, observe how they are doing everywhere in their personal interactions with all kinds of people they live with or come in contact with regularly or occasionally, casually, at home, in the office, and everywhere. You can make discreet inquiry from others who know them intimately.

The objective is very simple, to find out whether they are now more polite and courteous with people of various backgrounds, work circumstances, status and ranks, that they have to deal with, more polite and courteous than before they took up meditation.

That is a very simple study to do, and you can do it without falling prey to any biases from your part, for you do know -- from what I read of your messages here, about how to achieve clinical impartiality in such an endeavor.

What do you say?


Yrreg
 
Ryokan, any news on that peer-reviewed study?

According to the article, the scientist that did the research was Paul Ekman.

Background info on Paul Ekman :

http://www.paulekman.com/index.php
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Ekman

Looks like a 'real' scientist to me. However, on the 'contact' page of his site, he makes it clear he's unavailable for questions.

So my task then is to track down a peer reviewed article that supports the claims quoted in the OP.

http://psych.umb.edu/faculty/perez/Psych612/Psych612_files/Ekman_Buddhist_psych_2005.pdf#search='%20Paul%20Ekman%20Buddhism'

Here's a peer reviewed (I assume it is, I'll admit to not being knowledgable about American academic circles) article that at least shows that Paul Ekman is involved in research on Buddhism. No reference to actual scientific research, however.

I'll keep looking.

Last edited by Ryokan : 12th January 2006 at 09:43 AM.​
​

Well, I just clicked on the refresh button of the browser, and still no new post from the author of this thread, Evidence in Buddhism, to show us peer-reviewed scientific studies on Buddhism as a scientific system, or at least Buddhist meditation.

So, let's continue to wait, and in the meantime put out a paging for Ryokan.

Paging Ryokan, paging Ryokan: Please report to your thread on Evidence in Buddhism.​
​

Om Mani Padme Hum ----- Om Mani Padme Hum ----- Om Mani Padme Hum​


Yrreg
 
Paging Ryokan, paging Ryokan: Please report to your thread on Evidence in Buddhism.​
​

I wasn't going to bump the thread until I had a definite answer for what epepke is asking for. I've e-mailed some of the scientist involved in the project, but so far no answer.
 
I've e-mailed scientists involved with both projects mentioned in the first quote in the original post, as well as their universities.

I've had no reply from any of them.

This is, of course, not evidence that there has been no such research with the stated result, but it must be discarded as evidence regardless.
 
err no?

Actually, this is really not evidence of Buddhism at all. Infact, its evidence against it once you know all the facts. Let me explain.

In Bernard Wards book "Think Yourself Well" he talks in depth about meditation and its benefits. In the book you can read that "Dr.Dean Ornish of the University of California at San Francisco advocates the use of meditation and relaxation to reverse the effects of heart disease." and "Dr. Herbert Benson was the first modern researcher to demonstrate the value of relaxation in treating and healing a host of human ailments."

Basically what I'm getting at is that relaxation, or meditation is good for you, period. But so is working out and stretching. Relaxation techniques like meditation help calm a person down and relieve stress in most cases. This is in no way an argument for Buddhism. Buddhism is not the only religion that practices meditation and in no way is belief in Buddhism required to perform meditation.

Just because a Christian that works out every other day is in good shape does not mean that if working out gets him into shape then Jesus Christ exists.

You see, meditation is good WITHOUT Buddhism. Just like normal stretching is good without believing in any religion that practices Yoga. Which is why I consider this to be an argument AGAINST Buddhism and not FOR it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom