nosho
Thinker
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2006
- Messages
- 179
This point probably already has been made, but I think there's a difference between offering evidence of Buddhism and offering evidence of the effectiveness of a certain meditation technique.
The Buddhist practice of concentration on the breath is a technique that probably is much older than Buddhism and that can be found in other traditions. One of the experts cited in a post above (Kabat-Zinn) has a stress-reduction clinic in a hospital where mindfulness meditation techniques are used to help people deal with stress, disease, etc. His approach mirrors basic Buddhist meditation practice, but there is no mention of "Buddha" or Buddhism.
Meditative states of concentration featured prominently in the Christian mystic tradition, as well. In some Catholic circles, there is an attempt to revive non-discursive prayer. I'm sure we could find examples of meditative practice in virtually every religious tradition.
These states of concentration (or absorption) appear to be real, physiological phenomena that can be measured and that can have an effect. I think that the effect on an individual probably is tied to how an individual interprets what is happening. For one person, loss of a sense of self can be frightening. For another, it can be uplifting. For another, it might just be annoying. Meditation might be powerful precisely because human health cannot be separated from human self-perception.
Buddhism, as I understand it, adopts meditation practice as part of a broader path that must include an attempt to do the right thing. That means, from a Buddhist perspective, meditation is not going to be effective if the practioner is out breaking the precepts of right conduct when he's not meditating.
I doubt there's any way of coming up with "evidence for Buddhism," since Buddhism is such a huge tent with so many different traditions, as these threads have made plain. But if one views Buddhism as an ancient self-help course rather than a religion, it puts a little different spin on things. A self-help course is only valid for the people it helps. If someone tries a self-help course and doesn't benefit, then the course is not valid for that individual. So it's really not useful to talk about evidence for the effectiveness of a self-help course. As others already have pointed out, the only way to evaluate a self-help course properly is to try it and see if it works. If it doesn't for you, then it's not valid for you.
So I guess a person could spend weeks or months debating whether there is evidence to support a self-help course, but that doesn't really accomplish anything unless the person actually decides to try out the self-help course. And if that person decides not to try it out, fine. But I don't see the benefit in spending too long debating it. To me, that seems like a way of avoiding the issue, or of avoiding some other issue.
The Buddhist practice of concentration on the breath is a technique that probably is much older than Buddhism and that can be found in other traditions. One of the experts cited in a post above (Kabat-Zinn) has a stress-reduction clinic in a hospital where mindfulness meditation techniques are used to help people deal with stress, disease, etc. His approach mirrors basic Buddhist meditation practice, but there is no mention of "Buddha" or Buddhism.
Meditative states of concentration featured prominently in the Christian mystic tradition, as well. In some Catholic circles, there is an attempt to revive non-discursive prayer. I'm sure we could find examples of meditative practice in virtually every religious tradition.
These states of concentration (or absorption) appear to be real, physiological phenomena that can be measured and that can have an effect. I think that the effect on an individual probably is tied to how an individual interprets what is happening. For one person, loss of a sense of self can be frightening. For another, it can be uplifting. For another, it might just be annoying. Meditation might be powerful precisely because human health cannot be separated from human self-perception.
Buddhism, as I understand it, adopts meditation practice as part of a broader path that must include an attempt to do the right thing. That means, from a Buddhist perspective, meditation is not going to be effective if the practioner is out breaking the precepts of right conduct when he's not meditating.
I doubt there's any way of coming up with "evidence for Buddhism," since Buddhism is such a huge tent with so many different traditions, as these threads have made plain. But if one views Buddhism as an ancient self-help course rather than a religion, it puts a little different spin on things. A self-help course is only valid for the people it helps. If someone tries a self-help course and doesn't benefit, then the course is not valid for that individual. So it's really not useful to talk about evidence for the effectiveness of a self-help course. As others already have pointed out, the only way to evaluate a self-help course properly is to try it and see if it works. If it doesn't for you, then it's not valid for you.
So I guess a person could spend weeks or months debating whether there is evidence to support a self-help course, but that doesn't really accomplish anything unless the person actually decides to try out the self-help course. And if that person decides not to try it out, fine. But I don't see the benefit in spending too long debating it. To me, that seems like a way of avoiding the issue, or of avoiding some other issue.