Evidence of Buddhism

This point probably already has been made, but I think there's a difference between offering evidence of Buddhism and offering evidence of the effectiveness of a certain meditation technique.

The Buddhist practice of concentration on the breath is a technique that probably is much older than Buddhism and that can be found in other traditions. One of the experts cited in a post above (Kabat-Zinn) has a stress-reduction clinic in a hospital where mindfulness meditation techniques are used to help people deal with stress, disease, etc. His approach mirrors basic Buddhist meditation practice, but there is no mention of "Buddha" or Buddhism.

Meditative states of concentration featured prominently in the Christian mystic tradition, as well. In some Catholic circles, there is an attempt to revive non-discursive prayer. I'm sure we could find examples of meditative practice in virtually every religious tradition.

These states of concentration (or absorption) appear to be real, physiological phenomena that can be measured and that can have an effect. I think that the effect on an individual probably is tied to how an individual interprets what is happening. For one person, loss of a sense of self can be frightening. For another, it can be uplifting. For another, it might just be annoying. Meditation might be powerful precisely because human health cannot be separated from human self-perception.

Buddhism, as I understand it, adopts meditation practice as part of a broader path that must include an attempt to do the right thing. That means, from a Buddhist perspective, meditation is not going to be effective if the practioner is out breaking the precepts of right conduct when he's not meditating.

I doubt there's any way of coming up with "evidence for Buddhism," since Buddhism is such a huge tent with so many different traditions, as these threads have made plain. But if one views Buddhism as an ancient self-help course rather than a religion, it puts a little different spin on things. A self-help course is only valid for the people it helps. If someone tries a self-help course and doesn't benefit, then the course is not valid for that individual. So it's really not useful to talk about evidence for the effectiveness of a self-help course. As others already have pointed out, the only way to evaluate a self-help course properly is to try it and see if it works. If it doesn't for you, then it's not valid for you.

So I guess a person could spend weeks or months debating whether there is evidence to support a self-help course, but that doesn't really accomplish anything unless the person actually decides to try out the self-help course. And if that person decides not to try it out, fine. But I don't see the benefit in spending too long debating it. To me, that seems like a way of avoiding the issue, or of avoiding some other issue.
 
A lab right before your nose

Let's talk about something very concrete, like equanimity or not getting angry.

Here is a study that anyone can do about Buddhism on equanimity or dissimulation of anger, or not letting annoyances get to your goat.

Please read all my posts here from the very first, use the search link here.

In the process you will come across people who react to my posts; among them mostly Buddhists or people who call themselves Buddhists, or people who defend Buddhism or who react adversely to my skeptical criticism of Buddhism.

Now, tell me, who is more possessed of equanimity, Yrreg or his controverting respondents.

If you produce all the instances where Yrreg calls people names here, and all the instances where people here call Yrreg names, I will give you a surprise reward.

Hahaha and hehehe!


According to my favorite student of human behavior, one Pes Oir Amsus:

"When you can't laugh at your own religion or craving and attachment, then you have not attained genuine gentleman and erudite status."​


Yrreg
 
Honest, I hadn't read this before composing my response to cajela, but I think this is an example.

There are many valid reasons to question the value of talk therapy. As I've pointed out, Freudian therapy went on for a long time without any good studies, and when studies were done, they turned out not to support it very well. As a result, Freudian is now widely considered pseudoscience.
And believe me I do question the value of talk therapy that is not behavioral and goal directed.
Freudian therapy as practised by Freud is in adifferent category that the Alderian and postmodern schools. Freud was able to admit his failings.
What I am concerned about is this kind of argument: "most rejection of buddhism comes from those misconceptions."
And it was meant as a general response, in general when people object to buddhism, it is grounds that are mistaken beliefs of what buddhism is. Such as 'Buddha is god, idol worship and world rejecting'.
This is problematic. First of all, it can lead to the tacit assumption that acceptance of Buddhism should be the default position, by the fact that it is necessary to come up with reasons why people do not accept Buddhism without evidence.
That would be problematic, and was not my intention.
Second of all, as I've pointed out, the "woo" concepts within Buddhism as a broad category can make the "non-woo" concepts seem good by comparison and divert attention away from the idea that they are amenable to skeptical testing just as any other claim is.
As true of any human endevour that does not have peer review and open evidence based practise.

I am very sceptical of all woo beliefs, including mine.
In my view, from a skeptical position, this is nonsense. However, there was a recent thread about what one has learned from this forum, and several people have pointed out that even self-identified skeptics can exhibit faith and dogmatism.
A mischaracterization of scepticism by those seeking shelter in self delusion. OOOOK
This seems to me to be true, and it's just part of the environment I have to deal with, even though I don't like it. It relates to the specific here, because in my observation, Buddhism gets a free ride that is not granted to, say, Christianity.
Well I would say the opposite, in the US people are very rarely sceptical of Xianity, they just accept it and all the cultural baggage of americans as 'the right stuff'.
Sceptics not withstanding.
I hope that buddha does not get a free ride, he should pay full fare!
So let me put it this way, if it makes it clearer. There is a practice called "Christian counseling," which involves claims substantially similar to the psychological claims about Buddhism. However, in my estimation, people on this forum would be more "skeptical" of these claims simply because there is a higher probability of suspecting Christianity than there is of suspecting Buddhism. This is irrational, of course, but it happens all the time.
/quote]
Hmm I said that the practices of buddhism are similar to CBT, but I made no claims that they were counseling.
The only issue I have with Xiam counseling is two fold:
1. They don't observe very good boundaries.
2. They use suspect techniques and call it counseling.

But I agree that it may be the concepts of buddhism are not put to the fire the way Xian concepts are, in a sceptics forum.
I, however, don't think that skepticism of the claims of Christian counseling, qua Christian, should be any different from skepticism of the claims of Buddhist self help qua Buddhist, or the claims of CBT qua secular.
snif , CBT is research based, as least in theory.
I am pleased that people are actually looking up papers now, but I do have to point out that this has happened only after some prodding.

Poke , poke.
 
Let's talk about something very concrete, like equanimity or not getting angry.

Here is a study that anyone can do about Buddhism on equanimity or dissimulation of anger, or not letting annoyances get to your goat.

Please read all my posts here from the very first, use the search link here.

In the process you will come across people who react to my posts; among them mostly Buddhists or people who call themselves Buddhists, or people who defend Buddhism or who react adversely to my skeptical criticism of Buddhism.

Now, tell me, who is more possessed of equanimity, Yrreg or his controverting respondents.
Hmm, lets see.
You misquote the buddha, you mischaracterise buddhism, you refuse to answer questions, you refuse to debate you ideas or even defend them.

It is impolite to act the way you do as well.

I didn't read your Troll's Credo, why won't you answer questions?
Because you can't defend your ideas?
If you produce all the instances where Yrreg calls people names here, and all the instances where people here call Yrreg names, I will give you a surprise reward.

Hahaha and hehehe!


According to my favorite student of human behavior, one Pes Oir Amsus:

"When you can't laugh at your own religion or craving and attachment, then you have not attained genuine gentleman and erudite status."​


Yrreg

You are ignorant yrreg, it is not a name, it classifys your behavior of pontification based upon ignorance.

You are a troll, that is why you don't answer questions, and can't or won't debate.

Your attidue that buddhists sit around all day doing nothings and not participating in life is just as insulting as any name calling.
 
The PLATO system. Originally developed at the University of Illinois, there was a daughter project at FSU, and they had a satellite in Sarasota, Florida, where I happened to live, as well as many other satellites distributed throughout Florida.
Go PLATO, 1977 for me, in Shampoo-Bannana, the home of PLATO!
 
I find the quotes very interesting. I have seen others like them before, but when I see statements like "feel a loss of their sense of themselves." expressed as a negative I wonder what the words mean. To a buddhist, losing the sense of self is a good thing, not a bad thing, but the words in the quote might mean something entirely different...

...I can see how some persons could experience what would be regarded as adverse effects from meditation, but it almost seems silly to think that mediation should come with a warning label. I mean it is just sitting still and focusing on the breath for 20-30 minutes (as a common example). How can something so innocuous be so powerful?

That is something I would like to see science explore.

I'm not sure how we would set up an ethical study on meditation. In a study on prayer a few years ago, some of the subjects 'prayed for' got worse. Nobody stopped praying. Prayer studies only seem to count hits, and meditation studies seem very similar.

I agree that the 'losing sense of self' seems weird wording. My short experience with a group that did meditation was probably a good example of "bad experience meditating". I'll see if I can put something down into writing later.
 
Let's talk about something very concrete, like equanimity or not getting angry. Here is a study that anyone can do about Buddhism on equanimity or dissimulation of anger, or not letting annoyances get to your goat. Please read all my posts here from the very first, use the search link here. In the process you will come across people who react to my posts; among them mostly Buddhists or people who call themselves Buddhists, or people who defend Buddhism or who react adversely to my skeptical criticism of Buddhism.
Yeah, but you are just referring to your own self-restraint and maturity and calling it Buddhism. The practice of Buddhism alone can't accomplish that any more than poetry. It is the rarely known, greater upliftment and satisfaction of living in hidden accord with nature and reason - that is always possible no matter what hell one finds themselves in through hard work, that Buddhism points to. Buddhism doesn't point to Buddhism, or advocate Buddhism.

When you can't laugh at your own religion or craving and attachment, then you have not attained genuine gentleman and erudite status.
You never slammed a beautiful woman in the ass while snorting lines off her back and beating your chest like a Greek God, I take it. Oh well, perhaps in the next life. Why would anyone want to be a gentleman or a erudite anyway? Both don't really exist, except as pretentiousness. Craving and attachment don't go away until the very end, they just become felt as lesser forms of satisfaction. Everything in balance.
 
Last edited:
How the hell do you go about being skeptical about Buddhism, anyway. It's like being skeptical about nonviolence and self-discipline. The religious trappings it turned into of course, are undeniably nonsense. But is that even worth debating?
 
First used Plato IV (around 10,000 workstations around the world, most in Champaign-Urbana, Illinois) at the Univ. of Illinois in 1974. Played with it and used it for some courses (Computer Calculus, Chemistry, Physics) through 1980. Awesome workstation for the time - orange-on-black touch-sensitive plasma display, able to project microfiche onto the back of the display, state-of-the-art authoring and user environment. Plato was sold to a private company years ago. Plato educational software is still being produced in the Minneapolis, Minnesota area.
 
My take on Buddhism...

Buddhism is a moralistic religion of the negative type bordering on pessimism, nihilism.

Now if you just disregard the non-self, karma, rebirth, and the nirvana end of the world scenario for all sentient life forms, as some kind of parousia or Buddhist eschatology or end things, Buddhism as I said is a moralistic system of a religion or even philosophy; indulging in it might render you a peaceable person within yourself and also with neighbors, yet not make you useful for solving the problems of the world like hunger, disease, and the scorch of natural disasters, very important also ignorance.

And should you want to give yourself the best health care and the most number of years before you finally opt for definitive nirvana, Buddhism can't help you.

If you have to support a family and run a home, and give your kids the best preparation for life, then Buddhism practiced full time can't help you; quite the contrary it is tantamount to some kind of premature retirement, like the kinds I have seen in guys who use some kind of sickness to not do anything in life anymore, being occupied with their sickness, like for example easily prone to dizziness.

Why should I have to see any resources in Buddhism for ordering my moralistic existence? when I can fashion my own and get to be a happy, productive person, decently adjusted in society, having a purpose in life and finding life meaningful and satisfactory.

So, I invite Buddhists here to do the same.

For those Buddhists who don't accept the non-self, karma, rebirth, Nirvana in Buddhism, then I apologize to them. But then I don't see why they have to defend Buddhism, and get all worked up with people like myself doing skeptical criticism on Buddhism.


Yrreg
 
Buddhism is a moralistic religion of the negative type bordering on pessimism, nihilism.
Now if you just disregard the non-self, karma, rebirth, and the nirvana end of the world scenario for all sentient life forms, as some kind of parousia or Buddhist eschatology or end things, Buddhism as I said is a moralistic system of a religion or even philosophy; indulging in it might render you a peaceable person within yourself and also with neighbors, yet not make you useful for solving the problems of the world like hunger, disease, and the scorch of natural disasters, very important also ignorance.
I'm speaking soley on behalf of the Zen and Mahayana philosophical schools when forming my responses. With that said, solving issues in your enviornment or even becoming a celebrity is moot, if you are mindful of your actions, and it developing into an attachment.

If you have to support a family and run a home, and give your kids the best preparation for life, then Buddhism practiced full time can't help you; quite the contrary it is tantamount to some kind of premature retirement, like the kinds I have seen in guys who use some kind of sickness to not do anything in life anymore, being occupied with their sickness, like for example easily prone to dizziness.
They can be preoccupied or not be preoccupied, as long as they follow the four rules of conduct or some variation.

Why should I have to see any resources in Buddhism for ordering my moralistic existence? when I can fashion my own and get to be a happy, productive person, decently adjusted in society, having a purpose in life and finding life meaningful and satisfactory.
It is a cultural tradition with philsophical and religious underpinnings, and some people enjoy that as opposed to puritan pragmatism.

For those Buddhists who don't accept the non-self, karma, rebirth, Nirvana in Buddhism, then I apologize to them. But then I don't see why they have to defend Buddhism, and get all worked up with people like myself doing skeptical criticism on Buddhism
What Buddhism points to is very difficult to learn, much less practice, in life, but acting like religious fundamentalists is the height of idiocy.
 
Two kinds of evidence here

The way I size it up, there are two kinds of evidence being pursued in this thread: one the laboratory evidence, and the other the personal experience evidence.

Ryokan maintains that at least for the advantages of Buddhist meditation there is evidence in the laboratory.

As regards the evidence from personal experience, it can prove everything in Buddhism to the true believers, and it proves nothing in the laboratory.

I have to read the thread more carefully as regards the evidence in the laboratory firming up the advantages of Buddhist meditation.

But I would like to suggest maybe too simplistically that there is the laboratory that is like the operating room in the hospital, and there is the laboratory that is the streets and homes and offices and even war fronts, and above all personal interactions among people who have to live and work together, exist together in the same place at the same time.

And the situation I see it here in this JREF forum, in regard to skeptical criticism of Buddhism, the Buddhists here are not as conspicuous for equanimity of which Buddhism is supposed to be famous for, as I would or people would reasonably expect.

But that is my personal observation and tentative conclusion. I have seen here Buddhists who started calm and peaceable but ended up with harsh words, and one or two after crossing over the threshold of self-equanimity have not returned to their Buddhist imperturbability, as they might imagine that they have acquired with their meditation.

There is an essential insecurity with Buddhists here, that they have to explain and defend and get annoyed to the extent of resorting to harsh words, to kind of abolish any criticism on Buddhism, like people with a gun would shoot others who criticize their ways.

I am losing my equanimity, so I will recite:

Om Mani Padme Hum -- Om Mani Padme Hum -- Om Mani Padme Hum​
​

[For people who are curious what questions D David is asking me and I am refusing to answer, ask him. Om Mani Padme Hum. Okay? If anyone has any serious complaint against me, please report me to the authorities here; use the complaint link. Otherwise let's all just have a good time here.]


Yrreg
 
So it's really not useful to talk about evidence for the effectiveness of a self-help course. As others already have pointed out, the only way to evaluate a self-help course properly is to try it and see if it works.

Not necessarily. One can also read reviews and research about it, and that might be wiser if there is a heavy investment required for the course, monetary or otherwise (and in the case of Buddhism, it would mostly be otherwise).

Kopji said:
I'm not sure how we would set up an ethical study on meditation. In a study on prayer a few years ago, some of the subjects 'prayed for' got worse.

I would think that would depend on how much worse the subjects would get, and whether the resulting problems were temporary or reversible.
 
I would think that would depend on how much worse the subjects would get, and whether the resulting problems were temporary or reversible. --jjramsey

I can agree with that. If laboratory tests do not account for potential harm as well as potential benefits of a practice, it is evidence of measurement bias. A casual glance at previous 'meditation' testing shows a bias toward a positive outcome. If they want to have meditation taken seriously as science we need to see better designed tests.
 
I wanted to add something on the topic of meditation doing harm without titling it something like how crazy is kopji?

'Crazy' runs in my family enough for me to just call it plain old 'crazy' instead of something more PC. Schizophrenia, bipolar, depression, autism... sheesh we got it all. All people I love and care about.

I see dim reflections of them in myself sometimes. One of those ways is that things sometimes 'fold up'. If you typed a sentence on a page, and then fan-folded the paper into "z". You would see the beginning of the sentence and the end, but the middle had 'vanished' in the fold.

Time can be like that if I'm working on a difficult problem. I got in huge trouble once when I was working on a programming problem a few years ago. I looked down at 12 noon, and looked up a 'second' later and it was 3pm. (Unfortunately I was supposed to pick up someone from school...)

I am not conscious of these 'quirks' most of the time. I notice it mostly with numbers (and really long Internet posts), where they are not so much reversed or 'dyslexic', just 'missing the middle'.

Anyway, mediation needs to be practiced regularly and that was the real problem for me. Once started there was no way to stop it. It would be like words echoing around in my head - like a twisted version of the 'folding' thing, where there was no middle, only slamming against the rails at each end. Thinking about nothing but the next meditation - sort of like 'mind hic-cups'. Add that to two parts 'feeling like you are slowly becoming transparent' - not really here. And then, fear that you are going crazy just like those frigging' relatives.

Am I better now?

Well I lost all religious faith and that is a bittersweet thing sometimes. I still don't think people can choose to not believe. They either never did, or it is burned out somehow. I have the scars to prove I once believed.

The 'quirky' folding is mostly harmless, but a way of understanding new things broadly and then more narrowly. It is easier to explain with paint than words. I compensate by being careful when it happens and not get too upset about it. It is embarrassing to be caught doing it but I get over it.

I hike and draw instead of meditate, and I do them when I feel like it and at my own pace. The 'transparent' feeling can be called upon without too much effort: A quiet and still place. It is a place like where the 'folded up sentences' go. :)

The real battle for me is avoiding feeling nothing. I think a Buddhist might feel that is a kind of enlightenment but I do not. I lean more toward the Taoist way, compassion is something that grounds and orients us.

I could be wrong, but to the Buddhist pov meditation itself must just be another form of attachment, because it is. I can't see arguing a scientific basis for Buddhism being more than a straw man. Whatever science would prove must be someday let go of.
 
Last edited:
The evidence that meditation is benefiacial would require the usual controls, good baseline, longitudinal basis and then tools designed to capture the alleged benefit, the hard part would be the control group design and matching for the different groups.

The effects that I feel benefit the user of meditation are the one tauted by the buddha

'the ub-reflecting mind is like a house without a roof'.

But how do you prove that meditation allows a person to reflect upon thier emotions and thought before acting upon them?
 
Meditation is an operational process of the human entity..

Meditation is no different as an operation from memorization, like memorizing the multiplication table.

Now, we would like to request the Buddhists here, in particular Ryokan, to inform us what are the concrete effects in a person Buddhist meditation is supposed to produce?

If it is going to make a person attain enlightenment, or experience Nirvana, or become convinced of karma and rebirth, then I can't imagine how evidence can be obtained that is useful in the laboratory.

I really don't know what laboratory certifiable effects and evidence are entertained in the minds of Buddhists here, who maintain the scientific validity of meditation, Buddhist style.

Tell us, Buddhists here, please.


Yrreg
 
Meditation is no different as an operation from memorization, like memorizing the multiplication table.

What is the sound of one mouth yapping?



ETA: Ok. That sounds worse than I meant. I'm being bad.

yrreg, I'm sure you mean well, but you really don't get it, and you never will until you stop making statements, and start asking questions. But, about those questions, I'm reminded of a story my father used to tell. He said he had a professor who, on the first day of class, told the class to ask questions, but he added. "There are three kinds of questions. One kind is meant to show how smart the person asking the question is. Another kind is the kind meant to show how stupid somone else is. Then, once in a while, someone actually wants some information."

Buddhism is much more, and much less, than you give it credit for.
 
Last edited:
This is perhaps a silly question, but if one part of the Eightfold Path is "right meditation," but meditation is harmful for a particular person, would the right meditation for such a one be no meditation?
 
The PLATO system. Originally developed at the University of Illinois,

I wondered if there were any other PLATO alums around. I was U of I from 1980 to 1987. (I did get two degrees, so it isn't quite as bad as it sounds.)

A fair number of people know that a lot of work on what became the WWW came out of the advanced computing lab in Champaign. They don't know that the people who invented it were inspired by PLATO.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom