Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well let's hope a good meal and a little quality time with the wife increases your mental acuity. Because with the above post as an indication, you surely do need it.

"just in a LOW energy magnetic field region, or a NULL."? Well since I never made any such "argument" your strawman is obvious and futile. As are your continued attempts to characterize others as religious zealots. It's time for a new shtick Michael Mozina, take your time, digest your meal, reflect on the quality time with your wife and get back to us when you feel up to putting at least some effort into your response.

You keep handwaving about the fact that Guass's law is satisfied in the NULL. So what? That same law is satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the NULL. The same number of lines that enter ANY region, exit that same region. That is fundamental TRUTH of basic EM theory.

Your RELIGION is MONOPOLISM. Clinger's maths are meaningless in OUR universe because monopoles do not exist, so B lines have no source and no beginning. They have no sink and no ending either. They are continuous loops, continuous rings, continuous PERIOD.

I've provided a DOZEN published references that all say you're wrong. You don't even seem to have a CLEAR definition of how you might try to differentiate between ordinary processes, such as magnetic flux changes, from what you're calling "reconnection".

The only HANDWAVE provided is NOT peer reviewed. It's NOT published. It GARBAGE in the first place! One CANNOT treat a B field as an E field in THIS UNIVERSE. In your monopolistic world to come perhaps, but in this universe, FORGETABOUTIT.

Unless and until one of you pulls a monopole out of your pocket, Clinger use of vectors is POINTLESS at a POINT. Gauss's laws are not just satisfied at THAT point alone, they are satisfied EVERYWHERE!
 
So, Mozina appears to agree that the null point satisfies Gauss's Law. So far so good. But now comes the real howler ...

This is so amazingly wrong that the mind boggles. Behold ...

Behold, you never read my discussion with PS when I said it was probably MORE appropriate to simply say NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.

I said it was POSSIBLE to look at it as two NOTHINGS meeting in a BAR, but it's LESS ACCURATE for the EXACT REASONS YOU SPECIFY.

I have provided over a DOZEN published references demonstrating that B lines are closed loops, have no beginnings or endings, no sources or sinks.

You folks have provided NOTHING BUT HANDWAVED, non peer reviewed GARBAGE thus far. It's all based on MONOPOLISM. You folks are still somehow CONVINCED that B lines "begin". They don't. Get over it already.
 
I've been involved in online discussions now on various websites, covering a LARGE volume of topics, for more than a decade. In all that time, I've never seen a topic argued *ENTIRELY* upon attacking the individual as you and other EU haters do on a REGULAR BASIS.

When we look at your statements, you ADMIT that YOU PERSONALLY never had a good fundamental grounding in EM theory. On the other hand, I personally applied that THEORY to in field repair processes for over 15 years doing repair work on security equipment. My foundation was strong, and I utilized that knowledge in the field for MANY YEARS.

I also built upon that strong foundation by continuing my education and reading a NUMBER of books on plasma physics, from a VARIETY of various authors. It was actually an "expensive" process by the way since each of those five books costs over $100 retail.

You on the other hand admit that you did NOT have a strong foundation, and you've never read a single book on plasma physics. You evidently have to beg, borrow and steal whatever you do understand from a guy that *STILL* treats B fields as E fields! OMG.

Attack me all you like. Creationists toughened my skin LONG before I met you haters. They argued just like you guys do. They do NOT provided PUBLISHED, or PEER REVIEWED works to support their views. They HANDWAVE like you do. You handwaved some pretty pictures at me because evidently you can't tell FLUX CHANGES from turnips.

Clinger handwaves a little math that he personally seems to think is the "be all-end-all" of mathematics, when in fact it's BASIC STUFF. It amounts to exactly 0+0=0 in a vacuum. PERIOD. That CONCLUSIVELY DEMONSTRATES THAT NOTHING could reconnect there. NOTHING could begin there. NOTHING could end there.

You don't even understand the basics. You refuse to continue investing in your education, and therefore you are personally reduced to attacking individuals that chose a path of EDUCATION and already had a better foundation than you did. How sad for you.

If this were the only subject where I have watched you debate a question that is clearly over your head, perhaps I might be tempted to give you some benefit of the doubt. However, I have witnessed your blathering on this and other threads involving the photosphere, solar imaging, dark energy, dark matter, negative pressure (the Casimir effect), solid iron sun, etc. You are clearly a living breathing example of the Dunning– Kruger effect -- in spades!

I do invest in my education on a daily basis by extensive reading in all areas of science. My knowledge of mathematics is a great aid in doing so. I pay particular attention to the opinions of those very talented people who have invested a lifetime studying their area of expertise. Most importantly, I know what I don't know! I don't flail around like a buffoon pretending I know more than people who have spent their lives studying an area where I have only a general understanding. Wake up, Mozina, you are only fooling yourself; everyone else here knows you for who you really are!
 
If this were the only subject where I have watched you debate a question that is clearly over your head, perhaps I might be tempted to give you some benefit of the doubt.

You're right back to attacking the individual. How predictable and how sad. Topics change, but haters are all alike. You are only fooling yourself if you think your involvement in this thread has "educated" you to this point in time. The time and effort you have spent on this conversation, attacking individuals blindly, would have been MUCH better spent in front of a plasma physics textbook, or in your case maybe just a good book on BASIC EM theory since that seems to be where your problem originates.

If you did have a strong grasp of BASIC EM theory, you'd already know that B lines have no beginning, no ending, no source, and no sink. You'd know that Guass's laws are not just satisfied in the NULL, but EVERYWHERE. You'd already know that Clinger's claims about B lines "beginning" anywhere are BS. You'd know that every single B line that EXITS any point ENTERED that POINT AS WELL.
 
Last edited:
http://www.answers.com/topic/magnetic-monopole

CE397800FG0010.gif


Part A demonstrates how OUR UNIVERSE operates. In OUR universe, B lines have no source, no sink, no beginning and no end. E fields have monopolistic charges that do all the "reconnecting".

In your RELIGION called "monopolism", in some other fictitious universe, B lines work the way Clinger suggests. They DO have beginnings. They DO have endings. His claims would (in that fictional universe) have scientific merit.

In *THIS* universe however, devoid of monopoles, Gauss's laws are satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just at ORIGIN THE DUD, but no B lines BEGIN or END anywhere.

Your religion sucks because mostly it's based on attacking the individual rather than PHYSICS in *THIS* universe.
 
...
If you did have a strong grasp of BASIC EM theory, you'd already know that B lines have no beginning, no ending, no source, and no sink. You'd know that Guass's laws are not just satisfied in the NULL, but EVERYWHERE. You'd already know that Clinger's claims about B lines "beginning" anywhere are BS. You'd know that every single B line that EXITS any point ENTERED that POINT AS WELL.

This is an excellent example of you having an opinion where you lack the fundamental skills needed to really understand the issue under discussion. If you really understood the mathematical significance of ∇⋅ B = 0, you couldn't possibly make the above comment! There is little else to say.
 
This is an excellent example of you having an opinion where you lack the fundamental skills needed to really understand the issue under discussion. If you really understood the mathematical significance of ∇⋅ B = 0, you couldn't possibly make the above comment! There is little else to say.

Oy Vey.
 
When an argument fails, just accuse the opposition of "closed-minded, religious thinking."

Typical pseudo-scientist...

What's left *BESIDES* "blind faith"? None of them have provided a PUBLISHED or PEER REVIEWED paper to support their claims. Clinger's ideas ONLY work in MONOPOLISM, not in THIS UNIVERSE. What else can it be OTHER THAN a religion?

They even demonize anyone and everyone that disagrees with them, *IN SPITE* of the fact I've provided them with more than a dozen published references demonstrating *THEIR* error!

It's like a hater's cult for monopolists.
 
Michael Mozina boasts of his credentials, part 1

Michael Mozina's usual arguments (misquotation, misrepresentation, misinterpretation, argument from dubious or misinterpreted authority, ridicule of silly phrases that Michael Mozina invented, ridicule of silly religions that Michael Mozina invented, attacks on other straw men that Michael Mozina invented, making stuff up, and shouted denials) aren't working.

Michael Mozina has been arguing from the authority of Hannes Alfvén and other authors of books he claims to have read, but that argument doesn't fly unless we trust Michael Mozina's interpretations of the science he's been reading. As can be seen by considering Michael Mozina's posts during the first three weeks of November 2011, Michael Mozina's scientific judgement should not be trusted.

To defend his scientific judgement, Michael Mozina is now touting his credentials.

Discussing a poster's credentials is usually off-topic, but Michael Mozina is arguing from his own personal authority. Because Michael Mozina has chosen to cite his credentials as evidence for his personal authority, and because that alleged authority is the foundation of his argument, we cannot discuss his argument without examining his credentials.

In what follows, I will take the liberty of comparing Michael Mozina's credentials to what is known about the credentials of those whom Michael Mozina has characterized as "haters that refuse to educate themselves", "aren't even particularly knowledgeable in the topic", an "ignorant crew" that argues "from a place of pure blind ignorance" because their "beliefs are IRRATIONAL and based on PURE IGNORANCE and irrational hatred", "refuse to read or comprehend" math, have "buried" themselves in "BS handwave claims" they "can NEVER demonstrate mathematically", "don't even debate logically or rationally", "do not comprehend even BASIC EM theory", "don't have the first clue about basic EM theory", "don't know squat about physics", "couldn't spot Clinger's BUSH-LEAGUE mistakes", "don't even have a CLUE about basic theory", and refuse "to abide by the laws of physics, specifically Gauss's law of magnetism". For brevity, I will refer to them as the "ignorant crew" (in quotes).

FYI, in case you are in fact interested in my *ACTUAL* background, rather than the beat up strawman they would like you to believe, I've studied Calculus formally for years, starting in *HIGH SCHOOL* and my passion is solar physics. While my profession doesn't require much calculus (self employed software programmer by trade), my hobbies have kept me relatively brushed up over the years. I can at least follow along in most papers that I read, although I admit that eigenstates of neutrino maths are still murky to me personally. Most of the rest of it is straight forward from my perspective, including Priest's little manipulations at equations 16 and 17.

I've also studied basic EM theory and spent more than a decade repairing circuit boards and doing basic repair work on general electronics equipment related to the security industry. I'm pretty competent with basic theory and I've read through at least 5 textbooks on plasma physics over the past decade, more than all the true haters in this thread combined.
At the university I attended as an undergraduate, calculus is a one-year course (two semesters). That university also offers a two-semester sequence in advanced calculus, which covers differential equations and vector calculus in more detail.

By studying calculus for years, we would expect Michael Mozina to be conversant with differential equations and vector calculus. As he has demonstrated within this thread, however, Michael Mozina does not understand a simple differential equation, cannot calculate a divergence, cannot follow an explicit calculation of divergence, and routinely refers to legitimate math (including basic calculus) as hand-waving.

Michael Mozina's years of studying calculus remind me of the high school dropout who considered himself the smartest guy in town because no one else had spent so many years in high school.

Most of the "ignorant crew" completed PhD or MS degrees in mathematics, physics, or engineering.

You're a liar and a fraud Clinger. Not only do I understand math *AND* physics, I pointed out YOUR error for you.
Michael Mozina did not identify an actual error. He only thinks he identified an actual error.

Michael Mozina only thinks he understands math and physics:

...
If you did have a strong grasp of BASIC EM theory, you'd already know that B lines have no beginning, no ending, no source, and no sink. You'd know that Guass's laws are not just satisfied in the NULL, but EVERYWHERE. You'd already know that Clinger's claims about B lines "beginning" anywhere are BS. You'd know that every single B line that EXITS any point ENTERED that POINT AS WELL.

This is an excellent example of you having an opinion where you lack the fundamental skills needed to really understand the issue under discussion. If you really understood the mathematical significance of ∇⋅ B = 0, you couldn't possibly make the above comment! There is little else to say.
Perpetual Student, whom Michael Mozina had characterized as one of the "ignorant crew", completed an MS in mathematics and a minor in physics.

Perpetual Student is correct. Michael Mozina pretends to base his argument upon Gauss's law for magnetism, but does not acknowledge mathematical proofs that Gauss's law holds for the magnetic fields in question. Even worse: Michael Mozina didn't recognize a correct statement of Gauss's law for magnetism.

"Source" means net outflow of magnetic flux through a surface. The null point in the center of Clinger's diagram has no net flux, because just as many lines point in as point out. Therefore it is not a source or a sink. You would understand this if you understood the math.

It's the BEGINNING of NOTHING. You'd understand that if you understood the PHYSICS! Not EVERY form of KNOWLEDGE is MATHEMATICAL in nature. Some of it is simply CONCEPTUAL UNDERSTANDING. Conceptually you CANNOT treat a B line *WITHOUT* BEGINNINGS like a E field. It's not acceptable IN PHYSICS, even if the "math" works out on PAPER to swap them.
Almo has an MS in physics.

I'm quite well aware and well educated in standard EM theory, not only based on reading materials, but also based on hands on experience in my professional life. More importantly, I'm not a clairvoyant physicist like Clinger. I've actually read plasma physics textbooks. :)
Michael Mozina has not earned any university degrees in math or physics.

Although Michael Mozina claims to have studied calculus "formally" for several years, he has demonstrated no knowledge of calculus. Although Michael Mozina claims to have read a college-level textbook on electromagnetism some thirty years ago, he cannot remember its author or title, and he cannot recognize a correct statement of Gauss's law for magnetism. Since Michael Mozina does not claim to have studied electromagnetism "formally", as he claimed for calculus, we may infer that Michael Mozina has never taken a university-level course in electromagnetism. Since electromagnetism is a freshman-level course that's prerequisite for more advanced courses in physics, we may infer that Michael Mozina has taken no more than one semester of college physics.

Since electromagnetism is an essential prerequisite for plasma physics, we should not be surprised by Michael Mozina's failure to understand the plasma physics textbooks he claims to have read.

When we look at your statements, you ADMIT that YOU PERSONALLY never had a good fundamental grounding in EM theory. On the other hand, I personally applied that THEORY to in field repair processes for over 15 years doing repair work on security equipment. My foundation was strong, and I utilized that knowledge in the field for MANY YEARS.
Michael Mozina, who never took a course in electromagnetism, is accusing someone who completed a minor in physics of not having "a good fundamental grounding in EM theory."

Michael Mozina, on the other hand, spent "over 15 years" repairing burglar alarms.

I also built upon that strong foundation by continuing my education and reading a NUMBER of books on plasma physics, from a VARIETY of various authors. It was actually an "expensive" process by the way since each of those five books costs over $100 retail.
Michael Mozina could have learned almost as much about plasma physics by buying himself a college degree.

You don't even understand the basics. You refuse to continue investing in your education, and therefore you are personally reduced to attacking individuals that chose a path of EDUCATION and already had a better foundation than you did. How sad for you.
Yes, Michael Mozina is accusing the "ignorant crew" that earned their PhD or MS degrees in math or physics of not choosing "a path of EDUCATION".

Unlike the mathematicians and physicists who "don't even understand the basics", Michael Mozina didn't even try to earn a college degree in math or physics. That's why he thinks he has a better foundation in math and physics than we do.

....Understanding some discipline like EM theory and, more specifically, the discussions in this thread involves a step by step process including a good deal of mathematics and grasping fundamental concepts like Maxwell's equations. There is an enormous difference between knowing about Maxwell's equations and understanding Maxwell's equations.

This is the root of Mozina's problem! He is a poster boy for the The Dunning– Kruger effect.
 
Wow! Pure attack of the individual. I've seen religious zealots spew less personal attacks during debate. You're essentially a two trick pony Clinger. Math handwaves are your personal "specialty", along with personal attacks. While the first attribute might be admirable, the second one is down right sleazy.

I've now provided you with more than a DOZEN unique published references from around the planet to demonstrate my claims. You won't even put your NONSENSE up for peer review and you've provided ZERO published claims to support your nonsense.

Your RELIGION is based on MONOPOLES, not NULLS. NULLS are not and cannot be the "beginning" of anything. If there were a "beginning" of a B line, it would BEGIN with a monopole, not a NULL. You're entirely ignorant of even BASIC EM theory. You REFUSE to provide PUBLISHED support for your claims. You attack individuals on a regular basis. Yep, you argue JUST EXACTLY LIKE A CREATIONIST alright. Your wussy maths amount to 0+0=0 and your Origin the DUD is a false god. Your prayers for the beginning of B lines will never be answered unless and until you find yourself a monopole.

Haters are exactly alike. The topics change but the behaviors are identical. Rather than provided PUBLISHED support, you handwave a bit, and attack the individual CONSTANTLY. When can I expect you to put your KLUDGE through a real peer review process? If not SCOTT, then whom? Let me guess? You're too "good" to worry about peer reviews, right?
 
Last edited:
...
I've now provided you with more than a DOZEN unique published references from around the planet to demonstrate my claims. You won't even put your NONSENSE up for peer review and you've provided ZERO published claims to support your nonsense.
...

This is another manifestation of your delusions about how scientific topics are discussed. The published references you mention have invariably proven to be off topic, counter to your opinions or written by some crackpot.
In any case, you have never presented a cogent argument stated in the language of physics (mathematics) to support your claims. You always link another paper or reference someone else's statements revealing your lack the skills and knowledge in the area under discussion. Every time I have asked a probing question or made a point countering your positions, you answer with a link or some evasive off topic comment. You have never responded with a direct statement addressing the point under discussion with any kind of logical argument. You simply have no clue how science is done and how it is discussed.
 
Originally Posted by Michael Mozina
When we look at your statements, you ADMIT that YOU PERSONALLY never had a good fundamental grounding in EM theory. On the other hand, I personally applied that THEORY to in field repair processes for over 15 years doing repair work on security equipment. My foundation was strong, and I utilized that knowledge in the field for MANY YEARS.
The above statement confirms that you do not understand what we mean here by "EM theory." Consider this:
In the US Air Force, I was trained (in its day) on one of the most sophisticated electronic systems in the world. The F106 had the world's first airborne digital computer, an automatic computer directed navigation system, communications, ILS, IFF, air/ground data link (SAGE), search and lock RADAR, TACAN, a fire control system using RADAR and IR missiles. I was trained on that system for two years and worked on that system for two years doing trouble shooting and repair.** Take a look: LINK. After that, I worked on encrypted X band troposcatter multiplex communications for two more years years before attending college.
I think the electronics involved in my pre-college years compares quite favorably to your burglar alarm training and work. Yet, it would be inconceivable for me to pretend that my training even comes close to the level of "a good fundamental grounding in EM theory." In reality I was a mere technician. The fact that you actually believe that your work with alarm systems in any way involves a grounding in EM theory reveals that you do not know what EM theory is! Case closed!

Addendum: **By the way, in my day, electronics repair did not consist of replacing a chip. We had vacuum tubes, resistors. capacitors and inductors in complex circuits to trouble shoot and then solder in a new circuit element to replace the defective one. It was not work for hand-waving pretenders.
 
Last edited:
The only handwaving pretenders are the EU haters that have never read a plasma physics textbook, and have provided absolutely NO PEER REVIEWED materials to even READ. You're utterly in full fledged denial as it relates to those dozen references I provided. They *ALL* explained that all B lines form as full loops, they have no sources, sinks, beginnings or ends.

Only in you monopolistic religion would it be possible for B lines to "begin" anywhere. The one point none of you wish to address is the fact that Gauss's law isn't just preserved in ONE SPECIAL place, it's preserved EVERYWHERE IN THE EXPERIMENT!

Origin isn't "special" boys and girls. He's a false god. It's just ONE POINT among many. It's NOTHING, and certainly not the beginning of anything. It's not a source of B lines. It's not a sink of them either. Just as many lines ENTER the point as exit it, just like ANY OTHER POINT.
 
Last edited:
This is another manifestation of your delusions about how scientific topics are discussed. The published references you mention have invariably proven to be off topic, counter to your opinions or written by some crackpot.

Which one of those college curriculum citations was written by a "crackpot"? How is it "off topic" or counter to my argument when they all explained that that B lines NO NOT begin, end, have a source or a sink and form as full loops?
 
Last edited:
Which one of those college curriculum citations was written by a "crackpot"? How is it "off topic" or counter to my argument when they all explained that that B lines NO NOT begin, end, have a source or a sink and form as full loops?

Clinger demonstrated that one can construct a scenario where B lines do begin and end. He then explained that the statement about B lines that you are fixated on is usually true and provides a general understanding of the difference between B and E lines, but is not true in every configuration -- as his demonstration clearly shows. Whether you like it or not, the neutral point in his demonstration is a place where B lines begin and end. Posting the same links over and over and repeatedly making the same statements (like the one above) over and over will not change that. His demonstration is consistent with Gauss's law and is a clear counterexample to your B line doctrine. If you want to make a meaningful counter-argument then do so with a mathematical demonstration proving your point. If you can't do that, accept his conclusion and move on. That's how science is done!
 
Behold, you never read my discussion with PS when I said it was probably MORE appropriate to simply say NO lines reach X to begin with, the PRESSURE keeps them from actually crossing.

The magnetic pressure is proportional to the square of the magnetic field strength:

[latex] P_{B} = \frac{B^2}{2 \mu_0}[/latex]

Now, the X-point has zero magnetic field in the examples that we are looking at, and thus at the X-point the magnetic pressure is zero. Also, a quick map of the magnetic pressure will show that the magnetic pressure is decreasing towards the X-point.

In a plasma current sheet, without reconnection, this is best described by the so-called Harris current sheet (E.G. Harris, Nuovo Cimento 23, 1962, 115-121, difficult to find, pdf available from me), where it is shown that in equilibrium the field strength has a tanh(z/L) shape etc. and it works perfect for the Earth's magnetotail or for current sheets in reconnection experiments by Yamada.

But the idea that the field lines cannot get to the Xpoint because of magnetic pressure is laughable.
 
You keep handwaving about the fact that Guass's law is satisfied in the NULL. So what? That same law is satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in the NULL. The same number of lines that enter ANY region, exit that same region. That is fundamental TRUTH of basic EM theory.

Once again, as I never claimed it was "just in the NULL", the "handwaving" and obviously futile strawman are still simply just yours (maybe you should have had a different entrée as the dinner doesn't seem to have helped you much).

Though as noted by Tim Thompson before, you agree, and explicitly state above, that "Guass's law is satisfied in the NULL".


Your RELIGION is MONOPOLISM. Clinger's maths are meaningless in OUR universe because monopoles do not exist, so B lines have no source and no beginning. They have no sink and no ending either. They are continuous loops, continuous rings, continuous PERIOD.

Certainly not my "RELIGION", you're the only one I've seen here insisting on monopoles for magnetic reconnection. So much like the "handwaving" and strawman above this purported " RELIGION" is simply yours. Trying to ascribe to others simply the positions you would like them to have is entirely dishonest on your part.

I've provided a DOZEN published references that all say you're wrong. You don't even seem to have a CLEAR definition of how you might try to differentiate between ordinary processes, such as magnetic flux changes, from what you're calling "reconnection".

Once again it is the reconnection of magnetic fields that differentiates between them.

The only HANDWAVE provided is NOT peer reviewed. It's NOT published. It GARBAGE in the first place! One CANNOT treat a B field as an E field in THIS UNIVERSE. In your monopolistic world to come perhaps, but in this universe, FORGETABOUTIT.

Again this purported "monopolistic world" is expressly just yours. If you don't like it perhaps you should just abandon it instead of simply trying to pawn it off onto others.


Unless and until one of you pulls a monopole out of your pocket, Clinger use of vectors is POINTLESS at a POINT. Gauss's laws are not just satisfied at THAT point alone, they are satisfied EVERYWHERE!

Attempting to combine your own "monopolistic world" with your obviously futile strawman and expecting others to conform to them again only exemplifies your dishonestly (perhaps you need some more quality time with the wife).

"Clinger use of vectors is POINTLESS at a POINT"? Well thank you at least for confirming the conclusion I couldn't escape before that you simply just don't understand vectors in general let alone a vector field.

You've still got a very long way to go Michael Mozina before you can demonstrate you have the ability to just understand the topics you want to discuss. Attempting to substitute your own "monopolistic world" and obviously futile strawman for the positions of others in such a discussion not only demonstrates your lack of understanding but also exemplifies your dishonest approach to such a discussion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom