Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
///I've presented *OVERWHELMING* evidence that it occurs, and electrical discharges occur in flares, starting with the work of Dungey.


If that were true, you wouldn't have been banned from BAUT...

It's not me that's acting "stupid" in the first place.

Um...excuse me...Iron coating around the Sun??????

That's just another example of your emotional need to villianize anyone that doesn't agree with your views.

Right...it's all MY problem...it couldn't possibly be that you have no evidence...of course not.

Sheesh...

I provided you with PUBLISHED SUPPORT of my claims.

Again you make false claims...if your ideas had merit, you should be able to convince others, yet you were banned from BAUT because of a lack of evidence.



My conclusion....there is either something "wrong" with the BAUT board, or there is something "wrong" with your evidence.

Guess which is the most likely?....
 
Which posting history is that?

You don't really want me to embarrass you by posting your posts from BAUT...do you? You were given ample time to prove yourself correct, yet you just couldn't do it.

I've never claimed to have NEVER made any mistakes.

If you are willing to admit that the whole "iron coating around the Sun" idea is nonsense, then I'll drop out of this thread right now....(it's a good "deal"...you ought to take it).
 
I realize that you don't believe me, but I don't understand how (or if) you differentiate between *ORDINARY MAGNETIC FLUX CHANGES* due to the movements of the magnets, and what you are calling 'magnetic reconnection'. The field topology changes alright, but it's just a "bending and twisting" of the lines that takes place. Nothing needs to 'reconnect' to explain the behaviors you're attempting to explain with two refrigerator magnets.

I realize (as most others here do) that it has already been explained to you, which is why I (and most others here) don't believe you. Again magnetic reconnection is s specific type of "MAGNETIC FLUX CHANGES" involving the, well, reconnection of magnetic fields. What exactly about that are you finding (or would you simply like us to believe you are finding) so difficult to understand?

Get a compass and a bar magnet. When the magnet is far enough from the compass the compass points to the magnetic north of the Earth. Magnetic regions of compass and the Earth are connected to such an extent as to determine the direction the compass points. As you bring the north end of the bar magnet closer to the compass at some point the compass will point to the magnet instead of the Earths magnetic north. Magnetic regions of the compass and the bar magnet are now connected to such an extent that the magnet now determines where the compass points. The compass having been primarily connected to the magnetic field of the Earth has now reconnected primarily to the magnetic field of the bar magnet, it's just that simple. Please explain by "just a "bending and twisting" of the lines" how the compass changes orientation from the Earth to the bar magnet to support your claim above?

Surely if this "reconnection" process is so prevalent, so 'simple' to achieve in a freshman experiment, there MUST BE some published papers/books describing this process, just as there are MANY books describing the fact that magnetic lines do not begin or end, have a source or a sink. Can you find me a legitimate published reference to support your claim?


Most published papers and books as well as experiments you can do yourself support such claims. Please provide any published papers/books describing the reorientation of a compass as described above by "just a "bending and twisting" of the lines" to support your claim above? What magnetic field vector(s) is(are) your 'magnetic line(s)' tangent to at a null point?

I've provided a dozen or so that claim that magnetic lines form as a full, continuous circle/loop.

Evidently you still just don't understand why such a claim is made. Again, do some basic experiments yourself. Many here have learned not only through instruction of theory and by understanding the relevant math, but we have also reproduced in hands on experimentation much of the fundamental research that resulted in those theories and math.
 
If that were true, you wouldn't have been banned from BAUT...

I don't even know how much *I* even knew or had read yet *WAY BACK THEN*! I don't even recall discussing Dungey's work there in fact.

Um...excuse me...Iron coating around the Sun??????

The "electrical discharge" debate isn't predicated upon that issue is it? When did I ever use the term "iron coating"?

Right...it's all MY problem...it couldn't possibly be that you have no evidence...of course not.

Well, I'd grant you that the evidence for a solid crust is limited, but in terms of the electrical discharges in the solar atmosphere and Alfven's coronal loop theories, there is *PLENTY* of evidence.

Again you make false claims...if your ideas had merit, you should be able to convince others, yet you were banned from BAUT because of a lack of evidence.

Nah. They just can't handle the truth. :) They have to "control" it. :)

My conclusion....there is either something "wrong" with the BAUT board, or there is something "wrong" with your evidence.

I'd be the first to admit that I've learned a lot since then. On the other hand I've never seen a more repressive message board on the web, and I've visited some fundy religious websites in my day. Anyplace you CAN"T DISCUSS SPECIFIC topics seems pretty ridiculous from my perspective.

To their credit, this website is MUCH better moderated, and MUCH more liberal in terms of free speech. I'm free (and so is Clinger) to make an utter fool of myself, and keep doing so if I like. :) You gotta appreciate that about JREF.

Guess which is the most likely?....

Guess which one CLOSES topics of conversation like any good cult?
 
I realize (as most others here do) that it has already been explained to you, which is why I (and most others here) don't believe you. Again magnetic reconnection is s specific type of "MAGNETIC FLUX CHANGES" involving the, well, reconnection of magnetic fields. What exactly about that are you finding (or would you simply like us to believe you are finding) so difficult to understand?

I find it difficult to understand why Clinger believes that B lines begin in Origin the Null *WITHOUT* even a monopole or plasma particle to his name. That's basically it.

I also find it difficult to understand how (or if) YOU PERSONALLY differentiate between ordinary flux changes over time (reconfiguration of full lines), and "reconnection'.
 
You don't really want me to embarrass you by posting your posts from BAUT...do you? You were given ample time to prove yourself correct, yet you just couldn't do it.

FYI, I'm absolutely not embarrassed by my learning processes, even if you did manage to find something that is kinda embarrassing from my perspective today. It's no sin to make mistakes, admit them and move on. IMO it's pretty damn embarrassing that you hold up BAUT as some sort of "bastion of truth". It's just A website, and a rather draconian one at that.

If you are willing to admit that the whole "iron coating around the Sun" idea is nonsense, then I'll drop out of this thread right now....(it's a good "deal"...you ought to take it).

I don't even know what you mean by "iron coating around the sun" in the first place. Do you mean do I still believe it has a CRUST under the surface of the photosphere? Sorry, but I do. You'll just have to keep ragging on me I suppose. :)
 
Last edited:
Been there, done that for a year now. 0+0=0 and NOTHING begins there.

1 + -1 = 0, 2 + -2 =0, 3 + -3 =0, 1 + 5 + - 2 + -4 =0 (and so forth) as well, perhaps you should begin there (evidently you've got a long way to go)? The implication would seem to be that you simply do not understand vector addition or for some entirely bizarre reason think the vector contributions to a null point must all and always be, well, 0. Since you do seem to at least agree that the resulting field vector at that point is "0" just how do you draw a field line tangent to no vector?
 
I find it difficult to understand why Clinger believes that B lines begin in Origin the Null *WITHOUT* even a monopole or plasma particle to his name. That's basically it.

Neither is required for magnetic reconection, "That's basically it". Not as difficult to understand as you would simply want others to believe. The fact of the matter is that you simply don't want to believe or accurately represent what W.D.Clinger actually claimed. Just as many "B lines" " begin in Origin the Null" as end there, that's what makes it consistent with Gauss's law. Your dishonesty is showing through again Michael Mozina


I also find it difficult to understand how (or if) YOU PERSONALLY differentiate between ordinary flux changes over time (reconfiguration of full lines), and "reconnection'.

Once again magnetic reconnection is just a particular type of "flux changes over time" as already explained to you multiple times. Agian not that difficult to understand. There's that dishonesty of yours again Michael Mozina. Do "YOU PERSONALLY" differentiate between" poodles and "ordinary" dogs?
 
Neither is required for magnetic reconection, "That's basically it". Not as difficult to understand as you would simply want others to believe. The fact of the matter is that you simply don't want to believe or accurately represent what W.D.Clinger actually claimed. Just as many "B lines" " begin in Origin the Null" as end there, that's what makes it consistent with Gauss's law. Your dishonesty is showing through again Michael Mozina
How could this be stated more clearly? If there is any chance for a breakthrough here, this is it! Let's see what responses you get to this easily accessible explanation. There are no monopoles!


Once again magnetic reconnection is just a particular type of "flux changes over time" as already explained to you multiple times. Agian not that difficult to understand. There's that dishonesty of yours again Michael Mozina. Do "YOU PERSONALLY" differentiate between" poodles and "ordinary" dogs?
This has been said and clearly demonstrated here -- ad nauseum. :confused:
 
Last edited:
IMO it's pretty damn embarrassing that you hold up BAUT as some sort of "bastion of truth". It's just A website...

A website where you are not allowed to post because you can't provide credible evidence for your ideas...now that is embarrassing.

...and a rather draconian one at that.

BAUT demands evidence from those who propose extraordinary ideas...why couldn't you "measure up" to that?

I don't even know what you mean by "iron coating around the sun" in the first place.

My error...can hardly be blamed for not keeping track of all the outrageous ideas on these boards.

Do you mean do I still believe it has a CRUST under the surface of the photosphere? Sorry, but I do.

...and that is all you have...belief...

Why not "act" like a real scientist and provide convincing evidence?

You'll just have to keep ragging on me I suppose. :)

Naw...not so much (but you should have taken the "deal")...I'll just keep reminding everyone that you have no credible evidence, nor are you even looking for such...

That's really all it takes to demonstrate to others that you are wrong...just steady reminders...
 
Neither is required for magnetic reconection, "That's basically it". Not as difficult to understand as you would simply want others to believe. The fact of the matter is that you simply don't want to believe or accurately represent what W.D.Clinger actually claimed. Just as many "B lines" " begin in Origin the Null" as end there, that's what makes it consistent with Gauss's law. Your dishonesty is showing through again Michael Mozina

NOTHING BEGINS OR ENDS THERE! Your dishonesty is showing. Just as many LINES EXIT there as ENTER there, but none of them BEGIN there! OMG. Gauss's law is satisfied EVERYWHERE, not JUST IN THE NULL. A B line HAS NO SOURCE OR SINK, so it can't "begin" or "end" anywhere. They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.

It's not clear AT ALL that you're even prepared to DIFFERENTIATE between ORDINARY FLUX CHANGES OVER TIME, and anything "special' we might call "reconnection".
 
Last edited:
A website where you are not allowed to post because you can't provide credible evidence for your ideas...now that is embarrassing.

Nah. A draconian website, that is supposedly devoted to science, where NOBODY can discuss topics that are "officially closed" for discussion, now THAT is embarrassing. I've seen less restrictive cults. It's lovely how one can discuss 'mainstream" topic without being put through an "inquisition", but God forbid anyone should speak heresy there. I'm certainly not the only witch that was burned at the stake at BAUT. I definitely wasn't the last.

BAUT demands evidence from those who propose extraordinary ideas...why couldn't you "measure up" to that?

Ya, but when I went back as ManInTheMirror and used their own rules against them, they didn't measure up either, so they changed the rules of the board just so nobody could discuss it anymore. :)

My error...can hardly be blamed for not keeping track of all the outrageous ideas on these boards.

It's Friday. I'll let you slide.


..and that is all you have...belief...

Ya, and satellite images galore to back it up.

Why not "act" like a real scientist and provide convincing evidence?

What might suffice? Keep in mind I have several projects I'm working on based on SDO images. I'm certainly not "done" collecting evidence if that is what you are trying to insinuate.

Naw...not so much (but you should have taken the "deal")...I'll just keep reminding everyone that you have no credible evidence, nor are you even looking for such...

No, that's not true. I am looking for such, pretty much on a daily basis. The more of those "deflecting shock waves" like we saw awhile back that occur while SDO can see them, the more evidence I'll have. It's not JUST up to me. ;)

That's really all it takes to demonstrate to others that you are wrong...just steady reminders...

No, that's just a mainstreamers way of trying to write off EVERYTHING based on SOME issues that remain to be demonstrated. Whether or not the sun has a solid surface, it *DEFINITELY* experiences electrical discharges in the solar atmosphere. The EVIDENCE IS OVERWHELMING. Only the most hard core denialist/hater could ignore it, and of course some do.
 
Last edited:
NOTHING BEGINS OR ENDS THERE! Your dishonesty is showing. Just as many LINES EXIT there as ENTER there, but none of them BEGIN there! OMG. A B line HAS NO SOURCE OR SINK, so it can't "begin" or "end" anywhere. They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.

"pass through the NULL with a zero field strength"? At least you are apparently claiming no field at the null point. So your apparently magical "zero field strength" magnetic field lines "pass through the NULL" point by never being at the null point? In what direction do your field lines " pass through the NULL with a zero field strength"? Given the number of field lines is proportional to the field strength, just how many of your field lines represent your "zero field strength" at that null point? "You've claimed they "EXIT" and "ENTER" yet have " zero field strength" at that point so your are claiming they 'BEGIN' and 'END' "THERE". Seems the only problem is that you're just as dishonest with yourself as your apparently are with everyone else. You certainly seem to be getting closer but there is just some serious disconnect that apparently simply wont allow you to admit to yourself what you're already claiming. For some reason you seem to want to claim that there are field lines that represent the magnitude and direction of magnetic field at a point where you claim there is "zero field strength". I sincerely hope you can eventually work through it, but in the end it's entirely up to you.


When you're driving your car it has some velocity (a vector with magnitude and direction). When your car is parked it has no velocity (relative to the ground). When you drive up and park in your driveway we can represent this a series of vectors at different points. Just as we can when you pull out of your driveway. However, when parked in your driveway your car has no velocity vector just as a null point has no magnetic field vector (that's what makes it a null point). Based on your assertions above you seem to be claiming that your driving never "BEGINS OR ENDS" where you park your car. A rather peculiar position to take. I can not escape the conclusion that a lot of your misunderstanding stems from a lack of understanding that the field lines represent the field vectors and an apparently profound lack of understanding of just vectors in general.

It's not clear AT ALL that you're even prepared to DIFFERENTIATE between ORDINARY FLUX CHANGES OVER TIME, and anything "special' we might call "reconnection".


"prepared to DIFFERENTIATE between ORDINARY FLUX CHANGES OVER TIME, and anything "special' we might call "reconnection"? The reconnection of magnetic fields is what "DIFFERENTIATE"s it from " ORDINARY FLUX CHANGES OVER TIME". Whenever you're prepared to acknowledge what you've already been told countless times (and are telling yourself above), you be sure to let us know.
 
I"m headed to dinner now with my wife The Man. Your argument is flawed because Gauss's laws are satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in a LOW energy magnetic field region, or a NULL. All lines are directional. All lines ENTER and EXIT various areas, including lower energy areas and Origin the NULL. No lines BEGIN ANYWHERE. They all form as CLOSED LOOPS due to the FLOW OF CURRENT.

Clinger's maths only apply to MONOPOLISM in a MONOPOLISTIC UNIVERSE. I guess you guys are MONOPOLISTS by 'religion'? "All hail Origin the Null, the all powerful beginor of all the B lines in the magnetic monopolistic universe!" :)
 
Last edited:
Magnetic field lines end at null points VI

Gauss's law is satisfied EVERYWHERE, not JUST IN THE NULL


So, Mozina appears to agree that the null point satisfies Gauss's Law. So far so good. But now comes the real howler ...

A B line HAS NO SOURCE OR SINK, so it can't "begin" or "end" anywhere. They simply pass through the NULL with a zero field strength.


This is so amazingly wrong that the mind boggles. Behold ...

Preface: What is a "Field Line"?

Magnetic field lines are mathematical devices for describing and analyzing magnetic fields. They are not physically real objects. I have pointed this out before.

From 26 January 2010
I want to take another crack at the concept of field lines. One of the complaints leveled at the idea of magnetic reconnection is that the field lines are not physically real, which I think is an irrelevant point. So it does not hurt to consider for a moment exactly what a "field line" is supposed to be in some detail.

What is a "field line"?

"In electric and magnetic phenomena, the magnitude and direction of the resultant force at any point is the main subject of investigation. Suppose that the direction of the force at any point is known, then, if we draw a line so that in every part of its course it coincides with the direction of the force at that point, this line may be called a line of force, since it indicates the direction of the force in every part of its course.By drawing a sufficient number of lines of force, we may indicate the direction of the force in every part of the space in which it acts.
Thus if we strew iron filings on paper near a magnet, each filing will be magnetized by induction, and the consecutive filings will unite by their opposite poles, so as to form fibres, and those fibres will indicate the direction of the lines of force. The beautiful illustration of the presence of magnetic force afforded by this experiment, naturally tends to make us think of the lines of force as something real, and as indicating something more than the mere resultant of two forces, whose seat of action is at a distance, and which do not exist there at all until a magnet is placed in that part of the field. We are dissatisfied with the explanation founded on the hypothesis of attractive and repellant forces directed towards the magnetic poles, even though we may have satisfied ourselves that the phenomenon is in strict accordance with that hypothesis, and we cannot help thinking that in every place where we find these lines of force, some physical state or action must exist in sufficient energy to produce the actual phenomena."

From the paper "On Physical Lines of Force" by James Clerk Maxwell, originally published in The Philosophical Magazine, vol. XXI (1861)
See The Scientific Papers of James Clark Maxwell, volume I; Dover publications, 2003, pages 451-452 (a republication of the 1965 Dover reprint of the original, published in 1890 by Cambridge University Press). Emphasis in the quote is from the original.
​
The concept for "lines of magnetic force" comes from Michael Faraday and was adopted by Maxwell (see On Faraday's Lines of Force; page 155 in the same volume I of Maxwell's collected papers; read Dec 10, 1855 and Feb 11, 1856). He later generalized the concept and used it to literally invent the theory of electromagnetic fields, and really the general topic of field theory (see A Dynamical Theory of the Electromagnetic Field; page 526 in the same volume I of Maxwell's collected papers; read Dec 8, 1864; and see the subsection On Lines of Magnetic Force, page 551 and On Magnetic Equipotential Surfaces, page 553). In the passage above, where Maxwell begins "We are dissatisfied ...", he is expressing his dissatisfaction with the notion of "action at a distance" (an idea Newton did not like either), and his belief that some "physical state or action" must permeate the space around the magnet. That "physical state or action" of 1861 became Maxwell's electromagnetic field of 1864.


Just in case Maxwell is not good enough, here is another, more recent definition for a field line:

"If we join end-to-end infinitesimal vectors representing E, we get a curve in space - called a line of force - that is everywhere normal to the equipotential surfaces. The vector E is everywhere tangent to a line of forces"
​
From Electromagnetic Fields and Waves, Lorrain & Corson, W.H. Freeman & Co., 1970 (2nd edition), page 46 [this was my undergrad textbook]. This definition for an electric field line works just fine for a magnetic field, just replace E with B and you have the definition for a magnetic field line; the definition is general, so just substitute your favorite letter for your favorite field and you've got it.

By now it should be obvious that the field line cannot exist unless the vector that defines the field line exists. This is a crucial point as we shall see.


I repeat: the field line cannot exist unless the vector that defines the field line exists. This is a logically necessary consequence of the definition of a field line of force. The definitions provided by Maxwell himself, or by Lorrain & Corson, are equivalent and both absolutely require that the field line cannot exist where the vector does not exist. At a null point the vector does not exist, and therefore the field line of force cannot exist. This should all be made obvious by the question asked by The Man: In what direction do your field lines "pass through the NULL with a zero field strength?" Vectors have both magnitude and direction. So how does one unambiguously determine the direction for a vector of zero magnitude?

Mozina's feeble attempt at "pass through the NULL with a zero field strength" is thoroughly destroyed by the definition of a line of force. All of those field lines which Mozina claims are "passing through the null" must actually end at the null. The physics is inescapable and Mozina's argument is nullified by the physics of nulls.
 
I"m headed to dinner now with my wife The Man. Your argument is flawed because Gauss's laws are satisfied EVERYWHERE, not just in a LOW energy magnetic field region, or a NULL. All lines are directional. All lines ENTER and EXIT various areas, including lower energy areas and Origin the NULL. No lines BEGIN ANYWHERE. They all form as CLOSED LOOPS due to the FLOW OF CURRENT.

Clinger's maths only apply to MONOPOLISM in a MONOPOLISTIC UNIVERSE. I guess you guys are MONOPOLISTS by 'religion'? "All hail Origin the Null, the all powerful beginor of all the B lines in the magnetic monopolistic universe!" :)


Well let's hope a good meal and a little quality time with the wife increases your mental acuity. Because with the above post as an indication, you surely do need it.

"just in a LOW energy magnetic field region, or a NULL."? Well since I never made any such "argument" your strawman is obvious and futile. As are your continued attempts to characterize others as religious zealots. It's time for a new shtick Michael Mozina, take your time, digest your meal, reflect on the quality time with your wife and get back to us when you feel up to putting at least some effort into your response.
 
An illiterate adult cannot simply be told about the workings of the alphabet, spelling rules and be expected to read. Leaning to read involves a step by step process that takes years.

Learning any discipline is a process of building on prior knowledge and skills. One cannot learn how to play golf without first learning how to swing a golf club, how to chip, how to putt, club selection, sand shots, and more. This should be trivially obvious to anyone attempting to gain skill in any activity like golf. One does not simply go out one day a decide to play golf without some effort made at developing the fundamental skills.

This is certainly true of academic disciplines like the sciences. Understanding some discipline like EM theory and, more specifically, the discussions in this thread involves a step by step process including a good deal of mathematics and grasping fundamental concepts like Maxwell's equations. There is an enormous difference between knowing about Maxwell's equations and understanding Maxwell's equations.

This is the root of Mozina's problem! He is a poster boy for the The Dunning– Kruger effect. Somehow and for some inexplicable reason he has decided he can just jump in and "play golf" in this area. These pathetic misinterpretations of all the *PAPERS* he reads are the obvious consequences.

I can use myself as an example. I earned a masters degree in mathematics, minored in physics, and (before going to college) worked in electronics for six years (as a result of military training). Yet, because I do not have a good fundamental grounding in EM theory, I need some help in grasping some of the consequences of Maxwell's equations and the discussions here.

I doubt if Mozina's education even matches mine in this area, yet he believes he has the inside track on EM theory and he has outsmarted tens of thousands of professionals with decades of training and research. Sometimes it's more important for one to know what one does not know than knowing what one knows. Unfortunately, the fact hat he is engaging many knowledgeable people in this thread and actually has deluded himself that he is winning the debate enables him to further confirm his fantasy that he has superior understanding and has outwitted the professionals.

It's hopeless and it's quite sad!
 
Last edited:
An illiterate adult cannot simply be told about the workings of the alphabet, spelling rules and be expected to read. Leaning to read involves a step by step process that takes years.

Learning any discipline is a process of building on prior knowledge and skills. One cannot learn how to play golf without first learning how to swing a golf club, how to chip, how to putt, club selection, sand shots, and more. This should be trivially obvious to anyone attempting to gain skill in any activity like golf. One does not simply go out one day a decide to play golf without some effort made at developing the fundamental skills.

.....

I can use myself as an example. I earned a masters degree in mathematics, minored in physics, and (before going to college) worked in electronics for six years (as a result of military training). Yet, because I do not have a good fundamental grounding in EM theory, I need some help in grasping some of the consequences of Maxwell's equations and the discussions here.

I've been involved in online discussions now on various websites, covering a LARGE volume of topics, for more than a decade. In all that time, I've never seen a topic argued *ENTIRELY* upon attacking the individual as you and other EU haters do on a REGULAR BASIS.

When we look at your statements, you ADMIT that YOU PERSONALLY never had a good fundamental grounding in EM theory. On the other hand, I personally applied that THEORY to in field repair processes for over 15 years doing repair work on security equipment. My foundation was strong, and I utilized that knowledge in the field for MANY YEARS.

I also built upon that strong foundation by continuing my education and reading a NUMBER of books on plasma physics, from a VARIETY of various authors. It was actually an "expensive" process by the way since each of those five books costs over $100 retail.

You on the other hand admit that you did NOT have a strong foundation, and you've never read a single book on plasma physics. You evidently have to beg, borrow and steal whatever you do understand from a guy that *STILL* treats B fields as E fields! OMG.

Attack me all you like. Creationists toughened my skin LONG before I met you haters. They argued just like you guys do. They do NOT provided PUBLISHED, or PEER REVIEWED works to support their views. They HANDWAVE like you do. You handwaved some pretty pictures at me because evidently you can't tell FLUX CHANGES from turnips.

Clinger handwaves a little math that he personally seems to think is the "be all-end-all" of mathematics, when in fact it's BASIC STUFF. It amounts to exactly 0+0=0 in a vacuum. PERIOD. That CONCLUSIVELY DEMONSTRATES THAT NOTHING could reconnect there. NOTHING could begin there. NOTHING could end there.

You don't even understand the basics. You refuse to continue investing in your education, and therefore you are personally reduced to attacking individuals that chose a path of EDUCATION and already had a better foundation than you did. How sad for you.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom