Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
This use of "pseudoscience" is just an example of Michael Mozina's inability to understand what Alfvén was actually talking about in his speech at the 1986 workshop on double layers.
Alfvén strongly stresses the danger of using the frozen-in concept (not MR)

The context implies that the 'pseudo-science' that Alfvén is using is not 'pseudoscience'!
It is any science that uses 'pseudo-plasma', i.e. plasma with frozen-in magnetic fields.

Alfven's double layer paper is *LIGHT YEARS* less confusing than 'reconnection' theory. You folks STILL think B field lines can begin and end in the absence of a monopole. You STILL believe that the rate of 'reconnection' is somehow detached from "current" through the NULL, but without it, equations 16, 17 and the total "reconnection" becomes "ZERO"!

The "reconnection" process is not, and never will be "plasma/current optional". Get real. Unless one of you has a monopole up your sleeve, FOREGETABOUTIT!

Aflven was right in the sense that it's "pseudo" correct, and therefore "pseudo-science". You're still all confused as hell because you still think "reconnection" is current optional, even though I've pointed out the equation in Priests paper that demonstrates that to be FALSE!
 
Last edited:
...complete lies and nothing but lies.


Tim seems to have done a fair job of exposing the actual source of the lies.

I've lost count not how many times I've asked you to meet me in the middle and call it 'current reconnection'.


There is no rational reason to refer to magnetic reconnection by any other term. Science isn't about negotiating a desired but unsupportable explanation into existence by demanding that everyone use some alternative terminology.

Priest demonstrated *CONCLUSIVELY* that CURRENT gets turned into "magnetic charge" between equations 16&17 in his source/sink paper. The whole 'reconnection' process requires current, otherwise equation 17 nets to ZIP/0/NADDA/NOTHING, and NOTHING reconnects.

Dance around the issue all you like but unless one of you folks has a monopole in your pocket, there is no "B LINE" reconnection going on in a vacuum. I do not deny that the *ELECTRICAL DISCHARGE* process is a REAL physical process, it simply REQUIRES plasma, and REQUIRES currents. No current, equation 17 nets to zero and you've got NOTHING in terms of 'reconnection'.


It still looks like a dishonest equivocation is being made between the terms "magnetic reconnection" and "electrical discharge". Nobody in this discussion is using those terms synonymously, so it's a non sequitur to complain that an explanation of magnetic reconnection fails to demonstrate an electrical discharge.
 
Hardly the same thing. They guy has spent YEARS professing to be some sort of expert on this topic, yet he's never read a single textbook on the subject.
You are lying. I have never said that I am an expert on plasma physics.
My expertise is in solid state physics (and fairly outdated!).

Not that makes a difference:
tusenfem is an expert on plasma physics and you ignore what he says about plasma physics.
Tim Thompson has displayed a good knowledge of plasma physics and you ignore what he says.
Somov is an expert on plasma physics and you cannot understand the simple fact that he describes MR in vacuum (Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section)
Demoulin & Priest are experts in plasma physics and you are deluded about their paper (Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!)
Priest & Forbes are experts in plasma physics and you cannot understand their introduction where they state why MR is considered the cause of solar flares.
Anthony Peratt is an expert in plasma physics and you cannot understand him (Michael Mozina's fantasy about Anthony Peratt's definition of electrical discharge!).
Dungey was an expert on plasma physics and you cannot understand that his term for large current density is obsolete (Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma).
L. VAN DRIEL-GESZTELYI is an expert on plasma physic s and you are ignoring his review of Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003.

These are just citations in this thread. You are also ignoring every plasma physics expert in the world who has published anything on MR :jaw-dropp.
 
Tim seems to have done a fair job of exposing the actual source of the lies.

No, Tim has just consistently avoided meeting me in the middle and accepting the fact that the process isn't "plasma/current optional" as demonstrated in Priests equation 16&17.

The only one "equivocating" here is you. You're still on the denial-go-round that electrical discharges occur in plasma, even though that is EXACTLY what *DUNGEY'S* paper describes. You folks want to LEAVE OUT the single most important feature of the process, *AND THE PLASMA* and still call it "reconnection". NOTHING happens in a vacuum, but magnetic flux changes over time, and NOTHING reconnects at equations 17.
 
You are lying. I have never said that I am an expert on plasma physics.

You're only lying to yourself RC, starting with you belief that electrical discharges cannot occur in plasma. Round and round you go on that hate-go-round, for YEARS now, and never once have you read a book on plasma physics. :(
 
Tim, the part that is "pseudoscience" is your (collective) belief that the "reconnection" process involves B LINE reconnection. It doesn't. Equation 16&17 relate to CURRENT, not MONOPOLES. B field *LINE* reconnection is pure PSEUDOSCIENCE unless you have a monopole in your pocket. Do you?
 
Last edited:
In case you haven't figured it out, it doesn't matter how many times you call me a liar. Your opinions are meaningless to me. It's clear from our conversations and your repeated statements over the years about your lack of any kind of effort in this topic, that you simply do not know what you're talking about.
In case you haven't figured it out: MM: Try to get it right for once - I pity you, not hate you.
It is obvious that the science is meaningless to you, e.g. MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.

And yes you are lying again :jaw-dropp!
I have made efforts to increase my knowledge of this topic. I have read many papers on MR and solar physics and are confident that I understand most of them because
  • I have a good knowledge of physics.
  • The more knowledgeable posters have not often corrected me.
And then there is you and your persistent displays of ignorance and inability to understand the corrections of the other posters. You have not been able to learn anything, not even high school science - Michael Mozina's ignorance of high school science (the right hand rule).
 
BZZT. He doesn't say anything about B *LINE* reconnection.
...snipped idoicy about E fileds and an nonexistent equation in Somov's book)
BZZT. Learn to read:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section
Reconnection in vacuum is a real physical process: magnetic field lines move to the X-type neutral point and reconnect in it as well as
| the electric field is induced and can accelerate a charge particle or
| particles in the vicinity of the neutral point.
(emphasis added)
followed by the induction of an electric field and that this field can accelerate charged particles.

Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!
 
BZZT. Learn to read:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section

(emphasis added)
followed by the induction of an electric field and that this field can accelerate charged particles.

Yes, I know he has charged particles in his "vacuum" RC, otherwise "reconnection" and charged particle acceleration doesn't happen. Equation 17 is zero without some charged particles. Unlike you, I've also read AN ENTIRE BOOK by Somov, including chapter 16 where he relates it all back to Alfven's views. But you wouldn't know anything about that, since your knowledge is limited to a nifty quote mine here and there and devoid of any actual (plasma) physics.
 
Last edited:
Alfven's double layer paper is *LIGHT YEARS* less confusing than 'reconnection' theory.
That is rather dumb - you thinking that MR is confusiing makes it invalid :jaw-dropp!
Acually MR is quite clear if you have the background to understand it


You folks STILL think B field lines can begin and end in the absence of a monopole.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.


You STILL believe that the rate of 'reconnection' is somehow detached from "current" through the NULL, but without it, equations 16, 17 and the total "reconnection" becomes "ZERO"!
Gibberish but maybe
Michael Mozina's delusion about "*RECONNECTIONS* per unit length" combined with
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!

The "reconnection" process is not, and never will be "plasma/current optional".
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section

Aflven was right in the sense that it's "pseudo" correct, and therefore "pseudo-science". You're still all confused as hell because you still think "reconnection" is current optional, even though I've pointed out the equation in Priests paper that demonstrates that to be FALSE!
Alfvén strongly stresses the danger of using the frozen-in concept (not MR)
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!
 
Yes, I know he has charged particles in his "vacuum" RC, otherwise "reconnection" and charged particle acceleration doesn't happen.
Still deluded: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section
He described MR in a vacuum then mentions that the induced E filed can accelerate any charged particles (obviously not a vacuum!).
and that equation 17 obsession raises its ugly head once again:
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!
 
Last edited:
That is rather dumb - you thinking that MR is confusiing makes it invalid :jaw-dropp!

It makes the conversion at equation 17 *UNNECESSARY* for starters. ;)

Acually MR is quite clear if you have the background to understand it

True, but then none of you have such a background or your wouldn't be claiming that actual B field lines "reconnect" in a vacuum without a monopole between you. :) No surprise. None of the four of you real EU haters even owns a book on plasma physics, let alone have read one. No wonder you're all confused as hell and think equation 17 is going to be anything other than ZERO in a vacuum.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina said:
Clinger is correct, Mozina is wrong.

IMO, it's highly disappointing you chose "hate" over science Tim. :(

It's not hate. It's science. If Clinger's result can be replicated by someone else, he's right. It has nothing to do with Clinger at all, and everything to do with what we can argee upon observing. It's not Tim's fault you insist on your incorrect understanding of physics being what is real.
 
It's not hate. It's science. If Clinger's result can be replicated by someone else, he's right.

Clinger's "result" involved a HUGE, GIGANTIC, GLARING, STUPENDOUS bait and switch at the end involving PLASMA, after he promised to replicate Dungey's reconnection process WITHOUT plasma. That's hate and bait and switch, not science.

I even pointed out the SCIENCE in equations 16&17 that makes it PHYSICALLY IMPOSSIBLE for "reconnection" to occur without plasma and without current. Those folks don't care one iota about science. It's all about a hate-go-round with this crew.
 
Last edited:
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper II

It makes the conversion at equation 17 *UNNECESSARY* for starters. ;)
Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper!
The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force-free field
3. Study of the particular case l=0
3.1 Singularity along the negative z-Axis
Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:
Ampere's theorem gives a current along the z-axis of magnitude
[equation 16]
Gauss' theorem applied to a core starting from the origin gives a density for magnetic charges along the z-axis of
[equation 17]
while Gauss' theorem applied to a sphere of radius r gives a total magnetic charge in the volume of radius r of
[equation 18]
The paper is about linear force-free fields - not specifically about MR. The conclusion includes that this multipole expansion of a linear force-free field can be used to understand solar flares.
There is no "conversion" at equation 17. There is the derivation of the density of magnetic charges from a current along the z-axis (the l=0 component of the multipole expansion).

One more time for you MM:
Section 2 is the multipole expansion of a linear force-free field. This has an infinite number of components labeled with l which has values of 0, 1, 2, 3, etc. In a multipole expansion, l=0 is the monopole component (l=1 is the dipole, l=2 is the quadrapole, etc.). For example the CMB power spectrum has monopoles (the l=0 component) :eye-poppi!

Section 3.3 is Demoulin & Priest explicitly proving that there can be no isolated magnetic charges (no actual monopoles) in a linear force-free field.
 
None of the four of you real EU haters even owns a book on plasma physics, let alone have read one.
That is a great big lie, MM :(!
tusenfem works in plasma physics. He has definitely read books on plasma physics. He probably owns several books.
Tim Thompson has displayed a good knowledge of plasma physics and cited books on plasma physics, e.g. Priest & Forbes. He probably owns at least 1 book on plasma physics.
I have read books containing plasma physics but this was 25 years ago so my knowledge is outdated and my memory of it quite vague. I do not own any plasma physics books. That is why I am refreshing my knowledge.
 
That is a great big lie, MM :(!
tusenfem works in plasma physics.

Neither Tim nor tusenfem are true "EU haters" RC. They both provide actual materials to read, and they've read the relevant materials. Whatever differences of agreement we may have are honest differences of agreement. The four official "haters" (the ones that don't own a plasma physics book between you) are you, GM, Clinger, and PS. The rest don't qualify as haters, because the rest have either:

A) read the material in question
B) do not engage in personal attacks

Tim and tusenfem take their shots, but at least I know they've read the material and they've provided useful references.

Now if I can just get either one of them to discuss equations 16 and 17 in Priests source/sink paper. :)
 
MM: Have you read Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003 yet

Neither Tim nor tusenfem are true "EU haters" RC. They both provide actual materials to read, and they've read the relevant materials.
Then you are at least lying about me because I have provided actual materials to read and I have read relevant material (just not the books that you demand that everyone read).

I will remind you that I have read books containing plasma physics.

You are persisting with the hater lie: MM: Try to get it right for once - I pity you, not hate you.

And talking about useful references: Have you rea Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003 yet?

After all if you can demand that I read another book on plasma physics then I can ask that you read a paper listing the evidence for MR on the Sun :D !
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom