Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Last edited:
Yes, only AFTER he cheated and added plasma. Prior to that point, equation 17 was NOTHING.
You reeally need to learn to read W.D. Clinger's posts:
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 5 of 5
Review of parts 1 through 4
...
Starting from Maxwell's equations, we derived the magnetic field that's generated by four conducting rods at the corners of a square. When all four rods carry the same current, with the current running in the same direction for rods that are on the same diagonal of the square but in the opposite direction for rods on the other diagonal, we get a magnetic field B4 that approximates Dungey's figure 1.
...
Reducing the current through the rods in one diagonal to zero while maintaining a constant current through the other rods gives us a much more dramatic example of magnetic reconnection. When current flows through only two parallel rods, and flows in the same direction through each rod, we get a "figure 8" field B2 that reproduces Dungey's figure 2.
...
Historical context
(onto a fuller analysis of Dungey's paper, e.g. that the 'discharge' term he uses seems peculiar to him and Cowling)

Dungey's figures were reproduced before part 5.

There is no equation 17 in part 5.

W.D. Clinger does not strictly introduce plasma (there are no MHD equations in his post). He introduces a plasma current, i.e. a current that should be produced in plasma.

The posts are also contained in his web page - Magnetic Reconnection
Magnetic reconnection refers to the merging and separation of magnetic field lines that can occur at neutral points of magnetic fields as those fields change over time. Alternatively, magnetic reconnection refers to changes over time in the topology of magnetic field lines.
Although magnetic reconnection is a simple consequence ofMaxwell's equations, it is usually discussed in connection with plasma physics. Magnetic reconnection has been observed in space plasma and in laboratory experiments. Magnetic reconnection is now known to be responsible forrapid movements and bursts of light in the aurora borealis, and is believed to be responsible for similar phenomena seen in solar flares. Magnetic reconnection may also play some role in heating the solar corona.
 
FYI, your website is an outright lie. I never claimed "reconnection' didn't occur, I claimed it didn't occur in a vacuum and I claimed it requires CURRENT. You're not only a liar, you're a first class fraud.
FYI: Your claim that MR does not happen in a vacuum is wrong to say the least (Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section).

And then there is the hypocrisy of claiming that MR happens in plasma when the definition of MR is breaking and reconnecting magnetic field lines and you claim that cannot happen :jaw-dropp!

Most of Deniers of Magnetic Reconnection is a list of the ignorance that you have displayed in the past and that still seem to retain:
  • the confusion between electromagnetic induction and permeability;
  • that magnetic fields contain kinetic energy;
  • the insistance that because you cannot understand the math that is posted (eventhouh other rposters can) that these posts are "handwaving";
  • denial of all of the published references and experimental results;
  • does not know what magnetic flux is;
  • cites books full of reconnecting magnetic field lines;
  • ignorance of the shapes of basic magnteci fields (those around wires);
  • the inability to tell EM theory (magnetic fields, field lines, and separatrices) from plasma theory;
  • your inability to 'bark math' and yet all these posts containing math are wrong because you say they are wrong (can you spell Dunning-Kruger effect ?);
 
You reeally need to learn to read W.D. Clinger's posts:

I already read all the lies he posted about me on his website. There are no extremes that haters will not go to in an effort to misrepresent EU theory. I never DENIED "reconnection" is a real process. That's another of his MANY lies, including his LIE about being able to demonstrate "magnetic reconnection" *WITHOUT* plasma. Lies, lies, and more damn lies.
 
It is a BLATANT LIE that I "deny" the reconnection PROCESS is real. If you two won't be honest about me and my opinions on this topic, and you'll go to an OUTRAGEOUS EXTREME of putting those lies on a website, there's pretty much nothing you won't do to get a hate fix.
 
Mozina disproved in one easy lesson

Mozina disproved in one easy lesson

The X point with zero magnetic field strength where two field lines cross can indeed be assumed to be the end and the beginning of a field line and note that that comes together begin and end, so that in the end there is continuity.
It can be "assumed" only *INCORRECTLY*! Literally *NOTHING*, no single field line "begins" or "ends" at X. It simply "passes through" X with NOTHING in it's pocket. PERIOD.


This explanation of Mozina's is of course quite impossible, As I have already proven.

Just in case Maxwell is not good enough, here is another, more recent definition for a field line:

"If we join end-to-end infinitesimal vectors representing E, we get a curve in space - called a line of force - that is everywhere normal to the equipotential surfaces. The vector E is everywhere tangent to a line of forces"
​
From Electromagnetic Fields and Waves, Lorrain & Corson, W.H. Freeman & Co., 1970 (2nd edition), page 46 [this was my undergrad textbook]. This definition for an electric field line works just fine for a magnetic field, just replace E with B and you have the definition for a magnetic field line; the definition is general, so just substitute your favorite letter for your favorite field and you've got it.

By now it should be obvious that the field line cannot exist unless the vector that defines the field line exists. This is a crucial point as we shall see.


I repeat: [size=+2]The field line cannot exist unless the vector that defines the field line exists[/size]. The field vector does not exist at the null point. Since the vector does not exist, the line defined by the presence of the vector also does not exist. Ergo, Mozina disproved.
 
Er, no. You simply demonstrated that NOTHING exists at X in a vacuum and you NEED current through the Z axis to get the "reconnection" process you're looking for. No current, no "magnetic charge" in equation 17.
 
I already read all the lies he posted about me on his website.
You are lying abut his lies :D.

They are observations about your displays of ignorance and arhuments from that ignorance suggesting the Dunning-Kruger effect.

I never DENIED "reconnection" is a real process.
Yes you have. The definition of MR is a process in which magnetic field lines break and reconnection (commonly in a plasma but there is also the trivial case of a vacuum). Denying the definition of MR is denying that MR exists.

But maybe you have altered your position:
Do you now agree with the scientific literature, that MR is the changing in the topology of a magnetic field in such a way the magnetic field lines break and reconnect (thus its name)?

This is a real process (see Somov) in vacuum.
This is a real process in plasma since it is seen in experiments and is the most probable cause of solar flares (Observational Signatures of Magnetic Reconnection as of 2003 and Eric Priest, Terry Forbes, Magnetic Reconnection, Cambridge University Press 2000, ISBN 0-521-48179-1, contents and sample chapter online ).
​
I hope that that we will not see another demand from you to change MRs name to sonething nonsensical.
 
Er, no. You simply demonstrated that NOTHING exists at X in a vacuum and you NEED current through the Z axis to get the "reconnection" process you're looking for. No current, no "magnetic charge" in equation 17.

Er insanely nothing to do with his post which has
  • No X point,
  • No z-axis.
  • No current.
  • No equation 17.
  • No 'magnetic charge'.
The last is probably Michael Mozina's delusions about the Demoulin & Priest 1992 paper! which includes that the paper has real monopoles in it.
The paper actually proves that there can be no real monopoles in a lineaf force-free field!

Tim simply stated what the definition of a magnetic field line means - no field = no lines.
MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.
 
Last edited:
I guess the only sure things in life are death, taxes and the outright lies of people who have decided to stay so ignorant that they have become deluded. :(
MM: Try to get it right for once - I pity you, not hate you.

If you pitied me, you'd just leave me alone. Your hatred drives you to attack me personally, lie about my position, and remain on your denial/hate-go-round, regardless of the physics. No current through the Z axis, no "reconnection". It's just that simple.
 
MM: What is the definition of a field line

If you pitied me, you'd just leave me alone.
It is because I pity your ignorance that I keep trying to educate you. I know from your history that this is virtually impossible. But I live in hope.

ETA: It also forms a record for other posters. They will get to know your debating style that is largely lacking actual science, with plenty of whining at people to make things simple enough for you to understand (which you never do).

No current through the Z axis, no "reconnection". It's just that simple.
No current through the z-axis and magnetic reconnection:
Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section.

Lets try one simple question MM: What is the definition of a field line?

I will make it really easy: Field Line
Precise definition
A vector field defines a direction at all points in space; a field line for that vector field may be constructed by tracing a topographic path in the direction of the vector field. More precisely, the tangent line to the path at each point is required to be parallel to the vector field at that point.
A complete description of the geometry of all the field lines of a vector field is sufficient to completely specify the direction of the vector field everywhere. In order to also depict the magnitude, a selection of field lines is drawn such that the density of field lines (number of field lines per unit perpendicular area) at any location is proportional to the magnitude of the vector field at that point.

The definition has 2 consequences:
  • If there is no vector at a point that there can be no field line at the point.
  • If you also draw the lines to depict the magnitude then the density of lines where there is no vector field is zero, i.e. no lines there.
 
Last edited:
It is because I pity your ignorance that I keep trying to educate you.

You can't educate me RC. You've never read the books you cherry pick from. You've never read a single related textbook on plasma physics. You aren't arguing from a place of KNOWLEDGE, you're arguing from a place of pure blind ignorance, and an irrational hatred of all EU oriented ideas. Even FLARE activity has to be a "knock down, drag out" with you because you can't accept an E orientation of the universe. It's pure hatred, nothing more. You can't educate me to hatred. I've seen plenty of it in my lifetime.

You can't educate me in a topic you've never read!
 
I will make it really easy: Field Line

Speaking of cherry picking....

Did you miss this quote from that same website RC?

For example, Gauss's law states that an electric field has sources at positive charges, sinks at negative charges, and neither elsewhere, so electric field lines start at positive charges and end at negative charges. (They can also potentially form closed loops, or extend to or from infinity). A gravitational field has no sources, it has sinks at masses, and it has neither elsewhere, gravitational field lines come from infinity and end at masses. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.

Oh wait, maybe you're hoping that WIKI page gets miraculously edited during our conversation too?
 
Last edited:
Speaking of cherry picking....

Did you miss this quote from that same website RC?
For the third time: No.
This interpretation is wrong because it contradicts the definition (no field = no field lines so field lines that cross a point where there is no field have to end and begin there).

Speaking of cherry picking.... Field Line
Precise definition
A vector field defines a direction at all points in space; a field line for that vector field may be constructed by tracing a topographic path in the direction of the vector field. More precisely, the tangent line to the path at each point is required to be parallel to the vector field at that point.
A complete description of the geometry of all the field lines of a vector field is sufficient to completely specify the direction of the vector field everywhere. In order to also depict the magnitude, a selection of field lines is drawn such that the density of field lines (number of field lines per unit perpendicular area) at any location is proportional to the magnitude of the vector field at that point.
Did you miss this quote from that same website MM?

MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.

And the answer to MM: What is the definition of a field line?is that you cannot understand the Wikipedia definition.
 
I don't suppose you've actually READ a book on plasma physics yet?
I do not need to. My knowledge of science makes it clear that magnetic field can break and reconnect. All a person need is the ability to read and they will see that The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point.

You ignoring what MR books state about MR just emphasizes that you are unable to understand them. If you cannot understand the literature on MR then there is no way that you can understand the books you have read.

For example look at the delusions that you have displayed about the trivial case of MR in a vacuum: Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section.
This is a section on MR in a vacuum. It states that it is a real physical process.
And yet you still deny that MR in a vacuum is a real physical process :jaw-dropp!

An idea: Buy the book, read it and then of course MR in a vacuum will magically become a real physical process just because you own the book and have looked at the words in it.
:dl:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom