Merged Electric Sun Theory (Split from: CME's, active regions and high energy flares)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Your whole question is a ruse. A NULL is not a "beginning" nor an ending of any magnetic line. You guy can't change enough wiki pages to hide the fact that B lines have no source or sink. :)

Your pretence of a "ruse" is not an answer, the question is simple and direct. Why hide from it, unless the only "ruse" is entirely yours? Oh and I've never changed or contributed to any "wiki pages".
 
http://electron9.phys.utk.edu/phys136d/modules/m8/inductance.htm

Maxwell’s equations predict that static magnetic fields are produced by moving charges or currents. There are no magnetic charges, and therefore no sources and sinks for magnetic field lines. Static magnetic fields lines ALWAYS form closed loops. They encircle moving charges according to the right hand rule.

I guess the University of Tennessee - Knoxville is clueless too eh?
 
Try reading what you cite:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_line
Precise definition
A vector field defines a direction at all points in space; a field line for that vector field may be constructed by tracing a topographic path in the direction of the vector field. More precisely, the tangent line to the path at each point is required to be parallel to the vector field at that point.
A complete description of the geometry of all the field lines of a vector field is sufficient to completely specify the direction of the vector field everywhere. In order to also depict the magnitude, a selection of field lines is drawn such that the density of field lines (number of field lines per unit perpendicular area) at any location is proportional to the magnitude of the vector field at that point....
A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.
The latter part of the quote is incorrect. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks. This does not mean that field lines cannot end or start. Gauss's law for magnetism means that any field line that ends at a point has to have a corresponding field line that starts.
A neutral point is not a source of magnetic field.
A neutral point is not a sink of magnetic field.
A neutral point is a point where there is no magnetic field.

Magnetic field lines that cross a neutral point have to break (MM: The definition of magnetic field lines = no lines at a neutral point) thus forming one incoming line that ends and one outgong line that starts. Gauss's law for magnetism is not violated.
 
Last edited:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetic_field#B-field_lines_never_end

Now I've seen EVERYTHING. You guys even changed that WIKI page! Unbelievable. :)
Now I've seen EVERYTHING. The belief that "we" guys even changed that WIKI page! Unbelievable. :jaw-dropp!

This just demonstrates how dangerous it is to rely on Wikipedia as your primary source. The definitions that it states (like that for field lines) are reliable. The interpretations can be wrong, e.g. Gauss's law for magnetism actually means that any field line that ends at a point has to have a corresponding field line that starts at that point. The definition of a field line means that there are no field lines where there is no vector field (the density of field lines is zero).
 
Your pretence of a "ruse" is not an answer, the question is simple and direct. Why hide from it, unless the only "ruse" is entirely yours? Oh and I've never changed or contributed to any "wiki pages".

I've already answered that question in this thread. 0+0=0. So what? That does not mean that the X is the beginning or the ending of any of those lines, let alone every magnetic line in the UNIVERSE! OMG.

I've even taken the time to POINT OUT where Priest turns electrons/current (equation 16) into "magnetic charge" (equation 17). Holy Cow. What more can I do? The E field is the source and sink of the kinetic energy, and the electron is the transfer device, not a monopole.
 
Last edited:
Look folks, it's really simple:

No electrons, no protons, no induced current, no electrical discharge in plasma. The E field is the source and sink of Priests energy conversion "device". The magnetic line is not a source, nor a sink of any B Line. The electron kinetic energy (AKA current) is simply being "mathematically transformed" in equation 17 into "magnetic charge". I don't know how much more fundamentally *WRONG* that is, not not mention DAMN CONFUSING, but not a single magnetic line begins or end at ORIGIN, the fake source/sink god of the magnetic NULL void. The source and sink of the actual kinetic energy is the induced E field, not Origin the big fat zero.
 
Last edited:
Look folks, it's really simple:

No electrons, no protons, no induced current, no electrical discharge in plasma. The E field is the source and sink of Priests energy conversion "device". The magnetic line is not a source, nor a sink of any B Line. The electron kinetic energy (AKA current) is simply being "mathematically transformed" in equation 17 into "magnetic charge". I don't know how much more fundamentally *WRONG* that is, not not mention DAMN CONFUSING, but not a single magnetic line begins or end at ORIGIN, the fake source/sink god of the magnetic NULL void. The source and sink of the actual kinetic energy is the induced E field, not Origin the big fat zero.


Again, arguing that there is a flaw in the premise while admitting to not understanding it is an argument from ignorance. When the "misunderstanding" is intentional, it's willful ignorance.
 
Again, arguing that there is a flaw in the premise while admitting to not understanding it is an argument from ignorance. When the "misunderstanding" is intentional, it's willful ignorance.

In your case it's willful ignorance. You *STILL* have never read a book on plasma physics.
 
Look folks, it's really simple:

No electrons, no protons, no induced current, no electrical discharge in plasma. The E field is the source and sink of Priests energy conversion "device". The magnetic line is not a source, nor a sink of any B Line. ...gibberish snipped....
Look folks, it's really gibberish wriiten by Michael Mozina :D
  1. No one would be idiotic enough to think that with no electrons and no protons, there would be plasma. That is a vacuum.
  2. The EM field is the source and sink of Priests energy conversion "device".
  3. No electrical discharge in plasma (Michael Mozina's delusion about electrical discharges in plasma) :eye-poppi !
  4. "The magnetic line is not a source, nor a sink of any B Line" is gibberish as is the rest of the post.
The null point in magnetic reconnection (e.g. in a vacuum, despite Michael Mozina's delusions about Somov's 'Reconnection in a Vacuum' section ) is no a source or sink of magnetic field. Any magnetic field line that enters the null point is matched by a magnetic field line that leaves the null point. A source has field lines that all start at it. A sink has field lines that all end at it.
 
In your case it's willful ignorance. You *STILL* have never read a book on plasma physics.


Regardless of the persistent, uncivil, and dishonest attempts to make it so, this discussion is not about me. It is about the electric Sun conjecture. With over 5000 posts and not a trace of objective quantitative support for that notion, pretty much everyone has noticed that any pretense of supporting an electric Sun conjecture was abandoned a long time ago. I, like most others here, recognize that the entire premise is built on nothing but logical fallacies, dishonest redefinitions of terms, severe misunderstandings of contemporary and historical science, and intellectually bankrupt arguments.
 
I've even taken the time to POINT OUT where Priest turns electrons/current (equation 16) into "magnetic charge" (equation 17). Holy Cow. What more can I do?
Holy Cow - you can try to understand the physics!
Holy Cow - you can try to understand that there are no actual monopoles in the paper. They are computational devices.
Holy Cow - you can try reading the abstract even!
The properties of sources and sinks of a linear force-free field
...The properties of monopole and dipole solutions in particular are discussed and it is shown that isolated magnetic charges exist only in the potential limit and not in a linear force-free field.
So we have a paper about "a linear force-free field" and the abstract states that "isolated magnetic charges" do not exist in a linear force-free field.

As for equations 16 and 17, there is no problem there.
3. Study of the particular case l=0
3.1 Singularity along the negative z-Axis
Equation (15) gives a singular field only on the negative part of the z-axis. Here both currents and magnetic charges are present:
Ampere's theorem gives a current along the z-axis of magnitude
[equation 16]
Gauss' theorem applied to a core starting from the origin gives a density for magnetic charges along the z-axis of
[equation 17]
Kinetic energy does not appear at all in the equations so your " E field is the source and sink of the kinetic energy" is just a fantasy.
 
I've already answered that question in this thread. 0+0=0. So what? That does not mean that the X is the beginning or the ending of any of those lines, let alone every magnetic line in the UNIVERSE! OMG.



"0+0=0"? What the heck are you talking about the question did not reference a summation. Oh and just for your edification 1 + -1 = 0 as well.

So here is the question again…

please tell us what is the magnitude and direction of the magnetic force vector (what the field lines represent) at a null point (hint the answers to both questions is given in the named of the point)?



I've even taken the time to POINT OUT where Priest turns electrons/current (equation 16) into "magnetic charge" (equation 17). Holy Cow. What more can I do? The E field is the source and sink of the kinetic energy, and the electron is the transfer device, not a monopole.

Take all the time you want to point out anything you want about that paper, since it is irrelevant to the question you are deliberately avoiding.
 
a simple derivation of magnetic reconnection, part 5 of 5

In this final part 5, we use the magnetic fields developed in parts 1 through 4 to understand the two main results of [Dungey 1958] (see references at the bottom of this post).


[size=+1]Review of parts 1 through 4[/size]

My web page on magnetic reconnection contains a more graphic summary of parts 1 through 4 of this derivation. Here I'll just highlight the main facts we need for part 5.

Starting from Maxwell's equations, we derived the magnetic field that's generated by four conducting rods at the corners of a square. When all four rods carry the same current, with the current running in the same direction for rods that are on the same diagonal of the square but in the opposite direction for rods on the other diagonal, we get a magnetic field B4 that approximates Dungey's figure 1.

The center of that square is a neutral point (where B4 is zero). Even tiny variations in the magnetic field can result in magnetic reconnection of magnetic field lines at the neutral point.

All magnetic fields, including B4, satisfy Gauss's law for magnetism, which states that the divergence of the magnetic flux density is zero at every point; equivalently, the magnetic flux through every closed surface is zero. That implies there are no magnetic monopoles, sinks, or sources. All of that is easy to prove for B4, and I have proved it several times using several different methods of proof.

I have also proved that, for every value of the z coordinate, the xy plane determined by z contains two magnetic field lines that begin at the neutral point and two other magnetic field lines that end at the neutral point. B4 therefore serves as a simple counterexample to a popular myth that has been repeated by Wikipedia and other unreliable sources. (Michael Mozina and other EU folk have relied upon that myth as the technical basis for their denials of magnetic reconnection. Since the myth is untrue, their denials have no technical basis at all.)

Reducing the current through the rods in one diagonal to zero while maintaining a constant current through the other rods gives us a much more dramatic example of magnetic reconnection. When current flows through only two parallel rods, and flows in the same direction through each rod, we get a "figure 8" field B2 that reproduces Dungey's figure 2.

That figure 8 field B2 also contains a neutral point, and provides yet another counterexample to the Wikipedia-endorsed myth. It's not quite as simple, because the magnetic field lines that begin or end at the neutral point of B2 are curved instead of straight. That makes this counterexample's calculations more complicated than for B4.

The magnetic fields B4 and B2 are vacuum solutions of Maxwell's equations. Once those vacuum solutions are thoroughly understood, we can reproduce the main results of [Dungey 1958] by considering what happens when we introduce some plasma and allow a magnetic field such as B4 to act upon charged particles that are moving in the z direction.


[size=+1]Historical context[/size]

Dungey's 1958 paper is only 5 pages long, but it contains several minor errors that confused me on my first readings of it. (I'll point out some of those errors below.) Another problem is that Dungey's paper is a reply to a 1953 paper by T G Cowling, and I have not read Cowling's paper (which does not appear to be available online).

In the first sentence of the introduction to Dungey's 1958 paper, Dungey writes:

Dungey said:
The suggestion that a solar flare results from an electrical discharge situated in the neighborhood of a neutral point of the magnetic field was made by Giovanelli [2].
That's puzzling, because I don't see the word "discharge" anywhere within the paper cited [Giovanelli 1947].

Dungey said:
The defining feature of a discharge in this context is the existence of a large current density.
Aha. Giovanelli talked a lot about current density.

It must have been Dungey (or Cowling) who put the word "discharge" into Giovanelli's mouth. Evidently "discharge" is Dungey's or Cowling's idiosyncratic synonym for "large current density". In what follows, I will speak of current density instead of discharges, because current density has a mathematically precise meaning and is less misleading than the word "discharge".

In [Giovanelli 1947], Giovanelli was trying to figure out how a large current density could be associated with sunspots and solar flares. Giovanelli argued that electric fields alone can't do the job, so he turned to magnetic fields. Giovanelli then argued that magnetic fields can't produce large current densities either except in the vicinity of a neutral point.

(Giovanelli was still assuming that the large current density would be generated by induction, and was trying to figure out how induction could generate a large current density fast enough to be consistent with observation. It is my impression that modern researchers have pretty much given up on induction as the source of these particular large current densities, because induction processes can't go fast enough.)

T G Cowling apparently objected to Giovanelli's hypothesis that large current densities occur in solar flares near neutral points of the magnetic field. Cowling gave two distinct reasons for his objection:
  1. According to calculations, the large current density would occur in a sheet that's only a few meters thick, and Cowling just didn't believe something so thin could cause the observed phenomena.
  2. Cowling thought Lenz's law would limit the current density.
The first of those objections was just an argument from incredulity. Dungey answered the second of those objections by a qualitative argument using magnetic fields similar to B4 [Dungey 1958].

Before we consider Dungey's arguments in detail, let's take a moment to understand how a small plasma current can interact with B4 to form a thin sheet of increased current density near the neutral point.


[size=+1]Interaction with plasma current: first-order approximation[/size]

The second paragraph of Dungey's second section begins with these observations:

Dungey said:
Consider a neutral point N, where the lines of force in one plane have the form shown in Fig. 1. The limiting lines of force through N form an X and would be perpendicular, if there were no current flowing in the z-direction (normal to the paper).
With no current, the situation is exactly what we saw in a vacuum with B4, and exactly what we saw when we zoomed in on the neutral point of B4.

Dungey said:
For the field of Fig. 1 there is a roughly uniform current in the z-direction, which contributes a field directed clockwise.
Something's wrong here. As we saw in part 2 of this derivation, a current in the z-direction contributes a field directed counterclockwise, not clockwise.

Dungey appears to be thinking of electrons drifting in the z-direction. Because the electrons are negatively charged, their movement in the z-direction counts as a current in the opposite direction. (We have Benjamin Franklin to blame for that.)

In what follows, I will assume the plasma current is in the negative z-direction, and consists entirely of electrons moving in the positive z-direction. I will also assume the plasma is electrically neutral, as would result from the presence of stationary protons or other positively charged particles that balance the charge of the electrons. So far as I can tell, those assumptions are consistent with everything in [Dungey 1958].

With those assumptions, Dungey's figure 1 makes sense:

dungeyFigure1.png


The magnetic force always runs perpendicular to both the current and the magnetic field. If the current were running in the positive z direction, then Dungey's magnetic force lines (labelled "f") would be pointed in the wrong direction, but Dungey's magnetic force lines are correct for a current flowing in the negative z direction.

Along the x axis, the magnetic force compresses the current toward the neutral point N. Along the y axis, the magnetic force pulls the current away from the neutral point. Those forces result in a narrow sheet of current near the neutral point. The sheet is narrow along the x axis, and long along the y axis.

(For that result, Dungey cites one of his own papers from 1953, but it's pretty obvious from Dungey's figure 1 and the argument given above.)

T G Cowling agreed that pre-existing magnetic fields similar to B4 would tend to flatten any current near the neutral point into a sheet, but Cowling thought that flattening process would be limited by Lenz's law:

The effect of induced currents is always to oppose the changes to which they are due.


The main result of Dungey's 1958 paper is that Lenz's law does not limit the flattening of currents near the neutral points of magnetic fields such as B4 and B2:

Dungey said:
It is found, however, that Lenz's law is reversed at a neutral point and this will now be explained.

To understand that reversal, we must look at what happens to the magnetic field when a fairly uniform current in the (minus) z direction is compressed into a small region of high current density near the neutral point.


[size=+1]Interaction with plasma current: second-order approximation[/size]

A small and uniform current in the z or minus-z direction has little influence near the neutral point of B4, so long as that current is centered near the neutral point and is uniform over a much larger region than the region we're examining. (Why? Because the magnetic field generated by that current at some point p is dominated by the contributions of the nearby current. When the nearby current is nearly uniform, its contributions to the magnetic field at p nearly cancel.)

As noted above, however, magnetic fields such as B4 tend to concentrate that current into a sheet near the neutral point. As that happens, the magnetic field generated by the increased current density near the neutral point begins to distort the original magnetic field, resulting in magnetic reconnection that looks something like this:

mr5origin.gif


That animation was created by adding a fifth conducting rod to the four rods that generate the field B4, and placing that fifth rod at the origin and parallel to the other four rods. When no current is running through that fifth rod, we get the initial magnetic field B4:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/figure1zoomout.png[/qimg]

Zooming in on the origin, we see this:

figure1zoom.png


Increasing the current through the fifth rod to 2% of the current through the other four rods begins to distort the magnetic field:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/b5.png[/qimg]

b5zoom.png


Comparing that graph to the one above it, we see that the field line in the NE quadrant that originally ended at the origin has merged with the field line in the SE quadrant that originally began at the origin, and that merged field line is moving away from the origin toward the east. Similarly, the field line in the SW quadrant that originally ended at the origin has merged with the field line in the NW quadrant that originally began at the origin, and that merged field line is moving away from the origin toward the west.

Meanwhile, the eight field lines whose arrows were originally marked near the y axis are becoming weaker as they advance toward the origin. (Why weaker? The current at the origin is running in the negative z direction, so its contribution to the magnetic field runs clockwise, which cancels some of the original intensity of the field lines that were running in more of a counterclockwise direction.) The original neutral point has now split into two black regions of very weak (but not quite zero) magnetic field intensity on the y axis above and below the origin.

Increasing the current through the fifth rod to 8% of the current through the other four rods results in still more magnetic reconnection and an even more obviously asymmetric magnetic field:

[qimg]http://www.cesura17.net/~will/Ephemera/Nerdliness/MR/b5A.png[/qimg]

b5Azoom.png


The vertical stretching and horizontal compression of the X shape is beginning to become evident in that graph, although it has not yet reached the level of distortion shown in Dungey's figure 1.

Getting back to Lenz's law, we can now use our five-rod approximation to answer a non-trivial question about plasma physics: Has the increasing current density at the origin acted to diminish the magnetic force that was causing the increase in current density?

No! The magnetic field lines that were compressing the plasma along the x axis toward the origin have become stronger, not weaker. Meanwhile, the magnetic field lines that were pulling the plasma away from the origin along the y axis have become weaker. The net result of increasing current density at the origin is to increase the forces that will increase that current density still further.

Dungey said:
It is only necessary to consider the signs of the variables to show that they all increase in magnitude indefinitely, and hence Lenz's law is reversed.

That is the most important result of Dungey's 1958 paper.


[size=+1]Dungey's speculation about magnetic reconnection[/size]

In his section 4, Dungey performs a few simple calculations to show that an extremely thin sheet of very high current density could produce the observed emissions from solar flares. Those calculations dismiss Cowling's argument from incredulity.

That's the second main result of Dungey's paper.

Dungey doesn't stop there, however.

Having gone through the exercises above, Dungey obviously knew about the magnetic reconnections that result from increasing current density near the neutral point of an X-shaped magnetic field, and was impressed by how rapidly those reconnections occur and by how violently they snap the magnetic forces around.

Dungey goes on to speculate about the possible importance of those magnetic reconnections. (Recall that "discharge" is just Dungey's word for the rapid increase in current density near the neutral point.)

Dungey said:
The effect of the discharge is to 'reconnect' the lines of force at the neutral point, and this happens quickly. The 'reconnection' upsets the mechanical equilibrium in the neighborhood in a way that can be visualized, if the lines of force are seen as strings. Then the mechanical disturbance will spread from the neutral point and may have energy comparable to the energy of the spot field in the solar atmosphere. This disturbance, characterized by a sudden onset, may account for several features: surge prominences and Doppler shifts, which are probably different aspects of the same phenomenon; the emission of a mechanical disturbance responsible for magnetic storms; the activation of prominences; the triggering of other neutral points, in whose neighborhood the field is weak, resulting in multiple flares.


I am not a physicist. To me, that looks like hand-waving. It was informed hand-waving, however. I am not qualified to evaluate Dungey's speculation, or to evaluate the role of magnetic reconnection in solar flares, but it isn't hard to understand that Dungey is speculating about the possible effects of magnetic reconnection.


[size=+1]Conclusion[/size]

Starting with the basics of electromagnetism as taught by first-year textbooks such as Edward M Purcell's Electricy and Magnetism, and using little math beyond basic vector calculus, we have proved that magnetic reconnection is an undeniable consequence of Maxwell's equations.

Along the way, we have refuted several common myths about magnetic fields.

We concluded this five-part series by using a variation of the experiment I've been recommending to Michael Mozina to replicate the main result of [Dungey 1958].

For easy reference, I have created a web page that links to all parts of this series (and links to some related material as well).


[size=+1]References[/size]

[Dungey 1958] J W Dungey. The neutral point discharge theory of solar flares. A reply to Cowling's criticism. Proceedings of Electromagnetic Phenomena in Cosmical Physics, edited by Bo Lehnert. International Astronomical Union number 6, Cambridge University Press, page 135.

[Giovanelli 1947] R G Giovanelli. Magnetic and electric phenomena in the sun's atmosphere associated with sunspots. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Volume 107, 1947, pages 338-355.
 
Last edited:
Very nice work W.D. Clinger!!!!


But just remember that “0+0=0”, so clearly Michael Mozina thinks the vector contributions at a null point must also be, well, null yet somehow presumes such a ludicrous position will help him. It does not bode well for him.
 
Very nice work W.D. Clinger!!!!

Ya, nice work LYING through his teeth when he said he would duplicate Dungey's reconnection process IN A VACUUM! Nothing like bait and switch advertizing.

Not a SINGLE magnetic line "begins or ends" in his experiment, either in a vacuum or in plasma. ORIGIN is neither a sink, nor a source of B field lines. All the lines simply traverse ORIGIN at a zero energy strength. Whatever kinetic energy occurs occurs due to the ELECTRIC field, not due to Origin the big fat zero.

No plasma, no DISCHARGE. No plasma, no INDUCED current. No CURRENT, no "magnetic charges" in Priests paper at equation 17, and no "magnetic reconnection". After BSing his way through the entire presentation, KLUDGING basic theory to hell in terms of B line sources and sinks, and then FINALLY doing a bait and switch at the end, yes indeed, he CAN come up with an 'electrical discharge' *IN PLASMA*.

Oy Vey. His *ENTIRE* presentation was pure BS. He accomplished NOTHING in his VACUUM in terms of the release of kinetic energy and he *STILL* thinks induction didn't do it. Pathetic.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by W.D.Clinger
I suggested that experiment to you because it would have helped you to understand that

Dungey is describing magnetic reconnection.
There is no "circuit reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
There is no "current reconnection" in Dungey's paper.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can be reproduced without plasma.
The magnetic reconnection described in Dungey's paper can occur with a near-zero electric (E) field.

Which of these statements do you still stand by?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom