Magnetic field lines end at null points II
Preface: What is a "Field Line"?
Magnetic field lines are mathematical devices for describing and analyzing magnetic fields. They are not physically real objects. I have pointed this out before.
From 26 January 2010
I want to take another crack at the concept of field lines. One of the complaints leveled at the idea of magnetic reconnection is that the field lines are not physically real, which I think is an irrelevant point. So it does not hurt to consider for a moment exactly what a "field line" is supposed to be in some detail.
What is a "field line"?
"In electric and magnetic phenomena, the magnitude and direction of the resultant force at any point is the main subject of investigation. Suppose that the direction of the force at any point is known, then, if we draw a line so that in every part of its course it coincides with the direction of the force at that point, this line may be called a line of force, since it indicates the direction of the force in every part of its course.
By drawing a sufficient number of lines of force, we may indicate the direction of the force in every part of the space in which it acts.
Thus if we strew iron filings on paper near a magnet, each filing will be magnetized by induction, and the consecutive filings will unite by their opposite poles, so as to form fibres, and those fibres will indicate the direction of the lines of force. The beautiful illustration of the presence of magnetic force afforded by this experiment, naturally tends to make us think of the lines of force as something real, and as indicating something more than the mere resultant of two forces, whose seat of action is at a distance, and which do not exist there at all until a magnet is placed in that part of the field. We are dissatisfied with the explanation founded on the hypothesis of attractive and repellant forces directed towards the magnetic poles, even though we may have satisfied ourselves that the phenomenon is in strict accordance with that hypothesis, and we cannot help thinking that in every place where we find these lines of force, some physical state or action must exist in sufficient energy to produce the actual phenomena."
From the paper "On Physical Lines of Force" by James Clerk Maxwell, originally published in The Philosophical Magazine, vol. XXI (1861)
See The Scientific Papers of James Clark Maxwell, volume I; Dover publications, 2003, pages 451-452 (a republication of the 1965 Dover reprint of the original, published in 1890 by Cambridge University Press). Emphasis in the quote is from the original.
The concept for "lines of magnetic force" comes from Michael Faraday and was adopted by Maxwell (see
On Faraday's Lines of Force; page 155 in the same volume I of Maxwell's collected papers; read Dec 10, 1855 and Feb 11, 1856). He later generalized the concept and used it to literally invent the theory of electromagnetic fields, and really the general topic of field theory (see
A Dynamical Theory of the Electromagnetic Field; page 526 in the same volume I of Maxwell's collected papers; read Dec 8, 1864; and see the subsection
On Lines of Magnetic Force, page 551 and
On Magnetic Equipotential Surfaces, page 553). In the passage above, where Maxwell begins "
We are dissatisfied ...", he is expressing his dissatisfaction with the notion of "action at a distance" (an idea Newton did not like either), and his belief that some "physical state or action" must permeate the space around the magnet. That "physical state or action" of 1861 became Maxwell's electromagnetic field of 1864.
Just in case Maxwell is not good enough, here is another, more recent definition for a field line:
"If we join end-to-end infinitesimal vectors representing E, we get a curve in space - called a line of force - that is everywhere normal to the equipotential surfaces. The vector E is everywhere tangent to a line of forces"
From
Electromagnetic Fields and Waves, Lorrain & Corson, W.H. Freeman & Co., 1970 (2nd edition), page 46 [this was my undergrad textbook]. This definition for an electric field line works just fine for a magnetic field, just replace
E with
B and you have the definition for a magnetic field line; the definition is general, so just substitute your favorite letter for your favorite field and you've got it.
By now it should be obvious that
the field line cannot exist unless the vector that defines the field line exists. This is a crucial point as we shall see.
For example, Gauss's law states that an electric field has sources at positive charges, sinks at negative charges, and neither elsewhere, so electric field lines start at positive charges and end at negative charges. (They can also potentially form closed loops, or extend to or from infinity). A gravitational field has no sources, it has sinks at masses, and it has neither elsewhere, gravitational field lines come from infinity and end at masses. A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism), so its field lines have no start or end: they can only form closed loops, or extend to infinity in both directions.
Wikipedia is not an "authoritative source" for anything. In this case, it happens to be wrong, so unending repetitions of the same wrong quote are an exercise in futility. The first part of the highlighted sentence is correct, a magnetic field has no sources or sinks and satisfy Gauss's Law everywhere. However, the language that follows is incorrect. Obviously, if a field line ends at a neutral point or null point, then Gauss's Law is satisfied, and that is the one and only true restriction. "Magnetic field lines have no start or end" is not a law of physics and is wrong. "A magnetic field has no sources or sinks (Gauss's law for magnetism)" is correct.
All of this should be painfully obvious as a
necessary consequence from the definition of a field line, given here from authoritative sources. Remember what i said would be crucial:
the field line cannot exist unless the vector that defines the field line exists. At the null or neutral point the magnetic field vector does not exist. Therefore neither does the field line exist
at that point. It is not esoteric & obscure reasoning to point out that if the field line exists, and then it does not exist, it must have ended somewhere. All of this derives not from the popular pages of Wikipedia, but from the rigorous definition of a field line (see
proof that magnetic field lines can begin/end at a neutral point,
W.D.Clinger, for the formal mathematics).
The final conclusion is obvious: Magnetic field lines can & do end at null or neutral points, and
Mozina has failed to provide any
authoritative evidence to the contrary.
I showed you in that source/sink paper in equations 16 and 17 that the "device" Priest actually uses is CURRENT.
I have no intention of further discussing the Invararity & Priest paper because it is entirely irrelevant. The computational trick used in that paper has never appeared anywhere else, yet
Mozina treats is as if it is some fundamental aspect of all magnetic reconnection arguments. In fact it was never a very good idea, it appears in two obscure papers, was never done before and has not been done since. It does not appear in any text book on plasma physics or magnetic reconnection, especially & including
Magnetic Reconnection: MHD Theory and Applications by Priest (the same Priest) and Forbes. If it was such a hot idea and Priest used it in a paper, then why does it not appear in his textbook? Because it was not such a hot idea, that's why. It has nothing at all to do with any
serious discussion of magnetic reconnection.