Edge dowsing # 2

Edge said:
No I'm not refrain from lying.
It would help a lot if you would tell us what this is in reference to. Also, I think there was supposed to be a period in there somewhere.

But you really should not admonish others not to lie when you have done it so often yourself. You have admitted you lied when you claimed you found the targets by dowsing during the "open" test. You are caught in a situation when you must have lied when you claimed the conditions for the test were okay, then later claimed they weren't. We have many other examples of where you have been shown to contradict yourself.

Now please don't take this the wrong way. Practically everybody lies at some point in their life. There are various reasons, some better than others. The point is not that you lied, it is that you were caught red-handed and yet still refuse to admit it. I have seen children do this, but it is rare in adults. That is the sad part.
 
Edge said:
No I'm not done, refrain from lying.
Nah, we'll leave the lying to you Edge. You haven't shown us that you can sucessfully dowse under test conditions setup and approved 100% by yourself.

But you have shown us that you do have quite a talent for prevarication about the test...




http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Tricky said:



And vodka is a far superior mixer for coke than rum. Rum is for fruit drinks.

You're welcome.

Tricky, I realize this is very late, but please allow me to respectfully say:

YOU GO TO HELL! YOU GO TO HELL AND YOU DIE!

Blasphemer! Vodka is better for coke than RUM?! What frickin' planet do you live on?!

Jesus. Sometimes you just really piss me off.

-Ed
 
Mossy said:


Tricky, I realize this is very late, but please allow me to respectfully say:

YOU GO TO HELL! YOU GO TO HELL AND YOU DIE!

Blasphemer! Vodka is better for coke than RUM?! What frickin' planet do you live on?!

Jesus. Sometimes you just really piss me off.

-Ed

If you ask me you are both damned. Mixing any liquor with coke is a nothing short of a blasphemy.
 
CWL said:


If you ask me you are both damned. Mixing any liquor with coke is a nothing short of a blasphemy.

I'm turning a blind ear, no - a deaf eye? Anyway, I'm turning an impaired sensory organ to this kind of wanton anarchy.

Drink your coke plain. I swear, sometimes it is like you people want to go to hell!

-Ed
 
Mossy said:


I'm turning a blind ear, no - a deaf eye? Anyway, I'm turning an impaired sensory organ to this kind of wanton anarchy.

Drink your coke plain. I swear, sometimes it is like you people want to go to hell!

-Ed

Keep your organs to yourself sir.

Coke is to be drank without any additives and only when hungover. Full stop.

You want to mix? Mix gin with tonic. Anything else will surely have you dispatched to a place more temperate than you would ever wish for.
 
Mossy said:


Tricky, I realize this is very late, but please allow me to respectfully say:

YOU GO TO HELL! YOU GO TO HELL AND YOU DIE!

Blasphemer! Vodka is better for coke than RUM?! What frickin' planet do you live on?!

Jesus. Sometimes you just really piss me off.

-Ed
It depends on whether or not you like Coke. If you like the taste of coke, then vodka is better. If you don't, then cover it up with some rum. Of course rum is superior to something truly bad like bourbon. I have a friend who drinks scotch and Coke. He's the one who is going to hell.

(BTW, don't you have to die before you go to hell?)
 
Tricky said:

It depends on whether or not you like Coke. If you like the taste of coke, then vodka is better. If you don't, then cover it up with some rum. Of course rum is superior to something truly bad like bourbon. I have a friend who drinks scotch and Coke. He's the one who is going to hell.
There really is just no talking to you people. Have you never, in your God-forsaken lives been exposed to a Cuba Libre (Bacardi, of course, not just any ol' rum)??? Find, I wash my hands of this!

(BTW, don't you have to die before you go to hell?)

(Sorry, South Park reference - couldn't help myself, I was overcome with the spirit)

-Ed
 
Mossy said:

There really is just no talking to you people. Have you never, in your God-forsaken lives been exposed to a Cuba Libre

Yah! When I was like 17, dude!

Guess some of us have become slightly more sophisticated with age (and that some of us have not).
 
CWL said:


Yah! When I was like 17, dude!

Guess some of us have become slightly more sophisticated with age (and that some of us have not).

Sophistication at what cost?! Taste?! No thank you - I prefer my lack of sophistication to taste good.

(and you're still going to hell)
 
Mossy said:


Sophistication at what cost?! Taste?! No thank you - I prefer my lack of sophistication to taste good.

Sophistication is taste my young friend. Some day you may understand that.

(and you're still going to hell)

That's fine. At least in my hell we will be drinking beverages for adults. Do you really want to spend eternity drinking Cuba Libres and Pina Colada?

Repent! Repent! For if you do not, the Ragnarok of Sickly-Sweet Cocktails will be upon us!
 
Did anyone else think about Edge when they read this dowsing piece in one of the recent commentaries from Randi?

I remember vividly a conversation with Charlie in which one of our group, reluctant to let go of the idea of supernatural powers, mentioned that it was important to remain open-minded. "To be sure," said Charlie, "but a truly open mind has to be open to the possibility that a radical idea, however exciting, may prove to be a load of codswallop!"
Too bad Edge is too stubborn to realize that he can't actually do what he claims to do. :rolleyes:

To return to my original theme; the point is that while none of us were deliberately or consciously cheating, we were making it all happen in accord with what we already knew, or with guesses based on the reactions of our friends.
As opposed to Edge, who doesn't cheat per se, but who does lie about a test that he helped set up and approved of 100%.

Only to fail miserably in the end. :)

As always, details of his failure are right here.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html



So I am quite prepared to believe that on some occasions, a person with a good underpinning knowledge of how local topography links to underlying archaeology, perhaps also a pre-existing familiarity with the site, can locate materials with a rod or pendulum. They are merely using these tools, consciously or unconsciously, to give voice to shrewd guesses.
Quite relevant to Edge's mining claims I think.

If you do find some gold edge, how would you know it wasn't a result of luck or preexisting knowledge? Why would you assume it's due to your your dowsing "powers".

Kind of a moot point anyways, since you've never shown us any actual proof of all the gold you've found. :)


And tell us.

Have you contacted Randi and the JREF to set up your second prelim test in march?

You've claimed you have a "secret weapon" that will allow you to win the million this time.

We await your second test with great amusement.... :)
 
Indeed, some dowsing believers believe with a religious zeal, based on faith, not evidence. Some claim a scientific basis:

"There's nothing scientific about breaking off a willow branch and walking over the ground with it looking for a stream of water underground. It's hit or miss... If I was going to sink a well, I wouldn't try to divine water with a piece of willow limb. I'd roll high-dice for it before I'd make a fool out of myself doing that."
"You just haven't got a scientific mind, Will."
E Caldwell, "God's Little Acre"
 
Pupdog: Water is my field and I've encountered a number of dowsers in my time. What I've noticed is that they have some very peculiar ideas about the underground world. Without exception (in my experience) they are completely clueless about the reality and carry round a vision of the "waters beneath" that is borrowed directly from their experience of the waters above, i.e. discrete and identifiable channels, even lakes and ponds. Given this picture it does make some sort of sense (to them) to claim that you have to locate water.

The reality is totally different - water percolates through interstices and pores within the rocks and to a reasonable approximation you might say that underground water is everywhere. That's not to say that there aren't better and poorer places to locate wells according to topography and strata. (Some limestone formations do have real streams - in reality just very large solution pores).

Actually this model of the underworld was the received wisdom right up to the enlightenment and beyond. Springs were a great mystery and were regularly debated in the early years of the Royal Society (of London). Their problem was not to entertain any theory which disallowed Noah's flood. Basically they had to imagine vast caverns beneath the mountains which communicated with the oceans, and a process of condensation explained how freshwater was lifted to the underside of the tops of the caverns which then dripped out via springs.

So dowsers are really just the last refuge of folk with a mediaevel mindset.
 
Good summary of dowsers' beliefs, maxberan. Here on the east coast (NC), it's damn near impossible to drill a dry well. Dowsers are especially successful here.

Two questions, if hydrology is your field. How widespread is the use of dowsing amongst well drillers? Also, how difficult is it to locate water in arid regions of the US? I'm told that dowsers in So. Cal. are particularly successful, where non-dowsers are not.
 
To TechHead

A few drillers in my area (MD-PA) are believers, some are just willing to go through the motions if the customer wants dowsing. But LOTS of people have employed dowsers here, even town water departments! We're East Coast, but this includes the crystalline rocks of the Piedmont, & some lots have had more than 20 dry holes. Well yields are very spotty; I've seen a complaint that a customer wouln't pay the driller because the driller had to move 6 inches away from the spot the dowser had picked.

The local papers occasionally print articles about local dowsers, but, as usual, without a trace of skepticism.
 
I always thought it would be fun to not only test a dowser, but also have an amateur metal detector fan also run through the test independantly. What it would show is the dowser equal to chance, and the metal detector close to 100%. Why bother with a stick, when an "alternative dowsing" is available.
 
Techhead asks:
Two questions, if hydrology is your field. How widespread is the use of dowsing amongst well drillers? Also, how difficult is it to locate water in arid regions of the US? I'm told that dowsers in So. Cal. are particularly successful, where non-dowsers are not.


In the UK the water supply industry is largely in the hands of large companies with regional responsibilities and who employ professional hydrogeologists either directly or via consultants. For historic and geographic reasons there is not a large body of small-time drillers working directly to landowners or individual municipalities who I would expect to be more credulous. Nevertheless I would not be surprised if more than a quarter would not dismiss dowsing. I worked for a research establishment before retiring and probably half of my scientific colleagues professed belief in a God. I always thought they must have something wrong with their wiring, but there you go.

As for the US, I suggest the USGS' website as a first port of call. From observations of backdrops of cowboy films (which is the sum total of my knowledge of So Cal) there does seem to be a lot of surface topographic detail and the sort of semi-arid environment which allows the surface geology to be readily seen (as well as being in black and white) both of which would be very helpful to anyone trying to locate a good site for a borehole.

Pupdog mentioned crystalline rocks - these would certainly be a lot harder to find water in as (a) more of the rainfall runs off instead of percolating, and (b) it is only large fissures such as fracture zones around faults which are capable of providing a useful supply. Also the vegetation being lusher, you have fewer surface clues as to the underlying geology.
 
It would be interesting to know if dowsers are more plentiful in arid regions or in wet regions, regardless of their success rate.

Also, I wonder if people are more likely to rely upon dowsers or geologists in arid regions vs. wet regions.

Basically, a market analysis. Where is the demand greatest? Where water is hard to find, or where water is easy to find?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom