Edge dowsing # 2

Ray Hyman might know. In "Water Witching, USA" (Vogt & Hyman) they talk about a large survey of well drillers they did, although I don't recall that they broke it down by regions. Also, the survey was done in the 1950's, so it's surely time for updated data! This would be an excellent thesis for some psychology grad student.


It would be interesting to know if dowsers are more plentiful in arid regions or in wet regions, regardless of their success rate.

Also, I wonder if people are more likely to rely upon dowsers or geologists in arid regions vs. wet regions.

Basically, a market analysis. Where is the demand greatest? Where water is hard to find, or where water is easy to find?
 
I always thought it would be fun to not only test a dowser, but also have an amateur metal detector fan also run through the test independantly. What it would show is the dowser equal to chance, and the metal detector close to 100%. Why bother with a stick, when an "alternative dowsing" is available

Metal detectors are limited in depth but it is a handy tool to have and use with all the knowledge to make money at mining easier and more confirmation is best.

I think the limits were a few feet of overburden but with new technology it could be more.

I have gone as far as Fort Pierce Lately and the next time I will look for a neutral ground there and as far south as sixty miles from here.
 
Edge said:


Metal detectors are limited in depth but it is a handy tool to have and use with all the knowledge to make money at mining easier and more confirmation is best.

I think the limits were a few feet of overburden but with new technology it could be more.
What are the depth limits for dowsing? Is there a weakening of the signal with distance?


I have gone as far as Fort Pierce Lately and the next time I will look for a neutral ground there and as far south as sixty miles from here.
I was wondering where you have been. Have you struck the mother lode yet?
 
Tricky said:

What are the depth limits for dowsing? Is there a weakening of the signal with distance?
There are no limits - depth or otherwise - for credulousness.
 
Tricky I have moved and was held up in time as the house I moved into wasn't ready till aboiut a week ago.
I'm glad that it's done I hate moving.

The next move I do will be to the west coast of Calli.; I hope.

I will tell you a story about a detector and a dowser later tonite.
 
Hooray! So you finally admit that you're just telling stories!

This whole thread reminds me of playing cowboys and indians as a child.

'Bang! You're dead, I shot you'

'No I'm not, you missed'

Lots more waving of plastic guns and many tears shed in the ensuing argument.

The only difference is that there is no way of proving if you were or were not on target in your imaginary world. I get the feeling edge is very happy discussing things in his own imaginary world. However, it is VERY provable in the real world. I question wether anything more can/should be said to edge? If you feel you have to have the last word and that by letting edge have the last post in this thread that you are in some way losing, I'd have to ask why. If edge wants to discuss this properly then he needs to show us there is something to discuss. Surely any other posts of his are irrelevent.

He knows how to go about the million dollar challenge so he has no reason to discuss that here.

The requirements for it have been done to death, he could not possibly need to know any more than he does.

We don't need to know why he failed last time, that also is irrelevent.

All that matters at the moment is his success for it is only after that that he will have a leg to stand on.

Any further stories/excuses/explainations are completely irrelevent. Why does anyone feel the need to credit them with a response?
 
I asked Tim the guy that taught me how to dowse to come down to our part of the creek to show us his stuff, as we were not doing well at all.
He did and said if I put in a certain spot that I would hit a once or more every day till the end of dredging season, which was about two months away.
Then he told the other guy Dave to stay where he was at that he would hit a big pocket and that after he was done it would run out and he would have to go else where as the property line was in front of him and the fact that he couldn't jump directly in front of me, he was dead in his chose of spots unless he got behind me and it was clean there so there was no point in doing that.

Dave brought down his metal detector and doubled checked the spot and it went off big time.
The overburden there was only about 2 to 3 feet and the bottom was that hard conglomerate that's black in color.

The spot or area that I was in had varying depths and thickness of over burden where his detector really couldn't tell us any thing but yet the dowser, Tim knew, and that impressed me so that was the winter that I had him teach me how to dowse for GOLD.
Dave hit a 9 once pocket and I was a little jealous.

Then he pulled out and I was alone during that next two months on that part of the creek. I pulled about a pound and a half and got two quarter once nuggets and a half once nugget.
True
 
Let me get this straight. The guy with the metal detector found the most gold in the shortest time, and this somehow proves dowsing? :rolleyes:

How much cash did you net for this two-months work?
 
Just a story. I have lots of those too. Irrelevent.

Edge, what are you hoping to achieve by continuing with this? Haven't you figured out yet that stories aren't going to win us over?

There is one way, and one way only that you could ever win us over and that's to walk away with Randi's Million. You say you can dowse and that it's an aquired skill. Well, I'm a sailor. I have an ability to read the wind which is above that of the average person. A lot of people are surprised by the extent to which you can read the wind, but it's just a skill that can be learned. I've been doing it for some 20 years now and am still learning more each time I sail. Now, if Randi told me I could win a million dollars for demonstrating my ability to read the wind there is no way I could turn it down. It's just something I do all the time anyway. There would be no meeting too important to miss or anything silly like that (this is a million dollars, a life changing amount of money). There would be no animosity on my part, if someone said they thought I couldn't do it, I'd just shrug my shoulders and get on with it. I'd PROVE them wrong, take the million and leave no-one in any doubt! A genuine person with a real ability would have NO REASON to turn down the challenge.

You say you go dowsing for gold. Why do people dowse for gold? Because it's worth cash. You were jealous when your friend found a big haul of gold. Therefore, the more gold you find, and hence the more money, the better.

RANDI IS OFFERING YOU ONE MILLION DOLLARS! You just won't find that much gold. There are simply no downsides to taking the challenge if you are genuine. None whatsoever.

You cannot dowse. Nothing you say on this forum can possibly ever prove that wrong/right. Similarly, nothing I can say could prove anything either. There is only one way to prove anything, and you know it. Stop lying and prove it.
 
robbersdog said:
Just a story. I have lots of those too. Irrelevent.

Edge, what are you hoping to achieve by continuing with this? Haven't you figured out yet that stories aren't going to win us over?
Ya See Edge?

Even people new to the thread see right through your attempts to convince us through worthless personal anecdotes.

And we've shown you direct proof that you've lied to us here.

Why should anyone take your personal anecdotes as evidence of any kind?

Having demonstrated without a doubt that you'll lie and make up stories about your "powers" it's a bit surprising that you'd persist in foisting them on us....

You know, March is right around the corner.

Have you contacted Randi yet about your second try at the million dollar challenge?

And if you haven't done so by now, why not?

written by Edge

I have gone as far as Fort Pierce Lately and the next time I will look for a neutral ground there and as far south as sixty miles from here.
Hey, you said your sisters house worked quite well for dowsing. Why not just go there.

Or

Just go where you dowsed when you tested the items that you said you can find 100% of the time during your prelim test. (The sacajawea dollars, etc...

We're all quite anxious to here about your "secret weapon" that you claim will net you the million this time.

And we're also quite curious to know the status of your prelim talks with Randi for your re-test.

Please don't bore us with unverifiable *and quite useless* personal anecdotes.

We want to know why you failed completely at a dowsing test that you helped personally design and that you approved of 100%.

Details of Edge's abject failure to dowse under fair test conditions are right here for those new to the thread.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
God you guys are dense.

Let me get this straight. The guy with the metal detector found the most gold in the shortest time, and this somehow proves dowsing?

Then he told the other guy Dave to stay where he was at, that he would hit a big pocket and after that he would be done, it would run out, and he would have to go else where as the property line was in front of him and the fact that he couldn't jump directly in front of me, he was dead in his chose of spots unless he got behind me and it was clean there so there was no point in doing that.

Mike said,That's me,
"He did and said if I put in a certain spot that I would hit a once or more every day till the end of dredging season, which was about two months away."

60+ ounces!!!! Verses 9 ounces?

Still can't figure it out?

His advice was correct in both situations Duh hu.

This is one of those nuggets on my ring.
 
Ok, I think this thread has pretty well been killed by edge, so I'm going to take a slight liberty here and ask that no-one else posts till he has replied to this post. I don't want to give edge any excuses to not answer a question. If asked two questions at once, he seems to dither between the two, without answering either.

I'm going to keep this really simple. A complicated question will almost always need a complicated answer, so edge could feel he has answered it, while to the rest of us it only leads to frustration. The following threads then lose the original point of the question, so I propose we keep questions to the yes/no kind, or at least to simple questions with short answers. If edge really believes what he can do, then this won't be a problem. If he doesn't believe his own stories, and has something to hide, he will make an excuse and not answer the question. There you go edge, that is the challenge. By not posting an answer or by posting an excuse, we can only assume you are a liar. Remember, this is a skeptics forum, and YOU are the one with the case to prove, not us.

Question: You have been trying to win us over by telling us stories from your past. While you may know them to be true, do you understand that since there is no way for us to check the facts, they are useless as proof of dowsing? Just to clarify, the yes/no question is 'do you understand why we can't accept stories as proof'?
 
Ok I can understand that, yes to a point.
But use some logic here, How many people do you know have raw gold or nuggets out of the river in their possession?
You could buy them.

Dave never hit again the rest of the season with his metal detector.
You know why?
Because it was very limited in it's ability.
It's still a useful tool to check with though.
The detector cannot scan the horizon and get direction.

The next time I go I will document every thing from myself leaving Fl. to Ca.

There is one spot there that I jumped over; it's virgin ground, which can be proved to be so.
If it's still there I will get a reading.
It was deep and hard to get to the bottom but in the path of the ancient line of gold that I was following.
At the time it was easier to skip it and get to the easier stuff, but knowing now and looking back I always regretted that decision.

I am thinking about doing the test again but in a more favorable spot, if I can find that here or anywhere.

I only know that it works in the gold fields, there could be a lot of false positives there as well when doing the test, I still am not sure why that is and like you am always learning.
 
Yet another story:

The water manager of the next town over from me was showing off their new high-yield well to my buddy, a hydrologist. He was mighty proud of it, and praised the dowser who picked the spot.
"What's that pile of cuttings over there?...and over there...and more over there...etc.?" my buddy asked, "did you do some test drilling?"
"No," replied the water manager, "the first couple of spots the dowser picked were dry, but when he found a spot with water, there was water there!"
 
Show us a picture of the well.
By the way I don't dowse for water I just pray for rain.......
Make sure you have an anchor stone.
 
Now that Edge has answered those questions, I would like him to return to one I asked earlier.

How much money did you make, Edge? Was it enought to cover your expenses? What do you figure was your hourly rate?

If you found 60 ounces, as you suggest, then at current prices, you grossed about $21,000. Not bad at all for two months work. You should be quite wealthy if you can continue this performance, and, of course, if this is true.

Of course, like all your stories, we only have your word for it.
 
Back then Tricky it was about 350 an once but nugget value was time and a half so it was closer to 35 not counting what went on before that and after.

When you get to quarter once chunks and half once pieces it jumps even more.


The vial also has some platinum, back then it was 500 dollars an once ,or 20 penny weight to an once.
 
Edge said:
Back then Tricky it was about 350 an once but nugget value was time and a half so it was closer to 35 not counting what went on before that and after.

When you get to quarter once chunks and half once pieces it jumps even more.


The vial also has some platinum, back then it was 500 dollars an once ,or 20 penny weight to an once.
So how much money did you clear?
 
it was closer to 35 not counting what went on before that and after.
 
Edge said:
it was closer to 35 not counting what went on before that and after.
$35? $35,000? 35 ounces?

What I was asking was how much money you made (gross and net) off of the gold you found.

Before what and after what? In the last two months, how much money have you put in the bank as a result of dowsing? It's an easy question. Ballpark figures will be fine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom