Echolocation in Lake Champlain?

Any evidence of echolocation in any freshwater body connected to the ocean must rule out whales visiting from the ocean before speculating on other possible sources, in my not-so-humble opinion.

Agreed. There's also been some rumblings that seals may use echolocation. If so, we can add another suspect to our list. Sadly, this line of thinking is often ignored in favor of the "unknown marine creature visiting from the ocean" idea.

The "surviving zeuglodon" theory always cracks me up, seeing as how the popular image of Champ and the "creature" depicted in the Mansi photo doesn't look like how a Basilosaurus is supposed to look.

Interested parties can find some other skeptical takes on the so-called echolocation here.
 
A crafty cryptozoologist could take this and bonk you on the head.

They endured the glaciers like a lungfish adapted to the far north. These prehistoric animals buried themselves deeply into mud and estivated. Slept through the whole thing.

Perhaps, if you can ignore how glaciers are built up and how they erode when moving. I would think anything slow enough to get caught in the snow storm that never melts will be spread thinly from Hudson Bay to Central Park. Some living things can estivate a long time, but I find 10-20,000 years doubtful in the extreme.

I'd want to see proof, and I might bonk back. Has, for example, anyone ever documented finding any creature frozen inside a bonafide glacier for 100 years or more ever come out of it alive? Anything the size of a dog or larger? Understanding the changes the ice goes through alone (ice crystals merging under pressure, for example) would, I would think, terminate the possibility.
 
A few years ago, a whale carcas (beluga, IIRC) was found near Fairbanks, AK, about 1000 river miles from the ocean. Any evidence of echolocation in any freshwater body connected to the ocean must rule out whales visiting from the ocean before speculating on other possible sources, in my not-so-humble opinion.

-David
Just to add an extra tidbit on whales outside their "place":
In November 2007 a minke whale was found at the Tapajós River (a tributary to the Amazon River).
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2007/11/071121-AP-brazil-whale.html

I would go one step beyond and say before labelling pictures, footage and eyewitnesses reports as being evidence for "lake monsters" in freshwater bodies connected to the ocean, one must rule out visitors from the sea such as whales, sharks, sturgeons, otters, seals, dolphins, etc. Not to mention the usual suspects such as logs and waves.

Now, a question.
Please forgive my ignorance, but the signals from sonar probes such as those commonly used by fishermen (sport and pro) to locate fishes, could they be somehow be responsible for the records? Such devices are small, cheap and used at very small boats. How would such signals appear after distorted say, by temperature boundaries, echoes, etc.?

Well, maybe this will become another "bloop" sign... An unknown.
 
Of course, you have to accept the possibility that a breeding population of whales have lived in Champlain now for 10,000+ years without ever once having a fresh carcass float ashore, get caught in a fishing line, stay still long enough to be photographed, etc. You also have to wonder how air-breathing mammals survive in a lake that gets completely frozen over every winter. But at least the idea makes more sense than pleiosaurs.

I'm pretending to be a cryptozoologist (CZ) in this thread.

I'm much more familiar with Bigfoot than lake and sea cryptids, but I can apply the same principles of 'CZ logic' to either in argument. I do not have to play by the same rules as scientists or skeptics choose to. I am virtually convinced that there is a unclassified animal living in Lake Champlain. There is secondary evidence (video, snapshots, eyewitnesses, recorded ticks, etc.) to support this. I start with the assumption that the animal is there and can work backwards to try to explain it. It makes little difference if there are unexplainable or seemingly impossible obstacles because the animal is there and unanswered questions don't change that fact. It got there somehow whether you can explain it accurately or not. You don't need to know where apple trees came from in order to acknowledge that they exist right now.

Why no found carcass? I don't really know. It seems odd. But I will remind you that Bigfoot exists and we still don't have a carcass from that one either. There is beauty in the logic of cryptozoology. Part of it comes from knowing what it means for a living species to be unclassified by science. You do need a body for that. But Champ and Bigfoot are no different than mountain gorillas. They were unclassified until we got a body. For the entire history of humans on earth, gorillas remained unclassified until that moment. Yet this whole time they were right there in Africa. The body allowed us to answer all sorts of questions about these gorillas without even observing it alive. These are the kinds of questions that we cannot answer now about Champ and Bigfoot.

Champ may deal with a frozen lake by estivating. That may be related to how it got into the lake in the first place.

shadron said:
Perhaps, if you can ignore how glaciers are built up and how they erode when moving. I would think anything slow enough to get caught in the snow storm that never melts will be spread thinly from Hudson Bay to Central Park. Some living things can estivate a long time, but I find 10-20,000 years doubtful in the extreme.

I'd want to see proof, and I might bonk back. Has, for example, anyone ever documented finding any creature frozen inside a bonafide glacier for 100 years or more ever come out of it alive? Anything the size of a dog or larger? Understanding the changes the ice goes through alone (ice crystals merging under pressure, for example) would, I would think, terminate the possibility.

Assuming that estivation is the answer in the first place, I would speculate that a glaciation period like you describe would account for about a 95% mortality of estivating Champs. That may also help explain why Champs are not found in the Great Lakes but do now live in Lake Champlain.

Cryptozoologists are unbonkable. You can point out bad arguments or poor logic, but you cannot change the reality of Champ living in Lake Champlain right now. I won't make you eat crow when Champ is finally confirmed, but you may choose to do so of your own accord.
 
Last edited:
Who or What Are They Visiting?

I kinda like the visiting whale idea. But isn't there a set of canals and locks leading to those lakes?
But as far as whale examples, the beluga in Fairbanks was excellent. What about that humpback way up the Columbia River a couple of years ago?
 
I'd be pretty surprised if something is echolocating in Lake Champlain, though I'd certainly be happy to find out that there is. I like the idea of Champ, I just don't think he's really there.
 
I was pleasantly surprised to see on this MonsterQuest episode Benjamin Radford discussing the Manzi photo and explaining how it is almost certainly a tree stump. Considering that over bigfoot, lake monsters are more his specialty I guess I shouldn't have been surprised. I wondered if he had commented on the echolocation recordings but had his comments edited out. I'm sure he's spoken on the matter and I'm interested to hear what he has to say on the subject.

The female biologist (can't remember her name and too lazy to check now) really did an excellent job of presenting the realistic, critical arguments. There really is no arguing with the absence of an ecological impact for this alledged unidentified species. The team of scientists taking years painstakingly three-dimensionally mapping Lake Champlain and never finding anything Champ-like isn't much hope for monster fans either.

When I hear suggestions of wayward whale I'm brought back to the accounts of the sweet, old woman who lives on the lake and claimed two separate land sightings of two different plesiosaur-type Champs approaching the light post outside her home.
 
I kinda like the visiting whale idea. But isn't there a set of canals and locks leading to those lakes?
But as far as whale examples, the beluga in Fairbanks was excellent. What about that humpback way up the Columbia River a couple of years ago?
Indeed, there are canals and locks at both ends of the lake. The path to the sea is pretty difficult to say the least, and for a whale or any other marine creature to get through the canals would be very unlikely. The lower lake is accessed through the New York State barge canal system, with 12 locks between the lake and the Hudson River. At the top is a canal that eventually leads to the St. Lawrence seaway, perhaps a better chance for visitors, but still a long shot.

Most of the hope for Champ rides on the lake's truly phenomenal depth, as well as its geological history, but it's a pretty dim hope these days. As Kitakaze points out, there's been a lot of underwater scanning and mapping done in recent years, both for biological and historical research, and while of course we must repeat the litany that the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, the likelihood decreases as the research continues.

I've always thought the Manzi photo is of a cormorant. It's quite common to see cormorants form that shape in the water, especially when the reflections are just right. The scale is dubious, and the resolution poor enough, especially when there's a lot of sunlight on the water, to make it impossible to determine the true outlines of the object.

In answer to one of your other questions, Lake Placid is not connected with Champlain, and is at a different elevation.

The problem with William Parcher's suggestion of estivation is that if the many Champ sightings reported are real, then it's clear that the critter is not estivating or at least not very good at it. If the many Champ sightings are not real, then there seems no other reason to suspect that there is such a beast, since sightings, as far as I know, constitute the only evidence.

On the other hand, the greatest concentration of sightings is traditionally around Bulwagga Bay, which is relatively shallow, and near the boundary between the "broad lake" and the "creek," which also constitutes more or less the boundary between the portion of the lake that always freezes in winter and that which cannot be counted on to freeze at all some years; and this is also relatively near to the point where the depth of the lake becomes extreme, reaching 400 feet or more. So I suppose that if we postulate an estivating creature that goes deep in summer, but occasionally comes out of estivation to forage in shallower water, Bulwagga Bay would be a good place for that to happen.
 
I was pleasantly surprised to see on this MonsterQuest episode Benjamin Radford discussing the Manzi photo and explaining how it is almost certainly a tree stump. Considering that over bigfoot, lake monsters are more his specialty I guess I shouldn't have been surprised. I wondered if he had commented on the echolocation recordings but had his comments edited out. I'm sure he's spoken on the matter and I'm interested to hear what he has to say on the subject.

The link I provided in my last post contains a link to his thoughts on the matter (It also has some information that Correa might find interesting in regards to his fish finder query).
 
Cryptozoologists are unbonkable. You can point out bad arguments or poor logic, but you cannot change the reality of Champ living in Lake Champlain right now. I won't make you eat crow when Champ is finally confirmed, but you may choose to do so of your own accord.

If and when, good sir, if and when.

Assuming that estivation is the answer in the first place, I would speculate that a glaciation period like you describe would account for about a 95% mortality of estivating Champs. That may also help explain why Champs are not found in the Great Lakes but do now live in Lake Champlain.

And what do you base that estimate on? As you know from my post, my "speculation" on the viability of a fair sized animal living through one hundred years of deep freeze in glacier conditions (let alone thousands) is zero. What proof? Inquiring minds want to know.

(I understand that I, perhaps, am in for it, as I've walked into this (cryptozoology) field cold with no more study than a scientist wannabe has available to himself in general. If so, I deserve my lot, but you'll have to come get it.)
 
The echolocation clicks are coming from a school of red herrings.
No, it's invisible bigfeet out on the lake bass fishing. Rumor has it that they've been moving into the Adirondacks, but they've had to adapt their fishing habits, since there are no river salmon available. So they're sneaking into people's garages and borrowing their fish finders. Of course, they're invisible, so nobody sees this, but there's no arguing with logic, is there?
 
Did the program mention when in 2003 the echo noises were recorded?

http://www.glerl.noaa.gov/res/Task_rpts/1990/ppsaylor02-1.html

In 2003 9 moorings were deployed in Lake Champlain in June including temperature data loggers, ADCPs and sound sources for deep water RAFOS experiments. Drifter experiments were conducted in Lake Champlain in July. All moorings were recovered and RAFOS experiments completed in August.
 
The link I provided in my last post contains a link to his thoughts on the matter (It also has some information that Correa might find interesting in regards to his fish finder query).

Oh, sorry, I missed that link.

So, fish finders may have had a role.

Something that I tink must always be remembered when it comes to lake monsters: Deep lakes tend to have their lower deeper parts unsuitable for anything other than bacteria (and the occasional frog, in Loch Ness case) due to lack of oxigen. The most productive areas are those where sunlight can still reach. This reduces a lot the space available for a breeding sustainable population of lake monsters.
 
I've always thought the Manzi photo is of a cormorant. It's quite common to see cormorants form that shape in the water, especially when the reflections are just right. The scale is dubious, and the resolution poor enough, especially when there's a lot of sunlight on the water, to make it impossible to determine the true outlines of the object.

IMO, that is not a cormorant or any other known bird species.

The problem with William Parcher's suggestion of estivation is that if the many Champ sightings reported are real, then it's clear that the critter is not estivating or at least not very good at it. If the many Champ sightings are not real, then there seems no other reason to suspect that there is such a beast, since sightings, as far as I know, constitute the only evidence.

Champ may not be an estivator, nor ever was. There are many sightings going back a long time. Much like with Bigfoot. They may all be wrong, but that would be pretty extraordinary. So the claim that they are all wrong should be backed up with extraordinary evidence that they are wrong.

So I suppose that if we postulate an estivating creature that goes deep in summer, but occasionally comes out of estivation to forage in shallower water, Bulwagga Bay would be a good place for that to happen.

Cool. We can add that to the growing list of hypotheses on how Champ lives his life.

Additionally, a frozen lake (the surface) is not much of a problem for an estivating air-breather that can adaptively respire through its skin while 'asleep'.

shadron said:
And what do you base that estimate on? As you know from my post, my "speculation" on the viability of a fair sized animal living through one hundred years of deep freeze in glacier conditions (let alone thousands) is zero. What proof? Inquiring minds want to know.

Well, there is no proof for this. It's a hypothesis. The 95% mortality rate estimation was based on the knowledge that the glaciation period was relatively long and harsh. It killed most Champs but left enough to prevent extinction. Some may have also 'woke up' in the Great Lakes but the population ultimately was not viable there. Champ bones might be discovered at the bottom of Lake Superior.

So, how did you come up with a 0% chance of Champ riding out the big freeze? Do you actually have facts about Champ physiology that would allow you to make your claim?
 
Last edited:
IMO, that is not a cormorant or any other known bird species.



Champ may not be an estivator, nor ever was. There are many sightings going back a long time. Much like with Bigfoot. They may all be wrong, but that would be pretty extraordinary. So the claim that they are all wrong should be backed up with extraordinary evidence that they are wrong.



Cool. We can add that to the growing list of hypotheses on how Champ lives his life.

Additionally, a frozen lake (the surface) is not much of a problem for an estivating air-breather that can adaptively respire through its skin while 'asleep'.



Well, there is no proof for this. It's a hypothesis. The 95% mortality rate estimation was based on the knowledge that the glaciation period was relatively long and harsh. It killed most Champs but left enough to prevent extinction. Some may have also 'woke up' in the Great Lakes but the population ultimately was not viable there. Champ bones might be discovered at the bottom of Lake Superior.

So, how did you come up with a 0% chance of Champ riding out the big freeze? Do you actually have facts about Champ physiology that would allow you to make your claim?

I'm not quite sure I agree with the idea that it requires extraordinary evidence to claim that all champ sightings are wrong, much as I'd like to believe that some are not. There are so many possible reasons for mistaking something else as the monster one has come to expect.

As for the Manzi photo, all I can say is that I've spent a lot of time on Lake Champlain over the years, and that shape shows up sufficiently often, especially when the waves are sparkling, that my wife and I joke about seeing another "champorant." Of course it could me any number of other things, but we'll never know, because the resolution of the photo is not good enough, and the scale is unknown. I've read many attempts to fix the scale using the waves as a reference, but again, having spent a lot of time on that lake, and seen how incredibly variable the waves can be, I am not persuaded.

With all that said, you can bet that I won't be going out on the lake without at least a reasonably decent camera, because if that critter does show up I would very much like to be the lucky SOB who gets the first clear shot!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom