Echolocation in Lake Champlain?

kitakaze

Resident DJ/NSA Supermole
Joined
Apr 5, 2006
Messages
9,272
Location
Sapporo ichiban!
First, let me make it absolutely clear that in no way do I believe any manner of lake monster inhabits Lake Champlain, Loch Ness, the Okanogan, or any of the various locations about the world where people make such claims. No plesiosaurs, no long-necked seals, no thank-you.

That said, I was recently watching a Monster Quest episode on Champ in which it was reported that in 2003 recordings were made of echolocation or biosonar by Fauna Communications at three separate locations on Lake Champlain. Is the claim true? Is it a hoax? My only intention with this thread is that if this claim is true, it's a very odd, anomylous thing. I was hoping to get some more heads, some better heads on this than mine. Because, at first glance it looks like a neat mystery and we all like mysteries.

Here are the relevant links:

MonsterQuest: America's Loch Ness Monster.

Fauna Communications' page regarding the recordings.

Invisible bigfoot underwater farts or not, I'd love to hear some thoughts.
 
Last edited:
You can start with the thought that Lake Champlain and the Finger Lakes, like the Great Lakes and most of the lakes in Canada, were all under a miles-thick glacier sheet up until less than 20,000 years ago (several different times in the last ten million years, as a matter of fact). That rules out the idea that they may have anything left over in them from the age of dinosaurs, or even most of the age of mega-mammals.

Lots of things cause acoustic echoes in SONAR gear; things like temperature differences in layers, schools of fish, anomalies in floor structure, and so on. Like anything else, these need to be interpreted by an expert, using more than one device or even technology to determine what it is that is being recorded.
 
Lots of things cause acoustic echoes in SONAR gear; things like temperature differences in layers, schools of fish, anomalies in floor structure, and so on. Like anything else, these need to be interpreted by an expert, using more than one device or even technology to determine what it is that is being recorded.
Thanks, shadron. Again, zero contemplation on my part that there is any cryptid involved. What I would love to know is if temperature differance in layers, schools of fish, anomalies in floor structure could account for the recordings.
 
You can start with the thought that Lake Champlain and the Finger Lakes, like the Great Lakes and most of the lakes in Canada, were all under a miles-thick glacier sheet up until less than 20,000 years ago (several different times in the last ten million years, as a matter of fact). That rules out the idea that they may have anything left over in them from the age of dinosaurs, or even most of the age of mega-mammals.
But here's the thing, shadron. It's a non-start. It's ridiculous to think that there's any animal existing in any of these lakes that fits the descriptions we're talking about. The biologist in the MQ episode put it the most unambiguously. An animal species surviving in sufficient numbers to reproduce would have a major impact on it's ecosystem. No silliness.

We're left to wonder if the recordings were legit or a hoax. That's the only question in my mind.
 
You can start with the thought that Lake Champlain and the Finger Lakes, like the Great Lakes and most of the lakes in Canada, were all under a miles-thick glacier sheet up until less than 20,000 years ago (several different times in the last ten million years, as a matter of fact). That rules out the idea that they may have anything left over in them from the age of dinosaurs, or even most of the age of mega-mammals.

A crafty cryptozoologist could take this and bonk you on the head.

They endured the glaciers like a lungfish adapted to the far north. These prehistoric animals buried themselves deeply into mud and estivated. Slept through the whole thing.
 
No Mention of Invisibility

My question, so far, is related to the purported monster and it's capabilities.
Is there any evidence of amphibians or reptiles utilizing echo-location?
 
It's ridiculous to think that there's any animal existing in any of these lakes that fits the descriptions we're talking about.

A creationist would have no problem with Champs now living in the lake.

I wonder what they would think about Bigfoot. Creationists might not feel obligated to try to explain Bigfoot origins in terms of ancestral migration from Asia or a lack of fossil evidence.

Can we get a showing of hands of Creationists in Cryptozoology?
 
Is there any evidence of amphibians or reptiles utilizing echo-location?

There is no need for evidence when you can simply propose that echolocation could have evolved anywhere in the animal kingdom and at any time. Oilbirds echolocate and they evolved from dinosaurs. Bang zoom... you've got a genuine echolocating Champ living in the lake. Somebody pop a cork because the cryptozoologists won the day again.
 
A creationist would have no problem with Champs now living in the lake.

I wonder what they would think about Bigfoot. Creationists might not feel obligated to try to explain Bigfoot origins in terms of ancestral migration from Asia or a lack of fossil evidence.

Can we get a showing of hands of Creationists in Cryptozoology?
WP, that abstraction is not our problem. Bio-funkety-clicks is a problem, if they're real. Lake creatures are not a necessary. Something, human or otherwise are.
 
I'm just telling you about the cryptozoologists who are not going away soon. ;)

I haven't even checked your links yet.
 
The Most Likely Culprit

The only known animals to utilize echo-location underwater are whales and dolphins. The readings were noted to be somewhere between belugas (I got a cool story about them) and orcas (killers).
The only actual animal to utilize echo-location in freshwater is the river dolphin, or blind dolphin, if I'm correct. This animal needs to be considered firstly, and analyzed and compared to the Champ readings. No matter how far fetched, that is the only known animal to fit the bill.
(Hehe) Maybe we could use a brazilian river dolphin's recorded echo-location as a comparison, just disregard the 'a cha cha cha' at the end.
 
Got This Covered Too

There is no need for evidence when you can simply propose that echolocation could have evolved anywhere in the animal kingdom and at any time. Oilbirds echolocate and they evolved from dinosaurs. Bang zoom... you've got a genuine echolocating Champ living in the lake. Somebody pop a cork because the cryptozoologists won the day again.

How about a proto-mammalian?
 
Or a true mammal. If you propose that they really did record echolocation clicks from a Champ - you don't have to then lock yourself into any particular branch of the animal "tree". Dinosaur, reptile, amphibian, fish, bird, mammal... just take your pick. Fish and bird seem out-of-place until somebody mentions lungfish and penguins.
 
Or a true mammal. If you propose that they really did record echolocation clicks from a Champ - you don't have to then lock yourself into any particular branch of the animal "tree". Dinosaur, reptile, amphibian, fish, bird, mammal... just take your pick. Fish and bird seem out-of-place until somebody mentions lungfish and penguins.

I saw the show. The people operating the sonar detectors seemed to be working under the premise that perhaps Champ is some type of cetacean. It's extremely far fetched, but at least not completely impossible -- whales once lived in the Champlain Sea, the post-Ice Age forerunner to Lake Champlain. (Due to ground depression caused by the weight of the receding ice, the Champlain Valley was directly connected to the Atlantic via what is now the Saint Lawrence River.) They even dug up a complete whale skeleton in Charlotte, VT, which caused more than a little confusion when they found it back in the 19th century.

Of course, you have to accept the possibility that a breeding population of whales have lived in Champlain now for 10,000+ years without ever once having a fresh carcass float ashore, get caught in a fishing line, stay still long enough to be photographed, etc. You also have to wonder how air-breathing mammals survive in a lake that gets completely frozen over every winter. But at least the idea makes more sense than pleiosaurs.
 
You'd also have to wonder what they eat in a lake whose fish population has been devestated by acid rain for the past 40 or 50 years.
 
Got My Helmet On Now

I saw the show. The people operating the sonar detectors seemed to be working under the premise that perhaps Champ is some type of cetacean. It's extremely far fetched, but at least not completely impossible -- whales once lived in the Champlain Sea, the post-Ice Age forerunner to Lake Champlain. (Due to ground depression caused by the weight of the receding ice, the Champlain Valley was directly connected to the Atlantic via what is now the Saint Lawrence River.) They even dug up a complete whale skeleton in Charlotte, VT, which caused more than a little confusion when they found it back in the 19th century.
.

Hibernating blind dolphins? That's too much for me even. Unless perhaps not all the lake is completely frozen? They would have to maintain a spot during the freeze over.

Or, do narwhals use echo-location? Maybe they could drill through the ice and breath through the hole created. :)

My son trained at Lake Placid and said there was supposed to be one there also. Are those lakes connected?
 
Last edited:
A few years ago, a whale carcas (beluga, IIRC) was found near Fairbanks, AK, about 1000 river miles from the ocean. Any evidence of echolocation in any freshwater body connected to the ocean must rule out whales visiting from the ocean before speculating on other possible sources, in my not-so-humble opinion.

-David
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom