Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Nope. But applying my experience I can intelligently say that I could definitely hit a speed boat that was 100meters away.

Actual experence of people who've tried it both in training (egypt) and warzones (allies trying to hit linse control boats) strongly suggest your confidence is missplaced.

You are also forgetting that its not like I would be taking one shot at the damn thing. I would have multiple magazines and the target would get even easier the closer it got to the boat.

You would plan on relevealing your position much befor the boat got close to point blank range? Risky.

Please stop trying to comment on marksmanship when you obviously are VERY inexperienced in the matter.

Zee irony it is painful.
 
Actual experence of people who've tried it both in training (egypt) and warzones (allies trying to hit linse control boats) strongly suggest your confidence is missplaced.

Please direct me to some links for this statement.

You would plan on relevealing your position much befor the boat got close to point blank range? Risky.

Revealing my position? What are you talking about now? We were discussing how hard it would be to hit a boat at 100m. I told you. I also informed you that it would be easier to hit when it got closer. For some reason you went off on a tangent about revealing my position. Again, you have no experience in this matter.
 
Shooting from a small moving dinghy with NO cover and at a lower elevation is a HUGE disadvantage especially when your target has cover.

Modern civilian ships do not provide much in the way of meaningful cover against RPG-7 rounds (well not for anywhere you could usefuly shoot from) which have annoying area of effect issues. There is a reason the RPG-7 has proven so popular even in places where armour is uncommon.

Please stop trying to comment about tactics, you really don't know what you are talking about.

It's pretty clear that you've never studdied the history of small boat combat but hey.
 
Modern civilian ships do not provide much in the way of meaningful cover against RPG-7 rounds (well not for anywhere you could usefuly shoot from) which have annoying area of effect issues. There is a reason the RPG-7 has proven so popular even in places where armour is uncommon.

Here we are talking about Rifles and you bring RPG7s into the matter attempting to avoid the fact that you are WRONG. By the way I would LOVE to see you shoot an RPG with any sort of accuracy from a moving dinghy. And how many of these pirates have boarded any ships with RPGs so far?


It's pretty clear that you've never studdied the history of small boat combat but hey.

We are talking about rifle marksmanship here, not small boat combat.
 
Please direct me to some links for this statement.

Egyptain experence gets mentioned in James Dyson's autobiography of all places (he sold them the boats).

Linse get covered in Lawrence Paterson's "Weapons of Desperation German Frogmen and Midget Submarines of World War II". Fortunetly the germans were never much good at handleing the expolsive ones so were mostly a risk to themselves. Good read if you want to know how not to build midget submarines.


Revealing my position? What are you talking about now? We were discussing how hard it would be to hit a boat at 100m. I told you. I also informed you that it would be easier to hit when it got closer. For some reason you went off on a tangent about revealing my position. Again, you have no experience in this matter.

Niether do you. Difference is I admit this and base my position off recorded incerdents.
 
Modern civilian ships do not provide much in the way of meaningful cover against RPG-7 rounds (well not for anywhere you could usefuly shoot from) which have annoying area of effect issues. There is a reason the RPG-7 has proven so popular even in places where armour is uncommon.

I'm not sure bringing RPG-7s into it is a good idea. Firstly, many of the ships we're talking about are container ships, and a loaded container would be an excellent defense against an RPG, secondly, the effective range of an RPG-7 is less than that of an assault rifle.
 
Egyptain experence gets mentioned in James Dyson's autobiography of all places (he sold them the boats).

Linse get covered in Lawrence Paterson's "Weapons of Desperation German Frogmen and Midget Submarines of World War II". Fortunetly the germans were never much good at handleing the expolsive ones so were mostly a risk to themselves. Good read if you want to know how not to build midget submarines.

In which one of these incidents were pirates attempting to board a much larger ship and the people on the ship were shooting rifles at them?

Niether do you. Difference is I admit this and base my position off recorded incerdents.

Actually yes, I do. If you knew even the basics of rifle marksmanship you would understand the concepts we are talking about. But since you don't, its probably best you stop commenting as to avoid digger yourself a larger hole than you already have.
 
A boat, however maneuverable it may be, is not as maneuverable as a human being, and regular infantry are trained to hit moving human targets at 300m.

Western infantry anyway but that doesn't really apply to crews on ships.

Now I don't actualy know offhand of any cases of regular western infantry engaging such targets (seals I think can be assumed to better than regular western infantry). Cases we do know about suggest that people below the level of Western infantry find them to be rather hard targets.
 
Cases we do know about suggest that people below the level of Western infantry find them to be rather hard targets.

You really are going to have to start providing evidence for these claims.
 
I'm not sure bringing RPG-7s into it is a good idea. Firstly, many of the ships we're talking about are container ships, and a loaded container would be an excellent defense against an RPG,

Indeed. Problem is you can't really shoot from behind a container.

secondly, the effective range of an RPG-7 is less than that of an assault rifle.

How are you defineing effective range here? In only moderately trained hands the area of effect of an RPG-7 tends to give it a better range.l
 
Western infantry anyway but that doesn't really apply to crews on ships.


No, these people would need to be trained. You might be surprised how little training is actually required.
 
In which one of these incidents were pirates attempting to board a much larger ship and the people on the ship were shooting rifles at them?

Both are cases where speed boats were engaged by regular militry personel. If you find WW2 and the 1970s to be too far back we could perhaps consider the sea tigers.


Actually yes, I do. If you knew even the basics of rifle marksmanship you would understand the concepts we are talking about. But since you don't, its probably best you stop commenting as to avoid digger yourself a larger hole than you already have.

Your statement makes no sense in the context. Or are you claiming to be baseing your position on engaments between rifle armed individuals with training below modern western levels and people in speedboats? If you are which engagements are you baseing your position on?
 
Both are cases where speed boats were engaged by regular militry personel. If you find WW2 and the 1970s to be too far back we could perhaps consider the sea tigers.

Again, I am not seeing ANY links only you talking about things and not providing evidence.

Your statement makes no sense in the context. Or are you claiming to be baseing your position on engaments between rifle armed individuals with training below modern western levels and people in speedboats? If you are which engagements are you baseing your position on?

I am saying that I have extensive knowledge and training in rifle marksmanship and know exactly what it takes to hit a target. I am also saying that you have none of this experience and cannot intelligently comment on this subject and should probably stop attempting to do so.
 
No, these people would need to be trained. You might be surprised how little training is actually required.

The availible evidence suggests a fair bit. Remember regular egytptian forces couldn't do it in the 70s. The LTTE fast attack boats gave the Sri Lankan Navy a hard time.

Now neither of those are first class outfits but it suggests a non trivial time investment would be needed.
 
Indeed. Problem is you can't really shoot from behind a container.

No but you can duck behind one, then pop back out, and so forth.



How are you defineing effective range here? In only moderately trained hands the area of effect of an RPG-7 tends to give it a better range.l


Effective range? That's generally held to be the range at which the weapon can effectively be brought to bear on a target with relative accuracy. From about 100m onwards an RPG-7s accuracy drops by about 50% every 100m.

When it has been most effectively used (the Mujahideen in Afghanistan and the Somali militia in the early 1990s) it was through RPG-spamming - firing hundreds of rounds at once at the same target, in the hope that one of them hits.

That's hardly a practical tactic for Somali pirates.

The problem is, as follows. To deter the defenders, the pirates have to actually hit or injure the defenders themselves. That's a small target - man-sized.

In contrast, to deter the attacks, the defenders only have to hit the attackers' boat - a much larger target.

I think pirates are smart enough to think ahead. If they're taking rifle fire at 300m distance from the ship, what is it going to be like while they're clambering up the side of the ship? What's it going to be like when they try to storm the bridge?

It's funny that all of the discussion has thus far revolved around trying to shoot at boats at 100m distance or greater. That's only the very first step in capturing a ship. Until the bridge is taken, the ship is still defended.

If you had half a dozen guys on the ship giving the pirates disciplined rifle fire at 100m range, I honestly cannot see the pirates pressing the attack. They'd quickly realise their odds of taking the bridge were nil.

Now, the flip side of all of this is what is it going to cost the shipping company to get half a dozen trained shooters on the ship with ammunition? Extra training? Weapons and ammunition? Increased insurance? Mercenaries? Increased wages? Additional crew? More living costs for crew?

And what's the cost of having your ship taken? Increased insurance? Danger pay for crew? Delayed delivery of shipment?

I want to be clear here. I am fairly certain that, within a reasonable budget, shipping companies could provide security details on their ships that could easily keep off all but the most tenacious of pirates. I think anyone who is arguing the impossibility of that is just not thinking realistically.

However.

I am also fairly certain that shipping companies simply don't consider the cost worth it, and I think anyone arguing it is worth it probably likewise isn't thinking realistically.
 
Again, I am not seeing ANY links only you talking about things and not providing evidence.

Links? Not everthing is online. Again:

Egyptain experence gets mentioned in James Dyson's autobiography (Against the Odds: An Autobiography).

Linse get covered in Lawrence Paterson's "Weapons of Desperation German Frogmen and Midget Submarines of World War II".

What more do you want ISBN numbers?
1587991705 and 9781861762795

I am saying that I have extensive knowledge and training in rifle marksmanship and know exactly what it takes to hit a target.

Well I don't actualy belive you there but it's of no importance. If you do not understand the nature of the target that experence means little.
 
There's a lot of chest-beating going on here.

To geni: yes, infantry can probably get some effective hits in were some pirates approaching their vessel. I know current and former members of the Army, Air Force, and Marines who could hit a small boat approaching at fairly high speeds. It might take half a dozen shots before they landed a good hit, and some of these guys are a couple decades out of service, but hit it they would.

To the others: there's no guarantee that the pirates would roll over after being shot at. If they knew they were being shot at by military, maybe. Being shot at from the merchant ships, not so sure.
 
To the others: there's no guarantee that the pirates would roll over after being shot at. If they knew they were being shot at by military, maybe. Being shot at from the merchant ships, not so sure.

This is where i think you are being unreasonable. I think it is a bit crazy to think that pirates would still try to board a ship while being shot at from 100m, 300m or whatever. Military or not, having bullets shot at you is a scary thing. To think that they would STILL have to try and throw hooks onto the boat and climb up it WHILE being shot at at almost point blank range with no cover is ridiculous. For a few pirates who are looking for easy targets, I think they would turn tail at the first gunshots.
 
The availible evidence suggests a fair bit.

I'm talking about how much training is required to bring a person up to a high level of marksmanship with an assault rifle.


Remember regular egytptian forces couldn't do it in the 70s. The LTTE fast attack boats gave the Sri Lankan Navy a hard time.


I can't find very much information on this Egyptian training you're referring to but the example of the Sea Tigers is a poor one. The Sea Tigers were using highly sophisticated tactics, had a totally different goal in mind, and were using substantially superior equipment to these Somali Pirates. I just don't see a comparison.

Typical Somali pirate vessel.

Typical Sea Tiger vessels.

I don't think you can compare these.

(Also the Sea Tigers only achieved real success taking on the small inshore patrol vessel that are pretty much the same sort of thing the Tigers themselves are using)
 
To the others: there's no guarantee that the pirates would roll over after being shot at. If they knew they were being shot at by military, maybe. Being shot at from the merchant ships, not so sure.
Why? Do bullets fired by a crew member do less damage than one fired by a marine?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom