E-Mail from David Chandler

Savitzky-Golay, Poly (10) and Poly (50) are three different methods of smoothing that produce somewhat different results, as shown in the graph.

"NIST" means the derivative of NIST's nonlinear fit curve given in the WTC7 report.

ETA: In short, the graph shows that the acceleration does not increase instantly to g.

That's mostly an artifact of the smoothing. With better analysis, it's easy to see the onset of acceleration was considerably quicker than you'd conclude from that graph.
 
That's mostly an artifact of the smoothing. With better analysis, it's easy to see the onset of acceleration was considerably quicker than you'd conclude from that graph.

Still not instantaneous, especially since the interior collapsed first. It is by no means a step function.

ETA: I took it as you meaning transition to g, however now I see you said onset of acceleration. In either case, interior collapse first precedes the acceleration onset.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the explanation, pgimeno.

A few points about the 'is he lying' issue: 'essentially instantly' is rather vague and doesn't necessarily preclude his meaning a definite (short) period of time. We would have to check with David Chandler for clarification.

I don't suppose that by 'instantaneous freefall' he means that if you measured the instantaneous velocity at any point within this 'protacted period' then you'd get a value that is at, or very close to g? Rather than meaning instantaneously initiated freefall?

Is it possible that the smoothing process has produced these faster than g values? I tried to read the wikipedia article on Savitsky-Golay smoothing but I don't know enough mathematics to understand it. What I'm asking is can it be said conclusively from the 'Dan Rather' graph that the NW corner of building 7 definitely attained greater than g acceleration and that it cannot be an erroneous value caused by the smoothing process?
 
Thanks for the explanation, pgimeno.

A few points about the 'is he lying' issue: 'essentially instantly' is rather vague and doesn't necessarily preclude his meaning a definite (short) period of time. We would have to check with David Chandler for clarification.

I don't suppose that by 'instantaneous freefall' he means that if you measured the instantaneous velocity at any point within this 'protacted period' then you'd get a value that is at, or very close to g? Rather than meaning instantaneously initiated freefall?

Is it possible that the smoothing process has produced these faster than g values? I tried to read the wikipedia article on Savitsky-Golay smoothing but I don't know enough mathematics to understand it. What I'm asking is can it be said conclusively from the 'Dan Rather' graph that the NW corner of building 7 definitely attained greater than g acceleration and that it cannot be an erroneous value caused by the smoothing process?

Forget about the S-G smoothing (seriously - we spent endless pages of debate on it that will drive your skull to mush, and are making me totally regret introducing a graph with it).

Just know that there are points where the acceleration could have exceeded free fall, and probably did by different smoothing techniques, The acceleration was so jumpy, and not - I repeat not - measurably constant.

Periods of at g, above g, can all be explained by unassisted collapse dynamics. That is because the inside of the building collapsed first.

When you are looking at the video, you are not looking at the entire building, you are just looking at it's exterior, during what Chamdler terms a sudden onset. Watch a full video collapse, and the penthouses on top of the building collapse first. This is critical, and a point Chandler will hand wave away, because it steals his thunder.

The interior is not disconnected from the exterior, so when it collapses, it puts a load on the exterior at the top, and the debris impacts it at the bottom. The bottom of the exterior breaks at some point, and down it goes, with the load of the interior still applied. This additional force, applied in addition to the pull of gravity on the exterior, can make the exterior accelerate at and over free fall. No explosives required.

Chandler is lying, because the transition to g is not instantaneous. He is also lying, because he does not have a graph showing steady free fall - no one does, or even can produce one that isn't artificial.

Above all, he is lying when he says that free fall or above acceleration of the shell of a collapsing building can only be caused by explosive removal of support. Simple stack up of forces shows otherwise. Simple physics - the kind you teach at the high school level.
 
Last edited:
Just know that there are points where the acceleration could have exceeded free fall, and probably did by different smoothing techniques, The acceleration was so jumpy, and not - I repeat not - measurably constant.
What definitely convinced me was that, in a certain period of about 1s, the mean acceleration (measured by doing a quadratic regression on the displacement data) exceeded g by a non-negligible amount. 34.something ft/s², I think. I can provide the data, if necessary.
 
What definitely convinced me was that, in a certain period of about 1s, the mean acceleration (measured by doing a quadratic regression on the displacement data) exceeded g by a non-negligible amount. 34.something ft/s², I think. I can provide the data, if necessary.

Yes, I like to qualify it, because there is a certain amount of error inherent in the measurement system of position and time that amplifies when you get to the second derivative (acceleration).
 
. As we've been told time and again by Truthers, CD uses explosives to "simultaneously remove all support", so any motion prior to his selected initiation time cannot be explained via these proposed explosives.

Once again, they don't even realize they're arguing against their own hypothesis.

Yes.

And even if the 1.75s of <g acceleration had been caused by a misreading of 'horizontal flexure' then simple trig would tell you that would be a huge amount of flexure progressing at an impossible horizontal rate. With no known mechanism to cause it.

Total bull.
 
Yes.

And even if the 1.75s of <g acceleration had been caused by a misreading of 'horizontal flexure' then simple trig would tell you that would be a huge amount of flexure progressing at an impossible horizontal rate. With no known mechanism to cause it.

Total bull.

Yes, and it doesn't matter because they can make up as many 'flux capacitor' style ways to jimmy in CD, it's pointless. That is because the simplest reason, the interior leveraging the exterior, fully explains all observations. CD is just not required to match what we saw.


And heard (no matter how far ahead of the collapse it was heard, and what stairwell it was heard in.)
 
Last edited:
Forget about the S-G smoothing (seriously - we spent endless pages of debate on it that will drive your skull to mush, (and are making me totally regret introducing a graph with it).

Just know that there are points where the acceleration could have exceeded free fall, and probably did by different smoothing techniques, The acceleration was so jumpy, and not - I repeat not - measurably constant.

Periods of at g, above g, can all be explained by unassisted collapse dynamics. That is because the inside of the building collapsed first.

When you are looking at the video, you are not looking at the entire building, you are just looking at it's exterior, during what Chandler terms a sudden onset.

Watch a full video collapse, and the penthouses on top of the building collapse first.

This is critical, and a point Chandler will hand wave away, because it steals his thunder.

The interior is not disconnected from the exterior, so when it collapses, it puts a load on the exterior at the top, and the debris impacts it at the bottom.

The bottom of the exterior breaks at some point, and down it goes, with the load of the interior still applied.

This additional force, applied in addition to the pull of gravity on the exterior, can make the exterior accelerate at and over free fall. No explosives required.

Awesome over simplification.

I love the part where you talk about how the interior is connected to the exterior.

But amazingly in spite of all this connectivity to the exterior, the collapsing column 79, and the plummeting East Penthouse of WTC7, do little more than produce some minor window breakage on the north face.

Col79_zpsd0dc9a41.png


WTC7Floor_zps00447482.png


WTC7EPenthouse_zps2faa672d.png


WTC7Freefall_zps4c564267.png


Supposedly at a lower level, fires have somehow induced all the south, east, west, north, and internal core columns for 8 storeys to fail in unison and allow this symmetrical D R O P.

Talk about an Emperor's New Clothes scenario.
 
Awesome over simplification.

I love the part where you talk about how the interior is connected to the exterior.

But amazingly in spite of all this connectivity to the exterior, the collapsing column 79, and the plummeting East Penthouse of WTC7, do little more than produce some minor window breakage on the north face.


So, what happened to the penthouses? Did a "space-beam" vaporize them or were they holograms?

Too funny.
 
But amazingly in spite of all this connectivity to the exterior, the collapsing column 79, and the plummeting East Penthouse of WTC7, do little more than produce some minor window breakage on the north face.
What should have happened instead?

Why that would not have happened if it was CD?
 
Awesome over simplification.

I love the part where you talk about how the interior is connected to the exterior.

But amazingly in spite of all this connectivity to the exterior, the collapsing column 79, and the plummeting East Penthouse of WTC7, do little more than produce some minor window breakage on the north face.

Supposedly at a lower level, fires have somehow induced all the south, east, west, north, and internal core columns for 8 storeys to fail in unison and allow this symmetrical D R O P.

Talk about an Emperor's New Clothes scenario.

You know what's funny? Not understanding that a Moment Frame holds a building exterior together, despite it being pointed out several times.:rolleyes:

Or thinking intact windows can't happen when the inside of a building collapses, yet are perfectly fine with several stories of simultaneous explosions.:boggled:

Or still running away from ackowledging that Free Fall can't be shown to have occured for more than a moment at a time (if even that), and can be perfectly explained by a simple answer.:cool:
 
I love the part where you talk about how the interior is connected to the exterior.

But amazingly in spite of all this connectivity to the exterior, the collapsing column 79, and the plummeting East Penthouse of WTC7, do little more than produce some minor window breakage on the north face.

Earlier you mentioned that your area of expertise was video production. At the time I asked you whether you had any formal training or experience in structural mechanics, such that your opinion of what the expected result should be would have some foundation.

Will you please answer that question?
 
Supposedly at a lower level, fires have somehow induced all the south, east, west, north, and internal core columns for 8 storeys to fail in unison and allow this symmetrical D R O P.

7 WTC fell in 3 distinct stages. Nothing symmetrical about it.

Next
 
Minor breakage of a few windows, plus loss of the east penthouse structure, plus the top to bottom of visible structure kink and leaning in towards said kink of all levels. All minor details.
 
But amazingly in spite of all this connectivity to the exterior, the collapsing column 79, and the plummeting East Penthouse of WTC7, do little more than produce some minor window breakage on the north face.

What are you trying to say, exactly? That the small window damage proves that the East Penthouse didn't drop? Was it a hologram? Or made of paper-mache? Or that it stopped at one of the top storeys? Have truthers given up on even trying to make sense? :boggled:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom