E-Mail from David Chandler

Trojan

Muse
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
512
Location
Pittsburgh
On another forum, I am in a discussion with one of the AE911 engineering petition signers regarding free fall implications and Richard the Gage claiming WTC 7 feel in 6.5 seconds. The petition signer has been in contact wtih Chandler and posted this e-mail he received from Chandler.


What I know is --NIST was tracking WTC7 from Camera 3, with a viewing angle looking up at the building. This made the initial horizontal flexure ambiguous, which they intentionally misconstrued to be vertical motion. This became the basis of their artificially early starting point. It also provided the early departure from a static situation which could round out the initiation time. In fact the motion of the building transitioned from rest to freefall essentially instantly, as viewed from a camera level with the roofline. --The curve they imposed on the data is meaningless apart from being a rather bad empirical curve fit. It doesn't fit the data in phase 3, and the data in phase 1 is erroneous, as mentioned above. --I have repeatedly implored Richard Gage to quit citing the total fall time. It is irrelevant to the physics. It is the fact of a protracted period of instantaneous freefall that is dynamically relevant. During the period of freefall the building is doing no work, so the loss of support had to have been caused by other events. The fact that the freefall had sudden onset is inconsistent with buckling because some shortening would have to occur to get the geometry right to reduce the resistance to near zero. By the way, even while buckling the resistance would not actually be zero.

:boggled:
 
Basically "I declare that NIST starts their initiation so as to suit their needs, and I would rather start it at a time that better suits my claims".
Sure........why would an investigation into the collapse start at the time of the collapse? Why NIST chose to look at the events starting at 8:46 am I could never guess. :rolleyes:
 
I think its interesting that Chandler and Gage do not agree on a point (significance of collapse time for WTC 7).
 
Chandler may understand high school physics, but he doesn't know anything about structural dynamics.



I love how he casually dismisses "the initial horizontal flexure", as if such flexure (visible from blocks away!) is nothing out of the ordinary for a 47-story building, and couldn't possibly have any impact on, or be indicative of, what might be happening elsewhere in the building.

And it's also interesting to note that, while the "progressive collapse" hypothesis can explain this motion, the "controlled demolition" hypothesis can't. As we've been told time and again by Truthers, CD uses explosives to "simultaneously remove all support", so any motion prior to his selected initiation time cannot be explained via these proposed explosives.

Once again, they don't even realize they're arguing against their own hypothesis.
 
Can you back that up, please?

This is a lie: "In fact the motion of the building transitioned from rest to freefall essentially instantly, as viewed from a camera level with the roofline"

As is this:
"It is the fact of a protracted period of instantaneous freefall that is dynamically relevant."

The transition to g took a definite period of time, and there was no sustained period of acceleration at g.

513801604.png
 
All one needs to know about Chandler is he is so delusional he thinks he can magically divine intent based on no evidence whatsoever.
 
This is a lie: "In fact the motion of the building transitioned from rest to freefall essentially instantly, as viewed from a camera level with the roofline"

As is this:
"It is the fact of a protracted period of instantaneous freefall that is dynamically relevant."

The transition to g took a definite period of time, and there was no sustained period of acceleration at g.

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/513801604.png[/qimg]
Thanks for responding. I'm afraid I don't know what Savitsky-Golay smoothing, Poly(50) or Poly(10) are, or what 'NIST' or 'Dan Rather' are referring to in this graph.
 
Thanks for responding. I'm afraid I don't know what Savitsky-Golay smoothing, Poly(50) or Poly(10) are, or what 'NIST' or 'Dan Rather' are referring to in this graph.
'Dan Rather' is the name used to reference the video where the data was extracted from.

It means this video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XL3kL0nXZvk
(minute 1:13 approx)

From that video (a higher quality one, I believe), raw vertical position trace data of the NW corner of WTC7 was extracted by forum member femr2, and acceleration was derived from said data.

The raw acceleration data, however, is unusable. It needs some treatment to make it usable, because there's too much noise in the original position data from which it is derived (the acceleration goes to absurd values of about ±1600 ft/s²). The treatment needed is called smoothing.

Savitzky-Golay, Poly (10) and Poly (50) are three different methods of smoothing that produce somewhat different results, as shown in the graph.

"NIST" means the derivative of NIST's nonlinear fit curve given in the WTC7 report.

ETA: In short, the graph shows that the acceleration does not increase instantly to g.
 
Last edited:
'Dan Rather' is the name used to reference the video where the data was extracted from.

It means this video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XL3kL0nXZvk
(minute 1:13 approx)

From that video (a higher quality one, I believe), raw trace data was extracted by forum member femr2, and acceleration was derived from said data.

The raw acceleration data, however, is unusable. It needs some treatment to make it usable, because there's too much noise in the original position data from which it is derived (the acceleration goes to absurd values of about ±1600 ft/s²). The treatment needed is called smoothing.

Savitzky-Golay, Poly (10) and Poly (50) are three different methods of smoothing that produce somewhat different results, as shown in the graph.

"NIST" means the derivative of NIST's nonlinear fit curve given in the WTC7 report.

ETA: In short, the graph shows that the acceleration does not increase instantly to g.

Thanks, a good explanation. Also, I'd like to highlight, that since the raw acceleration is unusable because it bounces all over, no one can say there is a "protracted period of instantaneous free fall". Chandler should know this, hence he is lying. If he doesn't know it, then he should not be teaching physics to young impressionable minds.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom