Merged Discussion of femr's video data analysis

Did you not read even the first sentence of Oysteins post ? ...

I did. I wonder. (and presented my challenge) in the response to my thought of "what's the point".

I think of it this way:
I witness a car crash where someone runs a stop sign and plows someone in the intersection. The accident report says the person that ran the sign left 100' of skid marks and was going 50mph. I go back to the scene and measure he only left 80' of marks and likely was only going 40 MPH. Does this change the fact he ran the stop sign?

Unless you can show what use your data is, the dude still ran the stop sign. :)
 
I don't.

If the data, analysis, discussion, results, conclusions...are of no use to you, ignore them.
Ten years from now when someone figures out how to combine all videos into one in 3d. Is your data then no good? Would you question how this extra precision matters?

femr2, I have no problem with your data. Now tell us how it should be used.
 
...femr2, I have no problem with your data. Now tell us how it should be used.
Aren't analogies fun toys to play with? ;)

I am often engaged to measure up retail trading tenancies so that they can be fitted out for retail shop front branches of a travel agency. Given the ways that shop furnishing are installed a couple of inches is near enough accuracy. I try for less than one inch - can be difficult when buildings not square and walls not straight and...etc. etc...

I sometimes have access to property outlines measured to land survey accuracy .
I have tape measures.
I have a laser distance measuring device.

I sometimes resort to a folded piece of paper as a template for "funny angles" - backed by triangulation cross tie measurements.

It is my call as to which device or combination of devices I use.

I don't see the need for the laser device manufacturer (Leitz) to tell me when I should use it.
Ditto "Stanley" for the tape measure;
Or "Reflex" for the paper.

...and to tighten up my use of the analogy a bit -- If I have surveyors data and "I have no problem with [his/her] data" I don't ask him/her how I should use it. ;)
 
You can't do this. This was my idea do you are stealing it. Come up with your own original insults.
It's one of the secondary signs of the decline of interest in 9/11 discussion Scott. No real discussion of the primary technical 9/11 matters for about a year. The ongoing technical issues being:

a) The several "thermXte in the dust" threads - which are of secondary importance at best. (there was no CD therefore thermXte in dust, even if true, is irrelevant. And, yes, that logic is correct despite the obvious "Yes but!" comeback. ;) )
b) The couple of NIST wuz wrong and femr2 measurement related threads where the actual OP topics are of primary importance because they are directly related to the collapses which did happen. (Same logic as for thermXte above..i.e. directly related is more important than unrelated.) But all those threads the OP is being swamped by personal attacks or attempted censorship of "move it to science" by those members who cannot match the level of discussion required.

The last "decent technical debate" I recall was the one about Col79 in WTC7 - and even there both sides got lost -- :o

Then the limits of Bazant's applicability thread a couple of years back.

All downhill since then. The party is over. Most serious debaters have withdrawn.

Against that scenario your reflections on a confused poe/troll who cannot decide which he is.

We have seen a steady decline in the quality of trolling. The days when trolls would make their points with clever humour long gone. Blunt dishonest insult becoming the norm for newcomer trolls.

(Edited out - the comment about "Why do we still feed trolls....:()
 
In a different thread, BasqueArch suggested "calibrating" the first seconds of trace data to 0:

The period 1(s)-6(s) should be recalibrated to produce a flat line 0 acceleration. This adjustment should be applied to the subsequent data (displacement,time) to see what the more accurate adjusted acceleration line would look like. A vertical line indicating the start of the east PH fall and the start of the NW corner fall would help.

While that is not possible, there are techniques that allow something similar. I said:

I'm thinking a sort of bandstop filter might be useful. Measure the frequencies/amplitudes of the noise in a section assumed to be static, then attenuate the same frequencies in the whole graph by about these amplitudes. It destroys data too, but at least it could respect other frequencies, and even part of these, if they are attenuated by these amounts instead of eliminated.

I don't have the tools to try it though; I only have two possibilities. The only program I have available for Fourier analysis and filtering is Audacity; the idea would be to convert the trace data to a 16-bit audio-like signal and process it like that. The second is making my own program. The first feels like it wouldn't work very well and would be imprecise. For the second, my ratio motivation/estimated effort doesn't pass the threshold.

It turns out that Audacity also handles floating-point 32-bit (single precision) data. So I went ahead and converted the Dan Rather DJ Y data from http://femr2.ucoz.com/load/0-0-0-29-20 to Audacity, dividing it by 341.0 first so it was normalized to -1..1, and applied Audacity's Noise Removal filter. Overall details of this filter are here:
http://wiki.audacityteam.org/wiki/Noise_Removal
and more technical details are here:
http://wiki.audacityteam.org/wiki/How_Noise_Removal_Works

I selected the first 600 samples of data as the silence reference, then applied the filter to the whole sample. The input parameters were:

Noise Reduction: 16 dB
Smoothing: 50 Hz
Attack/Decay: 0.05

Then multiplied the output data by 341 again. Here are the 1031 output values, that will hopefully work as a CSV file.


"0.000000"
"-0.000000"
"-0.000001"
"-0.000004"
"-0.000007"
"-0.000010"
"-0.000020"
"0.000015"
"0.000017"
"0.000022"
"0.000054"
"0.000070"
"0.000098"
"0.000174"
"0.000194"
"0.000194"
"0.000204"
"0.000191"
"0.000209"
"0.000224"
"0.000229"
"0.000242"
"0.000258"
"0.000284"
"0.000293"
"-0.000115"
"-0.000067"
"0.000432"
"0.000473"
"0.000537"
"0.000564"
"0.000602"
"0.000564"
"0.000550"
"0.000681"
"0.000853"
"0.000854"
"0.000645"
"0.000863"
"0.001145"
"0.001233"
"0.001433"
"0.001704"
"0.001877"
"0.001736"
"0.001640"
"0.001716"
"0.002164"
"0.002169"
"-0.000670"
"-0.000077"
"0.001094"
"0.000604"
"0.002190"
"0.002086"
"0.000525"
"0.000764"
"-0.001724"
"-0.001344"
"0.000143"
"-0.000530"
"-0.002358"
"-0.002546"
"-0.002027"
"-0.002158"
"-0.002353"
"-0.002750"
"-0.000847"
"-0.000591"
"-0.004105"
"-0.004688"
"-0.004708"
"-0.004124"
"-0.004002"
"-0.003141"
"-0.002084"
"-0.002456"
"-0.001047"
"-0.000997"
"-0.004773"
"-0.004554"
"-0.005864"
"-0.005556"
"-0.004950"
"-0.005128"
"-0.003276"
"-0.001980"
"-0.000982"
"-0.001228"
"-0.003141"
"-0.003644"
"-0.002655"
"-0.002117"
"-0.002259"
"-0.004361"
"-0.004415"
"-0.004756"
"-0.005095"
"-0.003952"
"-0.005022"
"-0.005126"
"-0.002836"
"-0.001808"
"-0.001086"
"-0.001774"
"0.000102"
"-0.000205"
"-0.001661"
"-0.001734"
"0.002644"
"0.002761"
"-0.001698"
"-0.003045"
"0.001003"
"-0.000518"
"-0.010031"
"-0.011404"
"-0.015826"
"-0.016159"
"-0.009936"
"-0.009809"
"-0.006772"
"-0.008270"
"-0.005536"
"-0.003579"
"-0.011672"
"-0.011320"
"-0.008656"
"-0.008237"
"-0.008280"
"-0.008274"
"0.004736"
"0.004646"
"0.013421"
"0.013928"
"0.029346"
"0.029297"
"0.021925"
"0.020583"
"0.006134"
"0.003690"
"-0.017787"
"-0.019775"
"-0.003340"
"-0.007519"
"-0.015488"
"-0.017427"
"-0.001137"
"0.003297"
"0.002693"
"0.006736"
"-0.013967"
"-0.012782"
"-0.000599"
"-0.001320"
"0.002042"
"-0.001446"
"0.004658"
"0.005092"
"0.008607"
"0.011570"
"0.014302"
"0.016142"
"-0.004967"
"-0.001635"
"-0.035997"
"-0.035301"
"-0.049460"
"-0.049872"
"-0.045934"
"-0.047831"
"-0.036852"
"-0.035505"
"-0.033889"
"-0.029637"
"-0.033727"
"-0.021407"
"-0.019733"
"-0.059587"
"-0.062760"
"-0.072477"
"-0.077495"
"-0.042247"
"-0.043274"
"-0.038517"
"-0.044041"
"-0.040284"
"-0.028307"
"-0.020843"
"-0.018367"
"-0.068792"
"-0.062753"
"-0.053304"
"-0.060316"
"-0.057620"
"-0.064355"
"-0.036366"
"-0.039065"
"-0.043165"
"-0.041661"
"-0.032566"
"-0.022716"
"-0.037101"
"-0.041085"
"-0.041282"
"-0.035874"
"-0.025089"
"-0.033341"
"-0.037834"
"-0.042965"
"-0.044463"
"-0.047639"
"-0.047454"
"-0.049483"
"-0.040395"
"-0.035241"
"-0.056180"
"-0.050346"
"-0.047922"
"-0.051963"
"-0.042904"
"-0.036980"
"-0.048485"
"-0.061455"
"-0.055990"
"-0.050335"
"-0.047916"
"-0.053226"
"-0.049937"
"-0.046530"
"-0.071882"
"-0.067642"
"-0.041943"
"-0.053255"
"-0.053803"
"-0.053881"
"-0.052358"
"-0.030739"
"-0.026503"
"-0.038938"
"-0.036642"
"-0.042620"
"-0.108571"
"-0.105064"
"-0.039041"
"-0.039153"
"-0.049842"
"-0.048069"
"-0.068166"
"-0.078634"
"-0.080987"
"-0.100923"
"-0.081936"
"-0.070952"
"-0.062486"
"-0.066137"
"-0.091260"
"-0.085455"
"-0.095206"
"-0.072212"
"-0.084907"
"-0.100671"
"-0.108197"
"-0.098060"
"-0.079427"
"-0.097818"
"-0.084136"
"-0.084782"
"-0.092538"
"-0.087208"
"-0.101515"
"-0.102370"
"-0.116081"
"-0.077265"
"-0.084278"
"-0.103556"
"-0.095695"
"-0.104038"
"-0.099895"
"-0.152508"
"-0.147656"
"-0.116713"
"-0.134691"
"-0.119155"
"-0.146352"
"-0.043784"
"-0.036190"
"-0.020524"
"-0.022082"
"-0.049002"
"-0.037719"
"-0.119352"
"-0.126069"
"-0.077406"
"-0.070543"
"-0.037211"
"-0.041602"
"-0.010765"
"-0.017986"
"-0.029533"
"-0.037676"
"-0.036901"
"-0.018393"
"-0.089932"
"-0.112581"
"-0.191590"
"-0.162905"
"-0.165297"
"-0.153033"
"-0.083926"
"-0.103779"
"-0.013635"
"-0.031041"
"-0.033557"
"-0.024450"
"-0.090452"
"-0.087779"
"-0.192952"
"-0.163716"
"-0.134969"
"-0.114518"
"-0.116938"
"-0.125044"
"-0.128568"
"-0.136892"
"-0.130951"
"-0.137103"
"-0.166720"
"-0.154100"
"-0.166335"
"-0.176119"
"-0.156465"
"-0.132163"
"-0.108107"
"-0.084895"
"-0.093392"
"-0.107039"
"-0.111130"
"-0.126132"
"-0.131642"
"-0.119554"
"-0.113070"
"-0.095884"
"-0.075427"
"-0.091062"
"-0.089417"
"-0.125914"
"-0.124857"
"-0.094995"
"-0.111441"
"-0.118481"
"-0.126443"
"-0.135420"
"-0.126182"
"-0.104556"
"-0.118740"
"-0.211201"
"-0.196532"
"-0.107255"
"-0.105009"
"-0.101168"
"-0.129578"
"-0.163353"
"-0.187565"
"-0.183597"
"-0.190697"
"-0.194562"
"-0.182926"
"-0.170953"
"-0.152776"
"-0.213892"
"-0.209400"
"-0.143200"
"-0.140485"
"-0.160838"
"-0.166202"
"-0.160250"
"-0.163488"
"-0.165025"
"-0.168846"
"-0.277079"
"-0.260850"
"-0.292801"
"-0.265256"
"-0.274142"
"-0.253448"
"-0.292776"
"-0.319471"
"-0.309501"
"-0.320992"
"-0.340176"
"-0.352468"
"-0.263483"
"-0.247174"
"-0.294017"
"-0.296227"
"-0.289201"
"-0.274716"
"-0.280321"
"-0.269172"
"-0.221849"
"-0.244133"
"-0.281851"
"-0.309550"
"-0.319619"
"-0.328441"
"-0.310096"
"-0.305181"
"-0.364420"
"-0.359534"
"-0.385395"
"-0.374206"
"-0.309660"
"-0.293097"
"-0.203769"
"-0.202620"
"-0.207010"
"-0.224715"
"-0.186909"
"-0.208301"
"-0.328640"
"-0.317776"
"-0.297773"
"-0.305330"
"-0.308834"
"-0.299052"
"-0.264808"
"-0.230549"
"-0.226350"
"-0.224333"
"-0.208334"
"-0.193243"
"-0.215044"
"-0.213641"
"-0.285110"
"-0.275100"
"-0.275899"
"-0.287905"
"-0.258533"
"-0.262357"
"-0.226934"
"-0.260556"
"-0.233664"
"-0.254548"
"-0.324672"
"-0.307748"
"-0.291220"
"-0.304672"
"-0.298446"
"-0.305148"
"-0.322301"
"-0.340595"
"-0.225350"
"-0.240204"
"-0.199588"
"-0.188453"
"-0.160404"
"-0.152112"
"-0.136810"
"-0.087500"
"-0.009089"
"-0.016791"
"-0.029936"
"-0.036258"
"-0.099256"
"-0.168244"
"-0.182873"
"-0.151416"
"-0.157063"
"-0.141489"
"-0.144012"
"-0.164465"
"-0.164088"
"-0.201248"
"-0.195400"
"-0.158189"
"-0.150646"
"-0.165811"
"-0.175206"
"-0.168084"
"-0.153249"
"-0.182048"
"-0.297138"
"-0.286616"
"-0.233525"
"-0.234788"
"-0.187412"
"-0.149258"
"-0.113011"
"-0.131668"
"-0.187448"
"-0.143402"
"-0.089720"
"-0.101342"
"-0.130522"
"-0.149434"
"-0.169293"
"-0.189845"
"-0.203038"
"-0.208177"
"-0.195238"
"-0.185470"
"-0.198700"
"-0.205729"
"-0.214482"
"-0.214439"
"-0.211686"
"-0.204789"
"-0.192317"
"-0.213045"
"-0.223403"
"-0.193716"
"-0.166121"
"-0.116522"
"-0.138524"
"-0.099951"
"-0.147510"
"-0.075544"
"-0.073146"
"-0.218308"
"-0.195808"
"-0.235220"
"-0.229139"
"-0.190047"
"-0.227445"
"-0.262404"
"-0.289408"
"-0.310072"
"-0.309745"
"-0.257958"
"-0.265240"
"-0.294658"
"-0.289165"
"-0.276212"
"-0.255441"
"-0.307997"
"-0.304450"
"-0.286628"
"-0.274869"
"-0.268689"
"-0.265057"
"-0.296394"
"-0.289227"
"-0.235279"
"-0.242861"
"-0.249579"
"-0.251949"
"-0.262402"
"-0.283365"
"-0.332189"
"-0.359232"
"-0.278490"
"-0.272344"
"-0.367786"
"-0.398732"
"-0.397236"
"-0.378726"
"-0.383066"
"-0.393108"
"-0.347012"
"-0.409738"
"-0.307972"
"-0.292665"
"-0.420915"
"-0.415728"
"-0.455906"
"-0.443537"
"-0.452624"
"-0.452555"
"-0.313182"
"-0.348102"
"-0.285899"
"-0.325591"
"-0.167800"
"-0.154101"
"-0.348820"
"-0.345833"
"-0.281382"
"-0.255659"
"-0.396831"
"-0.382089"
"-0.392496"
"-0.422267"
"-0.388947"
"-0.430023"
"-0.398222"
"-0.355909"
"-0.098169"
"-0.126603"
"-0.446656"
"-0.515480"
"-0.577456"
"-0.514676"
"-0.491500"
"-0.446337"
"-0.452437"
"-0.476128"
"-0.355871"
"-0.379438"
"-0.336222"
"-0.341180"
"-0.226915"
"-0.210544"
"-0.144391"
"-0.133643"
"-0.167315"
"-0.179248"
"-0.193042"
"-0.150706"
"-0.232071"
"-0.179181"
"-0.151914"
"-0.242906"
"-0.253696"
"-0.311252"
"-0.298106"
"-0.301272"
"-0.283819"
"-0.252116"
"-0.247306"
"-0.246851"
"-0.273206"
"-0.160714"
"-0.173681"
"-0.261980"
"-0.214682"
"-0.203295"
"-0.131481"
"-0.106759"
"-0.082094"
"-0.068366"
"-0.090832"
"-0.110420"
"-0.116230"
"-0.156402"
"-0.216393"
"-0.140180"
"-0.149721"
"-0.195688"
"-0.179392"
"-0.170109"
"-0.176535"
"-0.283960"
"-0.295702"
"-0.284562"
"-0.274431"
"-0.257925"
"-0.252705"
"-0.224458"
"-0.191932"
"-0.186755"
"-0.206380"
"-0.188654"
"-0.184977"
"-0.206513"
"-0.179637"
"-0.178972"
"-0.186657"
"-0.164820"
"-0.202797"
"-0.170130"
"-0.104907"
"-0.105539"
"-0.082020"
"-0.055730"
"-0.059280"
"-0.092420"
"-0.098166"
"-0.126833"
"-0.144560"
"-0.154744"
"-0.160606"
"-0.157285"
"-0.198123"
"-0.187060"
"-0.148826"
"-0.100511"
"-0.033714"
"-0.081908"
"-0.610464"
"-0.667721"
"-0.745012"
"-0.742841"
"-0.768020"
"-0.766288"
"-0.464660"
"-0.473347"
"-1.035692"
"-1.053336"
"-1.036122"
"-1.001160"
"-0.932932"
"-0.998414"
"-0.903672"
"-0.890536"
"-0.934462"
"-0.924754"
"-0.750490"
"-0.657134"
"-0.608650"
"-0.623947"
"-0.622513"
"-0.578220"
"-0.704042"
"-0.734504"
"-0.689326"
"-0.637798"
"-0.520957"
"-0.529192"
"-0.264169"
"-0.303658"
"-0.325961"
"-0.366289"
"-0.628682"
"-0.518409"
"-0.635030"
"-0.651292"
"-0.599131"
"-0.644094"
"-0.806280"
"-0.882709"
"-0.781536"
"-0.749139"
"-0.739416"
"-0.779029"
"-0.575296"
"-0.552100"
"-0.823979"
"-0.821771"
"-0.782919"
"-0.752302"
"-0.850757"
"-0.906254"
"-0.903208"
"-0.916599"
"-0.599220"
"-0.629307"
"-1.004227"
"-0.935550"
"-0.902118"
"-0.964586"
"-0.967766"
"-1.001476"
"-0.946235"
"-0.948920"
"-1.100173"
"-1.106539"
"-1.149182"
"-1.162515"
"-1.202513"
"-1.172931"
"-1.165049"
"-1.182843"
"-1.311767"
"-1.589141"
"-1.634035"
"-1.900895"
"-1.925676"
"-1.701600"
"-1.737973"
"-2.454983"
"-2.639224"
"-2.846924"
"-2.887842"
"-2.883820"
"-3.231317"
"-3.355914"
"-3.912734"
"-4.013086"
"-4.072578"
"-4.374276"
"-4.551469"
"-4.879971"
"-4.873317"
"-5.171028"
"-5.302041"
"-5.535003"
"-6.316927"
"-6.463390"
"-6.989729"
"-7.974610"
"-7.978430"
"-8.133956"
"-8.286523"
"-8.546284"
"-9.442648"
"-9.536527"
"-9.941903"
"-10.952392"
"-11.049410"
"-11.273194"
"-12.232913"
"-12.432056"
"-12.791568"
"-13.672886"
"-13.912360"
"-14.438830"
"-14.979329"
"-15.231174"
"-16.066430"
"-16.642235"
"-16.931104"
"-18.005861"
"-19.073814"
"-19.357616"
"-19.807284"
"-20.574618"
"-20.657153"
"-21.226916"
"-22.340187"
"-22.603690"
"-22.994513"
"-24.018389"
"-24.946252"
"-25.593914"
"-26.296466"
"-27.017340"
"-27.268770"
"-27.860006"
"-28.972973"
"-29.555823"
"-30.018434"
"-31.105445"
"-32.245998"
"-32.643531"
"-33.105812"
"-34.342604"
"-35.588411"
"-36.053329"
"-36.441782"
"-37.510975"
"-38.672664"
"-39.544873"
"-39.960086"
"-40.885556"
"-42.284972"
"-43.182642"
"-43.541554"
"-44.333261"
"-45.632274"
"-46.434834"
"-47.303253"
"-48.334542"
"-49.402783"
"-50.562447"
"-51.838675"
"-52.876271"
"-53.287515"
"-54.126793"
"-55.409292"
"-56.594240"
"-57.978867"
"-58.721133"
"-59.452098"
"-60.784962"
"-62.024626"
"-63.025707"
"-63.654639"
"-64.792530"
"-66.226487"
"-67.628934"
"-69.081723"
"-70.406950"
"-71.204063"
"-71.762152"
"-73.000052"
"-74.597495"
"-75.967631"
"-77.242325"
"-78.384016"
"-79.467653"
"-80.444293"
"-81.570562"
"-83.048650"
"-84.544162"
"-86.005833"
"-87.261096"
"-88.114133"
"-88.880495"
"-90.160005"
"-91.724018"
"-93.285389"
"-94.728192"
"-96.276097"
"-97.885293"
"-99.352131"
"-100.783847"
"-102.077108"
"-103.093865"
"-103.931405"
"-105.261709"
"-106.992937"
"-108.682407"
"-110.305769"
"-111.891509"
"-113.399048"
"-114.718285"
"-115.850347"
"-117.135681"
"-118.297905"
"-119.482854"
"-121.171226"
"-122.946224"
"-124.621385"
"-126.218498"
"-127.724563"
"-129.200608"
"-130.593077"
"-132.024925"
"-133.360848"
"-134.315675"
"-135.504393"
"-137.125560"
"-138.772256"
"-140.481258"
"-142.183828"
"-143.675087"
"-145.110390"
"-146.668956"
"-148.297816"
"-150.170060"
"-151.945282"
"-153.654183"
"-155.347260"
"-156.921944"
"-158.610204"
"-160.280345"
"-161.690954"
"-162.882599"
"-164.416093"
"-166.323673"
"-167.764057"
"-169.198538"
"-170.514776"
"-172.151177"
"-173.872517"
"-175.413003"
"-177.101681"
"-178.748122"
"-180.572328"
"-182.285700"
"-184.052650"
"-185.822506"
"-187.620024"
"-189.400734"
"-191.240814"
"-193.004857"
"-194.761887"
"-196.554833"
"-198.366457"
"-200.181394"
"-201.945356"
"-203.683119"
"-205.423808"
"-207.130128"
"-208.916183"
"-210.783701"
"-212.563679"
"-214.414572"
"-216.185383"
"-217.862231"
"-219.713164"
"-221.498833"
"-223.232389"
"-225.087936"
"-226.895373"
"-228.630859"
"-230.287219"
"-231.987624"
"-233.857033"
"-235.746747"
"-237.504408"
"-239.278796"
"-241.134831"
"-243.046130"
"-244.716880"
"-246.301859"
"-248.092406"
"-249.984884"
"-251.856183"
"-253.593193"
"-255.662825"
"-257.607051"
"-259.446074"
"-261.525706"
"-263.563102"
"-265.452003"
"-267.360395"
"-269.128686"
"-270.778827"
"-272.596691"
"-274.530775"
"-276.297318"
"-278.109796"
"-279.852558"
"-281.595321"
"-283.424039"
"-285.093834"
"-286.975539"
"-288.779969"
"-290.529967"
"-292.359538"
"-294.041020"
"-295.814433"
"-297.734533"
"-299.518962"
"-301.224774"
"-303.024528"
"-304.873124"
"-306.645297"
"-308.344238"
"-310.060924"
"-311.831288"
"-313.631368"
"-315.485146"
"-317.196994"
"-318.970407"
"-320.854572"
"-322.590831"
"-324.062821"
"-325.600259"
"-327.308834"
"-329.010296"
"-330.304909"
"-331.559806"
"-333.263788"
"-334.791774"
"-336.366813"
"-337.895206"
"-339.214026"
"-340.648090"

(Just in case it's of interest to anyone.)
 
Ten years from now when someone figures out how to combine all videos into one in 3d. Is your data then no good?

I think you're being facetious, but I actually suggested this (maybe a couple of years ago?) in the femr2 video thread. He's got (at least?) 2 different camera angles worth of data. In terms of analyzing the real life movement of the building(s), wouldn't it be to sync them up and look at the 3d movement? I'm not an expert on broadcast video, but I would imagine that there's a SMPTE-like code that shows real time.
 
(Just in case it's of interest to anyone.)
At first glance of a plot, and familiarity with the original data, it's done a fair job of removing some very early "static" noise.

Would you like to see derivative views and compare to others ?
 
I think you're being facetious, but I actually suggested this (maybe a couple of years ago?) in the femr2 video thread. He's got (at least?) 2 different camera angles worth of data. In terms of analyzing the real life movement of the building(s), wouldn't it be to sync them up and look at the 3d movement? I'm not an expert on broadcast video, but I would imagine that there's a SMPTE-like code that shows real time.
An interesting idea but it seems to me to conflate two issues viz:
1) Can it be done technically; AND
2) What are the benefits.

I'll bow out of "1)" - not my game either BUT

When we are looking at movement for the purpose of some analysis we are dealing with movement which we most commonly measure agist three orthogonal axes - hence "3D". Plus the fourth "dimension" of time.

And we need the movement measured against a coherent location framework of which three axes rectangular orthogonal representation is the most commonly used. I'll leave it to the maths gurus to identify more because it is a moot issue - we haven't seen anyone try to use them.

"3D" is a visual spatial phenomenon essentially about "what we see".

But if we create this synthesised 3D imagery how do we measure anything. AFAIK we don't have "3D" measuring tools. We measure against whatever reference framework we want to use - i.e. three axis orthogonal.

So haven't we taken an unneeded side step plus need to come back to what we already have - measurements fitted against a three axis framework?
 
An interesting idea but it seems to me to conflate two issues viz:
1) Can it be done technically;
Yes, but...

2) What are the benefits.
With out having done so already, the pitfalls are obvious.

The kind of motion already extracted from videos is well sub-pixel in nature, and contains some noise.

Combining trace data from two or more viewpoints, each with their own noise sources, each with limited knowledge of exact camera location, each with...you're just ADDING noise.

You'd be MUCH better off performing an estimated perspective correction using a single viewpoint.

Neither methods are goinf to make an awful lot of difference to the level of detail that comes out of such analysis.

Certainly by the time we arrive at acceleration data there is little point asserting much beyond trend and general magnitude.
 
2) What are the benefits.
The "benefits" of any analysis would be based on an evaluation of how said analysis contributes to the goal of such analysis. As there is no goal, it's impossible to gauge the benefits of the analysis.

femr2's opinions on 2d / 3d video analysis are worthless. Silly statements like "motion already extracted from videos is well sub-pixel in nature" confirm this. One may as well say "eighth notes extracted from Charlie Parker solos are well radians per second in nature." Meaningless technobabble, designed to fool or impress the credulous.
 
The "benefits" of any analysis would be based on an evaluation of how said analysis contributes to the goal of such analysis. As there is no goal, it's impossible to gauge the benefits of the analysis.
The blatantly obvious goal would be to attempt improvement in vertical motion data quality or accuracy, obviously. I'm not aware of anyone, including me, who actually wants to know the specific direction of any non-vertical motion that would be separable by generation of such four dimensional data.

As I've said, I think it likely performing such would decrease data quality and accuracy, not improve it.

femr2's opinions on 2d / 3d video analysis are worthless.
Ahh, you're very sweet.

Silly statements like "[The kind of] motion already extracted from videos is well sub-pixel in nature[, and contains some noise.]" confirm this.
It would appear you simply do not understand what I'm saying, or why. Would you like me to explain ? (not that it should be necessary)

One may as well say "eighth notes extracted from Charlie Parker solos are well radians per second in nature."
No, that would be stupid.

Meaningless technobabble, designed to fool or impress the credulous.
Incorrect. See above. What part of my statement do you not understand ?
 
The "benefits" of any analysis would be based on an evaluation of how said analysis contributes to the goal of such analysis.
You asked the question. you got two considered answers. If you have no goal the fault is yours.
... As there is no goal, it's impossible to gauge the benefits of the analysis.
Actually if you are admitting that yours was a trick question you still got reasoned answers. A lesson to learn when trying to be tricky. At least be prepared for the probability that you will fall flat on your face.

That said seeing as you tricked me with your trick post. How about you answer the serious answer I gave you?

I'll leave the rest of your -- "comments" -- for now.
 
Would you like to see derivative views and compare to others ?
That'd be nice, to see how effective it is when the error is amplified by taking derivatives. But I don't have a lot of hope. You don't have to upload the result if it's bad, I'll take your word on it. OTOH if it's good enough to be useful, it may be worth posting it :)

Note that the default noise reduction is 24 dB, while I used 16, so it is still possible to try a further reduction.

And the window was 2048 samples, which posed a little problem of having extra noise added at the end. I might redo it using 1024 of the 1031 samples, or using zeros at the beginning to fill 2048 samples, and see if that helps. No doubt the results will be different, but the question is if they will be of better quality.

I forgot to specify that I left the data at 44.1 KHz because Audacity was behaving strangely if I set it to 60 Hz, which I did at first. I think it should not matter as the frequencies used for filtering should be relative to the original sampling frequency. The strange behaviour I observed was not with this filter.

I'll try other variations and post the results.
 
That'd be nice, to see how effective it is when the error is amplified by taking derivatives. But I don't have a lot of hope. You don't have to upload the result if it's bad, I'll take your word on it. OTOH if it's good enough to be useful, it may be worth posting it :)
It's not good news I'm afraid...

837548388.png


(The difference between the original data and that output by Audacity)

An "eyeball" viewpoint would be:

a) Early motion has been indiscriminately removed (due to it being of small magnitude and within your selected "silence reference" window)

b) During descent, extreme change with a clear shape is apparent. Given the technical trace data generation methods, however "noisy" the data may be, it is based upon a pattern match which is guaranteed to be under a pixel "out". The shape of the difference data during descent kinda highlights what the frequency based filtering has done.

c) The difference is actually visible on a displacement/time graph...the shape during descent has changed.

I'll try other variations and post the results.
I don't think that would prove very productive.
 
The blatantly obvious goal would be to attempt improvement in vertical motion data quality or accuracy, obviously.
For the purpose of _____________? (thirtieth time asking)

I'm not aware of anyone, including me, who actually wants to know the specific direction of any non-vertical motion that would be separable by generation of such four dimensional data.

As I've said, I think it likely performing such would decrease data quality and accuracy, not improve it.
Well, if one's purpose was to study the motion of the building in 3 dimensions, it would seem useful to me. One side gave way before the other. It might have been interesting to study that in 3 dimensions (plus time).

Ahh, you're very sweet.
:)

It would appear you simply do not understand what I'm saying, or why. Would you like me to explain ? (not that it should be necessary)
I understand it just fine, and your edit helps. It's just a meaningless statement.

No, that would be stupid.
Would you prefer Hertz? It's analogous to your statement.

Incorrect. See above. What part of my statement do you not understand ?
As above.

You asked the question. you got two considered answers. If you have no goal the fault is yours.
Incorrect.

Actually if you are admitting that yours was a trick question you still got reasoned answers. A lesson to learn when trying to be tricky. At least be prepared for the probability that you will fall flat on your face.

That said seeing as you tricked me with your trick post. How about you answer the serious answer I gave you?
Not a trick question. In an honest dialogue, femr2 would have answered, "the reason I'm studying the vertical motion of this building is to _______________. 3D analysis wouldn't help because ________." I'm not playing silly games here.

I'll leave the rest of your -- "comments" -- for now.
Whatever.
 
It's not good news I'm afraid...

[qimg]http://femr2.ucoz.com/_ph/7/837548388.png[/qimg]

(The difference between the original data and that output by Audacity)
I wouldn't be too worried about that. What does worry me, however, is that noise seems to pass happily during the last stage without attenuation. I did not expect that. The whole point of this method was to attenuate the main frequencies of the noise. Or maybe the data in movement is less noisy than the static data, but I doubt that's the cause.

a) Early motion has been indiscriminately removed (due to it being of small magnitude and within your selected "silence reference" window)
That was expected. Can you suggest how many samples should I consider for taking as static reference? Maybe 400?

I am not familiar enough with the videos. Is that the whole video, or just the last few seconds? If the latter, can you point me to the raw data of a more complete trace?
 
Last edited:
I am not familiar enough with the videos. Is that the whole video, or just the last few seconds? If the latter, can you point me to the raw data of a more complete trace?

For Dan Rather data, that's the full length. ~17.5s.

For Cam#3 data, a much longer timespan is available. Several minutes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom