Split Thread Discussion of cascade failure initiation at WTC1 and WTC2

Actually no. He is not using incredulity - he is mostly agreeing with me but his writing style is a bit hard to decode.

The key points IMO are:
Two factors and he is correct on both.- it should be "force" not "impulse" but the concept is correct.Correct interpretation of what I suggested as most probable. And the point which has almost always been missed by truthers and debunkers alike.

The references to the hat trusses and cantilevers are dubious and unclear. But they are signs of thinking not simple incredulity.

Plead guilty to language abuse... but thanks for reading though it.

My point about the FORCES of the floor.. whether pre 911 or during the event were applied to the inside of the facade panels.. resting on and bolted to angles which were welded to the spandrels at alternate columns... the key here is INSIDE.. meaning that the load applied to the column was asymmetrical and would *naturally* cause an weakened facade to then buckle in.... of there was no restraint in that direct... and that WAS the case of the truss were sagging. It did not have to even be very much sagging to determine that the facade would buck IN and not OUT as we see.

I see this IB as a clear sign that facade was buckling from over loads. There are only two ways this could present... more load was applied or the facade got weaker or some combination of the two.

The weaker route would have had to have been from heat weakening of the facade... Maybe... the extra load would come via the columns above the buckled area which were supporting the floors AND the hat truss. And the hat truss was designed as a horizontal load transfer structure... and it was able to distribute loads to various columns.

My HUNCH is that it did just that because it HAD been supported by all the core columns and 16 locations on the facade (out riggers) and the floor plates of the beef up mech floors. When columns of the core were destroyed the hat truss re distributed the loads the destroyed columns had been carrying to other columns INCLUDING the facade. And as more and more of the core columns *gave up* from heat weakening... more and more loads were hanging from the hat truss and being supported by the facade... and this reached the point of exceeding the yield strength of the facade at the out rigger location and buckled the facade were the sagging truss were even "gently" (excuse the term) pulling in.

And the buckled area is clearly being restrained by the non or much less sagging floors below and above. Further this was a local IB in my OPINION because it was related to the asymmetry of the heat weakening... that is the load redistribution was not symmetrical because the core damage wasn't and the core columns were no symmetrical in their strength.. and of course the facade had asymmetrical damage from the plane. The buckling should have appeared on the opposite side from the most facade damage. Is that where it was seen or first seen?

Short explanation: IB was from buckling (axial loads)
 
The shell is not a facade, it is 50 percent of the gravity load, and essentially 100 percent of the lateral support. Facade? The shell, floor system and core are a system making the WTC towers the strong structures.

wrong.

The facade carried about 57% of the outside the core floor loads (17,483SF)
The core carried about 43% of the outside the core floor loads (13,20SF)
The facade carried about 100% of the limited inside the core floor loads (up to about 7,000SF max on higher floors)

In the lower reaches the inside the core floor loads were very limited because there real estate was used for shafts.

The perimeter row of the long side of the core carried the most loads... with the 4 corners carrying about 7% each of the axial loads.
 
Hmmm... so incredulity trumps models?

Models are models... they REPRESENT reality using assumptions...

Right?

Incredulity of what? I am suppose to suspend my critical thinking because someone makes a model?
 
wrong.

The facade carried about 57% of the outside the core floor loads (17,483SF)
The core carried about 43% of the outside the core floor loads (13,20SF)
The facade carried about 100% of the limited inside the core floor loads (up to about 7,000SF max on higher floors)

In the lower reaches the inside the core floor loads were very limited because there real estate was used for shafts.

The perimeter row of the long side of the core carried the most loads... with the 4 corners carrying about 7% each of the axial loads.

What the hell are you talking about?

Specifically this part:

The facade carried about 100% of the limited inside the core floor loads (up to about 7,000SF max on higher floors)

:confused:


BTW: This is off topic in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Models are models... they REPRESENT reality using assumptions...

Right?

Incredulity of what? I am suppose to suspend my critical thinking because someone makes a model?

Feel free to critique the models all you like, but you said it: They represent REALITY using ASSUMPTIONS. I emphasized those two words because the representation of reality is, or should be, beyond dispute. If you feed the correct assumptions into a properly implemented model, you will get an acceptable facsimile of reality. It's the assumptions behind the model that you need to check, and hopefully you can do a better job of that than Chris "MSPaintFire" Sarns did with NIST's WTC7 fire analysis models.
 
What has all this got to do with Millette's study? Nothing. Take it to another thread. I've contacted the mod's to split this off.
 
What the hell are you talking about?

Specifically this part:



:confused:


BTW: This is off topic in this thread.

From the plans... did you ever calculate the floor or roof loads for a building?
 
Originally Posted by Sunstealer
What has all this got to do with Millette's study? Nothing. Take it to another thread. I've contacted the mod's to split this off.


Thanks - the split was already requested as noted at post 2284

....and seconded at #2286. :) Anyone call the question? ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom