Determining The Proper Age of Sexual Consent (Read First)

I know a few 40 year old which correspond to the description , do you suggest we put the age of consent on 40 ?


Mind you this would be a sure fire way to reduce earth population drastically within a generation or two.

You mean drastically increase the prison population, right? :D
 
This is my perspective as well. Society doesn't believe you have the maturity to enter into contracts or vote before you turn 18; why should society decide that you can make responsible decisions about sex? And in practice we know that many 16-year-olds don't make responsible decisions about sex.

Because society are not logical entities , but are chaotic patchwork of laws and rules and culture which grew with time and history, with almost no law being repelled , jsut not enforced. IIRC for example in France you could not serve high procent alcohol to a 16, but they can consent to sex, and can drink beer when in presence of a parent at a lower age. Sometime you could in some country vote before you could drink or have sex (21).
Heck at some point in UK in 17th century age of consent for female was 8 , no age of consent for female.
 
Asside from the maturity issue there is the imbalance of power issue. The status of under 18s in modern society is such that there is going to be a significant imbalance of power issue if you go much above that age.

So I'd tend to argue that by far the best appproach is to have 18 for unfettered age of consent combined with say 12 if they are within 2 years of each other. Of course of the odds of such a law being passed in the UK are pretty much zero.
 
The idea of the Age of Consent


It looks like you've done some excellent, scholarly ends-oriented work there to prop up your preconceived conclusion that you should be allowed to make it with a 16 year-old.


Sexual Maturity


Why does it matter when puberty ends?


Intellectual Maturity

The second factor to consider is if the mind is ready to understand the consequences of sex. Cognitive abilities includes attention, memory, producing and understanding language, learning, reasoning, problem solving, and decision making. This part of the brain reaches adult levels by the age of 16.


Yeah, you're completely wrong. Myelination of the brain is the major structural upgrade taking place during puberty. It allows for faster and better communication between neurons. Myelination starts from the back of the brain and works forwards. Incomplete myelination is frequently cited as the reason why teenagers exhibit poor judgment, defiance, and are bad at assessing risks (front brain activities). The maturation process isn't complete until age 24.



Emotional Maturity

Now full emotional maturity doesn't happen until the mid 20s. But when is someone emotionally mature enough to handle sex? Well, it seems 15 is the cut-off to prevent emotional damage from sexually activity.



Dear lard.

If you need to convince people that you should be allowed to put your dingle inside a 16 year-old, chances are you are not sexually mature enough to be putting your dingle anywhere.
 
18 seems like a good age for the simple fact that it's when most of the rights/responsibilities of adulthood start legally. However, age-of-consent laws should take into consideration that there is a considerable difference between a 12 and a 17 year old and shouldn't just lump all "under-aged" people in the same group. It should also take into account age difference to avoid the aforementioned high-school sweethearts. And, most importantly, the moral prudes should be given no say whatsoever, age of consent laws are about protecting children from abuse, not punishing them for having sex.
 
It looks like you've done some excellent, scholarly ends-oriented work there to prop up your preconceived conclusion that you should be allowed to make it with a 16 year-old.

Its already legal where I live. Same with most places.:)


Why does it matter when puberty ends?

A pregnant woman with an undeveloped pelvis would usually require a C-section.


Yeah, you're completely wrong. Myelination of the brain is the major structural upgrade taking place during puberty. It allows for faster and better communication between neurons. Myelination starts from the back of the brain and works forwards. Incomplete myelination is frequently cited as the reason why teenagers exhibit poor judgment, defiance, and are bad at assessing risks (front brain activities). The maturation process isn't complete until age 24.

You might want to read the sources I cited. It also mentioned that. I just quoted what it said.


Dear lard.

If you need to convince people that you should be allowed to put your dingle inside a 16 year-old, chances are you are not sexually mature enough to be putting your dingle anywhere.

Address the argument not the arguer.

Also, I don't think most 16 year olds show enough judgement to deal with something as complex as sexual activity. At that age, most kids are still a sea of hormones, and they demonstrate a great variety of maturity levels in different areas. Many states don't allow a kid that age to even drive an automobile with other teens in it!


Most states do allow teens do drive restrictively where they can possibly kill themselves and others, as well as enter the military at 17 with parent consent.

Asside from the maturity issue there is the imbalance of power issue. The status of under 18s in modern society is such that there is going to be a significant imbalance of power issue if you go much above that age.

So I'd tend to argue that by far the best appproach is to have 18 for unfettered age of consent combined with say 12 if they are within 2 years of each other. Of course of the odds of such a law being passed in the UK are pretty much zero.

I believe that the imbalance of power is only an issue when the person is in a position of authority. But isn't the age of majority 16 in Scotland?



Your point 3 is interrestring very sadly very unclear without real number. If I understand it it is a ratio. So the risk is higher. But you would still need to know the absolute risk for 1 to undertsand if the ratio is important or not and comapre to other suicide risk.

For example the germany have a 14 year old age of consent. USA has 16 to 18 IIRC.
But germany has a male suicide ratio of 15 per 100K and USA 19 per 100K. Therefore that factor , first time of sex, cannot be the main factor into suicide otherwise the relation would be inverted. It may be the second main factor for all we know or the last factor in a serie making it not very relevant. It is impossible to know with ratio only (although I might have missed the absolute number somewhere ?).

Furthermore the age of consent is really more oriented toward adult-adolescent from a law perspective. From EU country I know of no example of two adolescent being put on sex offender list for sexting each others naked body while being 16 or 17. I could be wrong though. I certainly don't recall any prosecution of two minor the same age , say 13 for me 12 for one of my girlfriend. Theoretically none of us could have concented.

As for asking a single age worldwide, why ? Culture differs geographically and temporally in how they view sex. Trying to impose an older age on culture which obviously don't have a problem with a younger age of consent make no sense.

No what would make sense is to request all culture, country, to sexually educate boys and girls on STD and Contraception, and maybe who knows as well as the difference between love and lust, as well as following up with school psyhcologue etc...

Good points, especially with the last sentence.


Would this include prostitution, where already legal, and participating in pornography?

Yes. I know I'm going to get some heat for this....but I also think that incest shouldn't be criminalized if there is no reproduction involved.
 
Last edited:
In a circumstance where the parents are still responsible for providing food, shelter, health care and access to education, it seems ridiculous to make it legal for the child to force the parents to subsidize the results of unwise sexual decision-making, be it a transmissable disease needing treatment, or a pregnancy and offspring to be paid for.
The problem I can see with this is that its completely and totally impractical. Teens have sex, they always have and always will; and places with the most stringent restrictions on teen sex (typically religiously motivated) also tend to have rates of teen pregnancy and STDs equivalent to or higher than less restrictive regions. Probably because the impetus that prohibits teen sex so strictly also tends to restrict the sort of sex education available.
 
places with the most stringent restrictions on teen sex (typically religiously motivated) also tend to have rates of teen pregnancy and STDs equivalent to or higher than less restrictive regions. Probably because the impetus that prohibits teen sex so strictly also tends to restrict the sort of sex education available.

Indeed.
 
I'm thinking that there should be two separate ages of consent. One age where it counts as a misdemeanor, another where it counts as a felony.

For example, if a 20 year old man has sex with a 15 year old girl, misdemeanor. But if a 20 year old man has sex with an 11 year old girl, felony.

Yes. I know I'm going to get some heat for this....but I also think that incest shouldn't be criminalized if there is no reproduction involved.

It also depends on what kind of incest you mean. In many places having sex with your cousin counts as incest, but in other places it doesn't.

I think the biggest problem with non-reproductive incest (between consenting adults) would be the potential for one partner having the potential to be in a position of unbalanced authority over the other. Such as between a parent and child.

And then... there's always the possibility of unintended reproduction.

So I'd tend to argue that by far the best appproach is to have 18 for unfettered age of consent combined with say 12 if they are within 2 years of each other. Of course of the odds of such a law being passed in the UK are pretty much zero.


That sounds similar to my earlier suggestion...

How about just making it illegal to have sex with any under-18 more than 366 days your junior?
 
This is my perspective as well. Society doesn't believe you have the maturity to enter into contracts or vote before you turn 18; why should society decide that you can make responsible decisions about sex? And in practice we know that many 16-year-olds don't make responsible decisions about sex.

The reason I'm against this is that there is a non-zero cost associated with trying to enforce laws against sixteen-to-eighteens having sex. Lots of them will have sex anyway, and you'll spend a lot of money trying to catch them at it, trying their sex partners in court and locking them up.

The same argument applies weakly to the under-sixteens, but the differences are that more over-fifteens have sex than under-sixteens, and there's no hard evidence of harm associated with the over-fifteens being sexually active. So you're putting in a lot more effort to prevent a harm which might not even exist in the first place.

I generally think that liberal societies have a strong obligation to be able to provide evidence that X is harmful in concrete, measurable terms before they spend public money and police time on criminalising X, for absolutely any X.

If we lived in a magical world where everybody obeyed the law all the time and we could stop all people from having sex until whatever age we liked just by passing a law, you could talk me into an age of consent of eighteen. Heck, you could talk me into requiring people to have a license to engage in unprotected sex and an additional license to have a baby. We don't live in that magical world however.
 
Riight, no need to look at the age teens actually start having sex. :rolleyes:
I think 18 is a good age as well, but as I said earlier there needs to be a recognition that 10, 14, and 17 year olds are completely different when it comes to maturity and ability to "consent" in all but the legal fiction meaning of the word.

For starters, I don't think the phrase "statutory rape" should be used at all for the older categories when consent was clearly given. Frankly, it's an insult to the actual victims of rape, and it trivializes the word both for those who did not consent and those who were genuinely too young to be "informed".

Any decent law should contain a graduated level of punishments based on the age of the minor and the age difference of the parties, and most importantly be focused on determining if someone is actually being abused, rather than (as is unfortunately often the case) used as an excuse for authoritarian puritans to punish people for "immorality".
 
For starters, I don't think the phrase "statutory rape" should be used at all for the older categories when consent was clearly given. Frankly, it's an insult to the actual victims of rape, and it trivializes the word both for those who did not consent and those who were genuinely too young to be "informed".

More sensible jurisdictions have laws against "unlawful sex", which is an excellent way to put it, rather than the misleading "statutory rape" which is a very poor term for describing that subset of incidents which involve no rape in the normal sense.

It's rather unfortunate that for one reason or another, "statutory rape" has become the default catch-all term for offences involving sex with an underage person. In this case the emotive misnomer has almost eclipsed the better terminology, to the delight of those people who like to appropriate the power of the word "rape".

(I think I recall that other jurisdictions classify sex with an underage person as "sexual assault", which is equally problematic in theory but which seems to lead to less confusion in practice).
 
I think 18 is a good age as well, but as I said earlier there needs to be a recognition that 10, 14, and 17 year olds are completely different when it comes to maturity and ability to "consent" in all but the legal fiction meaning of the word.

For starters, I don't think the phrase "statutory rape" should be used at all for the older categories when consent was clearly given. Frankly, it's an insult to the actual victims of rape, and it trivializes the word both for those who did not consent and those who were genuinely too young to be "informed".

Any decent law should contain a graduated level of punishments based on the age of the minor and the age difference of the parties, and most importantly be focused on determining if someone is actually being abused, rather than (as is unfortunately often the case) used as an excuse for authoritarian puritans to punish people for "immorality".

Malta is pretty much like that. It is one of only couple of countries in Europe where the age of consent is 18 (the other being Turkey). However, the law chooses to look the other way when there is clearly no real victim like this case below.

http://www.timesofmalta.com/articles/view/20080428/local/brothers-acquitted-of-defiling-girl.205978

I think Turkey might be the only European country that takes age of consent to the extreme.
 
Last edited:
Yes. I know I'm going to get some heat for this....but I also think that incest shouldn't be criminalized if there is no reproduction involved.

Just noticed this bit.

In very unusual cases of incest, like the melodramatic scenario where siblings separated at birth meet unknowingly later in life, I agree completely.

Most cases of incest are of a father sexually abusing their children, however, and the psychological consequences for the victims are often very serious. This kind of intra-family abuse should absolutely be criminalised, and punished heavily, regardless of whether reproduction is involved.
 
Just noticed this bit.

In very unusual cases of incest, like the melodramatic scenario where siblings separated at birth meet unknowingly later in life, I agree completely.

Most cases of incest are of a father sexually abusing their children, however, and the psychological consequences for the victims are often very serious. This kind of intra-family abuse should absolutely be criminalised, and punished heavily, regardless of whether reproduction is involved.

Sounds legit.
 
Thailand, like most of Asia, has a rather cloudy position. The AoC is 15, formally. But consent can apparently be withdrawn after the fact. Puts everything at the whim of law enforcement which is the way they like it here, as either the cops or the judge decide everything and both are open to "argument by financial consideration". That's usually peer-on-peer stuff, though, like and 18 or 19 year old with a 16 y.o.

The catchall in the law here is "prostitution". It's illegal for anyone under 18 to be a prostitute, so while consent can be given by sixteen year olds, if you gain that consent in lieu of remuneration (far and away the most common sex with teens in Thailand is sex tourism), you can be prosecuted and expelled from the country or jailed.

Aside: The good/reputable clubs check IDs, but drunken tourists looking for a little action assume that all bars are legit and many a client who's outworn his welcome finds himself a-cropper of a suddenly underage prostitute. There are also a number of bar girls here known for playing the opposite tactic. They'll get fake ID saying they're seventeen (when they're 28!!!) and try to extort from the customer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom