Determining The Proper Age of Sexual Consent (Read First)

DevilMayhem666

New Blood
Joined
Dec 9, 2012
Messages
22
The idea of the Age of Consent is when a person at a certain age is considered to be legally competent enough to consent to sexual acts. It is usually 14 to 16 worldwide, rarely below the former and above than the latter. But at what age someone truly competent enough for sex? There are three factors to consider when it comes to sex:

Sexual Maturity

When the body is ready for sex is obviously the first factor to consider when it comes to sexually activity. Puberty usually finishes around 16.

For girls, puberty begins around 10 or 11 years of age and ends around age 16. Boys enter puberty later than girls-usually around 12 years of age-and it lasts until around age 16 or 17. Girls and boys usually begin puberty around the same time their mothers and fathers did.

http://www.pamf.org/teen/parents/health/growth-11-14.html#Physical changes (Puberty)

Intellectual Maturity

The second factor to consider is if the mind is ready to understand the consequences of sex. Cognitive abilities includes attention, memory, producing and understanding language, learning, reasoning, problem solving, and decision making. This part of the brain reaches adult levels by the age of 16.

In contrast, differences in cognitive capacity measures increased from ages 11 to 16 and then showed no improvements after age 16 – exactly the opposite of the pattern found on the psychosocial measures. Certain cognitive abilities, such as the ability to reason logically, reach adult levels long before psychosocial maturity is attained, Steinberg said.
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/10/091007153745.htm

Policymakers face the question of when teenagers are responsible for their actions or can make reasoned decisions, such as in medical situations, and there is no simple answer because it is possible that an adolescent may be mature enough for some but not all decisions, according to Steinberg. The circumstances under which a 16-year-old makes medical decisions or commits crimes are very different and place different demands on their brains and abilities, he said. Brain systems implicated in basic cognitive processes reach adult levels of maturity by mid-adolescence, whereas those that are active in self-regulation do not fully mature until late adolescence or even early adulthood, he noted.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/08/120803153121.htm

Emotional Maturity

Now full emotional maturity doesn't happen until the mid 20s. But when is someone emotionally mature enough to handle sex? Well, it seems 15 is the cut-off to prevent emotional damage from sexually activity.

Compared to ages 15–17, those with age of first intercourse between 12 and 14 had increased rates of lifetime disruptive behavior, substance use, and any mental disorder, and suicidal ideation and attempts (adjusted odds ratio (AOR) range, 1.46–2.01).

http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-008-9463-5

With that said, if I could choose a single worldwide age of consent, it be 16 since those three important factors happen at that age and is already the most common AOCC worldwide. However, a person 16 and older having sex with a 15 year old who is sexually mature is a misdemeanor and the offender does not have to register as a sex offender.

So do you agree or disagree with me? If you do disagree state why and what would you have for a single worldwide Age of Consent?
 
So do you agree or disagree with me? If you do disagree state why and what would you have for a single worldwide Age of Consent?

I disagree, on the general principle that someone who chooses to make a first impression by announcing themselves as "DevilMayhem666" and starting a discussion about the proper age of sexual consent, probably shouldn't be taken seriously on any topic of their choice. At least, not until their body of work says otherwise.

As for a single worldwide Age of Consent: I wouldn't have one. The world is too big, and too varied to have any single set of rules. Let different regions, people groups, subcultures, etc., arrange amongst themselves whatever rules suit them best. Let whatever rules work edge out whatever rules don't.

<SNIP>

Edited by Locknar: 
SNIPed, breach of rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I believe in some places there is a variable "age of consent" at least as far as charging someone with statuatory rape is concerned. That is, in some states (US) it would be legal for a couple of 16-year-olds to have sex, but not for either of them to be partners with a 35-year-old. This is designed to avoid prosecuting high school sweethearts who cross the line when one of them has just turned 17, etc.

I favor making the age of consent 18, on the grounds that that is generally the age of receiving other legal rights and responsibilities (ability to sign an legal contract, voting rights, right to own real estate) and at which the parents are no longer legally responsible. In a circumstance where the parents are still responsible for providing food, shelter, health care and access to education, it seems ridiculous to make it legal for the child to force the parents to subsidize the results of unwise sexual decision-making, be it a transmissable disease needing treatment, or a pregnancy and offspring to be paid for.

Also, I don't think most 16 year olds show enough judgement to deal with something as complex as sexual activity. At that age, most kids are still a sea of hormones, and they demonstrate a great variety of maturity levels in different areas. Many states don't allow a kid that age to even drive an automobile with other teens in it!

I also agree that there are different cultural standards. In developing countries, teens are often an important part of the financial and/or work output to support themselves and the family; they are more grown-up because they have had to be so. Conversely, the current crop of American kids seem to be much younger for their calendar age than even their parents were--less interested in taking on responsibility, and less experienced in caring for themselves.

I don't see any harm being done to high schoolers by expecting them to wait until they are about the age they'd graduate at to get sexually active. Indeed, there is much to be said for keeping the age of consent high enough that there is at least somewhat less distraction from the goal of getting that diploma and the learning to support it. Especially in a school environment where peer pressure is so dominant, being able to play the 'its not legal' card may be a sophomore's last defense against the advances of a BMOC like the football team quarterback.

Just my thoughts, MK
 
Interesting first post, DevilMayhem666.

<snip>

My current view is pretty much the same as yours, which is to say that the currently available evidence indicates that it's not a good idea for under-sixteens to be sexually active. Hence for now we should draw the legal line there.

Since the causal mechanism of the harm done is not at all clear I wouldn't be hugely surprised if later research changed my view in one direction or another, but for now a line at sixteen seems best.

As for how harsh punishments should be, I don't think there's any good evidence available about the cost/benefit tradeoff of different degrees of punishment. There has to be some punishment or everyone would ignore the law, but what the optimal level is for good deterrence without the punishments becoming cost-ineffective I just don't know (and I don't think anyone else does either).

ETA: I do tend to think it's not a good idea to make it only a misdemeanour to be caught having sex with an under-sixteen who is "sexually mature", since the current evidence doesn't tell us that "sexually mature" under-sixteens are any less harmed by sexual activity than anybody else, depending on how you define "sexually mature". If we had a definition of "sexually mature" that accurately predicted whether people who are sexually active are at greater risk of harm, I'd change my view.


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited for Rule 11
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Setting an age of consent does absolutely nothing to prevent people under that age from having sex with each-other. Making it illegal won't stop it. Set it to sixteen, and 15-year olds are still going to have sex.

(And since neither of them are old enough to have consented, neither of them is guilty of statutory rape. Unless they both are.)

The problem comes when one of them turns 16. The could have been having sex for a year or more with no problems, but the moment one of them turns 16 then suddenly they're committing a crime if they continue to do what they've already been doing all year.

The purpose of the age of consent laws is to protect teenagers from being taken advantage of by adults. They're going to be having sex with each-other anyway. The law should reflect this.

How about just making it illegal to have sex with any under-18 more than 366 days your junior?
 
Last edited:
There exists, in most societies, two ages of consent.

One that appears in legal statutes and one that in effect child protection services and legal types determine.

For example in the UK the crime of statutory rape is always reported by child protection officers if the victim is under the age of 12. It is nearly always reported when the victim/partner is under 16 and the perpetrator/partner is significantly older then the victim/partner.

It is almost never considered a criminal act in cases where both parties are under the age of consent. It is often not considered a crime if the older partner is slightly over the age of consent.

It should be clear to most that ore-pubescent children should always be considered unable to consent. For a multitude of reasons not least lack of sexual or intellectual development. But beyond that consent really only serves as a proxy for things we have not the time or understanding to measure.

All of which add up to trying to answer the question: "When is someone ready to have sex?"

The answer is different for every individual and many individuals probably think they answered it themselves incorrectly (mostly by believing they had sex too soon or too young).

So what's an appropriate age of consent?

It depends on the culture. The individuals involved and to a messier extent the power balance between partners within the relationships.
 
How about just making it illegal to have sex with any under-18 more than 366 days your junior?

After 16 years of age if it doesn't contribute to a delinquency of a minor I don't think the law should have any business in a person's sexuality.
 
Last edited:
After 16 years of age if it doesn't contribute to a delinquency of a minor I don't think the law should have any business in a person's sexuality.

From a strictly legal perspective, perhaps not. Personally, my daughter's "age-of-if-you're-over-20-you're-not-gonna-get-my-dad's-boot-up-your-ass" was somewhere around 19.
 
Last edited:
From a strictly legal perspective, perhaps not. Personally, my daughter's "age-of-if-you're-over-20-you're-not-gonna-get-my-dad's-boot-up-your-ass" was somewhere around 19.

I wouldn't want my minor kids missing around with someone over a decade older (if I had any) but I wouldn't treat it as a rape nor do I think that person belongs on the sex offender list. I like how Pennsylvania handles this with its corruption of minor law. While the age of consent is 16 there if a legal adult has sex with a minor but the parent or legal guardian had disapproved of the relationship but still continued it is a first-degree misdemeanor.
 
Last edited:
I favor making the age of consent 18, on the grounds that that is generally the age of receiving other legal rights and responsibilities (ability to sign an legal contract, voting rights, right to own real estate) and at which the parents are no longer legally responsible. In a circumstance where the parents are still responsible for providing food, shelter, health care and access to education, it seems ridiculous to make it legal for the child to force the parents to subsidize the results of unwise sexual decision-making, be it a transmissable disease needing treatment, or a pregnancy and offspring to be paid for.

This is my perspective as well. Society doesn't believe you have the maturity to enter into contracts or vote before you turn 18; why should society decide that you can make responsible decisions about sex? And in practice we know that many 16-year-olds don't make responsible decisions about sex.
 
Setting an age of consent does absolutely nothing to prevent people under that age from having sex with each-other. Making it illegal won't stop it. Set it to sixteen, and 15-year olds are still going to have sex.

Making it illegal gives authority to the parents, which is usually the real point. It's the same reason that a lot of things are restricted for those under-age.
 
Your point 3 is interrestring very sadly very unclear without real number. If I understand it it is a ratio. So the risk is higher. But you would still need to know the absolute risk for 1 to undertsand if the ratio is important or not and comapre to other suicide risk.

For example the germany have a 14 year old age of consent. USA has 16 to 18 IIRC.
But germany has a male suicide ratio of 15 per 100K and USA 19 per 100K. Therefore that factor , first time of sex, cannot be the main factor into suicide otherwise the relation would be inverted. It may be the second main factor for all we know or the last factor in a serie making it not very relevant. It is impossible to know with ratio only (although I might have missed the absolute number somewhere ?).

Furthermore the age of consent is really more oriented toward adult-adolescent from a law perspective. From EU country I know of no example of two adolescent being put on sex offender list for sexting each others naked body while being 16 or 17. I could be wrong though. I certainly don't recall any prosecution of two minor the same age , say 13 for me 12 for one of my girlfriend. Theoretically none of us could have concented.

As for asking a single age worldwide, why ? Culture differs geographically and temporally in how they view sex. Trying to impose an older age on culture which obviously don't have a problem with a younger age of consent make no sense.

No what would make sense is to request all culture, country, to sexually educate boys and girls on STD and Contraception, and maybe who knows as well as the difference between love and lust, as well as following up with school psyhcologue etc...
 
By the same token, I'm sure there are plenty of 17 year-olds who are immature jackasses who wouldn't know responsible sexual conduct if it bit them on the devil-cheeks.

I know a few 40 year old which correspond to the description , do you suggest we put the age of consent on 40 ?


Mind you this would be a sure fire way to reduce earth population drastically within a generation or two.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom