Desperation fuels belief in the supernatural

You could say that, only there are a few fundamental differences. Perhaps you're talking about people like the Neo-Cons and war-mongering politicians in other countries sacrificing people to their sociopathic ambitions, or for the defence of their countries.

That leads on to another aspect of how desperation or strong emotion can prompt a turning to the supernatural. For instance, in wars where a lot of people are dying, mediums can become popular and widespread as they claim to be able to communicate with people's dead relatives. See, for instance, from a Wikipedia article on Spiritualism:

The surge of interest in Spiritualism during and after the American Civil War and World War I was a direct response to the massive casualties.
 
Desperation fuels belief in the supernatural
I think a lot of belief in the supernatural will disappear when living conditions throughout the world improve for people so there's more social equality.

I didn’t notice your thread at the time, but I couldn’t agree more!
(Well, actually, I would probably stress the improved living conditions rather than the equality. The same amount of misery for everybody wouldn’t help much …)
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=70329
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=138024
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=46293

Scientific test:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4205180#post4205180
 
I think it's absolutely true that desperation is a major player in reinforcing many people's beliefs in the paranormal as well as most forms of religion. Desperation to find some kind of meaning in a chaotic and often dangerous world, where it's increasingly the case that everyone really is alone to fend for themselves as best they can.

I'm nowhere near certain that simply raising living standards would be sufficient to wipe it out, or even reduce it significantly. Look at the USA for confirmation. The majority's adherence to religious and spiritual tradition has been constant, not only there but all over the world, since the species began pretty much. Debunking some 'psychics' and discrediting some homeopaths isn't going to cut it. It's been done to death in recent decades and hasn't really changed many people's opinions.

Other's in this thread and elsewhere have pointed out the fact that a majority of Americans, who supposedly enjoy some of the highest living standards in the world are still mired deeply in religious and paranormal beliefs.

The study detailed Americans' deep and broad religiosity, finding that 92 percent believe in God or a universal spirit -- including one in five of those who call themselves atheists. More than half of Americans polled pray at least once a day.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/story/2008/06/23/ST2008062300818.html

[ultimately unprovable but seemingly inevitably approaching woo] The conspiracy theories suggest that in a couple of generations, however, when populations all over the world are used to a modern, secular, reason based society in which children are brought up largely without troubling parental interference due to the enormous pressure for both parents to work 12 hours a day to make ends meet, the convenience of state sponsored childcare, healthcare and welfare, with standardized, state mandated education and cradle to grave media indoctrination (propaganda), those religous and paranormal beliefs supported by ancient, family structured traditions will fade peacefully into the night, along with the tribal and familial systems crafted over millenia often used to reinforce some semblance of a moral code over a species that in essence, at birth, are little more than malleable blank slate animals with opposable thumbs. Get them young, cram citizenship, duty, humility and obedience into their spongelike little minds and before you know it, you'll have a race of obediant workers, obedient workers with no conception of history or tradition, no apparent need to think for themselves and no socially cohesive notion of solidarity and resistence to a tyranny that poses as a utopia.[/end apparent woo]

Seriously, religions and some elements of paranormal and other 'woo' belief are dangerous when taken to extremes, nobody doubts that, but the other end of the spectrum is potentially just as frightening and dangerous to the species, if not more so, again when taken to the extreme. Some say we've tried religion and spirituality for long enough and it hasn't worked, and I wouldn't disagree much. It has been largely disastrous, but surely forced conformity to rigid non-belief in anything except physical reality isn't the best answer.

I'm all for exposing the quacks who make money off other people's misery, I'm totally down with efforts to show people that some things are not what they appear to be, but the vigorous thrust to seperate most people from their most cherished beliefs is going to do little more than alienate a lot of them from the people trying to enlighten them. You.

The path to species wide enlightenment in these matters, I believe, lies not in beating the religion out of them with blunt clubs of reason and logic, but in a co-operative effort to establish peaceful co-existence between those that differ in opinion on matters purely subjective. The admittance of both sides that these issues are purely subjective and ultimately unprovable either way. The education can't be one way, it will have to be mutual understanding and acceptance of wide and varying degrees of difference. Even if you don't like it.
 
Seriously, religions and some elements of paranormal and other 'woo' belief are dangerous when taken to extremes, nobody doubts that, but the other end of the spectrum is potentially just as frightening and dangerous to the species, if not more so, again when taken to the extreme. Some say we've tried religion and spirituality for long enough and it hasn't worked, and I wouldn't disagree much. It has been largely disastrous, but surely forced conformity to rigid non-belief in anything except physical reality isn't the best answer.

I'm all for exposing the quacks who make money off other people's misery, I'm totally down with efforts to show people that some things are not what they appear to be, but the vigorous thrust to seperate most people from their most cherished beliefs is going to do little more than alienate a lot of them from the people trying to enlighten them. You.

The path to species wide enlightenment in these matters, I believe, lies not in beating the religion out of them with blunt clubs of reason and logic, but in a co-operative effort to establish peaceful co-existence between those that differ in opinion on matters purely subjective. The admittance of both sides that these issues are purely subjective and ultimately unprovable either way. The education can't be one way, it will have to be mutual understanding and acceptance of wide and varying degrees of difference. Even if you don't like it.

"forcible conformity" to a non-religious worldview would have nothing to do with decent logic. I agree that it shouldn't be tried. I'm very far from believing that the elimination of religion from society should be pursued as a goal in itself. I think at its best, religion can be a good influence on society.

I actually think it would be impossible to use logic and reason to eliminate religion from society, for a few reasons:

A. Some things just aren't proveable either way.

B. Religious conviction tends to be based on emotion rather than logic. For instance, someone might feel sure they've sensed God's love around them, and you might have a very hard time persuading them it was some kind of projection of their imagination. If Jesus has become a precious figure in their lives because he represents freedom from a past burden of guilt they felt, you're going to have a hard time convincing them he was just an ordinary man or didn't exist.

To give an example from another board, someone had a serious accident when she was a child that could have killed her; but she said that while it was happening, she felt as if God's love was surrounding and shielding her. And while she was growing up, she took comfort in feeling as if God was there, and it was about the only thing that helped her cope with the physical and verbal abuse she got from her mother. Nowadays, she feels as if God is still a comfort, and feeling she owes her sanity to God makes her grateful even now, and it motivates her to behave better than she might have done otherwise. For instance, she might have been more likely to have affairs otherwise. So her allegiance to God actually makes her marriage more secure. Because of the benefits she's noticed in her life from her God-belief, I don't believe for one moment that anyone could stop her believing in God, and some have tried. She tends to dismiss what they say as their own opinions, or incorporate some of it into her belief system without losing her basic faith. I personally would feel sad for her if anyone did manage to make her lose all belief in God.

C. Using anti-religious arguments can simply motivate the opposition to refine their own arguments, especially since while you might be convinced you're using logic and reason, your arguments might actually be full of flaws. See examples of the pitfalls skeptics can fall into. And yes, it can antagonise the faithful against you.

I believe logic and critical thinking skills should be taught routinely on school curriculums. That might make people question religion more, but it wouldn't in itself turn people into anti-religionists.

For instance, people could be asked to reason through how, and whether, a good God could allow so much suffering in the world. On their own, many might come to the conclusion that they didn't know, but that it wasn't beyond the bounds of possibility that there was an answer and they might discover it one day. Even that could be taken as a logical answer, if it had been demonstrated to have been reasoned through a bit. In order to make children come to the conclusion that it means there is no good god, you'd have to be doing more than teaching logic and critical thinking skills; you'd have to be teaching with an agenda that was in fact the antithesis of teaching critical thinking skills - the idea of which is teaching them to question things more, not to conform their answers to someone's foregone conclusion.

Teaching logic and critical thinking skills could also teach skills that could improve morals and well-being, making society a better place.

For instance, teenage pregnancy is far too high in some Western countries. And that isn't just a religious concern, but one that can also be recognised by the most secular of secularists. Lots of teenagers behave recklessly, dismissing the risks because they assume it could never happen to them. Teaching them to think more critically about their actions before engaging in them could help cut down the risks. (along with other teaching techniques).

Teaching logic could also incorporate teaching about cognitive behavioural techniques that could help people reduce their risk of things like depression and anxiety disorders. For instance, part of a curriculum could involve teenagers thinking through this kind of scenario:

Imagine there are three women, who have each arranged to meet a new friend in a cafe.

One of them, Jane, has come to believe, because of the amount of abusive criticism she received from her parents as a child, that people find it hard to love her because she isn't a nice person, and so sooner or later, they'll abandon her.

Another one, Clare, has had abusive childhood experiences that made her think the world is a dangerous place and no one is safe or can be trusted.

Melissa, on the other hand, has grown up to believe that most people are fairly decent, and that things don't go badly wrong all that often.

The friend of each of the women doesn't arrive on time. Each woman has a different reaction, depending on what her beliefs about herself and the world are.

Jane thinks her friend must have decided she isn't worth coming to meet after all, so she gets upset and leaves.

Clare gets scared something bad might have happened to her friend, feels panicky, and buys herself a drink to calm her nerves.

Melissa assumes there must be a good reason for her new friend being late, and decides to look to see if she has her phone number if she doesn't arrive soon, to find out what's going on.

What it means for their emotions is that Jane is distressed and hurt, Clare feels very anxious, while Melissa keeps calm and is able to clearly think about what to do.

The beliefs of the two women who got upset weren't entirely wrong. They were just exaggerated. The world is a dangerous place sometimes, and nobody's perfect. The trouble is that they over-estimate how bad things are without realising they're doing it. Becoming aware that they habitually do that could help them talk themselves out of their states of worry and upset.

-------

Basically, teaching logic and critical thinking skills in schools could help people be more reflective, and go a long way to improving society.
 
There was a television programme recently about how a lot of children in Nigeria are being rejected and killed or threatened with being killed, because many pastors were accusing them of being witches who caused bad things to happen to their families or communities.

It said that though there's a longstanding tradition of accusing people like elderly women of being witches, the craze for accusing children of witchcraft started about seven years ago, when someone made a video about how children can get involved in witchcraft and do all kinds of terrible things, and lots of people saw it.

You can find out more information about the programme and the issues here: Saving Africa's Witch Children.

It features a charity that takes in abandoned children who've been accused of being witches:



It links to the charity's website, so you can find out more about their work raising such children.
There's just been a television programme on Channel 4 about how things have changed since the last one a year ago.

It said the charity it featured who looks after children who've been seriously ill-treated and abandoned after being accused of being witches received 200 thousand pounds in donations after the programme last year, and they've expanded and done new things. A lot of children are getting good education, and they've been working to publicise the problems.

The programme said there were other improvements after the programme last year. It said there's now a law in Nigeria making it illegal to accuse a child of witchcraft, and some pastors have been arrested and churches closed. There's still quite a big problem, but they think it's diminishing.

The programme said one thing that's done a lot to stop fresh accusations of witchcraft being made is that a famous Nigerian footballer, considered a national hero by many, visited the charity caring for the children in the summer, and many people think that if a national hero visited the charity to support the children, they can't be witches after all.

There's still quite a lot of violence towards children though, so quite a bit more needs to be done.

You can find out more and maybe watch the programme here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom