Debunked: Secrets of the Great Stone Spheres

I don't know. But wedge marks like those are supposed be associated with building techniques. It might be on one of the videos I linked. I think the use was to raise up large poles, and raise things up, I think.

I'm pretty sure I saw scientists on TV showing that this type of building method was used by several builder cultures. Something like that-
http://www.grahamhancock.com/images/gallery/yonaguni/1-6.jpg
 
Well sure, people have been using wedges to break stone forever and they still do it today.

You can still see this in action in quarries today in the United States.

Here it is being done in North Carolina at a modern quarry:

http://www.geology.enr.state.nc.us/...nes/Mt. Airy/Wedge setting in drill holes.jpg

If you look closely in the background, you can see stone that has been cut out using the wedge technique. You can see the pattern o fholes onthe edges of the stones.

Sure those holes under water resemble wedge holes, but are they actually? What else might they be? I find it odd that almost every site just says they are wedge holes as if it is a fact.
 
You know what I think that is really mysterious in those pictures?

The absence of fishes and benthonic animals (sponges, gorgonies, corals, whatever). Just a shoth algae (?) carpet. What a waste of crystal-clear water... OK, maybe that´s why there's not too many things living there, nutrient-poor waters.

No. Of course not. It must be, it has to be the remaining radioactivity from the nuclear weapons that destroyed the Harappan civilization. Same war, same age!

OK, I´m afraid I may have created and unleashed a monster...
 
If they really were buildings, they would have interiors, there would be artifacts to be found, (etc)... Minor things like right angles and so-called chisel marks would be overwhelmed by this kind of palpable evidence. You would not have room for interpretation.

This is more like some kid finding a pointy-looking rock and calling it an arrowhead.
 
http://www.morien-institute.org/imk5.html

http://www.morien-institute.org/imk9.html
" The images below are of the mysterious 'gusuku cave' that extends inward, and slopes downward, under the gusuku structure. The two images showing the entrance are taken from the outside of the cave looking towards the semi-circular wall feature (left), and (right) from the inside of the cave looking out. It is clear for everyone to see that the 'entrance' has been 'artificially shaped', and this is not something that it is possible to imagine anyone would undertake to do to an 'underwater' cave ..."
uw_gusuku_cave3.jpg



"It was obviously made, and used, in the distant past when the area was last above sea-level, and currently the cave is blocked by an enormous accumulation of soil and sand to a depth of approximately 50 feet ..."
uw_gusuku_cave4.jpg


It is very very old.
 
Those are caves.

Something less ambiguous like burial grounds or axe heads would be helpful.
 
Psi Baba said:
"Secrets of the Great Stone Spheres" was on again last night, on the Science Channel. To answer kilik's question, they debunked them by looking at well-known myths about stones one by one, then examining the stones scientifically, or researching historical facts to see if the myths stood up to scrutiny. None of them did. The myths include:
* They were naturally formed

If the myth that they were naturally formed was debunked, that would imply they are artificial or man-made. Is that correct or did they prove the rocks in question were actually naturally formed?

Kilik:

I haven't heard of this before, but some nice pictures. Very interesting. Some of those do seem quite like artificial structures, though the one with people in it looked like the apparent "stairs" weren't the right size for humans.

I don't see why the idea that the remains of ancient civilizations being found underwater is absurd. It seems quite possible and if it were to occur, I would expect the interiors to be filled with a lot of silt and sediments, just like the cave picture. It would take a monumental effort to excavate such a site if one existed.

At any rate, I may try to catch the show if it gets repeated here.

Beth
 
The stones were manmade. They were made by native craftsmen using simple stone and wooden tools. The show demonstrated how it was possible.
 
Beth wrote:
I don't see why the idea that the remains of ancient civilizations being found underwater is absurd.

I don't think anybody said it was absurd. A significant portion of Alexandria ended up underwater as the result of an earthquake. There has been recent archeological efforts to investigate this.

In addition going back much farther cave drawings from prehistoric times have ended up underwater in France as a result of raised sea levels after the ice age.

The difference between these sites and the sites referred to in this thread is that these sites contain simple unequivocal evidence of humans. For some reason, if we are to believe the artificial construction theory advocates all the simple unequivocal evidence of the builders has been swept away for the sites referred to in this thread and all that is left is ambigous evidence that takes some wishful thinking to massage into indicators of human involvement.

It is interesting to note that Graham Hancock, an individual who seems to have a pretty open mind to strange theories, doesn't think much of the human construction theory with regard to the stuctures in Japan.
 
From reading Heaven's Mirror I got the impression he thought it was man made agreeing with Dr. Kimura, and that Robert Schoch and John Anthony West should keep their minds open and examine it further in more detail. And even more finds in that area happened more recently I think.
 
Kilik said:
http://www.morien-institute.org/imk5.html

http://www.morien-institute.org/imk9.html
" The images below are of the mysterious 'gusuku cave' that extends inward, and slopes downward, under the gusuku structure. The two images showing the entrance are taken from the outside of the cave looking towards the semi-circular wall feature (left), and (right) from the inside of the cave looking out. It is clear for everyone to see that the 'entrance' has been 'artificially shaped', and this is not something that it is possible to imagine anyone would undertake to do to an 'underwater' cave ..."
uw_gusuku_cave3.jpg



"It was obviously made, and used, in the distant past when the area was last above sea-level, and currently the cave is blocked by an enormous accumulation of soil and sand to a depth of approximately 50 feet ..."
uw_gusuku_cave4.jpg


It is very very old.

Sorry Killik, but your bubble is about to be blown.

I´ve studied (and had a lot of fun in) caves some years ago. Those pictures show nothing that implies it was "artificially shaped". I´ve seen a lot of cave entrances (as well as galleries) like that, with a rectangular shape.

This shape is formed by collapse of the ceiling, along flat-lying structures in the rock that act as weakness planes (bedding, fractures, foliation, etc.).

So, the claim that "its clear for everyone to see that the 'entrance' has been 'artificially shaped' " is bogus.
 
It's not a bogus site. well it says that it is-

"more Yonaguni evidence from the personal website of
- Professor Masaaki Kimura -
University of the Ryukyus
Okinawa, Japan "

He is not bogus. He is very high level in his field

line engraved tablet

stonetab1.jpg
 
Kilik said:
It's not a bogus site. well it says that it is-

"more Yonaguni evidence from the personal website of
- Professor Masaaki Kimura -
University of the Ryukyus
Okinawa, Japan "

He is not bogus. He is very high level in his field

line engraved tablet

stonetab1.jpg

Is this from that same underwater site? If so, it would certainly lend more credence to the theory.

I agree with Correa Neto that the cave entrance could be entirely natural, as with most of the pictures you've posted, but they are also in line with it having been an artificial construct. It's an interesting theory, but so far there really isn't enough evidence (at least on this thread) for me to form a firm conclusion. If Professor Kimura is correct, and continues to investigate the site, I expect he will find more evidence to substantiate his theory.

Beth
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom