Debunked: Secrets of the Great Stone Spheres

Mercutio

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Mar 31, 2003
Messages
16,279
As I type, Discovery channel is busy debunking the mysteries of the great stone spheres of Costa Rica.

Finally, the Discovery channel is discovering things. Last hour, of course, it was building motorcycles.

Anyway...the show appears to be trying to be relatively hip, trying to make skepticism cool. Good on them.
 
Mercutio said:
As I type, Discovery channel is busy debunking the mysteries of the great stone spheres of Costa Rica.

Finally, the Discovery channel is discovering things. Last hour, of course, it was building motorcycles.

Anyway...the show appears to be trying to be relatively hip, trying to make skepticism cool. Good on them.

Are there any lizards living under those spheres?
 
I caught the show, it was interesting.

The artificial and forced "cool" was bearable, and the element of completing a set of challenges in a short amount of time was a bit like watching the Road Rules.

And after "Debunked", there was a special Mythbusters episode examining Pyramid power.
 
Mercutio said:
Anyway...the show appears to be trying to be relatively hip, trying to make skepticism cool. Good on them.
Old face of skepticism: James Randi
randi.jpg


New face of skepticism: Kari Byron (from "Mythbusters")
kari_bio.jpg
 
Re: Re: Debunked: Secrets of the Great Stone Spheres

The Central Scrutinizer said:
Are there any lizards living under those spheres?

Why, are you hungry?
 
Re: Re: Debunked: Secrets of the Great Stone Spheres

Yahweh said:
New face of skepticism: Kari Byron (from "Mythbusters")
kari_bio.jpg

Which one is Kari?
 
Re: Re: Re: Debunked: Secrets of the Great Stone Spheres

CFLarsen said:
Which one is Kari?

Hey! Watch yourself. That is a "cute" picture of Kari but she is actually quite hot.
 
Mercutio said:


Anyway...the show appears to be trying to be relatively hip, trying to make skepticism cool. Good on them.

I was shocked to see it myself. I thought to myself "Maybe the sucess of Mythbusters and Bullsh*t are making an impression on the media. Maybe they will start to look at these things from a non-credulous angle. Cool!"

Then I was brought back to reality by flipping through my channel guide and noticing a show on Psychic Detectives on NBC, another one on CourtTV, not to mention the sucess of "Medium", and the recent spate of shows on newsmagazines such as 20/20 and Dateline on psychics, Jesus, and other paranormal topics. Too bad.
 
In other news, Bill Nye's new show will finally air, after a 2-year delay for funding reasons (iirc). Check your local listings...

But the mythbusters assistants are still cuter than Bill Nye.
 
I caught most of the show also. I enjoyed it quite a bit.

A minor quibble. I thought they overstated the evidence for their conclusions. I know I would have been fairly grossed out if I didn't agree with their conclusions and the evidence for their conclusions was as flimsy as theirs was. As it was, I thought their conclusions were reasonable I just quibbled with how solid the evidence was for them.
 
davefoc said:
I caught most of the show also. I enjoyed it quite a bit.

A minor quibble. I thought they overstated the evidence for their conclusions. I know I would have been fairly grossed out if I didn't agree with their conclusions and the evidence for their conclusions was as flimsy as theirs was. As it was, I thought their conclusions were reasonable I just quibbled with how solid the evidence was for them.
Which show? The stone circles? Or Mythbusters testing of pyramids? If you mean the former, I would like to add in the latter (and vice versa, for that matter). The pyramid test had much much too small an N for a reasonable test.
 
I actually meant the comment about the spherical stones, but it applied even more so to the conclusions from the mythbusters show about the pyramids.

I enjoy the mythbusters show quite a bit but my two criticisms of the show are:
1. I would like to see them rely more on experts for their various projects and give the experts more of a role on the show.
2. Some of the experiments aren't done in nearly a precise enough way to draw definitive conclusions. Although, I for one, don't need a lot of experiments to convince me that placing a razor blade inside a wire pyramid isn't going to sharpen it.
 
I caught both shows also and thought that they didn't really state their debunking case sufficiently but I think that had to do with time constraints. However, the next day I was flipping through and turned on The Learning Channel and started watching a guy named Alain Nu (I tried to do a search here but couldn't find anything, perhaps it's a new show.) He was doing some blidfold stunt in which he picked out blondes from brunettes from redheads to prove his amazing "mind power". At first I thought that it was going to be another debunking show, but I soon figured out that it was just going to keep showing a bunch of tricks from this guy that kept talking about the power of the mind. Anyway, I was perturbed mainly because it was on the Learning channel. What the hell are we supposed to be learning from this guy?
 
After that they tried pyramid power on Mythbusters.

Anyway, the show was interesting. I'd never even heard of the balls before. They look like great lawn ornaments, no wonder everybody ran off and took them. But I don't seem to remember them debunking the myth that the balls are filled with gold...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom