Debate: Should the Senate filibuster rule be abolished?

Hey foreigners, stay out of America's 200 year old philosophizing about democracy. I don't care how your parliaments work!
 
Unfortunately they don't. It isn't doing something stupid which they have an incentive to avoid; it's looking bad to the electorate.

Doing and saying stupid things is not necessarily harmful to one's election prospects. On the contrary, doing and saying intelligent things is often much more damaging. A politician who speaks in slogans and sound bites is likely to do much better -- even if those slogans and sound bites don't stand up to sensible scrutiny -- than a politician who tries to present facts, figures, and rational analysis.

Fortunately it's what they do rather than what they say that we are ultimately concerned with. Strong partisanship means that every single person on thats party's ticket has to worry if their part does something that won't work out too well further down the line.
 
Sadly, I don't think I could ever rely on politicians not wanting to mess with something that's functional or depend on them being smart enough for anything.

Consider again the Tea Party movement in the U.S. They've got some really wacky and dangerous ideas. They are likely to get a lot of their candidates voted into office (for one term). I would hate it if they could actually pass their full agenda with just a simple majority.

And these kinds of movements happen with some regularity. A lot of people have a lot of misinformation and really bad ideas.

Well this is where you fall back on party hierarchies. For a party to function well enough to get elected it's going to have people who have a reasonable grasp on reality and will be able to point out to the others that using the goverment's power to break contracts will result in an instant 20%+ increase in the price of whatever they want to do.
 
I don't think you mean that.

I think government will continue to function.
Actually I do mean that. Yes, I agree that government will continue to function* but I disagree with you that any meaningful legislation will be passed. That is precisely what Mitch McConnell was saying when he said their goal is to make Obama a one-term president. And he is certainly in a position to take tough steps to try to make that happen.

* And there is even a caveat to that. There have been some noises on the right about shutting down the government next spring. I personally don't think it will come to that but Krugman does. It happened under Newt so it is not entirely out of the question.
 
Actually I do mean that. Yes, I agree that government will continue to function* but I disagree with you that any meaningful legislation will be passed.

I think where we disagree might be the definition of "meaningful legislation". I think the budget each fiscal year is probably the single most meaningful thing Congress does. And they will do that.

Even if things get really bad and someone threatens to shut down the government, it won't happen. At worst, they'll pass one or more emergency stop-gap budgets to keep things running until--maybe kicking and screaming on both sides--they reach an agreement and pass a budget.

When Gingrich "shut down government" what happened was a stay on nonessential services for 6 days before a temporary budget was passed. It was pretty extreme (but I still think it's wrong to claim it was actually a shut down of the government), and I don't think we'll see a repeat of that.

But the one big piece of legislation that I'm very glad won't happen is the GOP's "repeal and replace" plan.

ETA: Though I agree that landmark, history making legislation like we saw in the first have of Obama's first term won't happen. If the GOP takes the majority of both houses, I for one am glad nothing radical will happen.
 
Last edited:
You may be right, Joe, you may be right. In any case, it will be interesting.

But the one big piece of legislation that I'm very glad won't happen is the GOP's "repeal and replace" plan.
Agreed, but my guess is that they will try to gut the legislation by not funding it.
 
The Senate as designed is meant to exactly do what it does through the filibuster rule, it gives a balancing power to small states and minority views.

Now the consequence of that in the current application is somewhat strange... this is very similar to the bring down Clinton mentality but more extreme.
 
Well this is where you fall back on party hierarchies. For a party to function well enough to get elected it's going to have people who have a reasonable grasp on reality and will be able to point out to the others that using the goverment's power to break contracts will result in an instant 20%+ increase in the price of whatever they want to do.

I disagree, it has to be able to get voters to vote for their candidates, they can be totally divorced from reality in policy.

Just as a way of getting candidates elected, not as in actually running a governmenet.
 
I disagree, it has to be able to get voters to vote for their candidates, they can be totally divorced from reality in policy.

Getting votes requires organisational skills from people who have at least some grasp on reality. Politicans who stop listening to such people once elected are unlikely to last long.
 
The Senate as designed is meant to exactly do what it does through the filibuster rule, it gives a balancing power to small states and minority views.
I usually find that the best way to bring forth a rambunctious defence of the Senate rulebook is to be a foreigner and point out defects in it. :D

Now the consequence of that in the current application is somewhat strange....
What's not strange is the encouragement of stalemate/status quo. That's sometimes an advantage but not exculsively virtuous, since policies that reside in the supermajority approval zone tend to be spending rises (appropriately pork-laden) and tax cuts, and those outside it tend to be spending cuts and tax hikes . . . creating a ratchet effect over time that points towards excessive indebtedness but is quite difficult to reverse.

Without supermajorities you can be a "party of no" almost as much as you like and it won't make much difference as long as you are out of power.
 
If the left can take any solace from the 1994 election for this upcoming Tuesday, it's that the Republicans did miserably on implementing their published schedule of change.

Quite possibly nothing will change in the passed health care legislation, nor will general massive spending be curtailed much, if at all. :(
 
I think they should require those filibustering to actually filibuster. I want to hear Sen. Lindsey Graham read from the dictionary.

Yep, and get rid of secret holds where you can filibuster something with out anyone knowing who is doing it.
 
Agreed, but my guess is that they will try to gut the legislation by not funding it.

But it doesn't require funding. Or rather, the funding is part of the law. If they don't "repeal" they can't stop it.
 
Without supermajorities you can be a "party of no" almost as much as you like and it won't make much difference as long as you are out of power.
But remember, the minority in the Senate still has a constituency whose views should get representation in government. Otherwise, we have the "tyranny of the majority".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom