Debate: Should the Senate filibuster rule be abolished?

Nova Land said:
In doing so, the minority is thwarting the wishes of the majority -- who may or may not be their political opponents.


I disagree with you here. If they disagree on matters of politics, such as policy and legislation, then they are in fact political opponents.


Note the s at the end of matters. I would agree that two politicians who disagree on a large number of matters of politics are political opponents. And, in today's polarized political landscape, people who disagree on one matter often do disagree on many matters. But that is not always true.

There is no reason why people have to agree on every single issue in order to be political allies. There were a number of Democrats who disagreed with Obama on key features of legislation he wanted passed. Even so, they are essentially on Obama's side, and he's essentially on theirs.

Another way of looking at it is that if politicians are opposed to one another, they are by definition political opponents.


I can't think of any two politicians who agree 100% on every issue. Therefore by your definition every politician is the political opponent of every other politician. You can define the term "political opponent" in that way if you wish, but that's not what I was talking about when I used the term.

By political opponents I mean people who wish to see each other defeated in elections. Harry Reid is by my definition a political ally rather than a political opponent of Barack Obama (even though the two disagree on some policy issues, and are thus political opponents by your definition); John McCain is a political ally rather than a political opponent of John Boehner (even though the two disagree on some policy issues, and are thus political opponents by your definition).


I think you're trying to make "political" carry a more restrictive meaning that it conventionally does. It generally refers to anything to do with government.


Yes, I am using a more restrictive meaning of "political" than you are. If that's causing confusion, I'd be happy to substitute in the phrase "opposing party" for "political opponents".

Let me try again, avoiding the term political opponent it means something different to you than it does to me. How's this:

I am drawing a distinction between politicians who obstruct something because they feel the policy is bad for the nation and politicians who obstruct something because they believe doing this will weaken the opposing party's chances of re-election. I believe the former is a proper use of the filibuster (even if the filibuster is being used to obstruct something I personally happen to agree with). I believe the latter is an improper use of the filibuster (even if the filibuster is being used to obstruct something I personally happen to disagree with).​


But even so, if you're using "political" to refer only to partisan politics, I would say that alone is not a reason to oppose the use of the filibuster. It really could be that the party invoking it is right and the majority party is wrong.


Then this is something we are in significant disagreement over. My feeling on whether someone should be permitted to filibuster is independent of whether I agree or disagree with the policy they are trying to block.

If there are basically 2 positions on an issue and 2 parties, it makes sense to me that the positions will line up pretty well with party affiliation.


Not to me. But then, I grew up in a world where there were Republicans who supported the civil rights movement as well as Republicans who opposed it; Democrats who supported the Vietnam War as well as Democrats who opposed it; Republicans who supported separation of church and state as well as Republicans who opposed it; Democrats who supported capital punishment as well as Democrats who opposed it.

To me it makes sense that politicians should expect to be able to find agreement with those in the opposing party as well as to find disagreement with those in their own party. Their aim should be to work together to craft the policies which are best for the nation rather than to craft the policies which are most likely to get their party re-elected.

The idea that, on any issue, there could be only 2 positions astounds me. The idea that, given 10 major issues, every Democratic legislator would happen to fall on one side and every Republican legislator would happen to fall on the other, astounds me even more. It may make sense to you, but it does not make sense to me.
 
Get rid of the filibuster. Get rid of personal holds too.
Of course, as long as these rules are the rules, I think that democrats should use them to their full partisan advantage because the republicans surely will. But I would prefer to change the rules.
 
Keep the filibuster, and start insisting that the Senators act like adults for a change.
I have absolutely no idea what this means either theoretically or practically. Theoretically, the only way to "insist" is through the ballot box. But the Teabaggers, for example, either ignore or endorse behavior that is anything but adult. Practically speaking, acting as an adult has no descriptive value since Senator are adults. You (and I) may not like certain behaviors but saying they are not adult-like gets us nowhere.
 
I already answered this one too. The authority to set the rules is given to the houses of Congress. I would not want, for example, the judiciary to decide that the House should have the filibuster rule or that the Senate should not. That would be unconstitutional, IMO.
You missed my point entirely so I'll try again. Maybe I wasn't clear.

You are arguing that having a 60% filibuster rule in the Senate is a good thing. In light of that, do you believe that the House itself should also decide to have such a rule? Please provide your reasoning behind whatever stand you take.
 
The filibuster rule seemed to be good thing, until the GOP absolutely abused it since Obama took office. It's time to change the rules. Of course, the GOP and it's fans won't care until it's the Dem's in minority using it on them.
 
I've already answered this. It's basically the idea of slowing down radical changes in law. Think of how silly it would be if every time the majority of Congress changed from one party to another we completely changed our tax code, our approach to health care, etc.

Thats entirely possible in the UK. It doesn't normaly happen. The barrier to complete changes to the tax code is not checks and blances but that fact that over the centuries a tax code has developed that gets the core issues right. Its not in politican's interests to mess with the tax code to that extent.


The health insurance reform law has measures that go into effect over the next several years. It seems wrong to me that a simple majority could repeal it right away. People would never be able to make any sort of long term plans, and no project that extended beyond a fiscal year would be practical.

Thats where you rely on goverments being smart enough to realise what will happen if they start using lawmaking powers to break contracts.


As I said, I'm in favor of the majority in the Senate having the authority to choose the "nuclear option". I think this means that if the filibuster is abused too much, that it will have to go away.

The current evidence suggests it results in an endless game of chicken.

Which is a problem. It's reducing your ability to pass timely legislation, it ups the insentive to use pork to bribe senators to pass things. It means it's effectively impossible for voters to hold people to account.

I suspect we'll see more compromise and less filibustering (or threat of filibustering) in the next Congress.

So even more pork barreling and backroom deals.
 
Getting rid of the filibuster would only make the partisanship in Congress worse, in my opinion.

Why do you think that is a bad thing? Strong partisanship simple means that representatives have a high degree of collective responcibility for the parties actions. As a result they have a very strong interest in seeing it doesn't do anything supid.
 
I suspect we'll see more compromise and less filibustering (or threat of filibustering) in the next Congress.
I don't think so. Mitch has already said that defeating Obama is their main goal in the next congressional session. DeMint and others have expressed supporting sentiments. The teabaggers who get in have no incentive to compromise at all because doing so will piss off their base.

If the Reps take the house and get about 48 in the Senate, Congress is basically going to come to a halt.
 
Thats entirely possible in the UK. It doesn't normaly happen. The barrier to complete changes to the tax code is not checks and blances but that fact that over the centuries a tax code has developed that gets the core issues right. Its not in politican's interests to mess with the tax code to that extent.

Thats where you rely on goverments being smart enough to realise what will happen if they start using lawmaking powers to break contracts.

The current evidence suggests it results in an endless game of chicken.

Which is a problem. It's reducing your ability to pass timely legislation, it ups the insentive to use pork to bribe senators to pass things. It means it's effectively impossible for voters to hold people to account.
I entirely agree with this post.

The advantages of supermajority, and of executive veto etc tend to normally get expressed as "making change difficult" because "Americans prefer the status quo and the lack of radical changes". That's valid up to a point, but checks and balances may be a poor structure for dealing with required long term structural changes.

IMO the health reform act and the recovery act are testimony to the idea that legislation ends up riddled with kickbacks and perversities.
 
Why do you think that is a bad thing? Strong partisanship simple means that representatives have a high degree of collective responsibility for the parties actions. As a result they have a very strong interest in seeing it doesn't do anything stupid.


Unfortunately they don't. It isn't doing something stupid which they have an incentive to avoid; it's looking bad to the electorate.

Doing and saying stupid things is not necessarily harmful to one's election prospects. On the contrary, doing and saying intelligent things is often much more damaging. A politician who speaks in slogans and sound bites is likely to do much better -- even if those slogans and sound bites don't stand up to sensible scrutiny -- than a politician who tries to present facts, figures, and rational analysis.

So strong partisanship has not led to an avoidance of doing stupid things. It has led to increased attention to how to spin things to make whatever one's own side does look good and to make whatever the other side does look bad -- regardless of the actual merits or demerits of those actions.
 
The filibuster rule seemed to be good thing, until the GOP absolutely abused it since Obama took office. It's time to change the rules. Of course, the GOP and it's [sic] fans won't care until it's the Dem's in minority using it on them.

Even though the GOP abused it, Democrats passed a LOT of really big and important legislation. I do think we came close to the point where the should have used the "nuclear option".

Remember too that the GOP hardly participated in crafting the health insurance reform law. The compromises and concessions took place, for the most part, between mainstream and the Blue Dog Democrats (and Lieberman--however you categorize that guy). The GOP made itself irrelevant and only set itself up as feeling strongly opposed to the law.

Now they want to repeal and replace it, and now I'm glad that the filibuster exists, because it may well be the only way to prevent that from happening. (And the GOP won't have anywhere near a supermajority in the Senate.)
 
IMO the health reform act and the recovery act are testimony to the idea that legislation ends up riddled with kickbacks and perversities.

See above. The concessions were largely within the Democratic Party. This started even when they had a supermajority.
 
I don't think so. Mitch has already said that defeating Obama is their main goal in the next congressional session. DeMint and others have expressed supporting sentiments. The teabaggers who get in have no incentive to compromise at all because doing so will piss off their base.

If the Reps take the house and get about 48 in the Senate, Congress is basically going to come to a halt.

I don't think you mean that.

I think government will continue to function.

Congress will pass annual budgets that will have to have bipartisan support. [ETA: And by that I mean they will pass a budget each year that absolutely no one is completely happy with.] They will probably even pass a tax cut of some sort to replace the expiring Bush tax cuts.

If they pass any kind of immigration reform it will be very modest.

Repeal and replace of the health insurance reform law will fail.

They might get bipartisan support for some limited medical tort reform. (Though, sadly, it will probably simply be caps on damages, which I've always argued doesn't discourage frivolous cases since damage awards only go to cases with merit--the ones that win a judgement.)
 
Last edited:
Thats entirely possible in the UK. It doesn't normaly happen. The barrier to complete changes to the tax code is not checks and blances but that fact that over the centuries a tax code has developed that gets the core issues right. Its not in politican's interests to mess with the tax code to that extent.




Thats where you rely on goverments being smart enough to realise what will happen if they start using lawmaking powers to break contracts.

Sadly, I don't think I could ever rely on politicians not wanting to mess with something that's functional or depend on them being smart enough for anything.

Consider again the Tea Party movement in the U.S. They've got some really wacky and dangerous ideas. They are likely to get a lot of their candidates voted into office (for one term). I would hate it if they could actually pass their full agenda with just a simple majority.

And these kinds of movements happen with some regularity. A lot of people have a lot of misinformation and really bad ideas.
 
Sadly, I don't think I could ever rely on politicians not wanting to mess with something that's functional or depend on them being smart enough for anything.

Consider again the Tea Party movement in the U.S. They've got some really wacky and dangerous ideas.
The movement as a whole is simply about smaller government, which is in no way "wacky" and is "dangerous" only if you depend on government spending for your livelihood.

As individuals, sure. But they are hardly alone there.
 
Consider again the Tea Party movement in the U.S. They've got some really wacky and dangerous ideas. They are likely to get a lot of their candidates voted into office (for one term). I would hate it if they could actually pass their full agenda with just a simple majority.

Considering this thread is about the Senate, not the house, there is little danger of that. Remeber, only about 33 seats are up for election in any one given cycle. Therefore the most senate seats the TP can get in their first election is nowhere near a majority. Since they are not even running as a separate party, the number of TP candidates for senate is much less, because they did not win the Republican Primary for every open seat. That said, even with amazing success, the TP will not seat more than 10 senators.

The danger is that such a success can bring the rest of the Republican party to the right to pass some of their extreme agenda, not that one election will give the TP a senate majority to unilaterally pass an agenda were it not for the filibuster standing in their way.
 
The movement as a whole is simply about smaller government, which is in no way "wacky" and is "dangerous" only if you depend on government spending for your livelihood.

As individuals, sure. But they are hardly alone there.

The Tea Party movement as a whole isn't about anything really. It is merely a blank sheet of paper upon which individual conservatives can project their beliefs. It's sole purpose is to get conservatives energized about their beliefs (even if they are mutually contradictory) and get out to vote Republican.

There is no "there" there. They are the conservative equivelent hippies from the 1960's.
 
Remember too that the GOP hardly participated in crafting the health insurance reform law.
There is a view that Obama didn't participate much either . . .
The compromises and concessions took place, for the most part, between mainstream and the Blue Dog Democrats
. . . quite.

See above. The concessions were largely within the Democratic Party. This started even when they had a supermajority.
Yes, you're correct (after all no Republican in Congress or the Senate voted for it at any time). So I suppose I'd correct myself in respect of the PPAHCA to say that its myriad inefficiencies and oddities reflect selling it to Democrats rather than anything else.

What I said previously still applies to the recovery act, I think.
 
I prefer filibusters require 45 votes, not 41.

I'm not a fan of the tyranny of the majority, but still...majority does rule.


Who said slim majorities implementing massive changes was good, or had anything to do with the way the US government was designed?

"Great innovations should not be forced [by way of] slim majorities." -- Thomas Jefferson


Sure as hell not the founding fathers. If an idea is good, most people should think so, not just a transient majority. And they should think so 10 and 20 years down the road, too.

Too many people have a childlike mentality, and think, "Gawrsh! If'n only we could barely sqeak by a 50.01% majority, we can do anything, and I mean anything that we like! Golly! Don't thwart the Will of the Majority!"

This is an asinine attitude not in accordance with staving the grave problems of human history, most of which revolve around demagogues and the transient masses.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom