Nova Land said:In doing so, the minority is thwarting the wishes of the majority -- who may or may not be their political opponents.
I disagree with you here. If they disagree on matters of politics, such as policy and legislation, then they are in fact political opponents.
Note the s at the end of matters. I would agree that two politicians who disagree on a large number of matters of politics are political opponents. And, in today's polarized political landscape, people who disagree on one matter often do disagree on many matters. But that is not always true.
There is no reason why people have to agree on every single issue in order to be political allies. There were a number of Democrats who disagreed with Obama on key features of legislation he wanted passed. Even so, they are essentially on Obama's side, and he's essentially on theirs.
Another way of looking at it is that if politicians are opposed to one another, they are by definition political opponents.
I can't think of any two politicians who agree 100% on every issue. Therefore by your definition every politician is the political opponent of every other politician. You can define the term "political opponent" in that way if you wish, but that's not what I was talking about when I used the term.
By political opponents I mean people who wish to see each other defeated in elections. Harry Reid is by my definition a political ally rather than a political opponent of Barack Obama (even though the two disagree on some policy issues, and are thus political opponents by your definition); John McCain is a political ally rather than a political opponent of John Boehner (even though the two disagree on some policy issues, and are thus political opponents by your definition).
I think you're trying to make "political" carry a more restrictive meaning that it conventionally does. It generally refers to anything to do with government.
Yes, I am using a more restrictive meaning of "political" than you are. If that's causing confusion, I'd be happy to substitute in the phrase "opposing party" for "political opponents".
Let me try again, avoiding the term political opponent it means something different to you than it does to me. How's this:
I am drawing a distinction between politicians who obstruct something because they feel the policy is bad for the nation and politicians who obstruct something because they believe doing this will weaken the opposing party's chances of re-election. I believe the former is a proper use of the filibuster (even if the filibuster is being used to obstruct something I personally happen to agree with). I believe the latter is an improper use of the filibuster (even if the filibuster is being used to obstruct something I personally happen to disagree with).
But even so, if you're using "political" to refer only to partisan politics, I would say that alone is not a reason to oppose the use of the filibuster. It really could be that the party invoking it is right and the majority party is wrong.
Then this is something we are in significant disagreement over. My feeling on whether someone should be permitted to filibuster is independent of whether I agree or disagree with the policy they are trying to block.
If there are basically 2 positions on an issue and 2 parties, it makes sense to me that the positions will line up pretty well with party affiliation.
Not to me. But then, I grew up in a world where there were Republicans who supported the civil rights movement as well as Republicans who opposed it; Democrats who supported the Vietnam War as well as Democrats who opposed it; Republicans who supported separation of church and state as well as Republicans who opposed it; Democrats who supported capital punishment as well as Democrats who opposed it.
To me it makes sense that politicians should expect to be able to find agreement with those in the opposing party as well as to find disagreement with those in their own party. Their aim should be to work together to craft the policies which are best for the nation rather than to craft the policies which are most likely to get their party re-elected.
The idea that, on any issue, there could be only 2 positions astounds me. The idea that, given 10 major issues, every Democratic legislator would happen to fall on one side and every Republican legislator would happen to fall on the other, astounds me even more. It may make sense to you, but it does not make sense to me.