Cut Defense spending to cut the deficit?

Even though we have the technology that gives us great range on our vehicles and weapons and that capability to build temporary bases very quickly?

Yes. You see, that same technology can be used to enlarge existing bases even quicker, and you don't need to move a whole lot of equipment there if you already have a smaller base there.

Fuel consumption is also a concern - even if not from a financial point of view it is still a logistical concern. It's a lot easier to move vehicles from a number of nearby bases once than it is to constantly refuel them as they operate over large distances. Crew fatigue and equipment wear also come into play.

The forces are also a lot more flexible and don't have to always use the same bases, there are less bottlenecks. The range and speed you mentioned are just as or even more useful in quickly relocating the forces to where the enemy is.

That's why carrier battle groups are so prominent in US military doctrine and so vital to power projection. They're essentially mobile bases, with capabilities to service and supply a small air fleet. The relatively small size of the air fleet is secondary to it's capability to close in to almost any location. Add a capability to deploy special forces and the firepower from the escorts and you have a nice, smallish, rounded base.

McHrozni
 
Last edited:
Private research is a bit more than twice Federal reasearch funding. http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/91xx/doc9135/FigureA-1.gif
rwguinn is 100% right. The stuff the government funds is both vital to basic science and would be regarded as a hooker with syphilis in the eyes of industry. I don't blame industry for it though but to try and use those statistics in any manner without any information is useless.
Hitler funded the Autobahn and the V2 rocket, 2 concepts adopted by the USA.
You seem to be running into a rabbit hole of non sequitors.
 
Last edited:
Private research is a bit more than twice Federal reasearch funding. http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/91xx/doc9135/FigureA-1.gif

You may not consider computer programming to be "technology", but your shiny computer would be a very expensive paperweight without it. In fact, it is amazing how much of what people rely on every day simply would not function without software, whether it is "software" that isn't burned to a EEPROM, or if it is "firmware"...which is basically just software burned to an EEPROM. That's almost like saying steel and concrete aren't "technologies". Hell, something as simple as the horse collar transformed Europe and was largely responsible for the rise of a middle class and the emancipation of serfs.
Reading incomprehension much?
Programming is software. Technology is hardware. Without the hardware, programming is a useless endeavor.
 
An interesting graph related to the discussion.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:InflationAdjustedDefenseSpending.PNG

For comparison.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:USDebt.png

I was hoping to find a graph that showed the debt create per year rather than the total per year but it is still useful.

Obviously, eradicating the military/defense budget cannot solve the debt issue. I think that having an interventionist-ready military posture would still be beneficial and worth the cost, even though I disagree with size and number of interventions we have done in the modern era. I wonder if in the post-Cold War era it would have been possible to keep the total spending down about 200 Billion. If so that would have netted us almost 4 Trillion at this point, which does significantly impact the total federal debt. Obviously 200 Billion would not be possible every year, especially since the total debt did not accumulate each year as 2009 dollars.

Spending did decrease with the end of the Cold War, the decrease merely stopped at a level higher than I would have preferred. Obviously it was going to increase after 9/11 with the initiation of two wars. Wars increase spending.

I am not sure what is possible and what would still keep us and our allies relatively safe. It is a good discussion and am glad to see actual experts chime in on the issue. I think the way forward might be to have a military that can rapidly respond and deploy rather than to sit in previous hot spots. It might not be feasible yet or at all. Research is an area I do not want to see reduced too much overall, so my hopes for less military spending might be dashed from that perspective.
 
Yes. You see, that same technology can be used to enlarge existing bases even quicker, and you don't need to move a whole lot of equipment there if you already have a smaller base there.

Fuel consumption is also a concern - even if not from a financial point of view it is still a logistical concern. It's a lot easier to move vehicles from a number of nearby bases once than it is to constantly refuel them as they operate over large distances. Crew fatigue and equipment wear also come into play.

The forces are also a lot more flexible and don't have to always use the same bases, there are less bottlenecks. The range and speed you mentioned are just as or even more useful in quickly relocating the forces to where the enemy is.

That's why carrier battle groups are so prominent in US military doctrine and so vital to power projection. They're essentially mobile bases, with capabilities to service and supply a small air fleet. The relatively small size of the air fleet is secondary to it's capability to close in to almost any location. Add a capability to deploy special forces and the firepower from the escorts and you have a nice, smallish, rounded base.

McHrozni

Because you feel you have a better military strategy than Rummy, you think he's not a war-monger?
 
Because you feel you have a better military strategy than Rummy, you think he's not a war-monger?

What makes you think the concept of smaller, more mobile, more quickly deployable forces is any different than Rumsfeld's basic ideas for force structure? That IS, by the way, signature Rumsfeld philosophy.
 
What makes you think the concept of smaller, more mobile, more quickly deployable forces is any different than Rumsfeld's basic ideas for force structure? That IS, by the way, signature Rumsfeld philosophy.

This is irrelevant to your assertion that Rummy was not an evil warmonger.
 
How much money would we save if we ended our Cold War commitments in Germany and Japan?

I have to assume we soend billions to keep all of our soldiers in these two countries.

Japan used to pay a significant percentage of the cost of the U.S. military bases, is that still true?

And as far as protecting Japan from a Soviet or Chinese invasion/attack..is that really plausible anymore?

The Chinese probably won't attack Japan, but it is useful for the U.S. to have bases near Taiwan in case that situation becomes violent.
 
Last edited:
What makes you think the concept of smaller, more mobile, more quickly deployable forces is any different than Rumsfeld's basic ideas for force structure? That IS, by the way, signature Rumsfeld philosophy.

I think that is exactly what Rumsfeld's basic idea was. I agree with it in certain areas and disagree with it in others. For instance at the point of planning an invasion. At that point escalation is needed and overkill in terms of staffing power and other resources is not exactly wasteful, it is precautionary. Shock & Awe felt silly to me, and I am not a military buff. The military is a blunt instrument when used offensively. It should be respected as such.

I'm not even certain Rumsfeld was himself a warmonger. I have not read the fallout books on the subject and have not seen it mentioned in the media so I am not aware if he fell into the neoconservative camp or one of the other camps during the internal squabbles of the early administration. Having a poor military stategy does not speak one way or another to a person being a warmonger. I recall he was one of the people using religious rhetoric in his reports to President Bush, but wasn't the Pentagon one of his major political opponents internally?

Now I need to look up what his personal views on starting the wars were to see how to mock him accordingly.
 
Because you feel you have a better military strategy than Rummy, you think he's not a war-monger?

Do you think a one line response like that addresses anything?

Better strategy? That will be difficult for you to show, since I wasn't discussing which strategy would be better, but which strategy enables foreign interventionism (warmongering) better. Notice how the plan was shelved after 9/11, when it was clear interventionism was the order of the day? Why do you think that was? Rumsfeld was on the job for another 3 years afterward.

Your position is entirely nonsensical: Rumsfeld planned wars all over the world and decided it would be best to concentrate forces more. Then when it became evident he would have to fight wars all over the world he decided to keep the forces dispersed. Eh?

The only logical conclusion is that Rumsfeld wasn't a warmonger and that he didn't plan a lot of foreign operations, but that changed on 9/11. If you can draw another remotely sensible conclusion, let's hear it.

McHrozni
 
Truth is, Isolationism, the idea that the US should not get involved with any foreign countries and should, except for "trade" (ie, except when we can make a buck) simply ignore the world outside our borders (except for maybe Canada and Mexico) has always had an appeal in the US, on both the left and the right. It is most recently going under the name on "Non Interventionism" and it's most vocal advocate is Ron Paul.
IMHO, common sense dictates that it is equally stupid for the US to Intervene at the drop of a hat, or to NEVER intervene no matter what is at stake.
And I might argue that a large US economic presence overseas is going to be seen by many overseas as US Imperialism, even if the US Government is not involved.
The point is a lot of those who want to cut defense spending "to the bone" really want to cut defense spending to the point where US Military invention is just plain impossible.

Actually I my self would love to see Europe pay for their own defense!
Lets see them pay for all their progressive crap and their defense at the same time!
IMVHO they have gotten away with way to much while at the same time biting the very country that made their crap possible!
Lets see maybe we can afford health care?
 
Considering how much money is spent on military programs, I think at least some reduction is necessary. I do NOT believe by any means that we should just dismantle our military...
 
I would also like to see future interventionist missions to be more multilateral endeavors. Iraq was primarily a US and Uk mission, with a very so so committment from others. Having few allies willing to commit heavily should be a sign to heavily reconsider a course of action. This would also help ease the burden of military action by spreading the cost across more countries. Yes, I think European countries could possibly invest more into NATO forces even if that investment is only money and the staffing power and equipment ultimately comes from other NATO countries.

I do not want evil regimes to be free to do whatever they want but I do not want the US to be the policing nation responsible for keeping this issues in check. It should be a cooperative consensus in my opinion.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom